14 Weirdest Reality Dating Shows

by

In recent years, reality dating shows have gained considerable popularity and acclaim, particularly through streaming platforms such as Netflix. Notable series like “Love is Blind,” “Too Hot to Handle,” “The Perfect Match,” and “The Ultimatum” have left viewers hooked with their unique twists on the classic format. Concurrently, traditional TV networks continue to capitalize on this trend with successful shows like “Love Island,” “The Bachelor,” and “Temptation Island.”

In the relentless pursuit of capturing audience attention, the reality TV dating scene has introduced some extraordinarily unusual concepts. From quirky themes to unexpected contestants, it seems the boundaries are constantly being pushed. In this article, we’ll explore 14 of the most bizarre reality TV dating shows to ever grace our screens.

14 Milf Manor (2023 — Present)

2 Seasons

TLC, known for its provocative programming, is where you’ll find some extraordinarily outlandish content. Among its many controversial productions, “Milf Manor” stands out as one of the most intriguing. In this reality show’s first season, single mothers and their sons lived together, competing against each other for reasons that raise eyebrows.

Experiencing this situation firsthand feels just as uncomfortable as you could imagine. We’re asked to play “naughty games,” where not only mothers but also their sons must observe each other undertake provocative tasks and reveal intimate details about our sex lives.

Watching Mom Make the Moves on a Younger Man

In the second season, the producers abandoned the storyline involving the sons and focused instead on attractive bachelors courting older women, or “milfs.” Despite its questionable premise, the competition reality show has managed to maintain a loyal audience. However, its unique concept remains one of the most peculiar and awkward in the realm of 2020s reality television.

You can stream Milf Manor on Max.

13 A Double Shot at Love (2008)

1 Season

In the reality TV show “A Double Shot at Love” by Telia Tequila, the stakes were raised as a set of identical twins, referred to as the “Ikki Twins,” took turns eliminating a pool of suitors in their search for a romantic connection.

The concept of twin dating is a recent development in the realm of dating shows, with productions like “Twin Love” and “Dated & Related” on Prime Original drawing criticism from some viewers. However, MTV’s “Double Shot at Love” was the pioneer in this format, following the same provocative and bold personalities that characterize many reality TV dating programs.

First Dating Show to Feature Twins

The program offered a tumultuous emotional journey, marked by controversy surrounding Tila Tequila’s departure and the unfamiliarity of the Ikki twins compared to other MTV “love” shows. The conclusion was harsh, and many contestants displayed unpleasant behaviors.

The 2019 relaunch of the show was deliberately chaotic yet engaging, featuring DJ Pauly D and Vinny Guadagnino selecting a suitor from a pool of twenty singles.

12 Date My Mom (2004 – 2006)

4 Seasons

Choosing an MTV program from the 2000s to exemplify the network’s absurdity in shaping reality TV is a challenging task. Among your options were the excessively loud speed dating competition “Next,” the chaotic teenage room invasion show “Room Raiders,” and the parent-focused dating series “Parental Control.” However, “Date My Mom” rises above the crowd of sensational teen programming that swamped MTV’s lineup.

Mother Knows Best

In the reality show “Date My Mom” on MTV, a teenager goes on three dates with prospective partners. However, the first date is always with their own mother. Based on this initial encounter, they make their decision. The program shares similarities with other MTV productions, yet it lacks authentic romance and appears heavily scripted. Despite its unrealistic feel, the show can be quite uncomfortable and embarrassing to watch. It may only attract viewers who appreciate old-fashioned or poorly produced television.

11 Fool Around With… My Girlfriend (2004 – 2006)

3 Seasons

In the UK, there are some unusual reality dating shows, and “Fool Around With… My Girlfriend” is among the most peculiar. In this program, a bachelor would encounter four ladies, three of whom were already in committed relationships. The boyfriends would watch their girlfriends from a distance, offering comments, and encouraging them. If the bachelor selected a taken woman, that couple would be rewarded with a cash prize instead.

A View from the Cuck Chair

As a fan of the show, I’d describe it this way: In each season, there are three competitors vying for the top spot. On occasion, the roles reverse, with three suitors attempting to deceive and swindle money from a single bachelorette. The atmosphere remains tense and uneasy, with the audience’s commentary only intensifying the awkwardness. Most of the contestants are socialites, making jealousy and superficial remarks common occurrences.

10 Flavor of Love (2006 – 2008)

3 Seasons

Instead of just mentioning “A Double Shot at Love,” MTV produced several other reality shows centered around love. For instance, there was “Rock of Love” with Bret Michaels, “Daisy of Love” featuring Daisy De La Hoya from the second season of “Rock of Love,” and “Real Chance of Love” starring rapper Kamal Givens. The concept remained consistent: choose a C-list celebrity, invite a group of uncertain singles to live together, and witness the resulting chaos.

Riding the Catchphrase to the Bank

Perhaps it’s unjustified to label Flava Flav as a Z-list celebrity given his successful career as a rapper and multi-instrumentalist with Public Enemy. However, his portrayal on the show may not have been particularly positive.

The cast members’ unusual behaviors and propensity for conflicts during the three seasons set this series apart from a typical dating game show. Flavor Flav’s distinctive personality and catchphrases were just one aspect of the show’s quirkiness. Instead, it took on the feel of a competition reality show due to the frequent disputes among the contestants.

9 Gay, Straight or Taken? (2007)

1 Season

In intriguing British game show “Gay, Straight or Taken?”, a solitary woman goes on dates with three gentlemen, aiming for a grand reward and a romantic rendezvous with her preferred suitor. Yet, an unexpected twist exists: if she mistakenly selects a ‘gay’ or ‘taken’ man, that very person receives the prize instead. The concept of three men vying for one woman’s affections is intriguing enough; however, this added element of guesswork amplifies the awkwardness.

An Awkward Guessing Game

During the 2000s, formats featuring queer culture weren’t entirely unfamiliar, although they were frequently viewed as novelty items. However, “Gay, Straight or Taken?” feels remarkably out of place in contemporary reality television for valid reasons.

8 Dating Naked (2014 – 2016)

3 Seasons

Intrigued by the longstanding appeal of nudity in Western society, producers have often considered exposing contestants on television as an intriguing concept. Among the most provocative representations of this trend is “Naked Attraction,” a notorious British program, where a singleton makes his or her choice based solely on examining potential partners’ genital areas.

As a fan, I’d say that visiting a meat market and selecting the most succulent cut for dinner strips the romantic element from a reality TV dating show. Consequently, it’s fair to conclude that “Dating Naked” holds a more alluring edge due to its raw and unfiltered approach.

Bearing It All for TV

Dating Naked was a provocative spin on the dating show format, but its approach managed to get the show to three seasons. Despite what some might think, nudity was not the focus, and instead of highlighting it, the show tried to normalize it. This attracted free-spirited viewers, but it also allowed for the personalities of the contestants to shine more than their physical assets. Still, seeing people dating naked is, and always will be, an odd format choice to draw in viewers.

You can stream Dating Naked on Paramount+.

7 Chains of Love (2001)

1 Season

As a fan, I can’t imagine enjoying the idea of being tethered to strangers for an extended dating experience filled with demanding tasks. Nobody wants that kind of ordeal… nobody! However, Chains of Love presented an intriguing reality TV concept where five individuals were linked together, vying for a substantial reward of 10k. The ‘picker’ had the power to eliminate suitors one by one until the finale, when they could opt to share the winnings with their final choice or keep it all for themselves.

Bound By The Love of Money

As a gamer, I’d say: Back in the early 2000s, there was this bizarre reality show called Chains of Love. It only lasted one season on UPN, but it wasn’t entirely panned, considering the premise. Yet, looking back, many viewers found its concept distasteful and even akin to abusive relationships. Contestants were forced into uncomfortable physical tasks and socially awkward situations, handcuffed together throughout the show. Nowadays, Chains of Love is an odd relic from the barrel-scraping era of reality TV, best left forgotten.

Stream Chains of Love on Tubi.

6 Puppy Love (2020)

1 Season

As a gamer, I can tell you that my experience with “Puppy Love” was brief and disappointing, lasting just one season with only five episodes produced. It’s unclear to me whether the idea didn’t resonate with audiences or if external factors like pandemic disruptions played a role. Nonetheless, I believe this show is worth mentioning due to its unique premise: a single person goes on dates with three different dogs and selects the one with whom they connect best.

What Does Your Dog Say About You?

For dog enthusiasts, the concept behind selecting a prospect based solely on their canine companion may carry inherent drawbacks or lack a solid rationale. This notion raises several concerns. Firstly, many dog owners will be disheartened if their beloved pet fails to secure a match due to the belief that every dog is exceptional in its unique way. Secondly, a pet’s behavior does not always accurately represent its owner, with the exception of cases involving maltreatment or neglect (a regrettable truth). Essentially, this program provides opportunities for romantic interactions between singles and their dogs.

Puppy Love is available to stream on Brit Box and Tubi.

5 Phone Swap (2018)

1 Season

As a fan of intriguing storylines, I found “Phone Swap” to be an engaging concept despite its limitations. Before making its way to Fox from Snap Chat, this innovative show featured two individuals going on a blind date and exchanging phones, granting each other access to their personal data before determining whether to continue the romantic encounter.

Judging Someone By Their Search History

In today’s world of dating, this program is both intriguing and nerve-wracking for some viewers who cling to their phones. Although there are possibilities for cringeworthy moments, the show generally concludes by browsing through photo albums and unearthing amusing images that could deter potential suitors from pursuing a romantic connection.

Although the situation could have been more dire, it’s disconcerting that making judgments about people based solely on their phone preferences feels so shallow and insubstantial.

You can stream Phone Swap on Tubi.

4 There’s Something About Miriam (2004)

1 Season

For the male contestants on the British reality TV show, it appeared uncomplicated: Six attractive men had the chance to win a £10,000 reward and capture the heart of Miriam Rivera, a young Mexican model, all while enjoying their time in the stunning locale of Ibiza.

As a gamer, I’ve recently come across the intriguing game titled “There’s Something About Miriam“. The hype surrounding it stems from both its tragic real-life background and its disturbing premise. In this game, the producers kept a significant secret from us contestants – they failed to reveal that Rivera was a transgender woman who hadn’t undergone gender-affirming surgery yet.

A Dark Day in Reality TV With a Horrible Concept

Reports have recently circulated once again about specific scenes from the program, most notably the awkwardly cringeworthy moment when the victor was taken aback by a surprising revelation. It’s debatable whether it’s appropriate to label the show with terms like “weird” now, but looking back, the disregard for the emotional well-being of all participants appears quite outdated by today’s standards.

As a dedicated gamer reflecting on my favorite reality TV shows from the 2000s, I can’t help but recall with sadness the way Miriam was treated by her fellow contestants. Her heart-wrenching experiences of rejection and humiliation following public setbacks are a stark reminder of how ruthless and insensitive the reality TV landscape could be during that era.

3 Labor of Love (2020)

1 Season

As a dedicated gamer, I’d rephrase it this way: In “Labor of Love,” a reality TV show, they introduced me as a contestant with a unique goal – to find a partner willing to help me start a family, even if marriage wasn’t an immediate possibility. At 41 years old, my desire for a child was strong, and I was prepared to raise the kid on my own if necessary. The focus of the show was less about romance and more about achieving this dream.

Kristin Davis, famously known as one of “Sex and the City’s” leading ladies, served as the show’s host. She additionally portrayed a trusted friend to Katzmann, engaging in open conversations about her longings for love and starting a family.

The Clock is Ticking

The pursuit of having a child, tainted with a sense of melancholy, is encapsulated in this challenging television concept. With the clock ticking and fertility windows closing, some women are resorting to unconventional methods, such as casting it as an adorable dating show. The process of selecting potential partners based on their genetics can be unsettling, but the overall idea raised eyebrows among viewers and critics alike. Many believe that making such a significant life decision through a competitive format is inappropriate and diminishes the gravity of the situation.

The unique concept sets this dating show apart from the crowd, making it more noteworthy than the average reality TV dating program without its distinctive twist.

2 Sexy Beasts (2014 – 2021)

3 Seasons

Before making its debut on Netflix as an original production, “Sexy Beasts” initially aired on British television. In this unique dating show, a single person went on three blind dates with potential suitors whose identities were concealed under animal and supernatural-themed masks. Consequently, viewers had the intriguing experience of witnessing a panda court an alien or observing Frankenstein’s monster woo a vampire bat.

No Mask Can Hide the Amount of Cringe

Netflix’s reality shows come in various forms, and some can be quite irritating. “Sexy Beasts” stands out as particularly frustrating due to its quirky premise that transforms dating into a carnival spectacle. The prosthetics are impressive, and the idea of not judging people based on appearances has potential. However, the execution is farcical, making it hard to maintain any level of seriousness. Fortunately, “Sexy Beasts” didn’t last long on Netflix.

You can stream Sexy Beasts on Netflix.

1 Love In The Jungle (2022 — Present)

1 Season

The Bloodhound Gang may have foreshadowed the concept of “Love in the Jungle” through their lyrics, “You and me, my dear, are just mammals, so let’s act like animals on the Discovery Channel.” In this reality show, solitary individuals were transported to the stunning Colombian wilderness, where they had to embody an animal of their preference and attempt to win a partner’s affection without uttering a single word.

Strut Your Stuff, Show Those Tail Feathers

The Discovery+ reality TV dating show went relatively unnoticed, given that the platform isn’t typically associated with extravagant dating shows. Nevertheless, it is an intriguing quirk, as the program explores primal attraction through competition and courtship that largely dispenses with verbal communication in favor of grunts and physical gestures.

The program doesn’t provide profound insights about our connection with nature or our communication skills. However, it offers some amusing scenes inadvertently. For instance, competitors are tasked with mimicking animal courtship behaviors, such as those of flamingos and toads.

Read More

2024-07-14 21:02