As a cinephile who has spent countless hours delving into the rich tapestry of Hollywood history, I can’t help but be captivated by the what-ifs and might-have-beens that often lurk in the shadows of our beloved films. Two such instances come to mind, where iconic roles were offered to acting legends Marlon Brando, and we’ll touch upon another one with Harry Belafonte – but alas, they passed on the opportunity.
In the competitive world of Hollywood, securing major roles is tough, and many actors are eager to accept any offered blockbuster part. Rejecting a role could mean missing out on substantial income and potential career growth. However, not all stars face this dilemma. While some struggle to land roles, others remain selective, turning down offers in favor of projects that align more closely with their artistic vision or long-term goals.
Actors pass up on roles for various reasons. Many prominent actors prioritize having an impressive body of work, causing them to decline parts they feel don’t showcase their abilities at their best. Compensation and insufficient free time are additional considerations.
During the pinnacle of his acting success, Marlon Brando passed up on numerous roles, leaving fans to wonder what might have been if he had accepted. In certain cases, his decision was justified, while in others, it may have been to his detriment not to appear on set.
10 Randall P. McMurphy
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1975)
In an unforgettable performance by Jack Nicholson, the character of Randall P. McMurphy from “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest” intentionally feigns insanity to evade labor and unwanted same-sex relationships, thereby getting admitted into a mental institution instead of a penal facility. He anticipates spending his days leisurely sipping milk and napping, but is instead confronted by the oppressive and dominating figure of Nurse Ratched.
Nicholson Was Last in the Pecking Order
In an unexpected turn of events, Nicholson secured the role that earned him a Best Actor Oscar and propelled him into A-list fame. Initially an underdog for the part, he was originally the last choice of the directors. Noteworthy names like Marlon Brando, Kirk Douglas, James Caan, Gene Hackman, and Burt Reynolds were initially favored for the role, but they all opted to work on other projects instead.
In his role as a seasoned actor known for portraying defiant characters, Brando would have skillfully brought McMurphy’s gestures to life as he clashed against Nurse Ratched’s repressive rules. It’s quite possible that another Oscar would have been added to his collection, but he likely had no remorse over his choice. A year afterwards, they collaborated on Arthur Penn’s western, “The Missouri Breaks,” with Nicholson joining Brando in the cast.
9 T.E. Lawrence
Lawrence of Arabia (1962)
The classic film “Lawrence of Arabia” still seems as new and captivating as it did when initially released. It’s challenging to envision the movie without Peter O’Toole’s powerful portrayal of T. E. Lawrence. In World War I, this British Army lieutenant was dispatched to evaluate Prince Faisal’s potential against the Turks. Rather than adhering to his orders, Lawrence assumed additional tasks and ultimately exerted a significant impact on the conflict.
Geographically-Inspired Reasons
Adrian Turner’s book “The Making of David Lean’s Lawrence of Arabia” reveals that Alec Guinness and Anthony Perkins were initially considered for the title role. However, producer Sam Spiegel ultimately chose Marlon Brando for the part. Spiegel made a public announcement at a press conference about Brando’s casting, but to everyone’s surprise, Brando decided to take on the challenge of “Mutiny on the Bounty” instead.
An unfortunate decision for the actor as the film received a divide opinion from critics, in contrast to “Lawrence of Arabia,” which was universally praised and brought O’Toole a Best Actor nomination.
When sharing why he declined the part, Brando disclosed his desire to experience something on his life’s wishlist. In his autobiography, he selected “Bounty” as it was being shot in Tahiti, a place that captivated him for decades. He found this more appealing than enduring six months in the desert.
8 Mr. X
JFK (1991)
As a history enthusiast with a deep interest in the JFK assassination theory, I find the portrayal of “JFK” as America’s most intriguing and controversial movies to be both captivating and thought-provoking. The film, which posits that there was a government conspiracy to assassinate President John F. Kennedy, and that Lee Harvey Oswald was merely a patsy, is a compelling narrative that continues to fuel debates and discussions among scholars and the general public.
Stone Believes He Got the Better Actor
Oliver Stone shared with Truthout that his initial choice for the role was Marlon Brando, but he ultimately went with Kiefer Sutherland. Stone expressed gratitude for Brando’s decision to decline because “his improvisations during monologues would have extended that dialogue significantly.”
For a filmmaker, keeping the pace fast was essential for “JFK,” similar to most thrillers. Marlon Brando, an alum of “The Godfather,” may not have been the ideal choice due to this requirement. However, supporters of Brando would argue that he could have delivered a more compelling performance. Regardless, Sutherland’s acting in the film was not considered exceptional enough by any award-granting bodies despite receiving several nominations.
7 Vulcan
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen (1988)
The Unusual Tales of Baron Munchausen
A Memorable Meeting
Oliver Reed portrayed Vulcan in the film, a part originally intended for Marlon Brando. As per Rolling Stone, Terry Gilliam attempted to cast Brando but was unsuccessful. Instead of addressing the current issue, Brando regaled Gilliam with stories about attempting to court Sophia Loren during the production of “A Countess from Hong Kong.” He ultimately declined the offer.
On this occasion, the actor displayed good judgment since the film encountered numerous production issues and did not generate sufficient revenue at the box office. Additionally, Brando’s portrayal of Vulcan, a comical character, was quite different from his usual roles as an intelligent or intimidating figure.
6 Chief Old Lodge Skins
Little Big Man (1970)
The story of Little Big Man, told in a series of flashbacks, begins with Jack Crabb, who is 121 years old, recounting his experiences to a historian. He shares how, as a young boy of ten, he witnessed the tragic massacre of his parents by the Pawnee tribe. After this traumatic event, Jack was taken in and raised by the kind-hearted Cheyenne leader, Old Lodge Skins. The role of Old Lodge Skins is brought to life on screen by Chief Dan George, a genuine chief from the Tsleil-Waututh Nation.
Brando’s Love for Native Americans
Despite the challenges of collaborating with Brando, his advocacy for human rights touched many hearts. He bravely refused his Oscar for “The Godfather,” bringing attention to the unfair representation of Native Americans in Hollywood. Whenever possible, he took action to make a difference.
In the film “Little Big Man,” Marlon Brando was initially chosen by the studio to portray Chief Old Lodge Skins due to Hollywood’s common practice of assigning white actors to non-white roles. However, Brando declined the offer, advocating for a Native American actor to take on the part instead. Consequently, Chief Dan George, who had limited acting background, assumed the role and delivered an impressive performance that earned him a nomination for Best Supporting Actor.
5 Lewis Medlock
Deliverance (1972)
According to James Dickey’s novel “Deliverance,” four married city men – Lewis Medlock, Bobby Trippe, Ed Gentry, and Drew Ballinger – decide to escape the monotony of urban life by going on a canoeing trip in beautiful rural Georgia. Regrettably, their adventure turns sour when they encounter hostile locals, putting their lives at risk and forcing them into a desperate struggle for survival.
Pay Issues
In this scenario, it’s not difficult to picture Lewis in the what-if casting, given his egocentric and amoral nature. He would have perfectly showcased Brando’s talents. However, Brando’s absence didn’t leave a gaping hole. Instead, an equally impressive character, Burt Reynolds, stepped into the role.
Based on Vanity Fair’s report, Brando sought higher compensation than his current earnings, an demand the studio was unwilling to consider. Quoted in response was studio head Ted Ashley, “I would be ridiculed if I paid half a million for Brando.”
4 John ‘Joker’ Jackson
The Defiant Ones (1958)
Amidst the turbulent racial climate in America, The Defiant Ones tells the story of Noah Cullen (Sidney Poitier), a black prison escapee, and John “Joker” Jackson (Tony Curtis), his white counterpart. Their escape from prison occurs after an unfortunate accident with the transporting truck, leaving them shackled together. Regardless of their deep-seated animosity towards one another, they must work in unity to ensure their own survival.
Kramer’s Quest to Get Portier
Sydney Poitier was the actor that Stanley Kramer strongly preferred for his film, despite Marlon Brando’s greater popularity. However, Poitier wasn’t readily available at first, as reported by the American Film Institute. Nevertheless, Kramer was determined to wait for Poitier and postpone production for months. Unfortunately, this extended timeline conflicted with Brando’s schedule, leading him to ultimately withdraw from the project.
In his role as an actor who championed against racial discrimination and participated in civil rights marches, Brando could have taken pride in having “The Defiant Ones” added to his list of accomplishments. Furthermore, Poitier and Curtis earned Best Actor nominations for their parts in the film, meaning that Brando missed out on an opportunity to be recognized with an Oscar.
3 Will Kane
High Noon (1952)
Often praised as one of the best western films ever made due to its innovative storyline and live-action style, “High Noon” tells the story of Marshall Will Kane (played by Gary Cooper). As he prepares for a peaceful retirement with his new bride, an impending threat forces him to put his plans on hold.
As a weary gamer, I was looking forward to a blissful day of rest, snuggling up with my beloved in bed and sharing gentle words. But just as I was about to drift off, a pesky notification popped up – an outlaw I once apprehended was being released from prison and would be arriving at the train station by noon. My heart raced as I weighed my options: should I sneak away with my wife and hide until the danger passed, or bravely face the threat head-on? With a heavy sigh, I decided to stay and fight, much to the disappointment of my longing bride.
A Missed Opportunity to Become a Western Legend
Despite Marlon Brando’s illustrious acting resume, he never landed the quintessential leading role in a Western film. This part could have solidified his legend within the genre, but it slipped through his fingers. Nevertheless, Brando remains iconic as Don Corleone, which is no small feat.
In the Western tale, John Wayne was a leading contender for the part, but he declined due to his conviction that the movie symbolically represented the Hollywood Blacklist, an issue he identified with. As reported by Vanity Fair, the film’s producers subsequently considered engaging less expensive options such as Marlon Brando, Charlton Heston, and Montgomery Clift. Sadly, none of them accepted the offer.
2 John Norman Howard
A Star is Born (1976)
The original version of A Star is Born revolves around the romance between Esther (Barbra Streisand) an up-and-coming singer, and John (Kris Kristofferson) a world-famous rock and roll singer. Soon, their career projections take opposite routes. Esther becomes a popular singer, while John starts losing relevance because of his alcoholism and general hedonism.
Brando Would Have Been the Best Pick
USA Today reported that Brando and Elvis Presley were considered for the part of John. Presley seemed like the top choice due to his musical history, but he asked for a high salary. Similarly, Brando sought a substantial wage because of his global recognition following “The Godfather.” Ultimately, neither actor was selected, and the role went to Kris instead.
Brando likely didn’t regret missing out on the project as the original film received harsh criticism from critics. In contrast, the remake featuring Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga was praised with numerous awards. However, the initial production could have benefited greatly from Brando’s exceptional acting skills. Although it’s unfortunate that we didn’t get to see him in the role, fans can still appreciate the improved version of the story.
1 Harry R. Caul
The Conversation (1974)
In simpler terms, “The Conversation” by Francis Ford Coppola tells the story of Harry Caul, played by Gene Hackman, a skilled surveillance specialist. He is hired to monitor a young couple at the behest of an enigmatic figure and his associates. As Harry delves deeper into the assignment, he becomes increasingly apprehensive, convinced that the very people who engaged him may pose a threat to their targets. Moreover, his deep-rooted Catholic beliefs and emotional baggage from a previous investigation push him to intervene.
Too Basic for Brando
After the success of “The Godfather,” Coppola apparently relished the idea of collaborating with Brando once more. He attempted to recruit him on two separate occasions. However, it wasn’t until many years later that he managed to secure Brando’s commitment for “Apocalypse Now.” Despite Coppola’s efforts, Brando declined to play Harry Caul in the film. According to Far Out Magazine, Brando was straightforward in his refusal to Coppola: “I think it’s excellent. It just isn’t for me.”
In “The Conversation,” which featured alums from “Godfather” such as John Cazale and Robert Duvall, Brando might have felt comfortable. Nevertheless, he chose not to be part of the cast despite his impressive resume. Fortunately, Hackman delivered an exceptional performance and enjoyed the experience immensely, referring to the movie as “the best I’ve made in my career.”
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-07-21 19:02