The Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

As a film enthusiast and connoisseur of remarkable performances, I can confidently say that James Gandolfini left an indelible mark on the world of cinema with his iconic roles. Among these unforgettable portrayals, Tony Soprano from “The Sopranos” stands as the epitome of Gandolfini’s genius.


Aficionados of crime dramas likely recognize some well-known titles within the genre such as “The Godfather”, “The Godfather Part II”, “Scarface”, “Goodfellas”, “The Sopranos”, and “Boardwalk Empire”. Notably, these productions have often featured esteemed actors like Al Pacino, Robert De Niro, Ray Liotta, Steve Buscemi, among others, either collaborating or appearing individually. Although many actors in this genre may struggle with typecasting, they generally display remarkable versatility and consistently offer captivating performances across various films, television series, and even video games that span diverse genres.

As a die-hard film lover, I can’t help but reflect on the captivating journey of the talented James Gandolfini from New Jersey. Kicking off his acting career in 1987 with the fantasy comedy “Shock! Shock! Shock!” directed by Arn McConnell and Todd Rutt, he played an orderly. From there, he built a solid foundation with numerous supporting roles before breaking through as the hitman Virgil in Tony Scott’s romantic crime film “True Romance” in 1993.

Although James Gandolfini passed away in 2013, his remarkable acting career has left a lasting legacy that continues to inspire artists, critics, and fans alike for over ten years since then. This article aims to pay tribute to the esteemed actor by analyzing some of his most impactful and well-received performances.

17 Zero Dark Thirty

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

Kathryn Bigelow’s movie titled “Zero Dark Thirty” was released in 2012 to widespread global praise. This film tells the story of the 2011 mission to capture al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden, along with the intrigue and tension that surrounded this operation. The stellar cast features Jessica Chastain, Jason Clarke, Kyle Chandler, Mark Strong, Joel Edgerton, and Chris Pratt among others.

Gandolfini’s Brief-Yet-Impactful Appearance

Although Gandolfini briefly appears in Zero Dark Thirty, he goes against type in an exceptional performance as CIA director, Leon Panetta, portraying him as an austere man who takes his job as one of America’s leaders seriously. He makes the most of his limited screen time and his presence as the severe Panetta only adds to the intensity of the events depicted and reflects how important the mission was for the United States. Stream on Hulu.

16 Romance & Cigarettes

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

In the 2005 film “Romance & Cigarettes,” construction worker Nick Murder (the family man) embarks on a secret romance with a lively young woman, portrayed by Kate Winslet. This movie is set in 1980s New York City. When his wife Kitty (Susan Sarandon) finds out about the scandalous relationship after discovering an explicit poem meant for his mistress, Nick’s life takes a dramatic turn, and he must confront the consequences of his actions.

Gandolfini Lets Loose in Eccentric Musical

Gandolfini really got out of his comfort zone when he headlined the quirky rom-com musical, as friend and fellow actor John Turturro specifically wanted him to tackle the role of Nick Murder but had to wait until The Sopranos was finished filming its season. Seeing the normally serious performer break out into a zippy dance and lip sync along to famous tunes like “A Man Without Love” by Engelbert Humperdinck was a real treat for fans of Gandolfini, and it was a welcome switch-up to his more normally stoic portrayals and characters. Stream on The Roku Channel.

15 8mm

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

In 1999, the crime thriller titled 8mm, directed by the late Joel Schumacher, featured the incredibly gifted Nicolas Cage. This movie delved into the realms of BDSM and snuff films. Alongside Cage and Gandolfini, the film boasted Catherine Keener, Joaquin Phoenix, Peter Stormare, and Chris Bauer in supporting roles. Despite its impressive cast, strong box office performance, and technical prowess, 8mm was generally panned by critics, who found issue with the movie’s mature themes and violent scenes, suggesting it may not be suitable for viewing.

A Bright Spot in an Underwhelming Thriller

Despite facing criticism for his involvement in the disturbing world of snuff films, Eddie Poole’s portrayal by Gandolfini was often recognized as a highlight. In this grim and twisted profession, Poole stood out because he was the only character who seemed to feel any regret for his role. While others in his line of work saw it as merely business or enjoyment, Poole subtly showed remorse through his actions within the snuff film industry. Watch it on Hulu.

14 Where the Wild Things Are

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

In 2009, Spike Jonze’s fantasy adventure drama Where the Wild Things Are, modeled after Maurice Sendak’s 1963 children’s novel of the same name, presents a tale about Max, a solitary nine-year-old boy. After his mother sends him to bed without supper as punishment, he embarks on an adventure to an island populated by strange, beastly creatures known as Wild Things.

Gandolfini Showcases His Range

In Jonze’s modernized adaptation of a timeless children’s tale, James Gandolfini deviated significantly from his usual roles. This part demanded a blend of computer-generated imagery (CGI), heavy makeup and prosthetics, and the ability to convey anger, sadness, and deep affection for a friend – all while never physically appearing on screen. Although many viewers are more accustomed to Gandolfini’s performances in crime series, his portrayal of the troubled creature Carol underscores his versatility and solidifies his unique presence among crime drama actors. Watch it now on Max.

13 Welcome to the Rileys

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

In the 2010 indie drama “Welcome to the Rileys,” James Gandolfini and Melissa Leo play Doug and Lois Riley, a couple grappling with the aftermath of their daughter’s passing, growing increasingly distant as they grapple with their grief. When Doug encounters the equally lost teenager Mallory (Kristen Stewart), who mirrors his own pain, both characters assist each other in emerging from their shadows and forge a powerful relationship that profoundly impacts their lives.

A Raw & Moving Portrayal

In a truly exceptional manner, Gandolfini shone brightest in the film “Welcome to the Rileys, ” portraying Doug, a heartbroken father whose world collapses after the untimely demise of his cherished teenage daughter. His character forms a deep bond with Mallory, a troubled 16-year-old stripper, whom he attempts to aid, feeling helpless over his own child’s safety. Gandolfini’s performance was both painfully authentic and multi-layered, adding depth to the drama that became a profoundly impactful and emotional experience. Watch it on Tubi.

12 12 Angry Men

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

The 1997 courtroom drama “12 Angry Men,” directed by William Friedkin, is a modern retelling of the 1957 classic by Sidney Lumet, featuring Henry Fonda. In this version, notable actors like Jack Lemmon, Ossie Davis, Edward James Olmos, Courtney B. Vance, Mykelti Williamson, and George C. Scott take on the roles. Notably, this was the final project for the late James Gandolfini before his breakthrough role in the highly praised series “The Sopranos.

Gandolfini Helps Elevate Remake

As a movie enthusiast, instead of portraying Tony Soprano in that classic mob series, Gandolfini takes on the role of Juror #6 in this film. This character is composed and courteous, always working to preserve harmony amongst his fellow jurors. Given the legendary stature of Lumet’s adaptation, which has been extensively studied for its themes, it’s remarkable that Friedkin’s version still stands strong today, thanks in part to Gandolfini’s understated performance. Take a look at this timeless piece on Apple TV+.

11 Sesame Street

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

Even though adding a Sesame Street episode to our list might seem as unusual as James Gandolfini’s appearance on that children’s program, we believe our rationale will make it understandable. In the year 2000, The Sopranos was at its peak of fame, garnering widespread acclaim from critics and audiences globally. It significantly shaped what is now referred to as “prestige television,” and is frequently cited as one of the best, if not the best, TV series ever made. Furthermore, Gandolfini earned his first Primetime Emmy Award for The Sopranos, giving him the opportunity to star in any project during breaks from the HBO mafia drama.

A Fun & Heartwarming Appearance

It’s intriguing to note that Gandolfini chose to make an appearance in Episode 33 of Sesame Street, starring in a touching segment about overcoming fears. For those who are familiar with The Sopranos, Tony is a multifaceted and troubled character known for his explosive outbursts, so it’s unexpected that he would reveal his fears to anyone, save perhaps Dr. Melfi. Therefore, witnessing Gandolfini playing a fictionalized version of himself in a sketch admitting his fear of the dark, bad haircuts, and oversized vegetables is amusing, puzzling, and testament to the actor’s light-hearted approach to life. Watch now on Max.

10 Lonely Hearts

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

People were eager to know what Gandolfini’s next venture would be after The Sopranos ended in 2007. Instead of sticking with his familiar roles, he chose an unexpected path, starring as Detective Charles Hilderbrandt in Todd Robinson’s period drama, Lonely Hearts. This character was a sarcastic yet loyal lawman who tirelessly pursued a series of murders in 1940s New York City, inspired by the real-life Lonely Hearts Killers.

A Worthy Follow-Up to The Sopranos

After his iconic role, James Gandolfini opted to star in a less mainstream film rather than a big-budget summer movie from Hollywood. The movie’s box office earnings were nothing extraordinary, but it managed to captivate audiences, with Gandolfini’s performance being one of the key factors that made it relatable to viewers. Unfortunately, it is currently not available for streaming.

9 In the Loop

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

Armando Iannucci’s 2009 film, titled “In the Loop“, is derived from his BBC television series called “The Thick of It“. This movie uses humor to criticize many aspects of American politics, primarily focusing on issues related to the war on terror and the invasion of Iraq. Critics appreciated its witty satire, and it even received a nomination for the Academy Award in the Best Adapted Screenplay category.

Gandolfini Flexes His Acting Muscles

In a noticeable change from his New Jersey tone, James Gandolfini portrays Lieutenant General George Miller, a character who is against the prolonged U.S. invasion of Iraq. Sharing the screen with British comedy icons Peter Capaldi and Steve Coogan, Gandolfini delivers witty remarks and humorous facial expressions that prove his comedic acting prowess. Watch or Purchase on Prime Video.

8 Perdita Durango

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

The 1997 film, titled “Perdita Durango,” was a cinematic adaptation by Spanish director Álex de la Iglesia of Barry Gifford’s 1992 novel “59° and Raining: The Story of Perdita Durango.” This movie stars Rosie Perez and Javier Bardem. Similar to many other works by Gifford, such as “Wild at Heart” and “Lula and Sailor’s Holiday,” “Perdita Durango” is set in the world of his Sailor and Lula series and introduces some of the most eccentric characters and wild storylines ever penned.

A Scene-Stealing Performance

The violent themes in the movie failed to resonate with viewers, but James Gandolfini’s portrayal of the devoted DEA Agent Willie “Woody” Dumas was a standout aspect. This performance underscored Gandolfini’s versatility as an actor and his knack for immersing himself completely into any character he played. Now available on Freevee.

7 The Taking of Pelham 123

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

In 2009, Tony Scott remade the novel “The Taking of Pelham 123” by John Godey for the third time. This movie features a powerhouse cast including Denzel Washington, John Travolta, John Turturro, and Gandolfini. The film is just as intense and action-packed as its star-studded lineup suggests. Notably, this project marks the second teaming of Travolta and Gandolfini, the second collaboration between Scott and Gandolfini, and the third time Washington has worked with Gandolfini. In this 2009 thriller, each actor gives an outstanding performance.

A Worthy Remake of the ’70s Classic

In this movie, the response was fairly balanced between critical acclaim and commercial success. However, it was the acting skills of the cast that truly won over both audiences and critics. James Gandolfini portrays the Mayor of New York City in this production, a role reminiscent of his performance in In the Loop. He adopts a New York accent instead of his usual New Jersey one, immersing himself perfectly into the character of the Big Apple’s Mayor, which fans of his have thoroughly enjoyed. Watch/Purchase on Amazon Prime Video.

6 Killing Them Softly

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

Andrew Dominik’s 2012 crime-thriller movie titled “Killing Them Softly” features Brad Pitt as Jackie Cogan, a merciless assassin carrying out his hits coinciding with the inauguration of former U.S. President Barack Obama. Originally based on the 1974 novel “Cogan’s Trade” by George V. Higgins, the movie didn’t receive significant acclaim at the box office or from critics upon its release. However, it has since garnered a dedicated following over the past decade. The film marked the third collaboration between Pitt and Gandolfini, allowing for a display of Gandolfini’s more restrained and introspective acting style.

Gandolfini Brilliantly Embraces His Dark Side

In contrast to Tony Soprano, the ruthless characters portrayed by Gandolfini before, Mickey appears worn-out and disillusioned, a departure from what we’re accustomed to seeing the actor deliver. Despite having minimal screen time, Mickey stands out due to his profound dissatisfaction with life, choosing indulgence over confronting issues. Although many of us may not be involved in organized crime, we can all identify with feelings of doubt and unease, and Gandolfini’s portrayal beautifully encapsulates these sentiments. Stream/Purchase on Apple TV+.

5 The Drop

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

2014 saw the release of Michaël R. Roskam’s crime drama titled “The Drop“. Although it didn’t fare well at the box office, it garnered appreciation from both critics and viewers. The movie was lauded for its thoughtfully crafted script, grim portrayal of organized crime, and the acting prowess displayed by its ensemble cast. Particularly noteworthy were the performances of Tom Hardy and Gandolfini, who received rave reviews for their exceptional, unexpected chemistry on screen.

A Complex & Committed Portrayal

Hardy takes on the role of Bob, a character deeply entangled with the mob, while Gandolfini portrays Marv, his cousin who owns a bar. Initially, it appears that Marv cares for Bob, but as the story unfolds, we discover that Marv owes money to a merciless Chechen gang and is prepared to do whatever necessary to repay his debt.

Watching Gandolfini play a character who’d go to any lengths to save himself is both chilling and amusing, given that many of his tough guy roles would vehemently reject Marv’s tactics. Moreover, Marv stands out among the characters in Gandolfini’s esteemed film career as he was one of its final portrayals. Stream/Purchase on Amazon Prime Video.

4 The Mexican

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

In 2001, Gore Verbinski directed the intriguing mix of road trip and crime-thriller film called “The Mexican,” which featured Brad Pitt, Julia Roberts, and James Gandolfini in pivotal roles. The story revolves around Jerry (Pitt) and Sam (Roberts) as they embark on a mission to retrieve an old gun belonging to a merciless criminal mastermind. During their journey, they cross paths with a supposed hitman named Leroy, who informs Sam that she must keep herself safe until Jerry hands over the gun.

Gandolfini’s Poignant Performance

Unlike what one might expect from an assassin, Leroy develops a unique connection with Sam over time. As it turns out, he’s deeply romantic at heart, and she endeavors to assist him in finding love. Although the film received mixed opinions, Gandolfini’s portrayal of a man grappling with life’s enigmas as a homosexual resonated strongly with both critics and viewers. Moreover, the performances of Gandolfini and Roberts were highly commended, frequently being cited as the movie’s most noteworthy aspects. Watch it on Paramount+.

3 Enough Said

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

When we imagine romantic comedies, we often have set ideas about their content. We usually picture the main characters as youthful and good-looking, or the plot filled with exaggerated humor. However, Nicole Holofcener’s film Enough Said challenges these conventions, as Gandolfini and Julia Louis-Dreyfus make an unlikely onscreen pair, and the humor is subtle rather than over-the-top.

Sensational On-Screen Chemistry

In the movie “Enough Said,” Tony Gandolfini portrays Albert, a divorced middle-aged man with a grown child, who is once again venturing into the dating scene. At a gathering, he meets Eva, played by Julia Louis-Dreyfus, and they soon go out on a date. Gandolfini’s acting in this film showcases his versatility as an actor, convincingly depicting a middle-aged man who is both exhilarated and apprehensive about dating at his stage in life. Fox Searchlight Pictures dedicated the movie to Gandolfini, who sadly passed away before its premiere. While the film was widely acclaimed, the standout aspects were the performances by Dreyfus and Gandolfini in director Nicole Holofcener’s romantic comedy. You can watch it on Hulu.

2 True Romance

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

1993’s romantic-crime-thriller “True Romance” was penned by Quentin Tarantino and helmed by the late Tony Scott. This film chronicles the tale of a young couple, Clarence and Alabama, who unwittingly get entangled with the Italian mafia and their illicit substances. Despite not performing well at the box office initially, “True Romance” garnered critical acclaim for its witty dialogue, vibrant characters, and innovative take on the crime genre.

Moreover, “True Romance” signifies Tony Soprano actor James Gandolfini’s debut collaboration with director Scott and Hollywood heavyweight Brad Pitt. In this film, Gandolfini embodies Virgil, a trusted enforcer of Vincenzo Coccotti in the mob. His subtle smile and commanding presence hint that it’s wise to avoid any confrontation with Virgil from the start.

An Impactful & Career-Defining Performance

Despite having a minor role, Virgil is involved in one of the movie’s most impactful scenes alongside Patricia Arquette’s character, Alabama. In this intense scene set within a motel room, Alabama resorts to using whatever objects she finds as weapons in a violent altercation. The confrontation concludes with Alabama defending herself by killing Virgil.

In the movie True Romance, although Virgil’s screen time is limited, his subtle humor and confrontation with Alabama are standout moments that rival the earlier Sicilian scene featuring Christopher Walken and the late Dennis Hopper. Tony Gandolfini’s portrayal of Virgil was so striking, it earned him an audition for The Sopranos, which eventually led to Susan Fitzgerald, a casting director, selecting him for the iconic role of Tony Soprano. Watch/Purchase on Amazon Prime Video.

1 The Sopranos

The Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, RankedThe Best James Gandolfini Performances, Ranked

Without a doubt, our top choice for James Gandolfini’s most memorable character is his portrayal of Tony Soprano, the New Jersey mafia boss. This role earned him an impressive 21 Primetime Emmy Awards out of 111 nominations. Created and produced by David Chase, “The Sopranos” premiered on HBO on January 10, 1999, quickly becoming a significant part of pop culture. Over its six-season run, the series offered 86 thoughtfully written episodes filled with intriguing characters, deep reflections on life, and a fresh take on the crime drama genre through its captivating dream sequences. Among the numerous accolades it received, Gandolfini’s portrayal of Tony Soprano is one of the reasons that helped “The Sopranos” achieve its legendary status.

A Truly Unforgettable & Unparalleled Performance

He perfectly portrayed a family man and an overworked mob boss seemingly with ease and brought a vulnerability not often seen in characters in the crime drama genre. With the show’s conclusion in 2007, other acclaimed shows with villain-protagonists would emerge, such as Mad Men (created by The Sopranos writer Matthew Weiner), Breaking Bad, Dexter, and Boardwalk Empire (created by The Sopranos writer Terrence Winter).

I can’t help but marvel at how profoundly Tony Soprano reshaped the television landscape; Vince Gilligan, the genius behind “Breaking Bad,” admitted that there wouldn’t have been a Walter White without Soprano. James Gandolfini, with his versatile acting skills, breathed life into Soprano in a way that was strikingly authentic, both physically and emotionally. His performances as a man grappling with severe trauma were nothing short of extraordinary, earning him three Emmy Awards. Even years after the show ended, his portrayal continues to captivate generations of fans. Catch it on Max.

Read More

2024-09-22 00:33