10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

As a longtime aficionado of chilling tales and spine-tingling suspense, I found myself utterly captivated by the dual offerings of Lyle and Fright Night. The former, with its poignant exploration of motherhood anxieties, serves as an impressive reinterpretation of Rosemary’s Baby, while the latter delivers a delightful blend of supernatural horror and comedy that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats.


When asked about their initial response to one of their favorite movies being remade, it’s highly likely that they would express strong disapproval. Though remakes might offer the chance to re-examine an excellent story from a new perspective, the numerous poorly received remakes have left moviegoers with a bitter taste.

Furthermore, it’s often challenging to successfully remake a movie. When the idea of replicating the enchantment of an initial film arises, a dedicated team strives diligently to preserve the loyalty of fans while expanding the narrative for a broader audience. During production, unforeseen circumstances can arise; actor replacements, contentious modifications to the plotline, and even significant transformations in a character’s traits and motivations.

In the realm of horror films, remakes often provoke an unsettling sensation in viewers due to concerns about studios prioritizing profits over artistic integrity and the diverse abilities of the chosen cast. Yet, history has demonstrated that a well-executed remake can not only preserve the original’s alluring aspects but also infuse it with innovative risks.

For Halloween this year, why not spend the season revisiting some lesser-known, yet awe-inspiring remakes of timeless horror movies that managed to both astound and petrify viewers at the same time?

10 The Hills Have Eyes (2006)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

The horror movie “The Hills Have Eyes,” created by Alexandre Aja and Grégory Levasseur, marks their first venture into English-language filmmaking. This remake of the 1997 Wes Craven film shares the same title, and it chronicles the Carter family’s seemingly ordinary road trip that takes a terrifying turn when their vehicle breaks down in a remote location. Unbeknownst to them, they find themselves in grave danger from hideous mutants with an insatiable appetite for humans. As the family fights to see another sunrise, they maneuver around the mutants and concoct a survival strategy. However, even their determination fails to prevent the barren desert landscape from transforming into a hauntingly vivid shade of red.

Blood And Monsters Galore

Previously mentioned, the 2006 film represents an adaptation of Craven’s initial concept. The 1977 version received praise for its pace, dark humor, and creative storyline, but the newer version garnered mixed opinions, with critics such as Roger Ebert suggesting that it emphasized violence over character development. Furthermore, some reviewers criticized the film as “torture porn” due to what they perceived as excessive gore. Despite these mixed reviews, for those who appreciate a certain brutality in their antagonists, revisiting The Hills Have Eyes is suitable for both long-time fans and newcomers alike.

9 My Bloody Valentine 3D (2009)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

The movie titled “My Bloody Valentine 3D” reunites actors such as Jensen Ackles, Jaime King, Kerr Smith, and Kevin Tighe in a remake based on the 1981 Canadian film with the same name. This new iteration is set primarily in Harmony, a small mining town where a tragic mine accident ten years ago took the lives of several prominent residents and sparked a gruesome killing spree, attributed to Harry Warden, one of the miners who was suspected of murdering his fellow workers to save oxygen.

To prevent Warden’s schemes from causing chaos, Sarah Mercer-Palmer (Jaime King) and her brother Sheriff Axel-Palmer (Kerr Smith) join forces with Tom Hanniger (Ackles), the son of the mine’s proprietor, with the intention of foiling his disruptive plans.

A Flashy, Small Town Slasher

In the vein of classic horror flicks, the movie “My Bloody Valentine 3D” garnered generally favorable reviews, with critics noting that it blends old-school horror elements and contemporary technology to produce a satisfyingly chilling thriller. The film stands out for its exploration of Harmony’s folklore and Harry Warden’s backstory, as well as the complex dynamics among the townspeople. The movie delivers on gruesome, gory deaths, which are even more unsettling thanks to the characters’ connections and the immersive 3D technology. As such, it makes for a suitable choice for horror enthusiasts looking for a thrilling watch in the run-up to Halloween.

8 Willard (2003)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

As I sat down to watch “Willard,” directed by Glen Morgan, I found myself drawn into the world of the titular character, an outcast (portrayed brilliantly by Crispin Glover) who endures torment from his ill mother, Henrietta (Jackie Burroughs), and his cruel boss, Frank Martin (R. Lee Ermey). Yet, Willard finds a unique companionship in a white rat named Socrates, which he befriends amidst the chaos of his life.

Bone-Chilling on All Fronts

In the style of its 1971 predecessor, the film’s praise will primarily revolve around Crispin Glover’s exceptional performance. Known for his captivating portrayals of peculiar characters, Glover skillfully illustrates how Willard transforms into the film’s menacing villain, aided by his legion of four-legged companions. The movie masterfully explores horror from various perspectives, offering viewers a mix of the grotesque, the psychologically harrowing, and the truly revolting. For those seeking an underappreciated tale that leaves audiences with thought-provoking questions, Willard could be the perfect story to explore.

7 House of Wax (2005)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

The movie titled “House of Wax” revolves around a group of friends, primarily Carly Jones (played by Elisha Cuthbert), who find themselves in peril after venturing into a spooky town called Ambrose. As they uncover family mysteries, Carly and her companions try to dodge wax sculptures with sinister intentions. With an estimated budget of $40 million, the movie grossed $70.1 million at the box office. Although it didn’t receive fantastic reviews, there are ardent supporters who appreciate its numerous appealing aspects.

An Overlooked Horror That Gets to the Point

2005’s movie received harsh criticism from critics who felt it didn’t measure up to its 1953 counterpart, both named “Mystery of The Wax Museum.” However, some reviews have praised it as a somewhat enjoyable flick, particularly due to Paris Hilton’s stint in the cast. For instance, critics at the San Francisco Chronicle and The Washington Post gave it four out of five stars, emphasizing its entertaining aspects. If you decide to watch this film, do so for the chance to see one of Elisha Cuthbert’s top-notch performances on screen.

6 Let Me In (2010)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

Let Me In is a 2010 romantic horror movie featuring Dylan Minnette (from 13 Reasons Why), Chloë Grace Moretz (Kick Ass), and Kodi Smit-McPhee (The Road)). The film primarily revolves around 12-year old Owen (played by Smit-McPhee) who is often tormented by a group of bullies, led by Kenny (Minnette). A new neighbor named Abby (Moretz) moves in and Owen befriends her. As their bond deepens, Owen discovers Abby’s unusual background that appears to link with a series of mysterious assaults.

A Daunting, Eerie Coming-of-Age Classic

Let Me In, reminiscent of the 2008 Swedish film Let the Right One In, provides audiences with emotionally resonant moments, heartwarming displays of friendship, and a coming-of-age tale that leaves an impact. For horror enthusiasts, it also delivers the expected dose of blood and fangs. The performances of the young actors enhance the film’s engaging premise and have garnered praise from critics. Critics have particularly commended its focus on character intimacy and ability to evoke fear in viewers. Let Me In skillfully combines tender camaraderie with suspense, making it ideal for those seeking a blend of emotion and horror.

5 The Town That Dreaded Sundown (2014)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

“The Town That Shuddered on Sundown

A Gritty, Ultimately Successful Experiment

Presented as a “metafictional follow-up” to the 1976 movie with the same title, the film The Town That Dreaded Sundown delivers on creativity. It excels in its narrative approach and connection to the original work, offering the usual dose of fear and suspense, but going beyond the norm by creating a palpable tension that permeates throughout the movie. Although it largely follows as a direct sequel, the unique style of The Town That Dreaded Sundown manages to make it a memorable watch.

4 Maniac (2012)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

In a genre where most slasher films concentrate on the victims, I find “Maniac” remarkably intriguing, sharing similarities with “American Psycho.” It offers audiences a captivating and disquieting peek into the life and mind of a serial killer, Frank Zito, portrayed by Elijah Wood. By day, he runs his family’s mannequin repair business, but at night, we bear witness to his chilling acts of violence and mutilation. While the film does tread on questionable grounds when it comes to mental health representation, it still stands out as an undervalued psychological thriller that’s rich in intrigue and worth appreciating.

An Unnerving Yet Underappreciated Terror

A multitude of reviewers have been drawn to applaud Wood’s acting, and it’s not hard to see why. His depiction of Frank is undeniably haunting and ominous, causing shivers to run through viewers. The camera work enhances this sense of fear by filming primarily from Zito’s point of view, revealing only his face whenever a mirror or camera comes into sight. As the background story unfolds, a complex mix of empathy and revulsion arises, making for a demanding movie that provides horror enthusiasts with the desired harshness and gore they crave.

3 The Crazies (2010)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

In a small rural Iowa town named Ogden Marsh, the chilling sci-fi horror film “The Crazies” unfolds. The story revolves around four friends who find themselves grappling with the increasingly alarming behavior of their fellow townsfolk. A seemingly ordinary resident disrupts a local baseball game by brandishing a shotgun and attempting to kill attendees, but Sheriff David Dulton (Timothy Olyphant) successfully thwarts this initial threat. However, it soon becomes clear that this is not an isolated incident. Throughout the film, David and his allies uncover a shocking secret capable of turning the town upside down, with devastating consequences already underway.

A Whirlwind of Lies and Fear

The 20XX remake of the 1973 film titled “The Crazies” has been praised by critics for effectively portraying the fear and chaos that sweeps through a town following each violent incident. Delving deeper into theories about government mismanagement and its treatment of citizens, “The Crazies” also aligns with thought-provoking science fiction narratives that examine power structures, accountability within institutions, and their efforts to dodge blame for their actions.

Often praised as an impressive reboot that matches or surpasses its predecessor in terms of allure and acting, “The Crazies” is definitely recommended for those seeking a dose of suspense and mystery in their entertainment.

2 Lyle (2014)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

Hailing from the genius of Stewart Thorndike, the horror movie titled “Lyle” subtly weaves in a link to its base narrative that discerning viewers might spot. Set in a tranquil town, a newly settled lesbian duo – Leah (Gaby Hoffmann) and June (Ingrid Jungermann), who are trying to recover from the loss of their child, find themselves ensnared in a sequence of enigmatic and chilling occurrences as they prepare for another. The pair strive to unravel these peculiar happenings.

A Fascinating Look at Motherhood Anxieties

One might assume that attempting to recreate the classic film “Rosemary’s Baby” requires considerable bravery. This is due to the contentious history of its creation and its prominent position in the Western cinematic canon, which creates certain expectations for viewers, critics, and studios alike. The very mention of a movie like “Rosemary’s Baby” stirs specific anticipations. The powerful portrayal by Hoffman and the delicate handling of challenging topics such as pregnancy and queerness, through a profound examination of motherhood, make “Lyle” a remarkable reimagining of a cherished film.

1 Fright Night (2011)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes10 Best Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

Fright Night tells the story of a regular family living in the suburbs of Las Vegas, with their ordinary teenage son Charley Brewster (Anton Yelchin) and his mother Jane (Toni Collette). A mysterious new neighbor named Jerry Dandridge (Colin Farrell) moves in next door, but as Charley gets to know him better, he starts noticing strange occurrences such as missing students, including an old friend. As these events unfold, Charley uncovers a hidden battle between humans and vampires, finding himself right in the thick of it.

An Undoubtedly Enjoyable Race Against Time

After viewing “Fright Night,” the supernatural horror elements seem comical at times, yet the movie manages to instill enough fear to truly scare viewers. Colin Farrell delivers an impressive portrayal of the typical attractive and brooding vampire. Unlike other villainous characters, Jerry’s threats should not be underestimated. Charley is also a compelling protagonist in his own right, while David Tennant leaves a lasting impression with his eerie, ominous performance as Ed. The 2011 remake of the 1985 film featuring Chris Sarandon does an admirable job of staying faithful to the original and has even increased its popularity as a must-watch horror for Halloween.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-10-14 06:32