10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video

10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video

As a seasoned horror enthusiast who has braved countless nights of sleep deprivation in pursuit of the chills and thrills that only this genre can provide, I must say that these three films have left an indelible mark on my psyche.


Among all months, October stands out for its affinity with horror films. Classic scary movies resurface, inviting us to revisit them, while innovative filmmakers unveil their newest horror creations. Each year, we relish this occasion as if it were our first time experiencing it, and Halloween celebrations are never complete without the chilling presence of horror films at their core.

Have you ever pondered over the idea that there are countless hidden gems among horror movies, ones you may not have heard of? Lucky for you, we’ve always kept our eyes peeled for such finds, and to celebrate this spooktacular season, we’re eager to introduce you to some under-the-radar horror flicks. Proceed with caution, for the selections that follow promise to unveil horror films you never knew existed, and they might just keep you awake not once, but twice if you’re easily startled.

These are some underrated horror movies you can stream today with a Prime Video subscription.

10 Red State (2011)

As a fervent admirer, I’d rephrase it this way: In the gripping film, Red State, I find myself as one of three unsuspecting teenagers who answer a tantalizing offer of group sex from a mysterious woman. Upon our arrival, we are drugged by her and awaken to discover ourselves ensnared in the clutches of a conservative church and its fanatical pastor, harboring an extremist ideology steeped in hatred. As we struggle to break free, we bear witness to the terrifying reach of this malevolent priest who has brainwashed the entire town into believing that Rapture is imminent.

Kevin Smith’s Underrated Experiment in Horror

Red State serves as director Kevin Smith’s response to doubters who thought he couldn’t create a serious horror film. This chilling tale steers clear of supernatural elements, but still leaves a lingering sense of unease that feels particularly timely given current political circumstances. Michael Parks delivers an extraordinary performance as Pastor Abin Cooper, a role that may haunt your dreams.

9 Hell House LLC (2015)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video

In Hell House LLC, a bunch of youthful companions opt to lease an abandoned hotel in a quaint hamlet, intending to create a spooky Halloween attraction there. Presented as a mockumentary, the movie recounts the disastrous incidents leading up to the opening night and the horror that ensued when they seemingly opened a gateway to Hell.

One of the Best Found Footage Horror Films of the 2010s

I found the movie so terrifying that it spawned a franchise that’s thriving to this day – that’s Hell House LLC for you. When it needs to, it’s straightforward, but this simplicity is what gives its director room to shine with minimal resources. It’s intensely claustrophobic and jump-scare heavy, and let me tell you, the clowns in here are downright horrifying. I dare say even Pennywise and Art the Clown from Terrifier might find themselves outdone this time around.

8 Dave Made a Maze (2017)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video

In my case, I found myself at a crossroads when my girlfriend went away for the weekend. Labeled as a slacker, I decided to prove them wrong by constructing a labyrinth out of cardboard. To my surprise, this project of mine took on a life of its own and grew into an intricate world that even surpassed Annie’s wildest imaginations upon her return. However, just like every ecosystem, it seemed to harbor something sinister as well.

The Genius of a Truly Bizarre Film

Bill Watterson’s independent hit, Dave Made a Maze, masterfully blends genres beyond its unique visual aesthetic. The movie delves into a narrative that tackles complex themes like mental health and depression. However, the director refuses to make it a walk in the park. Instead, viewers are challenged to traverse a nightmarish cardboard labyrinth teeming with terrifying creatures that would give you sleepless nights. To call this film a creative achievement is a significant understatement.

7 The Taking of Deborah Logan (2014)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video

The Film Crew’s Unsettling Experience with Deborah Logan recounts the tale of a group of filmmakers who opt for Deborah, a woman exhibiting signs of Alzheimer’s and residing with her daughter, as their next subject. As Deborah displays unanticipated instances of aggressive and peculiar behavior, the crew finds themselves bearing witness to something that has seized Deborah, and it is not merely a neurodegenerative condition.

The Found Footage That Dared to Take a Very Risqué Jump

In hindsight, some viewers might argue that the movie “The Taking of Deborah Logan” exploits a genuine condition for cheap horror thrills, but the found footage style doesn’t mince words when it comes to revealing its supernatural aspects. Initially, it only creates an uneasy feeling, but as the story unfolds and you learn where Deborah is led, it will send shivers down your spine.

6 Saint Maud (2019)

Katie, who now goes by the name Maud as a private nurse, has recently faced a heartbreaking situation where she was unable to save a patient. This event led her to become deeply religious and decide on a name change. In her new role caring for a bedridden former artist, Maud encounters various challenging situations that test her resolve. However, her unwavering faith in God remains her greatest strength.

A Fine Example of Religious Horror

In a chilling fashion, Saint Maud unnerves as Maud transforms into an overzealous devotee, relentless in her pursuit to validate her beliefs, leaving the audience questioning her sanity. Director Rose Glass skillfully employs ambiguity in her impressive directorial debut, making it uncertain if Maud’s convictions are delusional enough to create hallucinations. However, the movie culminates in a bone-chilling revelation that instills an everlasting fear of fanaticism.

5 Three… Extremes (2004)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video

In the chilling anthology “Three… Extremes,” three masterful horror directors have crafted unique, haunting tales that will leave an indelible mark on your memory. As a fan, I was captivated by the stories of Kyoko, a writer whose dreams plunge her into realms of dread so deep they threaten to unravel her very reality; a filmmaker and his spouse, who find themselves in the clutches of a twisted artist; and Mrs. Li, who discovers a price far too steep for eternal youth.

The Best Horror Anthology You’ve Never Seen

Originally intended as a sequel to “Three,” the anthology titled “Three… Extremes” encountered scheduling issues, leading American viewers to perceive it as the initial installment in the series. This unintended first impression might have been beneficial, as “Three… Extremes” showcases the finest offerings from three talented Asian horror directors. The segment by Fruit Chan, titled “Dumplings, ,” was even released as a standalone film, but it’s Park Chan-wook’s “Cut ” that arguably receives the least recognition.

4 The Returned (2013)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video

In “The Returned”, humanity has endured its darkest hour: a zombie epidemic claimed countless lives, yet scientists found a remedy, or at least a short-term vaccine. This vaccine, when administered to infected individuals, can alleviate symptoms temporarily. Dr. Kate has chosen to hoard doses for her spouse Alex, but eventually, she finds herself low on supplies.

The Serious Zombie Film You Didn’t Know You Needed to See

The Returned is an unusual movie in its approach. Unlike many films in this genre, it avoids relying on sensational special effects or exploiting the horror aspects typically linked with zombies. Instead, it maintains a realistic tone and focuses on developing the characters and their dramatic situations, who, despite their questionable morals, are simply trying to survive, much like anyone would in such circumstances.

3 Horror in the High Desert (2021)

In the Arid Highlands, we find another staged documentary, this time revolving around the enigma of Gary Hinge, a vlogger who mysteriously disappeared during a hiking trip in Nevada’s barren wilderness. Initially, the whereabouts of Gary remained unknown, but as days passed, a pivotal clue surfaced: a disconnected hand gripping a video camera, which captured Gary’s chilling encounter with something otherworldly.

One of the Scariest Horror Movies in Recent Years

Although the storyline delves into less important details regarding Hinge, the suspense is worth the wait as it culminates effectively. Similar to how most found-footage films operate, Horror in the High Desert focuses primarily on the climax – the unveiling of what befell the daring hiker who ventured into darkness and switched on his camera. Does it succeed? Indeed. Is it a hassle to watch? Maybe, but it’s worth it. Will you sleep peacefully after viewing it? Highly unlikely.

2 The Lie (2018)

The story unfolds around Jay and Rebecca, former spouses of Kayla, as they grapple with the shocking event of Kayla killing one of her friends, Britney. The circumstances surrounding this crime are peculiar. Despite this, Rebecca, a bold lawyer, chooses to shield Kayla, who gradually discloses details that might clarify everything. However, Kayla eventually reveals that nothing is as it initially appears.

A Lie With a Valid Purpose

Veena Sud’s work with Amazon and Blumhouse offers a rollercoaster ride of surprises, culminating in a third act that leaves a lasting impression. Despite mixed reviews upon its release, the movie compels you to ponder the lengths individuals go to protect their children. Mireille Enos and Peter Sarsgaard deliver outstanding performances as Rebecca and Jay, respectively. Joey King’s portrayal of Kayla is so chilling that it may make you question her in future films. Indeed, she delivers an exceptional performance in this horror-thriller, which unfortunately did not receive the attention it deserved from many viewers.

1 The House at the End of Time (2013)

10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video10 Best Underrated Horror Movies on Prime Video

“The House at the End of Time” is about Dulce, a woman who spent three decades behind bars for a murder she maintains her innocence of. Her husband met an enigmatic end, and she believes there’s a ghost haunting their old house—possibly her late spouse. However, it’s not the occasional spectral apparitions that hold the real key to this ancient dwelling; instead, there’s a far greater secret hidden within its walls.

An Underrated Foreign Horror Film You Have to See at Some Point

Venezuela isn’t known for producing many horror films, but “The House at the End of Time” shows that the country’s folklore can be effectively translated to the silver screen. The script is boldly crafted around a fantasy narrative that seamlessly intertwines with the chilling tale of spectral presence. Trust us when we say, you won’t predict where this lesser-known foreign horror film takes its twisted turn in the thought-provoking conclusion.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-10-20 21:02