Is Netflix’s Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?

Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?

Quick Links

  • Cheryl Bradshaw and Sheryl Bradshaw Appear to be Very Different People
  • An Audience Member Didn’t Recognize Rodney Alcala During the Show

As I delve into this gripping tale of deceit and terror, I can’t help but feel a deep sense of admiration for the women who bravely navigated their way through the chilling web spun by the infamous serial killer, Richard Ramirez, also known as the Night Stalker. The story of Cheryl Bradshaw, portrayed in the film ‘Woman of the Hour’, is a poignant reminder of how the actions of one can save countless lives.


The Netflix series “Woman of the Hour” has garnered significant attention on the platform, largely due to its association with true crime. The movie portrays the real-life story of Rodney Alcala (played by Daniel Zovatto), a serial killer who competed on the television show The Dating Game in 1978, during his infamous killing spree. This appearance earned him the moniker “The Dating Game Killer” and solidified his place among the most notorious serial killers ever. It’s a tale that seems too extraordinary to be true, but it is essential to remember that this is a film, and certain creative liberties have been taken to enhance its 94-minute narrative.

In the narrative of “Woman of the Hour,” Alcala’s murderous history forms a backdrop, with certain murders being portrayed, but the main focus is on Sheryl Bradshaw, played by Anna Kendrick and making her directorial debut. Her participation in “The Dating Game” is a significant part of the storyline. Here, she chooses Bachelor #3 as her date, unaware that he is none other than the dangerous Alcala. For those who may not be familiar with the format of “The Dating Game,” a woman would select among three men without seeing them first, based on their witty responses to questions that often leaned towards misogyny, these answers being suggested by the show’s producers.

1978 marked a notorious chapter in television history when the show’s contestant, Alcala – who was portrayed as a successful photographer – had previously served prison time for molesting underage girls. Remarkably, he managed to get on the show himself. Shockingly, producers were oblivious that he had committed rape and murder of five women just months before his appearance. Adding to the tragedy, Alcala’s charisma attracted Cheryl, who chose him as her date.

Cheryl Bradshaw and Sheryl Bradshaw Appear to Be Very Different People

Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?

Is it true or false that the initial alteration was regarding Cheryl’s name? In the movie, she goes by “Sheryl Bradshaw,” a determined actress striving to succeed in the industry. However, she faces obstacles when she refuses to indulge in casting couch practices upon moving from New York to Los Angeles, even going as far as rejecting nudity for roles. On the verge of returning to New York, The Dating Game offers her an opportunity, causing her to reconsider and stay in Los Angeles instead.

It seems that there is some confusion surrounding the real identity of Cheryl Bradshaw, largely due to her distancing herself from her appearance on the dating show and its association with Alcala. Contrary to what was portrayed on the show, she does not appear to have been an aspiring actress; instead, during her appearance, she claimed to be a drama teacher living in Phoenix, Arizona. However, research for a film revealed that there was indeed a woman by that name who was a communications teacher in Avondale, Arizona, but she had passed away in 2004. Despite this, it is known that she withdrew from public life to lead a more secluded existence, a fact confirmed in several true-crime documentaries about Alcala, which emphasize her desire to disassociate herself with the escalating notoriety of the case.

In the movie, it appears that the character Sheryl possesses a more assertive demeanor than the real-life Cheryl Strayed, as demonstrated in scenes from her time on The Dating Game. Sheryl is particularly sensitive to the sexism she encounters, particularly during her stint on the show. Occasionally, she deviates from the script and even asks her own questions, such as the provocative question, “What are girls for?” It seems that Cheryl Bradshaw, based on available footage, conforms more to the image the producers wanted to project rather than challenging it.

There is one clip where she asks Alcala to act like a dirty old man, which is chilling in its own right given all the things he had already done, but it isn’t included in the movie. The main focus of Woman of the Hour isn’t Alcala or his murders, but how women were treated in 1978 and wanting to push back against that. This is why Sheryl is presented as intuitive to the game and doing what she can to flip the script.

The film hints at Alcala’s past beyond his notorious crimes; it suggests that he worked for The Los Angeles Times in 1977, a year before his television debut. His exact role isn’t specified, but scenes depict him among colleagues who seem impressed by his extraordinary tales, such as his photography skills, often showcasing images of nude women. This underscores the misogyny prevalent at the time even more. The movie further implies that he exploited his position at the newspaper, however minor it may have been, to attract potential victims.

In this section of the tale, it seems authentic and stands out due to its implications about whether thorough background checks were conducted before employment. Remarkably, Alcala did not hide behind an alias, demonstrating his audacity even with previous convictions on his record. Surprisingly, Alcala was employed by The Los Angeles Times as a typesetter in 1977, and he displayed photographs of nude women to his peers, according to most accounts. Interestingly, his colleagues perceived these images as artistic rather than inappropriate or suggestive.

Regarding the possibility that the job was used for a killing spree: In one instance, this could be seen with Pamela Jean Lambson in 1977. According to accounts, Alcala presented Lambson with an opportunity that could significantly alter her life due to his contacts. This prospect excited Lambson, as she shared with her stylist. Sadly, the day following their encounter in October 1977, Lambson’s body was discovered.

The Dating Game Sequences in Woman of the Hour Are a Bit Embellished

Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?

During the segment of the movie titled “The Dating Game”, Jed Mills (Jedidiah Goodacre), who initially seems unappealing, finds himself in a rivalry with Alcala over who Sheryl will eventually choose. In a chilling statement, Alcala says, “I always get the girl,” which hints at something being amiss to Mills. Following Sheryl’s choice of Alcala and the other contestants’ obligatory cheek kisses, Mills is portrayed as cautioning her about Alcala based on their encounters.

In this scene, it seems as if events have been slightly modified for the movie. It’s uncertain whether Mills actually warned Cheryl about Alcala, but he did express concerns about him in multiple interviews, describing him as distinctly odd or creepy. He also admitted that Alcala boasted, “I always get my girl,” during one of their encounters. This dialogue change emphasizes Alcala’s unsettling demeanor and narcissism. However, a conversation between Cheryl and Mills might have been included in the film solely for dramatic purposes, as there’s no historical evidence to support it.

The depiction in The Dating Game scenes exhibits minor alterations. For example, Alcala was actually Bachelor #1 in the actual account, but he is portrayed as #3 in the film, presumably to heighten the suspense if he’s unmasked at the end. Regarding the prizes, the dating couple won an all-inclusive trip to Carmel in the movie, while in reality they only received some tennis lessons and a visit to Magic Mountain amusement park. The real prize lacks the glamour of the fictional one, making it understandable why this was adjusted for the film’s benefit. However, there seems to be a significant scene in the film that adds dramatic tension, but it appears this event may not have occurred in actuality at all.

An Audience Member Didn’t Recognize Rodney Alcala During the Show

Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?Is Netflix's Woman of the Hour Accurate to the True Story?

In the TV series segment called “The Dating Game,” a spectator named Laura (Nicolette Robinson) recognizes Bachelor #3, who is onscreen, as the individual responsible for murdering her friend while watching. She confides in her male associate that she must depart immediately. Later, she voices her apprehensions to him, but he downplays her fears by suggesting she might be mistaken. Eventually, Laura approaches a studio security guard with her concerns, however, he dismisses her worries. He deceives her by directing her to speak with one of the show’s producers, yet instead, he sends her to a janitor.

In this part of the narrative, we find a fictionalized scenario; however, it effectively portrays the era’s context, particularly concerning societal beliefs towards women. Throughout the movie, Laura’s concerns are often disregarded, even when she is proven correct, such as an influential figure leading her astray by setting her on a wild goose chase. Director Kendrick explains that Laura symbolizes the countless women whose lives were impacted by Alcala’s criminal activities and those who attempted to guide law enforcement towards his capture, albeit not during his television show appearance. One authentic detail is that the character Laura describes as her friend in the film, who was killed by Alcala, was loosely based on a real-life victim.

In the movie’s most nerve-wracking scene, Alcala and Bradshaw step out for drinks after filming ends, initially appearing friendly. However, Sheryl senses something odd about him. He requests more drinks from the waitress, but Sheryl subtly signals ‘no’ to her, leading to the bar closing and them ending up in an empty parking lot. The atmosphere grows tense as he presses for her number, only to discover it was false. After further exchanges, it becomes apparent they won’t be visiting Carmel together. He makes a threat towards her, prompting her to rush to her car and narrowly avoid attack by Alcala until a group of people from the studio intervene.

It was later discovered that the actual meeting between Cheryl and Alcala never transpired, as Cheryl expressed unease about going out with him after filming. She reportedly told the contestant coordinator Ellen Metzger that he gave her strange vibes and she wasn’t comfortable going on a date with him. When Metzger informed her that it was not mandatory to go on the date, their potential encounter was effectively called off. This decision may have potentially saved Cheryl’s life, as she likely would have been another one of his victims if they had met.

In the movie, it’s shown that Alcala was eventually apprehended via the character of Amy (Autumn Best), a young runaway. Initially found injured and tied up in the desert next to Alcala, she cleverly feigns sympathy towards him when he cries, trying to earn his trust. Once trust is established, he releases her restraints, and they start moving towards his residence. However, before reaching there, they halt at a gas station. Seizing the opportunity, Amy escapes, prompting the police to arrive and detain Alcala.

Amy, as you may know, is modeled after Monique Hoyt, a woman who successfully evaded Alcala and reported him to authorities. It was Hoyt’s accusations that led to Alcala’s arrest in February 1979, but his crimes did not stop there. As we learn from the movie’s end credits, Alcala was released on bail following his arrest and continued to commit murder while awaiting trial. He wasn’t apprehended again until July 1979 for the killing of a 12-year-old named Robin Samsoe. In total, Alcala was found guilty of seven murders, although many believe he is responsible for even more unidentified victims. He received a death sentence, but due to numerous appeals and reversals that lasted until 2019, California imposed a moratorium on the death penalty, transforming his sentence into life imprisonment. Alcala eventually passed away in prison from natural causes. The Woman of the Hour is currently available for streaming on Netflix.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-10-26 02:32