As someone who grew up in the golden age of television, I can wholeheartedly say that the reboot trend has left me with a bittersweet taste. On one hand, it’s exciting to see our beloved characters return to our screens. But on the other, many of these revivals fall short of the magic that made the originals so special.
Occasionally, it appears as if Hollywood resorts to dipping into the past for fresh ideas, drawing inspiration from classic TV series that captivated audiences, aiming to recreate their charm via revivals and sequels. However, not every remake can match the praise earned by blockbusters like Doctor Who, Battlestar Galactica, and Queer Eye, and viewers often show little enthusiasm for what they see as a greedy attempt by studios and executives to capitalize on past successes.
Moving from groundbreaking soap operas like “Melrose Place” and “Beverly Hills, 90210“, to popular animated series such as “Animaniacs” and “The Magic School Bus”, the television landscape has made numerous efforts to build upon these established classics, often falling short in their valiant (and sometimes audacious) attempts. Here’s a list of 10 poorly received reboots of ’90s TV shows.
10
‘Melrose Place’ (2009)
In 2008, The CW revived the TV show 90210, aiming to rekindle the magic of nostalgia in television. They then planned to revamp another ’90s soap opera, Melrose Place. Just like before, this new series is set at a fictional apartment complex in West Hollywood, where aspiring young residents chase their big ambitions. The cast includes rising stars such as Katie Cassidy, Colin Egglesfield, and Stephanie Jacobsen. To add to the excitement, original cast members from the hit show like Heather Locklear and Laura Leighton returned too.
Reboot Lacks the Camp of the Original
Regardless of the legacy of Melrose Place and the creative prowess of former producers Darren Swimmer and Todd Slavkin from Smallville, the reboot struggled to find an audience, leading to its cancellation after only one season. This was due to poor ratings and a failure to draw in its intended demographic. Many viewers felt that the reboot was overly serious compared to the lighthearted original ’90s series, missing out on some of the humor that made it so appealing. On Rotten Tomatoes, Melrose Place received a low 30% score on the Popcornmeter.
9
‘Charmed’ (2018)
For eight mesmerizing years, viewers became captivated by the tough, action-packed Halliwell sisters who battled evil, ensuring the world’s safety episode after episode, earning the affection of countless devoted fans through their “Power of Three.” Unsurprisingly, when news broke that a revival of the show was being planned, centering on sisters Mel, Maggie, and Macy in the fictional town of Hilltowne, Michigan as they uncover their witchy heritage, both die-hard fans and original cast members expressed shared disappointment.
Fans Push Back Against the Remake
As a passionate moviegoer, I found the modern take on “Charmed” aimed to champion diversity and inclusivity, showcasing three actresses of color and incorporating LGBTQ+ representation. However, despite its progressive stance, it failed to draw in audiences who felt it delved too deeply into political matters instead of maintaining the original series’ fun and enchantment.
8
‘The Magic School Bus Rides Again’ (2017)
In a beloved educational science series named “The Magic School Bus,” an oddly charming and quirky character named Ms. Frizzle played a significant role in shaping young minds while leading them on captivating journeys to mesmerizing locations across different eras. The esteemed Lily Tomlin lent her voice to this dedicated teacher, leaving an indelible impression. In the Netflix sequel series “The Magic School Bus Rides Again,” Saturday Night Live alum Kate McKinnon took center stage as Ms. Frizzle’s younger sibling, Miss Fiona Frizzle. The comedian was entrusted with driving the magical bus.
Skepticism Plagues the Netflix Sequel
Following the announcement of the revamped show along with its debut trailer, some skeptical viewers expressed concerns about the fresh take on the storyline. Criticisms were particularly directed towards the significantly changed visual style and the absence of Tomlin as the main actor. Later, Bustle suggested that this negative response stemmed from fans wanting to safeguard the original’s reputation. Initially, the animated series faced resistance but managed to run for two seasons and garnered critical acclaim, although it didn’t quite captivate fans in the same way as the contemporary spin-off did.
7
‘Walker’ (2021)
It’s clear that the primary factor behind the massive success of the Western crime drama “Walker, Texas Ranger” was none other than Chuck Norris and his breathtaking martial arts abilities. The show was known for its extravagantly action-packed scenes. Replacing Norris’ legendary cowboy persona was a daunting task, despite Jared Padalecki, a well-known figure on the small screen, being selected to play the part of the respected Texas Ranger Cordell Walker in the aptly titled “Walker“.
Padalecki’s Valiant TV Attempt
Jared Padalekski has quite a bit of experience battling formidable villains alongside Jensen Ackles, and for 15 seasons, he played a significant role in the long-running series Supernatural , vanquishing fearsome demons. Yet, even with all that monster-fighting under his belt, nothing could have prepared him for embodying Cordell Walker. Despite bringing a powerful and authoritative demeanor to the show, Padalekski was not on par with Chuck Norris. The series Walker lasted for 4 seasons, garnering decent viewership, but unfortunately, it was terminated in May 2024.
6
‘Fuller House’ (2016)
Without a doubt, Full House left an indelible mark on viewers with its heartwarming family stories and occasional corny morals that the Tanner sisters picked up in each episode. It’s not hard to see why this sitcom was called “The Brady Bunch of the 1990s” by its producer Dennis Rinsler. The series gained immense popularity for turning its talented cast, including John Stamos, Bob Saget, and the Olsen twins, into household names. Over its 8 charming seasons, Full House was a massive hit on ABC.
Full House 2.0 Panders to Fans
In the year 2016, around two-thirds of the Tanner girls got together for the follow-up series “Fuller House.” Notably, Candace Cameron Bure and Jodie Sweetin reconnected after a gap of 21 years, joining forces with Andrea Barber to lead the production. The storyline is set once more in San Francisco, revolving around D.J. Tanner-Fuller, who has recently lost her spouse, as she navigates parenthood to three boys with the assistance of her sister Stephanie and best friend Kimmy.
The show faced harsh criticism from reviewers because it followed a predictable storyline and repeated familiar patterns, leading some viewers to accuse it of being overly loyal to the original sitcom. Additionally, its humor and references were often considered awkward or embarrassing by many.
5
‘Animaniacs’ (2020)
1993’s animated series “Animaniacs” was highly praised for its wild spirit, sharp satire, and eccentric characters. It followed the antics of the Warner Bros. siblings Yakko, Wakko, and Dot who, locked away in a tower during the 1930s, found freedom in the ’90s after their confinement. The sketch comedy show aired from 1993 to 1998, only to return again on November 20, 2020, with many of its original cast members reprising their roles.
Original Creator Was Disappointed in Revival
Despite numerous attempts, both critics and enthusiasts found it hard to appreciate the remake’s ability to recreate the enchantment and eccentricity of the ’90s series. This shortcoming was mostly ascribed to the absence of active participation from the original creative team. Viewers also pointed out that the modern version of Animaniacs fell short in terms of its wit and energy, with the creator of the initial animated program expressing profound dissatisfaction towards Warner Bros. and the end result, labeling it as “unethical, unprofessional, and morally questionable.
4
‘90210’ (2008)
Without a doubt, one of the most talked-about and highly-watched shows from the ’90s was none other than the teen drama sensation, “Beverly Hills, 90210.” This show chronicled the lives of a group of troubled teenagers residing in the famous Los Angeles neighborhood, as twin siblings Brandon (Jason Priestley) and Brenda Walsh (Shannen Doherty) grappled with adapting to their new lavish surroundings after relocating from Minnesota. Similar to its predecessor, “90210” focused on the Wilson family and their children Annie and Dixon, who underwent significant growing pains following their move to Beverly Hills.
A Cliched, Uninspiring Reimagining
The original cast members such as Doherty, Garth, and Spelling appeared in the revival to bring a blast from the past for the audience, but it fell short of being a success. Despite their best efforts, the new students at West Beverly Hills High didn’t quite match the cultural impact of the original series. The show leaned heavily on tired tropes and lackluster teenage narratives, which contributed to its gradual ratings drop during the five seasons that eventually led to its cancellation in 2013.
3
‘The Powerpuff Girls’ (2016)
In the new series titled “The Powerpuff Girls“, these superhero siblings, Blossom, Bubbles, and Buttercup, returned to their duty of battling crime and safeguarding Townsville’s residents. This thrilling sequel revived the beloved Cartoon Network classic that captivated audiences for six seasons. It was praised as “one of the rare American productions that manages to be both delightful pop culture and exceptional high art.
Initially, a comeback with the formidable threesome appeared to be an obvious choice, but the 2016 reboot fell short of expectations and left fans longing for the classic version instead.
Some Magic Is Lost in the Revival
In the revamped version, entirely fresh voice talents took on the roles of the miniature crime-fighters (which left many fans disheartened). Critics noted a scarcity of humor and intelligence, as well as criticizing the uninspired animation quality, acting, and character discrepancies.
Despite running for three seasons, the revamped version of The Powerpuff Girls failed to match the acclaim and affection of the ’90s original and even drew criticism from its initial cast members. Bubbles voice actress, Tara Strong, labeled the reboot as a painful blow.
2
‘Ren & Stimpy “Adult Party Cartoon”‘ (2003)
Back in the ’90s, there wasn’t a more daring or offbeat television show than my personal favorite, The Ren & Stimpy Show. This animated sitcom took us on a rollercoaster ride through the outrageous escapades of the eccentric chihuahua and the intellectually-challenged cat. It earned praise for its surreal humor and exceptional animation throughout its entire run.
A Notorious Animated Blunder
Often criticized as among the most distasteful animated series ever made, the “Ren & Stimpy ‘Adult Party Cartoon'” was met with disapproval by both critics and viewers due to its offensive, crass humor that seemed intended solely for shock value. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette labeled the reboot as “simply revolting… I’m not paid enough to watch cartoon characters eating snot,” and it aired only three episodes before being abruptly taken off the air and ultimately cancelled.
1
‘Good Times: Black Again’ (2024)
As a movie critic, I must admit that when Netflix’s adult animated sitcom “Good Times: Black Again” premiered in April 2024, it fell short of being the “great” or even “very good” in my opinion. Starring the likes of Jay Pharoah, Yvette Nicole Brown, and J.B. Smoove as an offbeat family, the show follows the contemporary Evans clan navigating the ups and downs of life amidst the challenges of living in a Chicago housing project, reminiscent of the original series. However, it seems audiences didn’t find it as “dy-no-mite!” as the creators intended.
Netflix’s Offensive & Insensitive Series
Critically panned and widely disliked for its controversial humor, degrading portrayals, and poor connection to the iconic ’70s show, Good Times: Black Again, failed to live up to the original’s prestige and influence. The reboot was universally criticized as offensive and disgusting, earning a dismal 10% Rotten Tomatoes score and 23% Popcornmeter rating. Huffpost stated that the series lacked any merit or understanding of genuine Black humanity, with its flaws being immediately apparent and frequently on display.
Stream on Netflix
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-12-21 06:02