‘Gladiator’ & ‘Saving Private Ryan’ Torn Apart by Real Historian

by

As a cinephile who’s spent countless hours engrossed in the rich tapestry of historical films, I must say that Dan Snow’s meticulous analysis of these cinematic masterpieces is nothing short of enlightening. It’s always fascinating to delve into the factual basis of these stories, even if they do take a few liberties for dramatic effect.

As a history enthusiast, I find that films based on true events or real history hold a special appeal for me. From the tumultuous times of World War II to the legendary Battle of Thermopylae, and even the extraordinary life story of Robbie Williams (in his monkey incarnation), these moments have been beautifully recreated on the silver screen. While numerous films draw inspiration from history, it’s unfortunate that the pursuit of drama often leads to historical accuracy taking a backseat in the editing room. Fortunately, one historian is bravely addressing the concerns of film fans worldwide and is shedding light on the truth behind five of the most iconic historical films ever made.

As a passionate film buff, I recently delved into the top five historical films of all time curated by Historian Dan Snow from History Hit, only to find that while these movies are captivating, they aren’t entirely faithful to history. The lineup included classics like “Gladiator,” “Apollo 13,” “The Last of the Mohicans,” “Schindler’s List,” and “Saving Private Ryan.” Kicking things off with Ridley Scott’s masterpiece, “Gladiator,” Dan Snow didn’t hesitate to point out its historical inaccuracies, remarking, “What a fantastic film, but oh so historically inaccurate.

I really appreciate this speech, but it seems to make little sense. It appears to be a jumble of words without a clear meaning. However, there was indeed a legion called the Felix Legion, which was also known as ‘the Lucky Legion.’ Yet, contrary to what’s stated in the speech, there was no ‘General of the Felix Legions,’ and at this particular time in the Roman Empire, there wasn’t yet a recognized ‘Commander of the Armies of the North.’

The movie “Apollo 13” was facing potential criticism next. One of the most famous lines in both cinema and history is “Houston, we have a problem.” However, it’s worth noting that the line was slightly misquoted; it was actually John Swigert who said, “Okay Houston, we’ve had a problem here.” Similarly, “The Last of the Mohicans,” featuring Daniel Day-Lewis, received more lenient reviews. During the scene where Native Americans ambush Red Coats, Snow commented on the scene.

Here, you witness a British contingent suffering heavy losses. This event transpired during the French and Indian War, also known as the Seven Years’ War in North America. In the guerrilla warfare that characterizes wooded regions like this, several units were completely wiped out. The British forces lacked appropriate equipment and training for such combat scenarios.

Dan Snow Rates the Two Best WWII Movies of All-Time

Dan Snow transitioned to discussing Steven Spielberg’s impactful movie, “Schindler’s List,” with Liam Neeson portraying the main character, Oskar Schindler, the Nazi industrialist. “The film presents a sympathetic image of Oskar Schindler,” Snow explained. “Indeed, he was a Nazi and an industrialist, exploiting Jewish labor. However, it’s crucial to remember that he also saved numerous lives. It’s documented that Schindler may not have been deeply committed as a Nazi. He did not support the extermination of every Jew in Europe.

Ultimately, Dan Snow shifted his focus to the movie “Saving Private Ryan,” a film widely considered one of the most gruesome depictions of World War II. He delved into the intense final battle sequence. “During the days following D-Day, there were scattered groups of paratroopers and units frequently engaging in fierce battles with powerful German counter-attacks using limited weaponry,” he explained. “What’s interesting about ‘Saving Private Ryan’ is that, despite spending a great deal of time emphasizing historical accuracy, the climactic battle is fictitious. It’s actually quite inaccurate.

Read More

2024-12-26 18:31