The Game Of Thrones Scene That Made Fans Throw Out His Book, According To George R.R. Martin

by

As a fan who has witnessed countless nail-biting moments and shocking twists in the captivating world of Westeros, I can confidently say that The Red Wedding stands out as one of the most impactful scenes in the entire saga of Game of Thrones. Even though it happened more than a decade ago, I still remember the chilling sensation that ran down my spine when I first watched this brutal sequence unfold.

George R.R. Martin‘s decision to include such a gruesome and heart-wrenching event in his books was undoubtedly one of the boldest moves in contemporary literature. It’s no wonder that fans were left in shock, anger, and disbelief – I know I certainly was! The scene’s devastating impact on Robb and Catelyn Stark, along with their soldiers, left an indelible mark on the series and forever changed the course of the story.

In a way, I find myself in solidarity with George R.R. Martin when he mentions that it was difficult for him to write such a heart-wrenching scene. Killing off beloved characters is never easy, but sometimes, as an artist, you have to take those difficult steps to create something truly extraordinary.

Now, let’s not forget the infamous Talisa twist in the TV adaptation of The Red Wedding – that poor pregnant woman! I’ve often joked with my friends that if I had a dollar for every time I cringed during that scene, I would have enough money to buy myself a new set of books (since I might need a few more copies after throwing them in anger at the original one)!

So, if you haven’t yet experienced the raw emotion and shocking brutality of The Red Wedding, I highly recommend streaming Game of Thrones with a Max subscription. Just be prepared to have your heart broken – and maybe even throw something at your screen!

Despite having concluded five years prior, discussions surrounding the gruesome deaths and jaw-dropping moments on “Game of Thrones” continue today. Scenes such as the Battle of the Bastards, Ned Stark’s execution, and numerous others have left viewers gasping in shock or feeling intensely stressed and agitated. In relation to this, George R.R. Martin disclosed a scene from the books that caused fans to toss their copies aside, and when I experienced the same scene myself, I felt compelled to throw my TV as well.

As a die-hard film enthusiast, I can’t help but reminisce about The Red Wedding – an unforgettable scene from Game of Thrones that continues to send shivers down the spine of viewers, despite being part of a book published in 2000 and an episode aired over a decade ago. In both the series and the books, this brutal slaughter of the Starks took fans by storm, with many left in shock, tears, and perhaps even retching. George R.R. Martin himself revealed to Rolling Stone in 2014 that this sequence was so impactful it made readers toss their books aside in disbelief.

2000 saw the publication of the book, which sparked a deluge of letters from readers expressing their anger: “I’m furious with you – I vow never to read your writings again. I burned the book, but a week later I found myself wondering what happens next, so I ended up buying another copy.” Some were so shocked that they declared they would avoid my future work entirely. I can empathize with their reaction.

In George R.R. Martin’s novel “A Storm of Swords,” Robb and Catelyn Stark, accompanied by numerous soldiers, tragically meet their end. This scene is undeniably grim, and the author himself acknowledges its distressing nature, admitting that he found it challenging to pen down such a harrowing event.

In the same interview, he mentioned that he found it difficult, as it was emotionally challenging, to eliminate popular characters he had grown fond of. Yet, he recognized it was necessary: a tough decision to make.

As I delve deeper into crafting a character, my affection for them grows – even for those who are less than admirable. However, this doesn’t mean they won’t face their demise. The phrase ‘Kill your darlings’ was coined to describe discarding cherished elements in a story, but it also applies to characters. Once readers start thinking that a character is invincible due to the writer’s protection, tension dissipates. The Red Wedding was an arduous scene to write. I postponed writing it until I completed the entire A Storm of Swords, then returned and compelled myself to pen that chapter. Despite my attachment to those characters, I knew it was necessary.

Even though I haven’t personally read the books, I vividly recall watching the Red Wedding scene, feeling deeply affected by it, and recognizing its significant impact on the narrative. The event significantly altered the course of the series, as it led to the tragic demise of the Stark family leaders in a brutal manner.

As for “Game of Thrones,” the ninth episode of Season 3, titled “The Rains of Castamere,” is renowned for its significant deaths and stands out as one of the most shocking and unsettling scenes across the entire series. Interestingly, author George R.R. Martin considers this scene to be even more impactful in the TV adaptation compared to its portrayal in the books, explaining his viewpoint by stating:

In a different phrasing, the TV adaptation of “The Red Wedding” from Game of Thrones surpasses the book’s grimness because David Benioff and D.B. Weiss amplified the scene by introducing Talisa, pregnant with Robb’s child, which was not part of the novel. Consequently, we witness a pregnant woman being brutally stabbed multiple times in the abdomen.

Besides Robb and Catelyn meeting their tragic ends, which were heart-wrenching for fans of the “Game of Thrones” series (played by Richard Madden and Michelle Fairley), it’s important to note that Robb’s wife and child suffered equally brutal fates. The scene, a striking, indelible moment, left both me and many viewers stunned in disbelief.

Indeed, it’s understandable why this particular scene in “Game of Thrones” left readers feeling exasperated, causing some to even toss their books in frustration. If you’d like to revisit this notorious and iconic sequence from the fantasy saga, you can stream “GOT” by subscribing to Max.

Read More

2024-12-29 19:37