The Traitors UK Does This One Thing WAY Better Than The US Version

by

In essence, both versions of “The Traitors” share some common aspects, but there are distinct variations that set them apart. The American edition leverages popular personalities from reality TV to attract large fan bases and generate viral sensations. The cast announcement for the US version has become a significant event among reality television aficionados. On the other hand, the UK version opts for ordinary individuals and unknowns instead.

As a movie aficionado, I’ve had the pleasure of diving into two captivating adaptations of “The Traitors”. Both series excel in their casting strategies, each offering unique storytelling perspectives. The hosts in both shows are quirky and endearing, adding a delightful touch to the reality TV genre.

However, when it comes to one particular aspect, I must admit that the UK version of “The Traitors” outshines its American counterpart. While both shows are excellent in their own right, the UK version manages to elevate this specific element, making it a truly mesmerizing viewing experience.

heads up: Some spoilers from ‘The Traitors US’ and ‘The Traitors UK‘ may lie ahead. Tread carefully if you haven’t seen them yet, or dive right in with a subscription to Peacock for an exciting watch!

I Prefer How The Traitors UK Presents The Weekly Challenges

Across various global adaptations of “The Traitors”, weekly tasks often bear resemblance or are identical. Notably, Seasons 1, 2, and 3 of both the US and UK versions have utilized a majority of the same challenges. Consequently, it’s hard not to notice subtle differences in their design and presentation.

Each adaptation handles the challenges distinctly: The UK version highlights their significance within an episode, while the US version portrays them as ancillary elements, albeit not entirely insignificant. Despite sharing similar visual aesthetics, they serve various operational purposes. My engagement levels differ based on the weekly challenges presented in the UK; however, the US adaptation fails to maintain my investment at the same level when presenting the same content. The approach and presentation of these tasks play a significant role in this difference.

The UK Version Makes Them Suspenseful

In their respective series of “The Traitors”, both the U.S. and the UK incorporate humorous and dramatic elements. Notably, the British adaptation gives a more somber tone to the weekly challenges compared to the American version, which tends to make the challenges seem like they’re straight from a comedy show. For instance, in Season 3 Episode 5 of “The Traitors”, titled “All This Murderous Power,” there is a challenge where contestants can win a shield by correctly answering questions and removing photos of a person.

In this competition, there’s a high level of tension since it could determine the fate of numerous participants. It’s filled with deceit, dishonesty, trickery, and manipulation, but for some contestants like Bob Harper, it seems more like an amusing blunder rather than a nerve-wracking situation. This is often how such competitions are perceived in the US, with a focus on humor over seriousness, as evident in many popular reality TV moments. There’s nothing inherently wrong with this approach.

I personally find the manner in which the UK version presents it more appealing. For instance, Episode 11 of The Traitors UK Season 3 showcases the contestants acquiring a significant power, revealing crucial game insights. The task has whimsical elements, such as tugging at a doll’s string to be ousted or to remain in the competition. Despite its playful nature, the editing kept me on tenterhooks. I found myself invested in whether the doll declared a monetary value or removed a contestant from the game.

The presentation of obstacles in the series can be either gripping, emphasizing their impact on a competitor’s performance, or comedic, showcasing contestants’ downfalls in a humorous light. Personally, I find myself drawn to the former style, particularly as seen in UK productions.

The US Version Is Missing Key Elements To The Challenges That Make Them Thrilling

One concern I had about The Traitors US Season 3 was the possibility that it might omit crucial elements that enhance a particular UK challenge’s appeal. Regrettably, my apprehensions seem to be materializing. For instance, in the US version, the identical challenge of three new players entering via coin distribution and cage lowering is problematic. While both series feature similar challenges, the twist in the UK edition is that only two out of the three contestants will receive the opportunity to join the game, with the order of receiving coins being crucial.

The US version wants all three players to enter the game so it doesn’t matter who is lowered first.

In the British version of the game, only two out of three contestants compete, which heightens the tension and makes it more engaging to spectate. Since we’re not familiar with these new contenders at the beginning of the season, we find ourselves invested in who will survive and who will be eliminated. The British version introduces an intriguing twist: one player is sent home based on a game of chance played with cards. In contrast, the American version omits this card game aspect and allows the Traitors to decide whom they’ll eliminate instead.

1) The American adaptation kept me hooked due to the suspense over which three contestants might be ousted. I found myself eagerly awaiting the results. However, I found the British presentation more captivating as it offered a higher level of excitement. To top it off, the narrative reached a climactic point where the Traitors appeared to inform someone they had been killed. This was followed by an intriguing exchange between one of the deceitful characters and Faithful. It was a truly engaging moment for reality TV enthusiasts. If the US version had adopted this format, it could have generated similar tension and response.

The UK Version Of The Traitors Use A Lot More Strategizing In The Challenges

These American TV shows, such as “Big Brother,” “Survivor,” “The Challenge,” and even “RuPaul’s Drag Race,” often require a great deal of planning and strategic thinking. As a result, these shows are quite familiar with strategy. Given that many contestants on the US version of “The Traitors” are skilled strategists, it is reasonable to anticipate more challenges that incorporate strategy. However, compared to the UK version, strategy isn’t utilized as frequently in these challenges.

In many situations throughout the UK, it feels like almost every problem requires strategic thinking or a well-planned approach, even in seemingly straightforward tasks such as gathering the most coins. A participant may realize that mathematically, they can’t secure victory due to insufficient funds, so instead, they pass on the coins to another player who has a chance of winning and whom they trust.

In my experience on the show, strategic planning hasn’t been a common approach in the U.S. versions of the game. However, in the fifth episode of Season 3 of The Traitors, one competitor attempted to employ strategy, but it turned out disastrously. It appears as though this player didn’t fully consider all the potential outcomes of their plan. So, while there can be an element of strategy on the U.S. version, at times, like Dylan Efron’s drag name, it can be misguided.

Both Versions Make The Challenges Important To The Overall Story, But The UK Makes Them Consistently Important

In the third season of “The Traitors” U.S., there’s an intriguing challenge where three contestants are confined in a coffin, potentially targeted for elimination by the Traitors. This isn’t your typical weekly challenge; it’s more like a twisted murder mystery and a test for the Traitors. Although it doesn’t occur every week, it shares some similarities with traditional challenges. This unique incident has led the remaining two contestants to be viewed with suspicion as potential Traitors. Consequently, these challenges significantly influence the U.S. narrative, just like they do in the UK version.

It appears that the UK scenarios frequently play a pivotal role in the narratives, as they are riddled with various challenges. These challenges have often sown seeds of doubt among competitors, or prompted them to alter their strategies. There have been challenges that drove players to mistrust one another, resulted in murders, and bestowed upon them significant power, dramatically influencing the game’s final outcome.

On both the UK and US versions, there are challenges, but it appears that those in the US often revolve around financial matters, though they don’t always play a pivotal role in the narrative.

I adore the Traitors series, and it’s incredibly hard to resist binge-watching them. However, I’m hoping that the American adaptation pushes itself a bit further to ensure that the obstacles faced by the characters in future seasons significantly impact the overall narrative.

Read More

2025-01-30 13:08