Katy Perry Is Being Replaced On American Idol. How Does It ‘Feel’ To Hand The Torch To Carrie Underwood?

by

Katy Perry has served as a judge on American Idol since ABC revived the show in 2018 after its cancellation on Fox. After six seasons, during which she brought her lively character to the judging table, a fun game of two truths and a lie led her to announce on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon that Season 22 would be her last. Since then, Carrie Underwood has taken over Perry’s role as judge. As Season 23 approaches in the 2025 TV schedule, Katy Perry discusses being replaced by Underwood.

As a passionate moviegoer, I can say that during the ABC-era of American Idol, the judges struck a perfect balance between constructive criticism and lighthearted humor. Moving forward into Season 23, it seems like Carrie Underwood will bring some fresh energy alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. With Katy Perry stepping away to focus on her music and other projects, there’s definitely a void to fill. However, from what I gather from her interview with People, Perry is confident that Underwood will rise to the occasion just fine.

She was born on that stage, and I believe she understands its intricacies well. In truth, she has a profound grasp of what it’s like to walk in their footsteps. While we can merely empathize with them as judges, she has experienced it firsthand.

It’s clear that the singer known for “Firework” is spot on. If you revisit Carrie Underwood’s audition from Season 4 of American Idol, it’s evident she was destined for this stage. Her continued fame among the show’s alumni speaks volumes about her talent. Back then, she was a young, vibrant 21-year-old who impressed the judges with her voice. Remarkably, she secured her passage to Hollywood with an unforgettable performance of Bonnie Raitt’s “I Can’t Make You Love Me,” demonstrating her remarkable vocal prowess.

According to Katy Perry’s remarks, the “Before He Cheats” artist can relate to contestants’ nerves due to her past experience, making it easier for her to empathize with them. I believe Carrie Underwood has the ability to spot raw talent, much like Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, and Randy Jackson did when they discovered her. As Perry put it:

“Katy Perry noted that the ‘Before He Cheats’ singer understands contestants’ apprehension because she’s been in their shoes. I suspect Carrie Underwood will be adept at recognizing talent in much the same way as Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, and Randy Jackson did when they found her.

As creators, we’ve walked similar paths, yet she has experienced each and every one of those days. Therefore, I believe she has a wealth of insights to share with anyone who is open to hearing her perspective.

Instead of directly stating that Katy Perry wants Jelly Roll to take her place, she mentioned desirable traits for a potential successor, including fearlessness, honesty, and some level of controversy. She implied that Jelly Roll fits these qualities very well.

Not just the seasoned pop legend is on board; Lionel Richie, recognizing Carrie Underwood’s past experience on reality competition series, has expressed approval for her involvement. Richie even noted that Underwood is already familiar to them. Keith Urban voiced an enthusiastic “yes” to the idea, and Simon Cowell, a longtime American Idol figure, also gave positive feedback. In other words, it appears that most former Idol stars are in favor of Carrie Underwood joining the show.

Excitedly handing over her judging role to Carrie Underwood, I can’t help but anticipate the unique blend of kindness and honesty she’ll bring to the table in the upcoming season of American Idol. Tune in on March 9th at 8 p.m. ET on ABC, or catch it the next day with your Hulu subscription, for the highly-anticipated debut of this accomplished singer on the judges panel!

Read More

2025-02-10 00:37