How ‘Lost’s Worst Episode Saved the Show From an Even Worse Ending

by

Over a decade after its conclusion, discussions continue about the final season and finale of Lost, with many fans finding “The End” unsatisfying because it failed to resolve the mysteries they had invested in for six years, leading some to believe that the writers improvised as they went along. However, others appreciated the finale as a fitting conclusion to an exceptional series, one that prioritized character development over mystery resolution and provided an emotionally satisfying ending. Regardless of personal opinions, there appears to be consensus among fans that “The End” is not Lost‘s weakest episode overall.

The ninth episode of the third season of Lost, titled “Stranger in a Strange Land,” is often criticized for its lack of significant story progression and for showing signs that the once-innovative flashback structure had become stale. This assessment comes even amidst a season where ratings were declining and plot development was slow (until the finale, which was remarkable). However, it’s not just our opinion – showrunners Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse also acknowledge this episode as a contributing factor to their decision to set an end date for the series. This move was aimed at maintaining its popularity even two decades after its initial broadcast.

Why Did ‘Lost’s Worst Episode Fall Flat?

In the current stage of the series, Jack Shephard finds himself in the Others’ encampment, compelled to operate on Benjamin Linus to extract a malignant growth. He reluctantly partners with Ben to rescue fertility expert Juliet Burke from execution by the Others, as she had slain one of their own while safeguarding James Ford (also known as Sawyer) and Kate during their camp escape. Notably, they manage to spare her from capital punishment in a crucial turn of events within the episode.

Initially, “Lost” thrived on its unique structure of flashback episodes, delving into each character’s history. Yet, as we moved through three seasons, it became evident that these flashbacks, which initially were fresh and insightful in enriching the series, seemed to overstay their welcome. It was becoming increasingly clear that there wasn’t much new ground to cover with them. The episode “Stranger in a Strange Land” made this particularly obvious, as it revealed the long-debated origin of Jack’s tattoos through flashback scenes.

The issue was that the episodes focusing on Jack were becoming rather predictable, as they didn’t add much to his character development beyond what we had already seen in the first half of the show. While the flashbacks provided depth for characters like Locke, Ben, and Sawyer, they just served to reiterate what we already knew about Jack – his strained relationship with his father, his obsession that led to him leaving his wife, and these repeated themes felt repetitive.

In “Stranger in a Strange Land,” the fans’ deepest concerns seemed validated: the storyline was moving slowly towards the next significant event, and Jack was in desperate need of development. However, even ‘filler’ episodes can be enjoyable. Unfortunately, the flashbacks in this particular episode were not only dull but also failed to contribute anything fresh on either a plot or character level.

How Did the Worst ‘Lost’ Episode Save the Series?

There’s hardly anyone who disagrees more with the ‘Lost’ fanbase about the episode’s poor quality than Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse. Lindelof, in particular, has been open about the difficulties they encountered in the early seasons due to ABC, who recognized they had a ratings hit on their hands but refused to prematurely end it, fearing they were killing their golden goose. The creative team found it challenging to spread the story across an entire season of 20-plus episodes. However, it was only after the release of “Stranger in a Strange Land” that received universal criticism that ABC agreed to set an end date, allowing for three shortened final seasons with fewer filler episodes moving forward.

In a 2009 conversation with TV critic Alan Sepinwall, he elaborated that if the episode hadn’t been produced, we wouldn’t have received a call expressing dislike for it. Instead, we could respond, “We share your sentiment, but this is the best we can manage without advancing the story.” At this stage, we find ourselves unable to progress the narrative any further. They then asked, “What if we provided an end date?” To which we replied, “Provide us with an end date, and we’ll inform you of our plans.” The discussions then intensified.

It’s hard to believe that the improvement in the quality of Lost after its sixth season was just a fluke, especially considering that: right after the decision to end it, the series began to show significant improvement; for instance, the second half of the third season was much better than the first, and the season finale, “Through the Looking Glass,” is still regarded as one of the show’s finest episodes with a remarkable plot twist. The flashbacks were abandoned in favor of flashforwards, bringing a new dimension to the series, and this change made the fourth season particularly well-received, being considered Lost’s best since its initial airing year.

Despite ongoing debate about the quality of seasons five and six, many fans continue to support these installments. It’s clear that Lindelof and Cuse dared to take risks with their storytelling in those seasons, skillfully pacing the narrative. On the other hand, “Stranger in a Strange Land” is often criticized, yet it could be argued that its lengthy nature served as a sort of safeguard, ensuring that Lost would never again reach such depths.

Read More

2025-02-22 04:02