Tombstone: The Most Accurate Wyatt Earp Story Ever Told

by

Few historical figures from the Old West are cherished more than Wyatt Earp. This legendary frontiersman was every criminal’s worst nightmare, and he is most famously known for his confrontation at the O.K. Corral with the Clanton and McLowry brothers. Beyond enforcing law and order in the territories of Kansas and Arizona, Earp possessed numerous other skills. It’s said that throughout his life, he worked as a traveling saloon owner, professional gambler, and security officer, among other roles.

Over time, Wyatt Earp has been portrayed in numerous films and series, but due to varying stories, myths, and legends surrounding him, some events are exaggerated or fictionalized. However, among all adaptations, the 1993 film “Tombstone” offers the most authentic account of the real Wyatt Earp. The movie centers around the well-known gunfight at the O.K. Corral and incorporates firsthand testimonies about incidents surrounding that event.

‘Tombstone’ Covers the Most Famous Moments of Wyatt Earp’s Life

In much the same way that it did when first released, the film “Tombstone” showcases Arizona’s breathtaking natural scenery alongside its lawless inhabitants. However, it deviates from a conventional biography format. The character of Earp (played by Kurt Russell) is depicted as wanting to retire and enjoy a serene life, but his tranquility is frequently disrupted by the chaos brought about by outlaws.

In Tombstone, we find the Earps – specifically, retired marshal Wyatt, his brother Virgil, and Morgan – seeking tranquility in the town of the same name. There, they reconnect with an old friend, Doc Holliday (played by Val Kilmer), who also calls this place home. However, peace is short-lived as a group of rowdy cowboys start causing havoc within the city. Matters escalate rapidly, leading to a famous showdown at the O.K. Corral, where notorious outlaws Billy Clanton and the McLaury brothers meet their untimely end due to gunfire.

After the shooting incident, swift reprisal ensues. Morgan perishes, whereas Virgil sustains injuries that leave him disabled. Demoralized, Earp and his kin depart Tombstone, pursued by the criminal elements. He confronts and dispatches these pursuers, subsequently recruiting Doc into a new posse. Later on, Earp slays Curly Bill, but his underling, Johnny Ringo, assumes control of The Cowboys. As Doc’s health deteriorates, it appears to grant him extraordinary durability. Eventually, he single-handedly eliminates Ringo. The film concludes with an enigmatic portrayal of Doc’s future, as his condition worsens and he is transported to a hospital to spend the remainder of his days.

What ‘Tombstone’ Gets Correct About Wyatt Earp

The 90s Western masterpiece, commonly hailed as the best of its kind from that decade, achieved significant success thanks to writer Kevin Jarre, despite his rocky association with the film’s production. Initially, Jarre was both the writer and director for the project; however, a disagreement with the production company led to his dismissal after six weeks because they questioned his inexperience. The movie was then passed on to George P. Cosmatos (known for films like Rambo First Blood: Part II and Cobra) who continued working from Jarre’s script.

Jarre collaborated extensively with Jeff Morey, a highly respected historian known for his expertise on the Old West, particularly Wyatt Earp. This collaboration led to a costume design that was praised for its historical authenticity and dialect, mirroring the language of that era. The well-known Western quote, “You’re a Daisy if You Do,” attributed to Val Kilmer as Doc Holiday, is actually derived from real newspaper articles.

In his fervor for the period, Jarre aimed to incorporate numerous historical details within the production to authentically depict the events surrounding the O.K. Corral. Many of these elements persisted even after he left the project. It’s difficult to measure the impact this change in direction had on the performances of Kurt Russell and Val Kilmer. However, both actors were highly commended for infusing the production with a sense of realism. Kilmer, battling Tuberculosis in reality, portrayed a gritty authenticity, while Russell embodied the legendary Wyatt Earp’s cool composure; to top it off, they both sported genuine mustaches.

Tombstone accurately portrays the sequence of incidents leading up to the O.K. Corral shootout, such as Marshal Fred White’s accidental shooting by Curly Bill Brocius, Virgil Earp’s assassination attempt, Morgan Earp’s murder, and the famous ‘vendetta ride.’ Some details have been dramatized for movie purposes, like the vendetta ride, which is said to have resulted in more deaths than actually occurred. The real shootout lasted just 30 seconds, but it lasts 90 seconds in the film. However, certain aspects, such as Doc Holiday killing Ringo, are purely fictional.

Why ‘Tombstone’ Is the Best Wyatt Earp Movie

Six months following the debut of “Tombstone,” another movie titled “Wyatt Earp” featuring Kevin Costner hit the screens. This version, however, received mixed opinions and was criticized for its extended duration and vague plotline. Unfortunately, it didn’t fare well at the box office, leading to a Razzie nomination for Costner. It’s essential to distinguish between the two films, as “Tombstone” is widely regarded as a classic, whereas “Wyatt Earp” is more of an ancillary piece.

Compared to films on Wyatt Earp, the 1946 film “My Darling Clementine” is the one that has received higher praise from critics. However, historians view Stuart Lake’s biography, which was the basis for this movie, as embellished and questionable. On the other hand, while “Tombstone” also takes creative liberties, its combination of action, drama, and impressive performances have earned it a cherished place in Western cinema. Despite some artistic license, “Tombstone” is as close to accuracy as any film can be about such a complex character. Additionally, with its contemporary allure, “Tombstone” stands out as the top choice for the best Wyatt Earp movie.

Read More

2025-03-20 03:02