10 Superhero Flops That Became Cult Classics and You Won’t Believe #3!

by

The superhero genre has grown into a billion-dollar global phenomenon: polished, meticulously orchestrated, and strategically designed to keep audiences hooked across age groups and geographical locations. Beneath this shiny facade, however, exists a gritty, sparkling underbelly of flops – films that aimed to soar but instead stumbled into something quirkier and more intriguing. These are the movies that were no match for Marvel’s ironclad synergy or DC’s self-mythologizing torment. They are laboratories of passion, studio blunders, and peculiar curiosities that, despite financial disappointments, discovered a second life in the chaotic populace of cult fandom.

There’s a certain allure to watching an unlikely superhero movie that shouldn’t have been made, such as a janitor turning into a toxic avenger slashing criminals or Dennis Rodman dodging explosions in “Double Team” like a glitch from the Matrix. These films are usually disorganized, barely functioning, and messy. However, it is precisely this lack of polish that makes them enduring. They represent the B-side of the superhero genre: peculiar, heartfelt, and occasionally brilliant. Best enjoyed with friends at midnight, preferably with an abundance of snacks and sarcasm, these films will reveal the contours of a different cinematic universe – one where failure becomes its own unique form of superpower.

10
‘The Toxic Avenger’ (1984)

The film that sparked countless late-night showings, perhaps even inspiring some counseling sessions, is “The Toxic Avenger.” This movie tells the twisted tale of a skinny janitor from New Jersey who accidentally falls into a vat of toxic waste and transforms into a superhero covered in boils, with an affinity for mops and vigilante justice. The studio behind this film is Troma, known for its low-budget, grisly horror flicks that embody the essence of tacky camp. Despite underperforming at the box office initially, it managed to carve out a niche for itself over time, achieving iconic status without ever striving for respectability, which is something many superhero films fail to accomplish.

So Gross, So Good, So Toxie

The longevity of “The Toxic Avenger” isn’t just due to its absurdity, but rather the raw, unadulterated chaos it presents. Unlike many modern movies, this film revels in poor taste without ever appearing cynical. There are no meticulously crafted worlds or polished franchises here; instead, we have violence, ooze, and genuine sincerity.

In a time when superheroes are either messianic figures or internet sensations, “Toxie” serves as a reminder that sometimes the most relatable savior is one who emerges from a sewer pipe, still determined to do what’s right.

9
‘Steel’ (1997)

During the mid-’90s, well before the Marvel Cinematic Universe elevated spandex to a level of respectability, someone at Warner Bros. decided to produce Steel – a superhero movie featuring Shaquille O’Neal as a weapons specialist who constructs his own homemade suit of iron and transforms into a vigilante. The team behind the project seemed unsure about the film’s appropriate tone, leading to a production that wasn’t serious enough for adults nor cartoonish enough for children. Critics were unimpressed, audiences chose not to attend, and Steel faded away, overshadowed by the likes of Batman and Superman.

Shaq as Sincere Icon, Not Irony Bait

As a cinephile, I must confess: “Steel” is surprisingly captivating, largely due to its audacious deviation from the typical superhero formula. Shaq’s endearing performance and peculiar charm serve as the film’s anchors, creating a realm where sincerity triumphs over finesse. He may not be a seasoned actor, but he doesn’t need to be – he embodies a unique brand of heroism: quirky, unpolished, and oddly comforting.

Watching “Steel” today is like stumbling upon an untouched alternate superhero universe, one that wasn’t fine-tuned by algorithms. It’s not a masterpiece, but it’s certainly memorable.

8
‘Super’ (2010)

Prior to creating the adored blockbuster “Guardians of the Galaxy,” filmmaker James Gunn crafted “Super” – an intense, humorous, and unsettling anti-superhero movie that embodies a chaotic mind in spandex. In this production, Rainn Wilson portrays Frank, a forlorn fry cook who assumes the identity of The Crimson Bolt following his wife’s departure to be with a drug dealer. Instead of showcasing a redemption arc, “Super” offers a brutal and violent descent into madness. This film was too grim for superhero enthusiasts and too superhero-focused for art house audiences, making it an ideal fit for this list due to its unique blend of genres.

Your Friendly Neighborhood Mental Breakdown

The stark portrayal of Super, the film, lies in its exploration of emotional turmoil as the foundation for its protagonist’s journey. Unlike a traditional hero, Frank is not a savior but a manifestation of distress. Ellen Page, now known as Elliot Page, brings an electrifying and unsettling performance to her role as Frank’s equally disturbed companion. The film is replete with violence, yet it offers a strikingly truthful perspective on heroism—viewing it not as virtuous, but as a last resort. This satirical piece doesn’t merely nudge at convention; it shouts its critique. In the pantheon of cult cinema, Super stands out for its courage in questioning what unfolds when an unsuitable individual attempts to uphold righteousness, and the outcome is far from appealing.

7
‘Blankman’ (1994)

In a unique twist, Damon Wayans plays a character who is overly sweet and socially awkward, choosing to tackle urban crime not through muscle or introspection, but by designing a suit made from rubber bands, Velcro, and old bathrobes of his grandma. The movie Blankman, with its absurd superhero backstory, seems more like a cartoon from Looney Tunes than the gritty realism of Batman Begins. This strange approach was likely why it failed at the box office in the mid-’90s. However, its lack of seriousness now appears to be visionary, as it foreshadows the humor and absurdity that would become popular in future superhero films.

The Power of Duct Tape and Delusion

There’s an authentic appeal in the unjaded spirit of Blankman. Wayans delivers a heartfelt performance, veering more towards empathy than caricature, playing a character who embodies such profound faith in justice that it’s endearing—and then slightly unsettling. The movie resembles a child’s interpretation of heroism tinged with adult absurdity, and in the era of massive CGI gloominess, its homemade, goofy earnestness feels surprisingly invigorating. This isn’t a mockery; it’s a heartfelt ode to the notion that even those considered uncool can still aspire to save the world.

6
‘Mystery Men’ (1999)

In the days prior to “The Boys” and even before the unconventional humor of Deadpool, there was a madcap ensemble comedy called “Mystery Men.” This film revolved around oddball heroes endowed with abilities such as throwing cutlery or being incredibly enraged. The cast was impressive (Ben Stiller, Janeane Garofalo, William H. Macy, Hank Azaria) and the visual style, a unique blend of Tim Burton’s whimsy and Joel Schumacher’s flair, was truly captivating. However, in 1999, it seemed to be a production that left audiences puzzled, and it didn’t fare well at all—crashing harder than The Spleen’s digestive system.

Ahead of Its Cape-Clogged Time

Currently viewing “Mystery Men,” it seems strikingly relevant: a lampooning of commercialization, harmful masculinity, and self-aggrandizing heroics. The characters are riddled with insecurity, overly sincere, and downright peculiar – traits Marvel has humorously acknowledged, but “Mystery Men” dived headfirst into them. It lacks sophistication or sarcasm; instead, it’s a heartfelt mess. And it serves as a reminder that superheroes, when not polished to pristine perfection, can be the most authentic of all. This was the precursor to multiverses long before they became commodified.

5
‘Orgazmo’ (1997)

Trey Parker uniquely crafted a movie where a Mormon missionary transforms into an adult film star turned superhero, and manages to imbue it with an unexpectedly heartwarming quality. The film Orgazmo is mindlessly funny at its core, leveraging the contrast between the purity of its lead character and the outrageousness of the adult entertainment world he finds himself in. It’s crass, immature, unapologetically cheap, and definitely not for the faint-hearted. However, it’s surprisingly intelligent beneath its unsophisticated veneer, using its blue-collar image as a protective shield.

What If Clark Kent Worked in Adult Video?

The reason why the film Orgazmo remains a cult favorite lies in its ambiguous ethical standpoint. Trey Parker portrays Joe Young with such genuine enthusiasm that the movie transcends into the realm of surrealism: the adult entertainment industry seems oddly virtuous, everyday life appears grotesque, and between these two extremes exists an individual armed with a dildo-shaped laser gun, yearning to satisfy both God and his fiancée. Essentially, it’s a comedic take on superheroes that doesn’t prioritize the genre—it tackles hypocrisy, repression, and the absurdity of living by rigid, unattainable moral standards. In essence, this might just be the most truthful superhero tale ever told.

4
‘The Guyver’ (1991)

Transform the vibrant, electric style of Power Rangers with squirm-inducing, gelatinous body horror, and have Mark Hamill star for an unexpected twist – this results in the bizarre American adaptation of a Japanese manga titled The Guyver. This series takes things to an extreme level, challenging expectations. The narrative revolves around a young man who combines with an alien mechanical suit, gradually mutating into a horrific combatant, while fighting off monstrous creatures known as Zoanoids. The creature designs, by the hand of Screaming Mad George (yes, that’s his real name), are part nightclub puppet show, part unsettling dreamscape.

When Gore Meets Morphin’ Time

The Guyver holds a unique position within the realm of cult films, appealing neither to young audiences nor hardcore horror enthusiasts due to its overly grotesque nature and structural chaos that makes following a plot difficult. However, this is precisely what makes it exceptional. Its tangible, hands-on monsters and practical effects offer a nostalgic delight, while the film’s bizarre tonal mix of slapstick and splatter feels as if a VHS tape has been possessed by two distinct entities. It transcends being merely a B-movie; it becomes an immersive journey through neon gore that takes you out of your body.

3
‘Freaked’ (1993)

Picture a carnival populated by genetically altered oddities, orchestrated by a cowboy with a dark side, portrayed by Randy Quaid. Envision this scene being visualized through the mind of Alex Winter (yes, the same Alex Winter), collaboratively created by a future creator of Idiocracy, and embellished with appearances from Mr. T, Bobcat Goldthwait, and Keanu Reeves in an unacknowledged canine disguise. The film Freaked is a wild, multi-genre fusion of superhero comedy. In this story, the main character, previously a sellout in Hollywood, transforms into a twisted, neon-pink mutant. He learns to rescue others by accepting and harnessing his own grotesque nature.

A Beautiful, Grotesque Mess

This movie leans more towards visual confusion rather than a traditional storyline. It’s been pieced together using Gen-X cynicism and the quirky aesthetic of Pee-wee’s Playhouse. Initially, it failed at the box office and was overlooked by the studio. However, with time, it has been reappraised as an energetic masterpiece of anti-corporate and anti-aesthetic ingenuity. Hidden beneath its slime and humor lies a film that explores themes such as personal freedom, cultural performance, and marketability. Freaked isn’t just unusual—it’s intentionally hard to watch in the most compelling way possible. You either find it captivating or repulsive, which might be a characteristic of all great cult films.

2
‘Double Team’ (1997)

In a different way of saying: Not exactly, Double Team doesn’t fall under the category of a traditional superhero movie. However, it isn’t really a structured action film either, so we’re inviting it in based on its unique atmosphere. This brightly lit, genre-blending extravaganza teams up Jean-Claude Van Damme with Dennis Rodman (yes, the same Dennis Rodman you’re thinking of). The storyline includes cybernetic tigers, post-Cold War spying, a bizarre techno-amphitheater, and dialogue that seems to have been penned by Mountain Dew. Directed by Hong Kong action maestro Tsui Hark in his foray into Hollywood, the film was heavily criticized by critics and largely overlooked by audiences. However, in the realm of cult cinema, it stands tall like a neon-lit hallucination.

More Hair Dye Than Logic, and That’s the Point

Today’s viewing of Double Team feels like leafing through a ’90s European fashion mag filled with energy drinks: it’s frenetic, overly colorful, yet undeniably thrilling. Dennis Rodman, with his vibrant hair and monotone dialogue delivery, seems to embody his own chaotic persona rather than act – surprisingly, this works. The movie is packed with gadgets, explosions, and excessive splits, but it also radiates a delightfully unhinged quality in its disregard for logic. Double Team isn’t just a film; it’s a campy artifact, an exhibit of attitude, and a testament to the fact that superhero spirit doesn’t require a cape – all it needs is dedication and a leopard-print parachute.

1
‘Turbo: A Power Rangers Movie’ (1997)

As a kid growing up in the ’90s, Turbo was the film that made me question if every action-packed movie with explosions and helmets wasn’t just a bit confusing. Initially conceived as a cinematic link between the classic Mighty Morphin Power Rangers and their upcoming TV series reboot, Turbo is like it was drawn up by a group of overly enthusiastic children – there’s a villainous pirate, a magical wizard named Lerigot, a spooky volcano, and a 10-year-old boy who mysteriously turns into a fully grown Ranger. Despite its flop at the box office, it still holds a special place in my heart. It may have bombed hard, but it rules just as much!

Nostalgia with Nitrous Oxide

Something truly unique about the movie “Turbo” is its unabashed absence of embarrassment. It charges forward with an infectious enthusiasm that compensates for its lack of coherence. There’s no attempt at realism in sight – instead, you get outrageous stakes, radiant swords, and a cast who seem to be both acting and trying not to laugh simultaneously. Essentially, it’s the opposite of Nolan – a delightful absurdity, sincerely earnest, and made with the same exuberant energy as a playtime game at an elementary school. If modern superhero films are weighed down by significance, “Turbo” transports us back to a time when transformation was all that mattered.

Read More

2025-04-07 03:04