10 Action Movies That Defied Critics and Became Hidden Gems

by

Winning with a movie can sometimes be challenging; the recipe needs to be perfectly balanced. Even a small excess can easily become overwhelming. A touch of humor is essential for counteracting the violence, but not too much or it becomes a comedy. The violence is crucial, yet if it’s excessive, it edges towards horror. If the storyline becomes overly complex, action enthusiasts might get confused, and instead of an action film, you end up with a suspenseful drama.

Despite numerous films in the action genre flouting established rules and garnering mixed reviews from critics, many of them may have been unfairly judged. Some managed to prove their worth by raking in huge box office earnings, while others were overshadowed by negative feedback and failed to attract a large audience. Regardless, there are plenty of undiscovered action masterpieces out there that will leave viewers exhilarated by their brilliance.

10. Soldier (1998)

17% On Rotten Tomatoes

In an unexpected turn for the popular actor Kurt Russell, the film Soldier presented an uncommon challenge: it made him virtually silent. The character he portrays is subdued and battle-scarred, communicating more through actions than words. This works particularly well when he forms a bond with a speechless boy. Despite Russell’s commendable performance in this unique role, his captivating charm and charisma seem to fade somewhat due to the scarcity of dialogue. Nevertheless, there are many enjoyable aspects to this otherworldly action film.

In a universe similar to that of Blade Runner, this story explores the fates of individuals who are no longer needed by society. After spending years as a soldier, Todd 3465 is exiled to a waste planet. He seeks tranquility and resolution in his new circumstances, but is soon pulled back into the fray. The ensuing action lives up to expectations. Despite receiving unfavorable reviews from critics and audiences alike at its release, it has since gained a dedicated fanbase.

9. Supergirl (1984)

8% On Rotten Tomatoes

By the 1980s, the Superman series had gained significant popularity, thanks to a string of successful movies featuring Christopher Reeve in the lead role. Given this success, it was logical to broaden the scope by focusing on his cousin, Kara. The idea worked well when a six-season show was produced three decades later, but the Helen Slater adaptation fell short. It was marked by clichéd elements and hollow feminist themes, making it difficult to appeal to audiences.

Despite not being a box office hit initially, much like other flops from past decades, Supergirl has found a devoted fanbase who enjoy its over-the-top action and cheesy dialogue. Faye Dunaway’s portrayal of the antagonist is deserving of every accolade for her dramatic intensity and sheer absurdity. The visual effects, though less advanced than those seen in ’70s films, somehow enhance the enjoyment during multiple viewings. It may be that the concept was simply ahead of its time, making a return to this nostalgic adventure quite rewarding.

8. Daylight (1996)

28% On Rotten Tomatoes

Sylvester Stallone is undeniably an authentic action star, and it’s hard to argue with that fact. However, because he’s dedicated himself so fully to this genre, he’s also amassed a collection of films that haven’t been well-received. The interesting thing about these poorly reviewed movies is they can still be incredibly enjoyable. From the greatness of Rocky to the disappointments like Judge Dredd, his filmography has its fair share of questionable projects. Yet, one that may not have won over the critics but has many commendable aspects is Daylight.

As a passionate movie enthusiast, I found myself drawn to a thrilling tale where I, along with a band of individuals, find ourselves trapped in a crumbling tunnel. Sylvester Stallone steps up as our fearless guide, determined to lead us to safety amidst the chaos. This story bears striking resemblance to “The Poseidon Adventure”, as there are those who defy his leadership and ultimately face dire consequences. Along our perilous journey, we stumble upon stragglers too, not everyone makes it out alive. Critics may have panned its lack of originality, but the heart-pounding tension and action sequences certainly kept me on the edge of my seat until the very end.

7. Armageddon (1998)

48% On Rotten Tomatoes

In the 1990s, Bruce Willis enjoyed tremendous success and popularity. He became known as everyone’s favorite action star, starring in some of the decade’s most beloved and financially successful blockbusters. Despite a few missteps along the way, his enduring appeal ensured that these setbacks didn’t significantly affect his career trajectory. It’s worth noting that while “Armageddon” was a massive box office success, it received mixed reviews from critics.

1998 seemed to be the golden age of asteroid movies, with an unusual surge in their production. Perhaps it was due to the upcoming millennium, sparking fears of the end times, as both “Deep Impact” and its counterpart shared similar themes that year. However, it was “Armageddon” that truly reigned supreme in the disaster movie genre, raking in a staggering $200 million more than its competitor worldwide, and leaving an indelible mark with its iconic Aerosmith soundtrack that has become a karaoke classic for generations.

6. San Andreas (2015)

48% On Rotten Tomatoes

Disaster movies often receive mixed reviews from both viewers and critics, as what makes one successful in this genre can vary greatly. It’s challenging to pinpoint exactly what sets a hit apart from a miss, but it could be attributed to factors like timing and casting. Despite similar plot structures, they all feature a protagonist who embarks on a mission to save their loved ones from a perilous, thrilling predicament. For instance, in the movie San Andreas, the hero is none other than Dwayne Johnson.

By 2015, Dwayne Johnson had become known for his role as a reliable action hero capable of delivering jaw-dropping rescues. In this movie, he confronts the aftermath of a massive earthquake, filled with collapsing structures, collisions, and explosions at an alarming speed. His mission is to save his daughter and ex-wife, and fortunately, he possesses the skill of being a proficient pilot, which proves useful amidst the chaos. Despite the predictable storyline, the action sequences in this film are exceptionally well executed.

5. Batman And Robin (1997)

11% On Rotten Tomatoes

It’s tough to picture the Dark Knight as a vibrant and humorous film spectacle. The ’60s Adam West series definitely increased the cheese and comedy elements, but when Tim Burton reintroduced Batman, he moved towards a darker and more brooding portrayal of the superhero. While Burton infused his unique gothic style into the two films he directed, when ‘Batman Forever’ arrived, it was much brighter and funnier. The success of this movie led to the next installment going a bit too overboard in that regard.

Despite some criticism that “Batman & Robin” nearly ruined the franchise prior to Christopher Nolan’s involvement, it’s hard not to appreciate how enjoyable this film remains. Admittedly, the overly colorful visuals, weak script, and George Clooney’s portrayal of Batman have been subjects of debate. Yet, even the film’s less appealing aspects can be surprisingly entertaining to watch. For instance, Arnold Schwarzenegger as Mr. Freeze is quite goofy, delivering cheesy one-liners and donning polar bear slippers. The awkwardly designed Batman and Robin suits are a sight to behold, adding an unintentional humor to the movie. Remarkably, it also addresses global warming in an unexpected way.

4. Bloodsport (1988)

48% On Rotten Tomatoes

This movie solidified Jean-Claude Van Damme as the preferred action star of the time period and made sure his powerful, acrobatic kicks would be witnessed globally. However, critics weren’t overly favorable towards this excessively violent revenge flick where the main character competes in an underworld martial arts competition. The fight scenes are gruesome yet exciting, and the film definitely meets its billing.

In a different rendition: Chong Li, portrayed by Bolo Yeung, stands as one of the most formidable and intimidating adversaries in action movie history, particularly when pitted against Frank. The battle they engage in is legendary to say the least. While the script of the film Bloodsport may not be perfect, it certainly delivers on its promises. It offers an abundance of action, a thirst for vengeance, and some remarkable fight scenes that leave a lasting impression. Despite not setting the box office ablaze, owing to its specialized theme and excessive violence, it has morphed into a genre-defying marvel that continues to captivate martial arts enthusiasts worldwide.

3. Man On Fire (2004)

38% On Rotten Tomatoes

As a devoted fan, I’ve come to expect exceptional quality in any work Denzel Washington takes on, as his level of success and respect in the industry is unparalleled. It’s almost as if every film he stars in automatically elevates its status, given that it’s a privilege to have him involved. That being said, I found it peculiar that the movie “Man on Fire” received such negative reviews. The storyline is intricate, the action is raw and intense, and the performances are remarkably believable.

In a gritty, action-packed film, Washington portrays a complex character – an anti-hero with a golden heart who tenderly interacts with a vulnerable child, brilliantly acted by Dakota Fanning. This relationship forms the emotional backbone of the violent and intense movie, leaving viewers in suspense as to his actions. The intriguing characters and unexpected plot twists keep audiences hooked, despite criticism from critics. Contrary to their views, the audience seems to have embraced this movie, giving it an impressive 89% score on the Popcornmeter.

2. Gone In Sixty Seconds (2000)

26% On Rotten Tomatoes

Somehow defying expectations, actor Nicholas Cage transformed into an unconventional yet highly successful action hero. With numerous pulse-pounding masterpieces in his repertoire, he combines intellect and physical prowess in a manner that captivates viewers. Blockbuster productions like “Con Air”, “Face/Off”, and “The Rock” propelled him to the crest of a wave of popularity and global admiration. His Academy Award, which conferred an air of quality cherished by the more discerning action enthusiasts, further boosted his appeal.

Many other films involving his actions received mixed critical responses and remain intriguing to delve into, but Gone in Sixty Seconds possesses an unique charm that makes it a captivating relic from the past. This film predates the launch of the Fast and Furious series, yet it shares the same passion for automobiles. In this story, Nicolas Cage portrays a retired criminal compelled to resume his activities, exhibiting the qualities that once made him exceptional by racing against time to steal several vehicles in order to aid those he cherishes.

1. Road House (1989)

44% On Rotten Tomatoes

Many people may primarily associate Patrick Swayze with his romantic roles in movies like “Ghost” or “Dirty Dancing,” but there was also a grittier side to him. This was evident in films like “Point Break” from the ’90s, and even before that, he showcased his action prowess in “Road House.” It’s worth noting that “Road House” is considered one of his finest performances, as he portrayed a tormented character with a questionable past, who moved to a tranquil town plagued by corruption and brutality.

Prior to the controversial reboot of Amazon Prime, this original version was the preferred action movie for fans of underestimated classics. The violence is exceptional, particularly during James Dalton’s rampage, and the poignant twist involving Sam Elliott’s character strikes a deep chord with viewers. Despite not receiving the critical acclaim it merited, it has since been recognized by numerous generations of viewers and serves as a tribute to both the action genre and Swayze himself.

Read More

2025-04-20 20:05