A significant amount of discussion has centered around the Harry Potter film series, particularly its departures from the original content. However, one cherished character from the books was afforded minimal development on the silver screen. When Remus Lupin is initially introduced in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, he leaves a lasting impression and becomes someone the audience grows fond of and wishes to see more of. Regrettably, this doesn’t occur in subsequent Harry Potter films.
Instead of merely noticing the difference between Lupin’s reduced presence in the films compared to the books, it’s the absence of significant storylines involving him that stands out. Key elements of his character such as his personality traits, backstory, romantic relationships, and tragic end are barely touched upon in the movies, which is unfortunate. The lackluster portrayal of Lupin on screen represents a missed chance to delve deeper into this captivating character.
Harry’s Bond With Lupin Was Closer In The Books
After The Third Movie, The Two Barely Interact
In the movie “The Prisoner of Azkaban,” Lupin’s debut is a memorable scene. He bravely intervenes, rescuing Harry and his companions from a Dementor. After two tumultuous years at Hogwarts with Defense Against the Dark Arts teachers who were either under Voldemort’s control or inexperienced, Lupin brought a welcome change for the students. He was knowledgeable and compassionate, making him an ideal teacher.
In the story, Harry faced a significant challenge with the Dementors, but it was Lupin who offered crucial assistance. He provided Harry with private tutoring on casting the Patronus Charm, took him under his wing, and significantly, connected with him by sharing knowledge about Harry’s father. Their bond is pivotal in the movie until Sirius Black is unveiled as Harry’s godfather, which could potentially introduce complications.
In the movies, since there wasn’t enough space to include all the plotlines from the books, the bonding and guidance that Harry was supposed to receive from a father figure shifted primarily to Sirius (though it’s less significant than in the books). For the rest of the film series, Lupin becomes largely marginalized and has minimal interactions with Harry, mostly limited to a few brief conversations.
Lupin’s Romance With Tonks Is Almost A Non-Factor
The Movies Totally Skip Over The Whole Saga
In the later Harry Potter books, the relationship between Lupin and Tonks plays a significant role, although they are not always at the center of events. On the written page, it becomes clear that Tonks harbors feelings for Lupin, and while he reciprocates these feelings, he has reservations and hesitations as well. Lupin often finds reasons to delay or avoid their relationship, citing his financial struggles and age difference with her.
As a devoted fan, I can’t help but reflect on how deeply those pivotal moments in Tonks’ journey resonated with me. Her descent into depression and the subsequent deterioration of her transformative powers, coupled with the transformation of her Patronus, were poignant and engaging. However, it was their eventual union and marriage that truly warmed my heart. These instances were instrumental in drawing audiences closer to these characters. Regrettably, the films seemed to bypass these significant milestones, instead hastily pushing them together without providing a compelling backstory. This oversight diminished the emotional weight of any scene featuring them, leaving many viewers, like myself, yearning for a more profound connection.
The Arc About Tonks’ Pregnancy & Lupin’s Worries Was Cut
Lupin Attempted To Leave Tonks At One Point
In the end, it seemed his explanations about poverty and age were merely masks, concealing his deeper worry – his lycanthropy. As a werewolf myself, I had always been an outcast, and I feared that by marrying me, Tonks would share my fate. The thought of her becoming a werewolf weighed heavily on me, and it became even more unbearable when she became pregnant.
In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Lupin fretted about potentially passing his werewolf condition to his baby and voiced his concerns to Harry, Ron, and Hermione when they were all at Grimmauld Place. He suggested joining the trio in their quest for horcruxes, but Harry refused and reprimanded him for considering abandoning his child. This emotional exchange is among the most impactful in the series, but it’s not featured in the movies.
In this scenario, giving Remus more depth as a character would’ve been particularly impactful. Instead of simply being known as the werewolf ex-professor associated with the Order of the Phoenix, he could be portrayed as a complex individual prone to error but capable of learning and evolving from his mistakes. The poignant moment when Remus stood by Tonks during the birth of their son Teddy serves as a rewarding payoff for the struggle with Harry, creating a heartwarming sentiment.
Lupin Being Turned By Greyback Should’ve Meant More
The Movies Don’t Even Touch On It
One of the characters who plays a smaller role in the films compared to the books is Fenrir Greyback. While he may not be a major figure in the written work, his brief appearances are imposing. The way other characters talk about Greyback offers valuable insights into him. For instance, Draco finds him unsettling, and he’s known as the most ferocious werewolf. Greyback derives satisfaction from causing pain and torment, making his presence always tense. In fact, readers often find themselves on edge when he appears in the story.
In the films, crucial aspects about Greyback’s background and his role in attacking Lupin as a child and turning him into a werewolf are not fully explored. Given that Bill is assaulted by Greyback and left with scars, this topic should have been addressed more in the movies. Additionally, it is significant because this event influences the story of Remus and Tonks. When Bill’s girlfriend Fleur vows to love him despite his scars, Tonks draws parallels between their situations, which helps Remus find hope.
Including details about Greyback and his past with Lupin could have enriched several storylines. This would not only have deepened the unexplored aspects of Tonks and Remus’ relationship, making it more impactful, but also would have given Greyback a stronger presence as an antagonist. Instead of being just another henchman of Voldemort in the movies, his very existence should have been truly terrifying.
Lupin’s Death Was An Afterthought In The Movies
He Was Just Another Body In A Pile Of Them
The portrayal of Remus Lupin’s death in the movies is widely considered an unjust treatment, as it lacked the emotional impact that the books provided by spending ample time developing the characters. In the books, Lupin and Tonks’ tragic demise during the Battle of Hogwarts is heart-wrenching, particularly because young Teddy is left without parents, mirroring Harry’s orphanhood in his early years.
Sadly, their deaths don’t carry as much emotional weight in the films, as they are often glossed over. For instance, Lupin and Tonks are briefly mentioned, and then the story swiftly shifts to Harry discovering Snape’s true character from the Pensive. The manner in which these moments are portrayed and the limited development given to these characters leaves a disappointing impression, as these Harry Potter characters deserved more screen time and a more impactful send-off in the movies.
Read More
- CRK Boss Rush guide – Best cookies for each stage of the event
- Fortress Saga tier list – Ranking every hero
- Glenn Greenwald Sex Tape Leak: Journalist Cites “Maliciously Political” Motives
- Mini Heroes Magic Throne tier list
- Grimguard Tactics tier list – Ranking the main classes
- Cookie Run Kingdom Town Square Vault password
- Castle Duels tier list – Best Legendary and Epic cards
- How to Prepare and Dominate the Awakened Hollyberry Cookie Update
- Hero Tale best builds – One for melee, one for ranged characters
- Overwatch Stadium Tier List: All Heroes Ranked
2025-06-04 21:50