Supernatural’s Original Ending Was Perfect—But One Hidden Detail Ruins It

For fifteen seasons, Supernatural, one of the most thrilling TV shows, kept viewers hooked alongside the Winchester brothers. Although it was delightful to spend so much screen time with these characters, the original intended finale could have been even more satisfying. Debuting in 2005, Supernatural consistently ranks high among The CW’s best series, and the production of 327 episodes is truly remarkable, considering how the show managed to retain a substantial audience throughout its run.

The characters Dean, portrayed by Jensen Ackles, and Sam, played by Jared Padalecki, are among the most memorable on television, and their storylines throughout the 15 seasons of “Supernatural” were frequently touching, particularly as the show reached its conclusion in 2020. Remarkably, “Supernatural” became the longest-running series on The CW network, a far cry from its initial conception. Originally, the creator Eric Kripke (also known for “The Boys”) had envisioned the series to span only five seasons, which would have concluded “Supernatural” in an impressive manner.

Supernatural’s Original Ending Was Great, But There’s One Detail I Still Don’t Buy

Season 5’s Ending Was Nearly Perfect

As a dedicated fan of the genre, I can’t help but express my admiration for the extraordinary journey that “Supernatural” took during its first five seasons. Interestingly, these were the episodes initially planned to wrap up the series, and the climax of season 5 is often hailed as the show’s crowning achievement, even earning the highest rating on IMDb among all episodes. The finale was nothing short of spectacular, with each meticulously crafted plot point reaching its pinnacle. The battle against the Apocalypse, steeped in biblical lore, offered some of the most thrilling and emotionally resonant moments “Supernatural” has ever delivered.

Although the finale was almost flawless in wrapping up the series, there’s one part that left some viewers puzzled. In the final season, Sam sacrifices himself to shield Dean and mankind from Lucifer and the Apocalypse. This act lands Sam in Hell for what might have been an eternity, while Dean decides to quit hunting and settle down with Lisa. However, it seems illogical that Dean would simply accept Sam’s sacrifice without ever trying to rescue him from it.

Dean’s Season 5 Ending Is Exactly Why Supernatural Had To Continue

More Seasons Allowed Dean, Sam, And Castiel’s Story To Evolve Even More

Over the initial five seasons of “Supernatural”, viewers witnessed Dean Winchester going to great lengths to safeguard his brother. With personal knowledge of Hell, gained at the close of season 3, it appears Dean would go to any extent to prevent Sam from experiencing the same ordeal. Regrettably, given its immense popularity, the show needed to carry on, providing “Supernatural” a chance to rectify minor flaws in the original finale.

Indeed, it wasn’t Dean who rescued Sam from Hell during season 6; instead, it was Castiel (Misha Collins) who struck a deal with Crowley (Mark Sheppard) to help bring Sam back, but this agreement cost him his soul upon return. This continuation of Supernatural beyond season 5 not only provided opportunities for both Sam and Dean to grow further, but it also delved deeper into the character of Castiel, who had gained widespread popularity since his debut at the start of season 4.

Despite Its Dean Problem, The Show’s Original Ending Still Worked Better Than Its Real Finale

Season 5 Was The Pinnacle Of Supernatural

Despite some doubts about Dean’s actions towards the end of season 5, the original finale still felt more satisfying compared to the series finale in season 15 of Supernatural. The ending, while it divided fans, served more as a gentle conclusion rather than a grand finale. However, it was touching to witness a less dramatic and more personal closure for such shows, and Dean’s death was particularly impactful, especially when he meets Sam again in heaven after many years have passed.

The Winchester brothers’ continuation is always delightful, yet I can’t help but think that Supernatural season 5 might have been the perfect finale for the series. It seemed to tell a coherent story from start to finish, wrapping up in a way that felt definitive. However, the slight ambiguity of the original five-season arc could have resulted in something truly remarkable, despite Dean’s decision not to fight to restore Sam seeming slightly out of character.

2025-06-05 01:27