Harry Potter’s Forgotten Heroine: Why Fleur Deserved Better

by

In the intricate and expansive realm of the Wizarding World, the series itself boasted a multitude of characters that seemed nearly infinite in number due to this complexity. Although the primary trio and their associates were generally handled with thoughtfulness and sensitivity, there was one character who consistently received less recognition than she deserved – Fleur Delacour from Harry Potter. Unfortunately, the author’s portrayal of her was not flattering, and within the narrative, characters who had no valid reason to dislike her treated her unkindly.

In the novel “Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire”, Fleur was initially presented to readers as one of the four contestants in the Triwizard Tournament. She hailed from the Beauxbatons Academy of Magic in France, a fact that captured the interest of numerous wizards and witches. Given her part-Veela heritage, Fleur was exceptionally beautiful, but also gifted – traits that ironically led to her characterization in the story. Instead of emerging as a strong female figure, Fleur appeared to be portrayed as being criticized or belittled for her uniqueness, which seemed unjust given her abilities and beauty. This treatment felt unfair towards a character who deserved appreciation rather than degradation.

Fleur Delacour Was Dismissed For Superficial Reasons

There existed a mystical, partially human race called Veelas, who often appeared as enchantingly beautiful women with an alluring charm. However, when provoked, they could transform into terrifying bird-like creatures and hurl flames at those who had upset them. Fleur, although not a full Veela, was the offspring of a wizard and a Veela, inheriting some magical abilities such as the hypnotic beauty that Veelas often used as a weapon. Consequently, her arrival at Hogwarts stirred quite a buzz, particularly among the male student population.

For a large portion of her time in “Harry Potter”, she was often perceived through a narrow perspective that reduced her to merely a pretty girl. Characters such as Ron and Harry were portrayed as attempting to win her favor. Female characters, in particular, were critical of Fleur, assigning her undeserved negative characteristics, despite her consistently kind and courteous behavior towards Hogwarts students. Her accent and appearance were often criticized, even by the author and other characters within the story, when characters like Ron should have faced scrutiny for their reactions to a beautiful student instead.

I was part of the scene when several fresh faces graced Hogwarts halls from Beauxbatons and Durmstrang, yet none of them faced the level of scrutiny that Fleur Delacour did. Similar to her, Viktor Krum and Cedric Diggory were charming young men who caught the eye of many Hogwarts students, but they were consistently portrayed as heroes, unlike Fleur. While Ron might have harbored some resentment towards Viktor due to his friendship with Hermione in Quidditch, Viktor was always written about with admiration.

Essentially, it wasn’t Harry who held a grudge against Cedric due to his relationship with Cho, but it was emphasized that he remained a likable character. Unfortunately, Fleur, like other strong female characters such as Ginny, Hermione, and Mrs. Weasley, was portrayed unfairly by J.K. Rowling, echoing the negative bias towards her, which is now recognized as undeserved given the treatment she received in the “Harry Potter” series.

She Had Demonstrated Her Courage More Than Once

It’s often understated how brave Fleur truly was, and she consistently demonstrated this bravery in multiple instances. For one, being selected as a Triwizard champion was an indication of her exceptional abilities and potential, given that the magical Goblet of Fire is an unbiased selection tool that identifies raw talent and determination among students from the three schools. As the representative from Beauxbators, Fleur valiantly took on each task without fear, employing ingenious strategies to conquer the obstacles placed before her.

Regardless, she was consistently undervalued and not given the same level of respect as her peers during the tournament. After the tournament, Fleur’s storyline evolved into a romantic one when she fell for Bill Weasley, a dashing Gringotts curse breaker. Their relationship seemed fitting, but it was once more dismissed as being insignificant and shallow by the Weasleys and their associates. Rather than acknowledging that Bill had found genuine love in Fleur, Mrs. Weasley and Ginny instead chose to be unkind towards her, repeatedly calling her the nickname “Phlegm,” which eventually became a family term.

The Weasleys had no substantial grounds for suspecting Fleur’s affection was temporary, which primarily sprang from deep-rooted bias and prejudice towards the ex-student of Beauxbatons. They consistently underestimated her, and unfortunately, this persistent mistreatment of Fleur lasted for a considerable period until Bill was bitten by Fenrir Greyback during the Second Wizarding War. Many assumed she would cancel the wedding, but true to form, she demonstrated courage, challenging Bill’s family about their belief that she would abandon her beloved. Her loyalty towards him was steadfast, underscoring her strength and unwavering convictions throughout.

In a consistent manner, she was deeply affectionate and faithful towards everyone, be it her younger sister or Bill. However, it seemed as though the Weasley women were determined to view her negatively, regardless of her actions. Yet, upon marrying Bill and maintaining her sincerity, there was a slight shift in how others perceived her. She demonstrated her courage and resilience during the war and even provided Shell Cottage as a safe haven for the Order of the Phoenix. Unfortunately, by this point, the damage had already been done, and she had been stereotyped for too long. The change in attitude came much too late in the story, leaving little justice for Fleur’s character portrayal.

Fleur’s Treatment Showed a Fatal Flaw In the Harry Potter Series

Although Fleur possessed great strength, courage, and emotional intelligence, she was unfortunately subjected to stereotypes and offensive remarks, revealing a regrettable aspect in the narrative. It seemed that this treatment towards her stemmed from her being an outsider – hailing from France, possessing a distinct accent, and adhering to customs unlike those of the British wizards. Other characters may have faced similar prejudices, but Fleur was unfairly targeted. Regrettably, instead of embracing her unique culture and welcoming her as the Triwizard Tournament intended, Fleur was ridiculed for her differences.

In the Harry Potter series, everything Fleur said was often seen as overly dramatic, cold, or foolish, even though her points were logical. Her accent, transcribed literally in the books, gave the impression that she was more silly than she actually was, leading readers to mock her accent rather than focusing on what she was saying. This treatment of Fleur shows a hint of xenophobia and was disheartening for those who admired the book for its messages of love, camaraderie, tolerance, and diversity.

Fleur was not cold or haughty; instead, she was a person striving to acclimate herself in a novel situation. She consistently displayed remarkable courage, kindness, and geniality, even under intense pressure, such as the Triwizard tasks. However, she was met with immense hostility from characters and readers alike, who failed to appreciate her significant role in the narrative. Fleur risked her own safety for love and welcomed the Order into her home following her wedding, an action not commonly taken. Bill and Fleur displayed comparable bravery as James and Lily, but Fleur was never elevated to the pedestal that Lily was. Her character was significantly undervalued, yet there’s optimism that the HBO reboot of Harry Potter will do her justice.

Read More

2025-06-05 02:06