Real Historian Slams Zack Snyder’s ‘300’ as Inaccurate & Cartoony

by

As a historian who has spent years delving into the annals of ancient Greece, I can confidently say that “300” is more of a fantastical retelling than a historical account. While it may appeal to those who appreciate Zack Snyder’s signature style, it’s important for history enthusiasts to understand the liberties taken in this film.

300 remains a popular choice among many as Zack Snyder’s most impressive work (with Watchmen close behind). This gritty historical action film portrays the clash between 300 Spartan warriors and the Persian army during the Battle of Thermopylae in 480BC. Gerard Butler, Lena Headey, Michael Fassbender, Dominic West, and David Wenham star in this production that delights Snyder’s fans with its intricate fight scenes, earthy color schemes, and frequent slow motion. However, it should be noted that the movie deviates significantly from historical facts.

Historian Roel Konijnendijk discussed the film 300 with History Hit and pointed out that it should not be relied upon as a historical source. While the movie is filled with action scenes, its title might not be an accurate representation of the number of Spartans involved in the battle. Konijnendijk explained, “While some sources suggest there were 300, others indicate that as many as 1000 Spartans may have been sent.

“In the movie 300, the first appearance of the Spartans in their armor is one of its most iconic moments. As Konijnendijk noted, their armor seemed quite extraordinary and humorous to him.

Over time, it has developed into such a recognizable symbol. It’s challenging not to associate it with this image now. You see these characters decked out only in cloaks, wielding what seems like poorly made replicas of shields and spears. In reality, Spartans would have donned armor in combat. While they do wear tunics and armor beneath their tunics, you’d expect them to be wearing helmets and greaves as well. Their shields are supposedly made of wood, with bronze plating. The depiction in the graphic novel is more of a cartoonish version.

Sorry ‘300’, War Rhinos Aren’t Real

During the conflict between King Leonidas and the 300 Spartans against the Persian troops, led by King Xerxes, an array of extraordinary soldiers arrived from various parts of the Persian empire. In Zack Snyder’s portrayal, these forces included war elephants, massive war rhinos (which are purely fictional), and the formidable Immortals. Konijnendijk explained, “There are some really unusual tactics employed here. It’s important to note that war rhinos don’t exist – they’re not a real thing.

“I have no idea what Frank Miller was snorting when he came up with this!”

In the movie 300, it was clearly the Immortals of Xerxes, a select band of Persian warriors, who posed the greatest threat. However, the portrayal of them by Frank Miller (author of the 300 graphic novel) and Zack Snyder is purely fictional. Konijnendijk found their depiction intriguing as he watched their introduction, saying, “It’s quite peculiar, what are these guys up to?

The Immortals, as described by Herodotus, are believed to be real but enigmatic entities because they have only been mentioned in his writings and have not been referenced again in history. Their appearance would have been vastly different from how they’re portrayed today. Frank Miller seems to have had some unusual inspiration when creating these ‘Immortals’, which resemble something between monsters and ninjas, but their true nature remains unclear. The movie suggests that the Immortals have been serving the Persians for 500 years. However, it’s important to note that the Persian Empire was established around 550 BCE at the earliest, making a 500-year service under the empire unlikely.

Still, while 300 may not be anywhere close to a documentary, that was never really the point. So sit back and enjoy Snyder’s ridiculously fantastical retelling while await the arrival of the prequel.

Read More

2024-12-24 17:31