The 17-Year-Old Anne Hathaway Drama That Was Robbed at the Oscars

by

2025’s Academy Awards season now seems like a distant memory, yet it’s already behind us completely. The 97th edition of the prestigious event ended not with a grand finale, but a quiet conclusion. Unlike past years marked by highly contentious winners such as Green Book for Best Picture or Will Smith for Best Actor after the slap incident, 2025 was remarkably controversy-free overall. However, it’s never possible to satisfy everyone, and 2025 was no exception. Occasionally, a disgruntled critic has voiced dissatisfaction with Mickie Madison’s Best Actress win, suggesting that Demi Moore or Fernanda Torres were wronged. Those claiming Madison’s victory as an injustice, however, may not be fully aware of the injustices from 2009.

2009 marked the unveiling of “Rachel Getting Married” for me, a movie that left me cringing and on edge with its raw, emotional drama. The story unfolds mainly at the wedding ceremony, and it boasts an ensemble cast that will tug at your heartstrings and make you squirm, even if you’re not easily uncomfortable. The standout performer in this film isn’t Rachel herself, but her sister Kym Buchman, brilliantly played by Anne Hathaway. Hathaway earned an Academy Award nomination for her role, a recognition that unfortunately didn’t translate into a win at the 81st Oscars, a decision that has since been considered one of the biggest oversights in Oscar history.

What is Rachel Getting Married About?

2008 marked Jonathan Demme’s return to storytelling cinema after a four-year hiatus following “The Manchurian Candidate”. During this break, his experiences with Neil Young and Jimmy Carter influenced the stylistic choices in “Rachel Getting Married”. The film was shot in a cinéma vérité style, characterized by a mobile and unsteady camera, authentic-sounding and seemingly spontaneous dialogue, and a strong emphasis on realism.

In a harmonious union, the documentary-influenced filmmaking approach teamed with Jonathan Demme’s knack for humanism created an ideal pairing. Demme, who wasn’t just terrifying viewers with movies like “Silence of the Lambs,” also showed a profound compassion and insight into unique human struggles. Films such as “Philadelphia” with Tom Hanks and Denzel Washington, and the less remembered “Citizen’s Band,” clearly demonstrate this empathy. “Rachel Getting Married” draws on Demme’s late-career expertise and learns from his early career missteps, resulting in near perfection.

The movie “Rachel Getting Married” mainly focuses on Kym Buchman, a woman recovering from drug addiction, who is allowed to leave rehab under certain conditions to attend her sister Rachel’s wedding. At first, everyone is happy and excited about Kym’s return, but old hurts soon resurface as Kym either intentionally or unintentionally draws attention to herself. The main source of conflict arises from a tragic incident that happened years ago, when Kym’s drug addiction unwittingly led to the death of their younger brother. Kym’s presence disrupts what was supposed to be a relaxing and harmonious wedding weekend, causing other family tensions to surface.

The movie ahead offers a raw, intense portrayal of a troubled family grappling with their emotional turmoil. Director Demme, screenwriter Jenny Lumet, and the stellar cast brilliantly capture the unbreakable ties of family. Over its 113 minutes, it delves into the intricate dynamics of love, dislike, violence, and recovery. This film is arguably the most authentic portrayal of addiction and recovery ever filmed. Each character’s journey is meticulously detailed, with profound insights into familial bonds, unresolved pain, grief, and the challenging path of self-forgiveness. Rachel Getting Married fearlessly tackles awkwardness and complexity, reflecting beautifully the complexities and messiness of real life.

As a devoted cinephile, I can’t help but reflect on the captivating movie, “Rachel Getting Married,” which has somehow slipped into obscurity in recent years. However, let me tell you, when it graced our cinema screens, this film was nothing short of a revolution!

Although it may not be a common topic of conversation today, its impact upon release was immense. The unique blend of drama and documentary-style storytelling was a risk that paid off handsomely for director Demme. Starring the talented Anne Hathaway, this movie was a moderate box office success, earning $17.5 million against a budget of just $12 million. Even more impressive is its subsequent success in small theatrical re-releases.

In terms of critical acclaim, “Rachel Getting Married” has solidified itself as a must-watch for both Demme’s masterful direction and the outstanding performances by its ensemble cast. On Rotten Tomatoes, it currently boasts a certified fresh 85% rating from critics, with a slightly lower, but understandable, 62% rating from fans. All in all, this film is a testament to the power of great storytelling and should not be forgotten.

Anne Hathaway Won the Wrong Oscar

2009 was an intriguing year at the Oscars, marked by a scarcity in the Best Picture category compared to previous years, yet brimming with remarkable contenders for the main acting categories. Notably, the Best Actress category boasted some of the most prestigious names in Hollywood, including Meryl Streep in Doubt, Kate Winslet in The Reader, and Melissa Leo in Frozen River. Despite this formidable lineup, Anne Hathaway’s loss in that category holds the record for the most significant upset in Academy Award history – a testament to the existence of the “consolation Oscar.

For a considerable period, just like her “Titanic” co-star Leonardo DiCaprio, the renowned actress Kate Winslet had endured similar luckless situations without winning an award. Up until 2009 when she triumphed for “The Reader,” she had been nominated five times in both Best Actress and Best Supporting Actress categories, but failed to clinch a victory. This string of losses led the Academy to come together in 2009 for what could be seen as an unfortunate consolation win. It’s important to note that Kate Winslet’s talent is undeniable, with her portrayal in “The Reader” being commendable; however, it doesn’t overshadow the brilliance of her other nominated performances.

The ripple effects of the 2009 consolation decision have persisted for many years and will probably continue to do so indefinitely. If Kate Winslet had received an award in 1998 for Titanic or in 2007 for Little Children, when she truly deserved it, the Academy would not have had to deny Anne Hathaway her win for Rachel Getting Married in 2009. Furthermore, if Anne Hathaway had won in 2009, she might not have gained the remarkable momentum that led to her outstanding performance in Les Misérables in 2013.

If Anne Hathaway hadn’t excelled in her role in 2013, it would have paved the way for Amy Adams to receive her first Academy Award for The Master. This chain of events could have continued indefinitely. The case of Anne Hathaway in Rachel Getting Married stands as a timeless lesson to the Academy of Motion Pictures that choosing the most deserving nominee is always the correct decision. Although Anne Hathaway has numerous award-worthy performances, none compare to the extraordinary talent showcased in Jonathan Demme’s 2008 masterpiece.

Rachel Getting Married’s Ensemble Holds Their Own

In this critically acclaimed film, the standout performance by the lead actress was met with stiff competition from the rest of the talented cast. The intense performances were further heightened by Demme’s unique, intimate filming approach. However, each actor and actress deserves immense praise for their exceptional performances. Whether it’s Debra Winger as the family matriarch or Rosemarie DeWitt in the title role, every performer delivers an outstanding performance. They skillfully convey unspoken emotions and decades of familial connection through realistic dialogue and meaningful glances. In this movie, the unsaid words carry just as much weight as passionate debates. The credit for such a powerful performance goes to the dedicated actors who brought the story to life.

Beyond Hathaway, the film’s standout performer is Bill Irwin. In his role, he depicts Paul Buchman, a father who is both deeply compassionate and highly anxious. Irwin delivers his performance with infectious energy, often bouncing around excitedly and at other times displaying trembling lips and watery eyes. Although Kym Buchman, played by Hathaway, is the most empathetic and emotionally volatile character, Paul, portrayed by Irwin, is the one who subtly resonates with viewers the most.

In the movie “Rachel Getting Married“, various facets of grief are delved into extensively. These range from raw emotion suppression, searching for diversions, long-term dedication to preserving memories, all the way to carrying guilt and blame. Every element of filmmaking here is finely calibrated, and it’s an experience that needs to be witnessed to be fully appreciated.

Read More

2025-05-04 02:51