Why Bioshock’s ‘Would You Kindly’ Twist Was Brilliant But Could’ve Been More Brutal

by

2007 saw me being captivated by the release of BioShock, a game that swiftly etched itself into the annals of gaming lore. It wasn’t just the haunting underwater setting that caught my attention, but a plot twist so mind-boggling, it left an entire generation of gamers in a state of wide-eyed wonder.

The phrase “Would you be so kind?” significantly altered how games presented their stories and the player’s involvement within them. This distinctive technique left an indelible mark, but perhaps its impact could have been even more profound if it had dared to venture beyond established limits a bit more.

In the tale of BioShock, the protagonist is a character named Jack, who finds himself stranded in the underwater metropolis of Rapture that’s fallen into ruin. As players navigate the chaos, they receive guidance from Atlas, a voice that appears to provide helpful counsel.

As I delved into the game’s world, I found myself often given seemingly mundane tasks – like picking up a wrench. Little did I realize, these simple commands were not just instructions but triggers, subtly guiding my actions. In truth, neither Jack nor I was making our own choices, but rather following a script laid out for us by the creators of this captivating universe.

Everything leading up to that moment was influenced by longstanding programming, as revealed dramatically to Andrew Ryan. This disclosure fundamentally changed the anticipated outcome, serving as a commentary on the deceptive nature of choice in video games.

As a gaming enthusiast, for years I’ve been navigating from target to target in countless shooter games, unquestioningly following instructions. Then, BioShock came along and challenged that blind obedience, asking: were we ever truly the masters of our own destiny? The gradual unfolding of the plot made it clear that the control was intentionally manipulated all along.

Ken Levine, the game’s creator, aimed to delve into the conflict between free will and destiny. The phrase “Would you kindly?” was subtly integrated throughout the initial part of the game, though it remained hidden yet obvious to players. For numerous gamers, this revelation felt like a hard blow.

In the same vein as your experience with the game, I found myself ensnared just like Jack, oblivious to the manipulation until it was too late to escape. This revelation is one of the most captivating twists in gaming history, sparking countless discussions. It masterfully intertwined storytelling and gameplay mechanics in a way that felt remarkably fresh and unique back then.

Rediscovering that saving or gathering the Little Sisters held little significance when considering the grander manipulation scheme wasn’t surprising. The plot twist was inventive, yet it might have been even more impactful had tension been established earlier in the narrative.

In most instances where Jack is under mind control – fighting adversaries, gathering tools, and investigating Rapture – these actions seem logical for a survival scenario. Given that players rarely pause to consider their own actions, the twist usually comes across as an intriguing detail rather than a shockingly impactful surprise for some.

The true force behind a mind-control plot twist comes from the tension it creates. Imagine being compelled against your will to perform an action that goes against your inclinations, perhaps something morally dubious or harmful.

Discovering later that your actions weren’t truly your own would amplify the shock of the plot twist. This concept is hinted at during the Andrew Ryan scene, but it’s here where the idea of mind control becomes more bone-chillingly real and significant in BioShock.

Minute variations in conduct, such as puzzling commands that seem slightly off, unexpected moves, or selections that give you a sense of discomfort yet can’t be avoided, might have sown seeds of uncertainty.

As a gamer, I found myself pondering the events unfolding before the big twist. A little more subtle hinting would have made the reveal all the more satisfyingly clever. Truth be told, there’s an in-game rationale for why things transpired as they did. Fontaine, disguised as Atlas, needed me (Jack) alive and functional for his own purposes.

As a gamer, I realized that pushing me towards perilous or morally questionable moves could’ve compromised his strategy. Jack was Fontaine’s secret weapon, and it was crucial to keep him on edge rather than revealing the whole deck.

The instructions are clear and follow a logical sequence, yet they don’t change the overall gameplay. A more impactful emotional response might have been achieved if the commands sometimes seemed unexpected or incorrect.

After the unexpected turn of events, you continue to hear echoes reminiscent of Tenenbaum’s voice, causing doubt about regaining full autonomy. The meaning is clear, yet it slips away, fading too swiftly amidst the shock’s passing. Over time, “Would you kindly?” has become one of the most frequently repeated phrases in gaming culture.

In this rephrased version:

* The first sentence was reworded to use “you” instead of “one,” making it more conversational and direct.
* The second sentence was restructured for clarity, emphasizing the speed at which shock fades away and how meaning slips away with it.
* The third sentence was revised to highlight the impact of the phrase over time, focusing on its enduring popularity in gaming culture.

In contemporary game design education and discussions about interactive narratives, BioShock is frequently mentioned as a significant influence. However, with modern games such as The Stanley Parable and Spec Ops: The Line exploring similar ideas in greater depth, it’s evident that BioShock might have delved even deeper into its themes.

It’s still a classic, no doubt, but its twist is both brilliant and a near-miss.

Perhaps that’s why such moments leave a lasting impact on individuals. It isn’t merely about what transpired, but rather the potential outcomes that remained unexplored.

Read More

2025-04-17 11:12