Young Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang Theory

Young Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang Theory

Quick Links

  • The Laugh Track Is Coming Back in the Young Sheldon Spinoff
  • What Fans Have to Say About the Georgie & Mandy Laugh Track
  • Could This Be a Generational Thing?

As someone who grew up in the golden age of television, I can’t help but feel a twinge of nostalgia when it comes to multi-camera sitcoms with laugh tracks. The ’80s and ’90s were a time when these shows ruled the airwaves, and they left an indelible mark on my formative years. Shows like Seinfeld, Cheers, and The King of Queens were part of the fabric of my life, providing both laughter and life lessons in equal measure.


Sitcoms vary greatly, ranging from the single camera approach to mockumentary styles. For instance, a show like “Modern Family” uses a unique blend of single-camera and mockumentary techniques, while something like “The Conners” is filmed with a live studio audience. Despite these differences, both formats are enjoyed by audiences for their unique qualities.

On the other hand, there’s a specific approach they’re using for the “Young Sheldon” spinoff, titled “Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage”, which many viewers aren’t finding appealing.

The Laugh Track Is Coming Back in the Young Sheldon Spinoff

Young Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang Theory

Laugh tracks were frequently used in sitcoms during the ’90s, serving as pre-recorded laughter played after a joke or humorous moment. They were popular at the time and are still effective in some shows. However, viewers find it inappropriate for the show “Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage“.

In contrast to some criticism, the creators have affirmatively stated that laughter sounds will be incorporated within this new series centered around Sheldon Cooper’s brother Georgie (Montana Jordan) and his wife Mandy (Emily Osment). It has also been suggested that the show will employ a multi-camera setup and feature a live audience for filming.

As stated by Cinemablend, creators Chuck Lorre and Steve Holland are unfazed by using the classic multi-camera approach, often deemed outdated by some. They argue that if a story resonates with viewers, it nullifies the notion that the format is obsolete. Notably, this method was successfully used in The Big Bang Theory, from which Young Sheldon spun off as a spinoff.

In a departure from its original format, Young Sheldon abandoned the use of laugh tracks and live audiences, instead adopting a more serious tone. As a spinoff series directly following Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage, which is itself a prequel to The Big Bang Theory, some fans find this change to be incongruous. However, producer Chuck Lorre remains resolute in his decision. “Was it funny?” he queries about the essence of producing a show. “If it made people laugh, that’s not a bad day. I don’t concern myself with what the industry deems viable; I focus on doing things I enjoy.

Given the heavy tone of the last episode in ‘Young Sheldon’, which dealt with the sad demise of George Sr. (Lance Barber), introducing a live studio audience and laughter could serve as a refreshing change, reminding viewers that despite its somber moments, this series is essentially a sitcom. Known for his quips and silliness, Georgie has always been the source of comic relief in tense situations within ‘Young Shendon’.

Mandy possesses a witty sarcasm that suits this particular style, just as Missy (Raegan Revord) does, having been cast in the upcoming series. She is set to reprise her role as Sheldon’s twin sister and Georgie’s younger sibling. This new approach could be exactly what the creators aim to achieve.

What Fans Have to Say About the Georgie & Mandy Laugh Track

Young Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang Theory

Nonetheless, the reception has been polarizing from fans looking forward to seeing a continued journey with these beloved characters delivered in a similar tone. Some outright say they won’t watch if this is the approach that the show takes. Redditor The_PoliticianTCWS believes that being a live audience show means the series is “so over” before it has even begun. Snoo-8954 says the laugh track is the reason they couldn’t continue to watch The Big Bang Theory.

ExtensionCake6 observes that canned laughter gives the impression of a live stage performance. I prefer to immerse myself in a show as a temporary escape from everyday life, but when it seems like the whole production is a staged setup with actors performing before a live audience, it ruins the illusion for me.

In simpler terms, DiamondFiveYT expresses disappointment if the new spinoff is a multi-camera production as it dampens his enthusiasm. On the other hand, user oktobeokk indicates they are okay with this format, even though others dislike the humor. They claim their mind tends to ignore it during episodes, but recall its presence only when it’s discussed on Reddit.

Captain_Aids reassures viewers that since the show is being produced by the team responsible for some of the most successful sitcoms ever made, such as The Big Bang Theory and Young Sheldon, among others like Two and a Half Men and Mom, they have a good chance of success. However, it’s important to remember that even this talented team has had shows that didn’t perform well. For instance, the sitcom United States of Al, released in 2021, was canceled after just two seasons. Similarly, B Positive, another show from their stable, met the same unfortunate end.

Could This Be a Generational Thing?

Young Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang TheoryYoung Sheldons Spinoff Is Borrowing One Aspect of The Big Bang Theory

The negative reaction might be more about generational preferences than a criticism towards multi-camera, laughter-recorded sitcoms from the ’80s and ’90s. People who grew up during those years are likely familiar with this format, as it was popular back then and gave birth to some of the most memorable sitcoms in history. In fact, these classic sitcoms have greatly influenced today’s productions and continue to be remade, reimagined, or revived in one way or another. It’s clear that they were successful in their approach.

Today’s younger audiences, having been raised on shows like “Young Sheldon” and “The Big Bang Theory,” find the format somewhat antiquated and reminiscent of programming their parents or grandparents might have watched. They struggle to connect with it due to a sense of staleness they can’t quite comprehend. However, there’s also an appealing retro charm to it that they can’t ignore.

The use of a laugh track and live audience clearly indicates that what we’re watching is scripted and performed by actors. While this is common knowledge, it tends to distract us from fully engaging with the characters and their stories. On the flip side, it allows for amusing moments like characters acknowledging the audience (as Will Smith frequently did in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air), which can be enjoyable. However, it’s worth noting that laugh tracks can sometimes diminish the emotional investment viewers have in the characters and storylines. Yet, they can also create a sense of shared humor with the audience at home.

If Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage resembles The Big Bang Theory, it means that its charm isn’t primarily in its storyline. Instead, it lies in the clever writing, the way lines are delivered, including iconic one-liners and catchphrases, and the humor present in every episode. This show might concentrate on portraying family dynamics, young parents struggling to make ends meet, and meddling parents offering unsolicited advice. Viewers at home may enjoy being prompted to laugh during some of the more light-hearted scenes.

These popular shows like “The King of Queens,” “Will & Grace,” “Everybody Loves Raymond,” “Seinfeld,” “Two and a Half Men,” “Cheers,” and “How I Met Your Mother” (and many others) often incorporate laugh tracks or live studio audiences. They’re staples of their respective genres, and Chuck Lorre has consistently shown courage in his creative choices. However, whether adding a laugh track to a show is the right choice remains debatable; viewers will only be able to form an opinion after watching the series and understanding its unique approach.

This isn’t “The Big Bang Theory” or “Young Sheldon,” but rather “Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage.” This new series might share similar characters, yet it blazes its own trail. Whether there’s a laugh track or not, the true test lies in whether the shows will bring laughter to audiences at home, which is what truly matters. Premiering on October 17, 2024 on CBS, episodes of “Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage” will be available for streaming on Paramount+ following their initial broadcast.

Read More

2024-09-10 03:31