10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

As we delve into the captivating lives of these exceptional actors who graced our screens with their mesmerizing performances, I can’t help but marvel at the paths they chose and the roles they turned down. Take Geoffrey Bayldon, for instance, a man whose thespian prowess was as enchanting as Shakespeare himself, yet he shied away from the allure of science fiction.


For over five decades, the enthralling science fiction phenomenon known as “Doctor Who” has spellbound viewers worldwide. First airing on November 23, 1963, it quickly became an essential piece of television programming. The show is centered around a mysterious extraterrestrial being called simply the Doctor, who belongs to the Time Lord race and travels through time and space using his spaceship, the TARDIS. The original series ran from 1963 until 1989, with an initial revival attempt in 1996 via the television film “Doctor Who.” It wasn’t until 2005 that the cherished classic was successfully rebooted.

Many captivating and indelible actors from Hollywood have taken on the lead role, with well-known figures like David Tennant, Matt Smith, and Peter Capaldi each giving a unique interpretation to the iconic character. Landing the part of the renowned doctor is considered a prestigious privilege, a dream that many aspire to attain, but some noteworthy actors have declined the chance to star in this groundbreaking show.

Here are 10 actors who were offered the lead role in Doctor Who and said no.

10 Hugh Grant

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

The captivatingly witty Hugh Grant has graced the silver screen consistently for more than four decades. However, it was during the ’90s that he truly captured the hearts of many with iconic performances in timeless films such as Sense and Sensibility, Four Weddings and a Funeral, and Notting Hill. He further solidified his status as one of Hollywood’s top leading men with roles in Bridget Jones’s Diary, About a Boy, Two Weeks Notice, and the cherished Christmas movie Love Actually.

Grant’s Big Career Regret

As a movie connoisseur, I’ve been fortunate to witness Grant’s versatile acting skills not only on the silver screen but also on television over the years. He graced our screens with unforgettable performances in the critically acclaimed miniseries ‘A Very English Scandal’ and ‘The Undoing’, though fate had him narrowly miss out on playing an iconic character when the legendary sci-fi series was reborn in 2005.

In 2004, Showrunner Russell T Davies contacted the actor to discuss his availability for a project. However, Grant turned down the offer at first, believing it wouldn’t succeed. His decision proved regrettable when he later realized how successful the revival turned out to be. In 2007, Grant himself admitted this.

A couple of years ago, I was given the chance to play The Doctor, and I felt incredibly honored. However, there’s a risk with such opportunities – you don’t truly appreciate how well it could have been until you see it on screen, and then think, ‘I wish I had accepted, that performance was great!’ Yet, considering my track record, I probably would have botched it up.

9 Boris Karloff

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

Legendary horror actor Boris Karloff is most famously recognized for his chilling portrayal of Frankenstein’s monster in the trailblazing 1931 movie “Frankenstein.” After that, he returned to the role in two more spine-tingling sequels. Throughout his career spanning over half a century and 174 films, Karloff remained faithful to horror, playing iconic characters like Imhotep in “The Mummy,” as well as roles in “The Old Dark House,” “The Ghoul,” “The Black Cat,” and “The Raven.

From Frankenstein to Doctor Who?

Previously, Karloff was well-known and acclaimed in the radio sphere. In the late ’60s, he was invited to play the Doctor not on TV but over the airwaves, an opportunity he respectfully turned down. Later, horror icon Peter Cushing consented to record the initial episode for the Doctor Who radio show, but the project failed to fully materialize after the BBC chose not to proceed with it.

In 1969, at the age of 81, Karloff sadly passed away. If he had accepted the role for the series, his portrayal as the Doctor would’ve been a brief run. However, it would have been intriguing to witness his unique take on playing an extraterrestrial character.

8 Peter Cushing

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

A highly recognized figure in the world of film, television, and theater, Peter Cushing, graced numerous screens with his presence, appearing in over a hundred films and twenty-two horror productions from Hammer Studios between the 1950s and 1970s. Renowned for embodying characters such as Baron Frankenstein, Dr. Van Helsing, and sharing the limelight with stars like Christopher Lee and Vincent Price, Cushing was frequently associated with horror films despite his versatility and notable roles in Hamlet, The Hounds of Baskerville, and Star Wars.

Cushing Had No Desire to Star in the Series

Despite taking on the role of the Doctor in two “Doctor Who” movies – “Dr Who and the Daleks” (1965) and “Daleks – Invasion Earth: 2150 AD” (1966) – Cushing declined to participate in the television series, despite being approached as a potential replacement for both the First Doctor William Hartnell and Third Doctor Jon Pertwee on several occasions.

As stated by Cushing, he was required to withdraw due to other artistic commitments, and it appears that he held no regrets about this choice whatsoever. Later on, he even disclosed:

At one point, they extended an offer to me, but at that moment, I was preoccupied and couldn’t accept it. Even if I had been available, I’m not sure I would have gone through with it. To be honest, I wasn’t fond of the Doctor Who images or the show itself; they just didn’t appeal to me. Furthermore, those pesky Daleks really grated on my nerves.

7 Alan Cumming

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

I’ve been fortunate to tread the boards and silver screen with great distinction, earning a BAFTA, two Tony Awards, and two Emmys along the way – that’s me, Alan Cumming, speaking here! While my quirky charm may have initially drawn you in, it’s my roles like Nightcrawler in X2: X-Men United, Fegan Floop in Spy Kids, and appearances in GoldenEye, Emma, Spice World, and Eyes Wide Shut that truly solidified my place in your hearts. And let’s not forget my small screen successes, gracing shows like The Good Wife, Schmigadoon!, and The Traitors with my presence. It’s been quite a ride!

Cumming Refused to Relocate

Following Hugh Grant’s refusal to lead the 2005 reboot series, Russell T Davies shifted his focus towards Cumming, who was then basking in the success of the blockbuster film X2: X-Men United. However, as Cumming was unwilling to move from New York to Wales (where Doctor Who was being filmed), he declined Davies’ offer to embody the beloved character.

Despite appearing as King James in a 2018 episode of the show, Cumming found it difficult to part with his home and Broadway career, even for a brief period. In an interview with The Huffpost in 2017, he expressed this sentiment.

Initially, I responded, “Absolutely, I still have a place in London, which would be ideal.” Then he mentioned, “For about eight months of the year, it’s Cardiff…” To which I replied, “Wait, what?” It seems that comment might have been the turning point. While I hold no grudge against Cardiff, let me make this clear: I’d go to great lengths for Doctor Who, but I won’t compromise on that.

6 Bill Nighy

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

Bill Nighy, the award-winning star known for his exceptional performances in films like “Love Actually,” the “Underworld” series, “The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy,” and “The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel,” is unquestionably one of cinema’s most distinguished actors. His television roles are equally impressive, with appearances on shows such as “State of Play,” “Page Eight,” and “Ordeal by Innocence.

Nighy Didn’t Want the Excessive Baggage

It’s thought that Nighy was first approached to star in “Doctor Who” around 2004, during the preparations for the show’s revival and the search for their principal actor. Similar to Alan Cumming, Nighy might not have accepted the role as the main character, but he did make an appearance in the “Doctor Who” universe in 2010, playing an art curator in the episode titled “Vincent and the Doctor.

Reflecting on his decision to decline the popular role, Nighy expressed disinterest in the passionate fanbase associated with the series, sharing this sentiment with Daily Express in 2013.

I can’t give you a specific timeline, as it’s considered impolite to mention declining an opportunity like that. Instead, I’ll tell you I was offered something, but I didn’t feel suitable for the role. No offense intended towards Doctor Who or the position itself; I simply believe it carries unnecessary burdens.

5 Peter Capaldi

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

Fans of Doctor Who know that Peter Capaldi gave a stunning performance as the twelfth version of the Doctor in the science fiction series, but he might have taken on this iconic role much earlier in his career if he hadn’t held himself back. Before gaining wider recognition with the groundbreaking show, Capaldi played Malcolm Tucker in the British comedy The Thick of It and appeared in films such as Paddington, Christopher Robin, and The Personal History of David Copperfield.

Nerves Get the Best of Superfan Capaldi

Peter Capaldi eagerly seized the role of the Doctor, commencing his remarkable stint in 2013 and appearing in “Doctor Who” for three series and four specials until 2017. However, he nearly became a part of the show as early as 1996 when he was invited to audition for the movie version, “Doctor Who: The Movie.” Yet, he declined the offer because he was too passionate about the character and felt he lacked the necessary experience to seriously contend for the role. Reflecting on his decision in 2014, Capaldi acknowledged that he was too much of a fan at the time.

“I was aware from the start that I wouldn’t land the role because I adored the show so deeply, and I didn’t want to participate unless it was for certain that I would play the part. The thought of going through all the necessary steps just to be disappointed wasn’t appealing to me. So I informed my agent, ‘I appreciate your efforts, but I prefer not to move forward with this opportunity.’

4 Benedict Cumberbatch

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

Following impressive performances as the beloved detective Sherlock Holmes in “Sherlock” and the gifted superhero Dr. Stephen Strange within the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Benedict Cumberbatch has consistently demonstrated his ability to captivate audiences as a leading man in Hollywood. Beyond these two blockbuster franchises, Cumberbatch has received Academy Award nominations for his compelling performances in “The Imitation Game” and “The Power of the Dog,” while also gracing the screen in “Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy,” “12 Years a Slave,” “1917,” and the “Hobbit” film series.

Too Much Branding & Merchandise for Cumberbatch

Benedict Cumberbatch was offered a chance to play the Eleventh Doctor before Matt Smith took on the iconic role from 2010 to 2013. His fellow actor and friend, David Tennant, encouraged him to audition for the part, but Cumberbatch felt he wasn’t suitable and thought he wouldn’t offer anything fresh to the show; he later stated, “Those are big shoes to fill, and I think I’m more like David than Matt [Smith].” Although Cumberbatch became known for portraying Sherlock Holmes from 2010 to 2017, he declined the opportunity to be the face of Doctor Who merchandise, expressing in 2011: “It’s a beloved series, and I didn’t want to represent it as a brand.

One reason the role of “Doctor Who” is challenging is due to the fact that you’re not just confined to the studio; you’re also seen on lunchboxes, school flasks, and even on school buses during promotional tours. I prefer to keep my work focused on set-based activities!

3 Ron Moody

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

Actor, musician, and vocalist Ron Moody is arguably best known for his award-winning portrayal of the sinister Fagin in both the 1968 musical film “Oliver!” and its Broadway revival. His captivating performance earned him nominations for a Golden Globe and Academy Award. Beyond this iconic role, Moody also excelled in films like “The Mouse on the Moon,” Mel Brooks’ comedy “The Twelve Chairs,” and “Flight of the Doves.” Furthermore, he graced numerous television series such as “The Edwardians,” “Starsky & Hutch,” “Into the Labyrinth,” and “Nobody’s Perfect.

Too Much Time & Commitment

Following his stunning portrayal in “Oliver!”, Moody had a chance to shine as the Time Lord in 1969. He was even offered the part to play the Third Doctor, but ultimately declined, leaving the role for Jon Pertwee to take on instead.

After spending many years playing Fagin, Moody felt reluctant to fully commit to another role so quickly. He believed that taking on the part in ‘Doctor Who’ would have limited him to television and a single character for an extended period. In hindsight, turning down the sci-fi series remains one of Moody’s greatest acting regrets.

2 Brian Blessed

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

Known for his deep, commanding voice, distinctive bushy beard, and grand presence, actor Brian Blessed has built a lasting career in film and television. He’s best recognized as Prince Vultan in Flash Gordon, Thomas Beaufort, the Duke of Exeter in Kenneth Branagh’s Henry V, Boss Nass in Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace, and as the voice of Clayton, the antagonist, in Disney’s Tarzan. His television roles span widely, including I, Claudius, Blackadder, Z-Cars, and Doctors.

Blessed’s Scheduling Conflicts

In 1966, Blessed was chosen as a potential successor for the original Doctor William Hartnell following his departure from the popular series after three seasons. At that time, Blessed was only 30 years old, and the creators of “Doctor Who” were looking to take the show in a new and contemporary direction with Hartnell’s replacement. They had their eyes set on the star of “Z-Cars,” who would later become the Second Doctor.

Back in 2014, I had to regretfully decline an exciting opportunity due to scheduling issues, but if given the chance today, I wouldn’t think twice about taking it up. In fact, as a fun anecdote, I made a brief appearance in a TV show back in 1986. I shared this tidbit during an interview with Radio Times.

Following my stint on Z Cars, the chief of BBC serials approached me privately and mentioned, “We’re contemplating a youthful version of Doctor Who, and we’re considering you for the role.” However, it conflicted with other commitments I had.

1 Geoffrey Bayldon

10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who10 Actors Who Turned Down the Role of Doctor Who

Known for gracing numerous stage performances of William Shakespeare’s works and playing lead roles in children’s shows like Catweazle, Worzel Gummidge as Crowman, and Watch as Magic Grandad, the celebrated performer Geoffrey Bayldon also made a mark with his chilling portrayals in horror films such as Dracula, Frankenstein Must Be Destroyed, Tales from the Crypt, and other well-liked movies like Casino Royale, The Pink Panther Strikes Again, and Porridge.

Sci-Fi Wasn’t Bayldon’s Cup of Tea

It’s widely accepted that Bayldon rejected the leading role in “Doctor Who” not just once, but twice. Initially, he was offered the lead when the series first started, before William Hartnell became the First Doctor from 1963 to 1966. Later, after Hartnell left the show following three episodes, Bayldon was approached again to take over, but he declined both times.

Later, the experienced performer elaborated on his reason for turning down the role in an interview given to Sci-Fi Bulletin.

I’ve never had a strong fascination for science fiction – it doesn’t capture my attention significantly. It wasn’t something that appealed to me, and I declined the role in part because I had been playing elderly characters, and I didn’t wish to continue…and when I was offered the role of Catweazle, I thought, “That’s why I turned down Doctor Who.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-09-16 02:32