10 Best Anya Taylor-Joy Characters That Explore the Dark Side of Humanity

by

Anya Taylor-Joy has become renowned for her exceptional ability to play complex characters that delve into the darker aspects of human nature. Ranging from tenacious survivors to cunning manipulators, her roles frequently challenge the boundary between victim and antagonist, offering intriguing insights into the intricacies of our psyche. With her remarkable talent for portraying multifaceted, morally ambiguous characters, Taylor-Joy has established herself as a notable actress in both independent films and major productions. Whether she’s conveying raw vulnerability or relentless ambition, her characters stay with audiences long after viewing, sparking discussions about ethics, ambition, inner struggles, and much more.

Let’s delve into some remarkable characters portrayed by Anya Taylor-Joy, where she bravely confronts inner demons or external challenges. With captivating acting skills, she tackles heavy themes like trauma, ambition, resilience, and moral complexity, infusing her roles with depth and sincerity. Whether it’s uncovering chilling family mysteries or asserting authority in ruthless power struggles, these characters reveal the extraordinary ability of this actress to delve into the deepest aspects of human nature. Prepare for a journey through roles that challenge preconceptions, redefine strength, and highlight the exceptional versatility of one of today’s most intriguing performers.

10
Charlotte Baughman

‘Barry’ (2016)

In the movie Barry, Anya Taylor-Joy takes on the role of Charlotte Baughman, a character who symbolizes Barack Obama’s college girlfriends in a combined form. Although Charlotte is not based on a specific individual, she plays a crucial part in the film’s examination of race, class, and self-identity. Taylor-Joy brings a sense of reality to her portrayal that makes Charlotte seem more than just a plot device in this biopic about the former U.S. president. Instead, she appears as a fully developed character with her own aspirations, hardships, and beliefs. The film delves into the intricacies of their relationship, as Barry struggles to reveal his inner turmoil and feelings of cultural disconnect to Charlotte.

Taylor-Joy delivers a multi-layered performance as Charlotte that gives emotional substance to the narrative, ensuring she appears authentic and real despite being a fictional character. She masterfully avoids turning Charlotte into either a stereotypical romantic interest or propaganda tool, allowing viewers to perceive her as an essential part of the story beyond being merely an accessory to Barry’s journey. This nuanced representation significantly enhances the film’s portrayal of Charlotte’s influential role in shaping the future president’s early life. Taylor-Joy’s talent for expressing both intensity and sensitivity in a character whose essence symbolizes deeper human traits underscores her ability to portray complex, introspective aspects of humanity.

9
Allie

‘Marrowbone’ (2017)

In “Marrowbone,” actress Anya Taylor-Joy plays the part of Allie, a kind and stable woman who serves as a beacon of normalcy for the troubled Jack and his siblings. As they grapple with their secluded existence after their mother’s demise, Allie’s romantic interest in Jack introduces a poignant layer to the film’s examination of grief and distress. Taylor-Joy’s performance skillfully communicates warmth and strength, making Allie a source of stability amidst the movie’s ominous and eerie ambiance. Although her screen time is limited, the importance of her character can’t be underestimated, as Allie symbolizes hope and human connection that Jack holds onto, despite the frightening circumstances he encounters in this horror film about unusual sibling ties.

Taylor-Joy’s portrayal of Allie underscores her capacity to create deep impressions in secondary roles. As Jack is ensnared by the ominous mansion, Allie’s visits represent temporary relief from the oppressive shadows that shroud his family’s disturbing past. Their connection offers a glimmer of normality amidst the chilling enigma that pervades the narrative. Via Allie, viewers witness Jack’s struggle to maintain whatever remnants of sanity he has left, making her part crucial in portraying his fragile mental condition. Taylor-Joy’s supporting role enhances the film’s eerie undertones, leaving a lasting impact despite the character’s limited screen time.

8
Illyana Rasputin/Magik

‘The New Mutants’ (2020)

In “The New Mutants”, Anya Taylor-Joy plays Illyana Rasputin, or Magik, a character whose troubled past molds her powerful personality. After experiencing trafficking, Illyana’s mind developed the fictional realm of Limbo as a means to cope, eventually turning it into a source of strength when her mutant abilities emerged. Unlike many X-Men characters who perceive their mutations as hardships, Magik sees hers as a blessing – one that equips her to confront her past with unyielding tenacity. Equipped with teleportation powers and the formidable Soulsword, she transforms into a fearless avenger, unafraid to exact retribution upon those who hurt children. Taylor-Joy’s powerful acting brings depth to Magik, illustrating the suffering and fortitude that shape her journey.

As a passionate film aficionado, I found “The New Mutants” an intriguing blend that grappled with both horror and coming-of-age elements. However, it was Saoirse Ronan’s captivating portrayal of trauma and survival that truly transformed this into a unique superhero horror experience. The character of Magik skillfully showcased the complexities of coping with unimaginable torment, as she straddled the thin line between innocence and savagery, revealing the film’s darker undertones. Her unyielding demeanor and resolute determination to shield herself and others made Magik one of the most riveting characters in the film. Ronan’s mesmerizing on-screen presence not only enriched the narrative but also provided a distinct portrayal of a mutant whose powers mirrored both the horrors she experienced and the fortitude she developed.

7
Casey Cooke

‘Split’ (2016)

In the movie titled “Split,” Actress Anya Taylor-Joy delivers an exceptionally multi-dimensional performance as Casey Cooke, a young woman who falls victim to a man suffering from dissociative identity disorder. As her captor’s personas alternate between gentle and menacing, Casey displays remarkable calmness, relying on her sharp perceptions and empathy to navigate this dangerous predicament. Taylor-Joy’s portrayal of Casey transcends mere fear, showcasing a quiet determination and tactical mindset as she scrutinizes each persona, devising a plan for survival. The actress’s knack for merging fear with fortitude infuses Casey with an impactful depth, making her one of the film’s most captivating elements.

The moving narrative of Casey is profoundly affecting, with a poignant past coming to light throughout the movie. It’s revealed that she has suffered years of abuse at the hands of her uncle, which provides a deeply emotional explanation for her composed and strategic demeanor. In a tragic twist, it becomes clear that Casey’s dark history has molded her into a survivor, underscoring the irony that the very experiences that caused her pain have also prepared her to endure her present ordeal. By the film’s conclusion, Casey is no longer just a victim but an empowered heroine, making Taylor-Joy’s portrayal one of her most memorable and nuanced characters due to her convincing display of resilience in the face of trauma.

6
Thomasin

‘The Witch’ (2015)

Anya Taylor-Joy’s standout role in “The Witch” skillfully portrays her talent for making innocence and wickedness indistinguishable. As Thomasin, a young Puritan girl suspected of witchcraft by her own kin, Taylor-Joy delivers an exceptional performance showing the transition from a submissive and oppressed daughter to a liberated figure welcoming darkness. The movie’s eerie ambiance escalates as Thomasin’s yearning for independence clashes with her family’s strict religious dogma, causing viewers to ponder whether she is a victim of circumstances or an awakening evil force. Taylor-Joy’s understated acting keeps spectators on tenterhooks, encapsulating both fragility and a hidden defiance that seethes beneath the surface.

The film’s eerie climax firmly establishes Thomasin’s transformation – or elevation – into witchcraft, as she agrees to Black Philip’s offer to “enjoy lavishly.” This crucial scene is chilling not just for its depiction of satanic liberation but also because it alters Thomasin’s persona. By joining the coven, she discards the suppressive dogmas of Puritanism, welcoming the dark freedom that had previously eluded her grasp. Taylor-Joy’s portrayal is mesmerizing, making Thomasin an intriguing character whose storyline is both heart-wrenching and empowering. With subtle gestures and quiet resilience, she delivers a performance that resonates powerfully even after the film ends, establishing Thomasin as one of her most memorable and multi-dimensional roles.

5
Beth Harmon

‘The Queen’s Gambit’ (2020)

Anya Taylor-Joy’s role in “The Queen’s Gambit” showcased some of her finest acting, masterfully depicting the shadowy aspects of ambition and addiction. As an orphaned chess prodigy, she skillfully portrays Beth Harmon’s journey through a world dominated by men, where personal struggles with demons are as significant as strategic genius. Taylor-Joy expertly blends Beth’s relentless pursuit of excellence with the burden of loneliness and substance abuse. Her captivating performance underscores the heartbreaking truth that exceptional talent often bears a high price, as Beth’s insatiable hunger to be the best is inextricably linked to her dependence on drugs and alcohol to alleviate her suffering.

What makes Beth Harmon’s story captivating is how Taylor-Joy skillfully portrays both Beth’s vulnerability and her strong-willed spirit. The series delves deeply into the theme of addiction, showing it in an honest, uncompromising way, highlighting the recurring pattern of Beth’s self-destructive actions. Even in her most challenging times, Beth’s undying love for chess remains evident, offering hope that triumph can still be achieved after hitting rock bottom. Taylor-Joy’s performance beautifully encapsulates Beth’s complexity, blending fragility with unyielding resilience, making The Queen’s Gambit a compelling portrayal of a character who is both flawed and strong.

4
Margot Mills

‘The Menu’ (2022)

In “The Menu,” Anya Taylor-Joy plays Margot Mills, a shrewd and down-to-earth final girl who throws a wrench into Chef Slowik’s carefully designed scheme. As an unforeseen outsider amidst the elite diners, she upsets the evening’s narrative, compelling Slowik to reconsider his intricately planned retribution against his pompous patrons. Hired by fellow diner Tyler to accompany him as a date, Margot lacks the self-important air of the other guests. Instead, she offers a genuine and compassionate demeanor that provides insightful commentary on the intersection of art and commerce.

In Taylor-Joy’s portrayal, Margot’s character showcases an exceptional blend of resilience and ingenuity, setting her apart as one of the most original ‘final girls’ in contemporary horror films. Her working-class roots and reluctance to engage with Slowik’s snobbish culinary skills earn her a reluctant admiration, ultimately leading to her survival.

The character Margot defiantly rejects the elitism that surrounds her, underscoring themes of classism and artistic authenticity. Her survival is not merely a result of her intelligence but also serves as a testament to her genuine human relationships and her keen ability to discern through the mask. In essence, Taylor-Joy skillfully reveals the sinister side of social stratification and the dangerous obsession with perfection through Margot’s character.

3
Gina Gray

‘Peaky Blinders’ (2019 – 2022)

In the TV show “Peaky Blinders,” Anya Taylor-Joy plays the role of Gina Gray, a character who is both cunning and driven, with an unwavering desire for power and prestige. As Michael Gray’s American wife, Gina makes her presence known early on, employing manipulation and charm to further her goals. Her dislike for the Shelby family, particularly Tommy, is evident, as she perceives them as inferior and seeks to boost Michael’s standing within the group. Taylor-Joy’s portrayal of Gina is cold and calculated, making her one of the show’s most contentious characters.

In the TV show, Gina’s sly personality and yearning to distance herself from the Shelby family dynasty delve into broader themes of class struggle and ambition. She symbolizes the potential for American influence disrupting the traditional British system, as she competes against the Shelbys using her own harsh strategies. Regardless of whether viewers admire or dislike Gina Gray, her character indelibly marks the series, showcasing how ambition can lead individuals to betray even their dearest confidants. Taylor-Joy’s portrayal in this historical drama is undeniably mesmerizing, effectively communicating Gina’s relentless ambition and readiness to manipulate others around her.

2
Lily Reynolds

‘Thoroughbreds’ (2017)

In the movie titled “Thoroughbreds“, actress Anya Taylor-Joy gives a remarkable portrayal of Lily Reynolds, a wealthy yet emotionally distant teenager. At first glance, Lily appears to be a calm and sophisticated young lady residing in an upscale neighborhood, maintaining a cool demeanor. However, her picture-perfect life hides a darker undertone. As she develops an unexpected friendship with Amanda, a girl who lacks emotions, the movie skillfully explores themes of wealth, empathy, and moral deterioration. It shows how excessive wealth and high status can gradually undermine one’s capacity for kindness and morality, as Lily’s transformation unfolds.

In Taylor-Joy’s portrayal, the character of Lily undergoes a chilling transformation from composed ambition to ruthless manipulation. As her anger towards her overbearing stepfather intensifies, she skillfully exploits Amanda’s inclination to commit murder, exposing a long-hidden darkness within herself. Although Amanda is unabashedly sociopathic, it is Lily’s transformation that leaves a lasting impact, as she discards any traces of empathy in favor of power. Taylor-Joy’s talent for conveying both vulnerability and cruelty makes Lily an intriguing examination of how privilege can warp even the most polished individuals. Through her character, Thoroughbreds invites audiences to ponder how societal norms and affluence might conceal a dark and relentless nature.

1
Sandie

‘Last Night in Soho’ (2021)

In the movie titled “Last Night in Soho“, actress Anya Taylor-Joy gives a chilling performance as Sandie, an aspiring singer who becomes enamored with a man who claims to fulfill her dreams. This story unfolds in the lively and energetic setting of 1960s Soho. At first, Sandie appears as a lively and driven young woman. However, her tale takes a grim turn when her dreams are crushed swiftly, leaving her exposed to exploitation and despair. The film’s examination of nostalgia serves as a warning about romanticizing the past, with Sandie representing the brutal truth hiding beneath the glamorous surface. Taylor-Joy skillfully depicts the transformation from optimism to sorrow, showing Sandie’s gradual slide into a realm of mistreatment and manipulation.

In Ellie’s story, she encounters Sandie’s harrowing past through intense, unsettling dreams. As Ellie unearths the bleak reality of Sandie’s life, the film explores topics like mental health struggles, shattered aspirations, and the predatory aspects of the entertainment world. Taylor-Joy’s captivating portrayal of Sandie powerfully portrays the tragic transformation from a hopeful dreamer to a resilient survivor, serving as a poignant reminder of the human toll when pursuing fame in a merciless environment. The film also underscores the emotional toll and destructive effects of unbridled ambition and exploitation on vulnerable people.

Read More

2025-03-28 04:03