10 Best Fantasy Movies According to Roger Ebert

As a cinephile who has spent countless hours immersed in the world of film, I find myself consistently drawn to the timeless tales that resonate deeply within our collective psyche. These stories, often filled with larger-than-life characters and fantastical elements, serve as mirrors reflecting our own humanity back at us.


Critics are frequently labeled as only preferring movies categorized as serious, encompassing dramas, biographies, or war films. It seems anything outside the realm of genre films, such as horror or thrillers, falls victim to this belief that critics favor films that are often dull or lack commercial appeal. However, this is a baseless claim, and the collections created by renowned film critic Roger Ebert serve as evidence to the contrary.

Absolutely! Ebert wasn’t shy about expressing his disdain for certain films, going so far as to outright hate some. However, behind this strong dislike was a deep-seated love for cinema overall. His preferences leaned towards genres like fantasy, sci-fi, and classic thrillers, which are evident from the films he included in his list of The Great Movies. To substantiate this, we’ve collated a selection of fantasy films that Ebert recognized as cinematic masterpieces.

10 ‘Groundhog Day’ (1993)

In essence, Groundhog Day recounts the tale of Phil Connors, a grumpy meteorologist who finds himself reporting on Punxsutawney’s Groundhog Day celebrations. However, it appears that divine intervention has placed him in an endless time loop that feels like an eternity. As he gradually understands, his means of escape lies in personal growth and transformation.

“We Can Learn To Be Better People”

In a simpler, more conversational style: This popular blend of fantasy and comedy featuring Bill Murray is a timeless example of its genre, posing thoughtful questions without delving too deeply into the philosophical reasons behind Phil’s predicament. It keeps you rooting for his transformation into a better person throughout the story.

Tomorrow will arrive regardless of it being any specific date, and we can’t change that. What we can do, though, is strive to be the best versions of ourselves we can be. Fortunately, we have the ability to improve and grow as people. The scene where Phil tells Rita, “You look like an angel standing in the snow,” isn’t meant to imply that he has fallen in love with her. Instead, it signifies that he has learned to appreciate and see the beauty within her.

9 ‘The Wizard of Oz’ (1939)

In a twist of events, Dorothy and her little dog Toto find themselves carried away by a whirlwind, ending up in the enchanting realm known as Oz. Realizing that getting back home won’t be straightforward, brave Dorothy embarks on a journey along the iconic yellow brick road, leading her to the mystical Emerald City. It seems that the Wizard within this city holds the key to Dorothy’s return, but she must fulfill certain tasks first.

“It Made Good Sense to Me”

This timeless, iconic fantasy work is often hailed as one of the greatest films ever made. Initially, it was costly for MGM to produce, but over time, it gained a dedicated following and ultimately earned its place as a classic Hollywood production. Even legendary critic Roger Ebert was captivated by it when he first saw it as a child.

Only when I watched ‘The Wizard of Oz’ for the very first time did it strike me consciously about black-and-white versus color. The moment Dorothy was swept away from Kansas and into Oz, my thoughts were that it made perfect sense.

8 ‘It’s a Wonderful Life’ (1946)

George Bailey appears deeply distressed, considering taking his own life on Christmas Eve, causing concern for those around him. Through their persistent prayers, a heavenly messenger is touched by George’s story and intervenes. He rescues George from his predicament and presents him with a glimpse of the world that would have transpired if George had never existed.

“’It’s a Wonderful Life’ Is Not Just a Heart-Warming “Message Picture”

Frank Capra’s iconic Christmas movie, It’s a Wonderful Life, is arguably one of the most heartwarming holiday films ever created. The film offers a unique take on the traditional Christmas tale, A Christmas Carol, and provides a touching “rising from adversity” narrative that will undoubtedly inspire viewers to strive for personal growth and kindness.

Per Ebert’s essay:

“What makes It’s a Wonderful Life special is its ability to remain relevant over time, much like classic films such as Casablanca and The Third Man. Unlike some movies that lose their charm once you know the ending, these timeless productions seem to grow even more captivating with age. While certain movies can only be watched once, others, like masterpieces of music, become richer with each listen or view. It’s a Wonderful Life definitely falls into the latter category.

7 ‘Pinocchio’ (1940)

A wooden puppet named Pinocchio is given life by a fairy, and his creator is a solitary woodcarver named Mr. Geppetto. Pinocchio yearns to become a real boy and must demonstrate bravery, honesty, and selflessness as instructed by the fairy in order to achieve this goal.

“A Narrative With Deep Archetypal Reverberations”

As a film critic, I’ve had the pleasure of reviewing countless movies, but few have left an indelible mark like the enchanting animated musical that I am referring to. This timeless tale, which resides proudly within Disney’s esteemed collection of traditionally animated films, is not just another entry in their catalog; it is a cherished classic, one of the most adored animated stories ever told.

As a movie enthusiast, “Pinocchio” stands out as more than just a children’s tale; it’s a profound parable that has resonated across generations. It’s the timeless wisdom like “let your conscience be your guide” and “a lie keeps growing until it’s as evident as the nose on your face” that truly captivates me. I believe the film’s impact lies in its authenticity; it’s not a contrived fairy tale, but a story with profound archetypal resonances.

6 ‘Un Chien Andalou’ (1929)

An Andalusian Dog (originally Un Chien Andalou) is a 16-minute surrealist work by Luis Buñuel that feels like a dream gone awry, blending various genres. The visionary director weaves together a collection of scenes, ranging from the shocking image of an eye being sliced symbolically to a peculiar love story that seems illogical and confusing. It’s not meant to be deciphered; just enjoy the absurdity.

“It Assaults Old and Unconscious Habits of Moviegoing”

Despite the movie lacking a traditional narrative, its meaning remains relevant from its 1929 premiere until today. It’s a controversial piece that challenges certain aspects, stirring debate among viewers. Roger Ebert famously described it as a film created by two young men “under the influence of Paris’s liberating atmosphere.

Per his essay:

This film challenges deeply ingrained and unconscious habits of movie-watching. It can be unsettling, aggravating, and infuriating. It appears aimless (though one might argue that many movies we watch serve little purpose). There’s a dry wit in it, and an unapologetic disregard for offending. Most modern audiences don’t find it offensive, which could suggest that the surrealists successfully led their revolution: They showed that art (and life) don’t need to conform strictly within traditional boundaries that have been set since ancient times.

5 ‘Orpheus’ (1950)

In the film Orpheus, a poet becomes smitten with Death after accompanying her into the underworld. As the story unfolds, it’s revealed that she is Death herself. Later on, he is sent back to our world where an unfortunate event takes place: his wife Eurydice meets a tragic end while pregnant. Desperate to revive her, he vows to complete an impossible task. If you find this storyline intriguing but confusing, then you’re in for a fascinating mystery as Orpheus is one of the most challenging cinematic enigmas ever created.

“One of the Pleasures of the Film Is To See How Audacious the Tricks Are in Their Simplicity”

1950 saw the creation in France of “Orpheus,” a dreamlike romantic tale steeped in mythology, which might be hard to follow outside its specific context. However, don’t let that deter you! This film will pull you into a chasm of visual and auditory illusions, early practical effects that continue to impress with their inventiveness.

This is what Ebert said about it:

One delightful aspect of this movie lies in appreciating the daring nature of its techniques, which are often deceptively straightforward. For instance, rubber gloves mysteriously appear on hands through backward cinematography. Objects like glasses seem to defy gravity, leaping back into their original positions. Mirrors serve a dual purpose, at times acting as mirrors and at others revealing sets hidden beyond them. Characters occasionally step out of mirrors, with the director cleverly transitioning to shots depicting their hands emerging from a tranquil pool of water that continues to reflect their faces. On one occasion, he employs a technique reminiscent of his work in Beauty and the Beast, whereby a character seems to float effortlessly by being moved on an unseen wheeled platform.

You can stream Orpheus on Max.

4 ‘My Neighbor Totoro’ (1988)

My Neighbor Totoro tells the tale of sisters Satsuki and Mei, who are obliged to settle into an antiquated house situated close to a hospital, where their mother is undergoing treatment. Unleashing her creativity, Mei establishes a friendship with a being that emerges from a tree, and eventually, Satsuki too catches sight of the colossal Totoro. They will embark on numerous escapades in one of the most enchanting animated movies ever made.

“Rich With Human Comedy in the Way It Observes the Two Remarkably Convincing”

The delightful and timeless animated movie “My Neighbor Totoro,” produced by Studio Ghibli and Hayao Miyazaki, holds a significant place in the annals of modern animation. Its influence is undeniable as it stands among Japan’s most essential contributions to this medium, resonating with audiences worldwide due to its enduring values that continue to feel relatable across age groups and cultures.

Per Ebert’s essay:

The film wouldn’t have garnered its global fanbase solely due to its emotional depth. It also boasts a deep well of human comedy in its portrayal of two incredibly authentic, lifelike child characters (referring to their personalities, not their physical appearances). The scenes featuring the Totoro are breathtaking, and those with the Cat Bus are captivating. The film is tinged with sadness, fear, surprise, and a touch of informative moments, much like real life itself. It relies on circumstances rather than a traditional plot, implying that the wonders of life and the power of imagination can provide all the excitement you require.

3 ‘Pan’s Labyrinth’ (2006)

In the year 1940s Spain amidst a civil war, audiences are transported to a world where a young girl named Ofelia struggles with her new stepfather, a merciless soldier deeply committed to the fascist cause of his companions. As fate would have it, Ofelia interacts with fairies who guide her into an intricate network of subterranean passages, leading her to encounter a faun who prophesizes that she is actually a reborn princess, destined to return to her realm.

“One of the Greatest of All Fantasy Films, Even Though It Is Anchored So Firmly in the Reality of War”

Guillermo del Toro’s contemporary fantasy-horror movie, “Pan’s Labyrinth,” stands as a remarkable achievement within its genre, having received three Academy Awards. This visually stunning yet ominous film challenges the boundaries and redefines the conventional aspects of fairy tale motifs.

Ebert was very vocal about his love for the film:

I believe what makes ‘Pan’s Labyrinth’ by Del Toro so impactful is its unique blend of contrasting elements, refusing to yield to any incompatibility. This film stays true to both storylines till the very end, offering no room for compromise or escape. The threats from each world are constantly intertwined, making the danger omnipresent. Del Toro often refers to the ‘rule of three’ in fables (three doors, three rules, three fairies, three thrones). I’m not sure three viewings would be sufficient to fully grasp this film.

2 ‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind’ (2004)

In “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind,” Joel Barish chooses to fight back when his girlfriend Clementine opted to erase him from her memory. After undergoing the same procedure himself, viewers are given an insight into a mind struggling intensely to expunge the most valuable memories from a heartbroken man’s consciousness.

“The Wisdom in ‘Eternal Sunshine’ is How It Illuminates the Way Memory Interacts With Love”

Michel Gondry’s movie offers a unique take on romantic films by exploring a genuine concept yet to be fully understood: the inner workings of the human mind when it comes to preserving and discarding cherished memories. Roger Ebert, in his praise for this 2004 film, particularly lauded the screenwriting abilities of Charlie Kaufman, whom he deemed as the most talented writer in screenplays during the 2000s.

Per the review:

In Eternal Sunshine, the insight lies in showing how memories influence love. Often, we remember pleasant experiences over painful ones. The instances that Joel and Clementine hold dear are those idyllic moments when life seems divine, bathed perpetually in sunshine. I wish those were the moments some of those characters find themselves preserved in – they appear content.

1 ‘Superman’ (1978)

As a cinema enthusiast, let me recount my take on “Superman”. Hailing from the distant planet Krypton, Kal-El is rocketed to Earth just moments before its destruction. Raised by a kindly farmer couple in Smallville and christened Clark Kent, this ordinary boy harbored extraordinary powers that would soon be revealed.

“He Is Superman, He Fights for Truth, Justice, and the American Way, and That’s That”

Richard Donner’s Superman marked the debut of the first big-league superhero movie in Hollywood, with Christopher Reeve taking on the iconic role that significantly shaped his career. In its day, the special effects were revolutionary, and it held the title of being the most costly film ever produced.

This grabbed the attention of Ebert who claimed the following in his glowing essay:

In contemporary superhero films, there’s an excess of special effects and non-stop action sequences. However, “Superman” stands out as it’s not overly flashy but still engaging, mainly due to its compelling narrative filled with classic archetypes. It pioneered…

Read More

2024-11-18 05:02