10 Comedy Movies That Split Audiences: Love or Hate?

by

In the realm of art, including comedy, personal preferences often lead to varying opinions and heated discussions. While one audience member may find a film gut-bustingly funny, another might perceive it as awkward, offensive, or simply not amusing at all. This article focuses on movies that have sparked a divide among viewers.

These films range from the quirky and unconventional style of Wes Anderson, the darkly humorous and absurd works of Yorgos Lanthimos, the extreme and outrageous humor of Jackass and Tom Green, to the over-the-top performances of Adam Sandler. Regardless of whether people adore or despise them, these are 10 movies that evoke strong opinions.

10
‘Sex and the City’ (2008)

The hit television series, “Sex and the City,” chronicles the personal and professional journeys of Carrie, Charlotte, Miranda, and Samantha as they navigate life in New York City. The show’s success and popularity are indisputable, having garnered over 50 Primetime Emmy Award nominations and being ranked by Variety as the sixth best TV show of all time. Notably, given its remarkable achievement, it was adapted into two movies.

Feminist? Anti-Feminist? Post-Feminist? Or Just Good Old-Fashioned Fun?

In the same vein that made the show popular, the movie continues the story as Carrie’s wedding plans unexpectedly unravel, sending her and her friends on a personal exploration. The film currently holds a 50% score on Rotten Tomatoes, indicating an even split between critics who enjoyed it and those who didn’t. This pattern of mixed reviews has been consistent throughout the franchise’s entire run.

For every individual who admires the franchise for its entertaining, elegant, identifiable, and inspiring characters, you’ll find someone else who faults it for being superficial, focused on materialism, uninteresting, and perpetuating old-fashioned gender norms and expectations.

9
‘Borat’ (2006)

Borat, modeled after a character by British comedian Sacha Baron Cohen from the show Da Ali G Show, presents an account following this fictitious Kazakh journalist as he engages in a sequence of improvised scenes where he converses and interacts with actual Americans who assume him to be a foreigner unfamiliar with American customs.

‘Borat’ Offended a Lot of People

The film, boasting a Rotten Tomatoes score of 91%, was an enormous success at the box office and earned critical praise for its biting satire. This satire serves as a reflection of U.S. society, uncovering hidden prejudices, ignorance, and inconsistencies within American culture by showcasing authentic reactions from people—bringing to light uncomfortable truths.

As a film enthusiast, I must confess that the release of Borat sparked quite a controversy. Some ardent Americans felt deeply offended by what they perceived as mockery of their nation, finding its tone distasteful. On the other hand, Kazakhstan initially took offense to the movie’s portrayal, claiming it depicted their country in an unfairly negative light. However, over time, Kazakhstan has come to appreciate the character of Borat and acknowledge the humor hidden within its absurdity. Meanwhile, some viewers found the film too crass, with humor that was excessive and tasteless, which made it challenging for them to enjoy it.

8
‘Napoleon Dynamite’ (2004)

The movie Napoleon Dynamite, with its quirky protagonist, unfolds his journey through high school life in rural Idaho. Made on a meager budget of only $400,000, this film turned out to be one of the most unexpected blockbusters from the 2000s.

‘Napoleon Dynamite’ Took a Very Different Approach to the Teen Comedy Genre

During the late ’90s and early 2000s, teen comedies started to adopt a bolder style, favoring vulgar and crass elements, with films like “Road Trip,” “National Lampoon’s Van Wilder,” and “American Pie” setting trends. However, “Napoleon Dynamite” took a completely different route. While it does contain some crude comments, its humor is primarily dry and eccentric. Instead of depending on lewd jokes and extreme actions, it leans more on awkward humor and peculiar characters.

Some found the film’s unique, quirky humor enjoyable, but others had difficulty connecting due to its dry wit and struggled to follow the movie’s leisurely tempo and confusing narrative structure.

7
‘Jackass: The Movie’ (2006)

As a film critic, I must admit that a motion picture revolving around a close-knit circle enduring self-imposed torment and mutual anguish wasn’t everyone’s cup of tea, but much like its television counterpart, this movie managed to captivate audiences nationwide. On a modest budget of $5 million, it proved to be a blockbuster sensation, amassing over $79 million at the box office.

‘Jackass: The Movie’s Extreme “Real-Life” Content Can Be Off-Putting

In the show Jackass, the stunts depicted are genuine, implying that the injuries sustained during these stunts are also real. However, it’s not just physical discomfort that the Jackass team willingly experiences for our amusement; they also include segments like “pee snow cones” and “Wasabi snooters”. Many people find this raw, unedited madness incredibly appealing, and despite receiving mixed to negative reviews from critics, viewers surveyed by CinemaScore gave the film a commendable average grade of “A−” on an A+ to F scale.

It’s clear that there’s an audience for this type of entertainment, and perhaps the most fitting description comes from the Golden Raspberry Awards, who named it as the “Most Fart-filled Film Targeting Teens.

6
‘Freddy Got Fingered’ (2001)

At the dawn of the new millennium, when events like Woodstock were often marred by disorder and college dorms displayed “Fight Club” posters, MTV aimed to capitalize on the trend for edgy entertainment. It was during this time that comedian Tom Green, known for his shock comedy style, gained popularity. His show, a mix of extreme stunts, pranks, and a touch of surreal humor, attracted large audiences on the network. Impressed by these numbers, 20th Century Fox allowed Green to have creative control over his own movie, which he both wrote and directed.

‘Freddy Got Fingered’ Is Widely Regarded as One of the Worst Movies Ever Made

As a movie enthusiast, I’ve got to share my thoughts on “Freddy Got Fingered.” This wasn’t your typical film; it was a wild, uncontrolled exploration of the boundaries of good taste. Tom Green didn’t simply step over the line – he bulldozed it, circled back for another go, and then joyfully jumped over it again. From spinning a newborn baby around his head by its umbilical cord to acting out inappropriate sexual acts with animals, this movie pushed every limit imaginable.

Although it failed at the box office and received negative reviews from critics, the film surprisingly gained a dedicated fanbase and was successful in the home video market. Notably, Chris Rock, a renowned comedian, has declared it as one of his favorites. Despite not appealing to everyone’s palate, Tom Green’s bold and fearless filmmaking style undeniably holds merit.

5
‘Friday’ (1995)

Friday, penned by Ice Cube and DJ Pooh, introduces us to Ice Cube and Chris Tucker as a couple of laid-back potheads. They navigate through a series of hilariously odd predicaments, keeping viewers entertained for 90 minutes with their quick-witted banter. The on-screen camaraderie between the two is evident, with Ice Cube playing the rational one against Chris Tucker’s fast-talking energy.

‘Friday’ Is the Definitive Stoner Movie

The humor in the stoner comedy genre is typically polarizing, as many jokes revolve around smoking cannabis, which some people may not be familiar with or find relatable. Much of the humor can be outrageous and is sometimes more enjoyable when under the influence, further limiting its appeal to a broader audience. However, if you’re a fan of stoner comedies, then Friday stands out as one of the best. This movie has earned cult status among its followers, with renowned filmmaker Quentin Tarantino even listing it among his favorites.

4
‘The Lobster’ (2015)

In a nutshell, “The Lobster” is a quirky dark comedy about a bachelor, portrayed by Colin Farrell, who checks into a hotel housing other unattached individuals. The twist? If they fail to find a suitable partner within 45 days, their fate becomes an animal for eternity.

‘The Lobster’ Is an Intentionally Unsettling Viewing Experience

In the movie, a chilling dystopian setting is amplified by Yorgos Lanthimos’ choice of stiff dialogues and cold-hearted characters, giving it an unsettling, unnerving vibe where human connections seem strange and mechanical. Sudden outbursts of violence and dark humor make the film even more uncomfortable, keeping viewers on edge throughout.

In my perspective, for certain individuals, immersing themselves in the world of Lanthimos’ distinct art-house cinema might seem akin to stepping into their own personal version of a challenging, thought-provoking realm. Conversely, there are others – myself included – who find ourselves utterly captivated by his innovative filmmaking style, going so far as to hail him as a “genius” and even drawing comparisons with the iconic Stanley Kubrick of our times.

3
‘Super Troopers’ (2002)

Hailing from the imaginative team behind Broken Lizard comedy group, Super Troopers tells the story of an unconventional band of immature, lighthearted state troopers who often prefer pranks and idleness over law enforcement. Facing the imminent closure of their station, they must demonstrate their value, buckle down, and take on a significant drug trafficking case.

‘Super Troopers’ Thrives on Silliness

The movie is quite divisive, drawing either passionate praise or strong criticism. On one hand, some viewers adore its wild humor, memorable quotes, and over-the-top stunts, while on the other, critics and skeptics see it as immature, lacking direction, or simply unintelligent. Despite this mixed reception, it has developed a dedicated fanbase among those who appreciate its physical comedy and unique style, who embrace its chaotic vibe. However, it has also been harshly criticized by many who consider the film to be an exhausting barrage of lowbrow humor and aimless nonsense.

2
‘Big Daddy’ (1999)

Adam Sandler is frequently seen as a contentious figure among actors of his time, with many of his films being potential candidates for this list. Known more for simplicity and lack of subtlety rather than sophistication, he has faced criticism for leaning heavily on lowbrow humor, over-the-top characters, and jokes that cater to the least common sophisticated tastes.

In a fresh take, Big Daddy features Adam Sandler as an unstructured individual whose world is flipped upside down when he becomes responsible for a young child. Although the plot might not be entirely novel, Sandler skillfully depicts a man in chaos who must rapidly grow up, seamlessly combining humor with heartfelt sincerity. This results in a unique blend of comedy and emotion that is seldom seen in similar movies.

As We Have Now Come to Expect, Adam Sandler’s Performance Was Hugely Divisive

Without a doubt, Sandler showcases remarkable comedic acting skills; he boasts an enormous following of devoted fans and a vast collection of blockbuster movies to his credit. However, he seems to polarize opinions more than any other contemporary actor might, and this is clearly demonstrated in the movie “Big Daddy“.

The film garnered a mix of positive and negative opinions from critics, but it proved to be a massive success at the ticket counter. Interestingly, Adam Sandler bagged several Best Actor accolades at events like the MTV Movie & TV Awards, Kids’ Choice Awards, and Blockbuster Entertainment Awards. However, he also received the Worst Actor award at the Golden Raspberries. In a similar vein, the movie collected numerous Best Film awards, but it was also put forward for consideration in the Most Unfunny Comedy category at the Stinkers Bad Movie Awards.

1
‘The Royal Tenenbaums’ (2001)

Under the guidance of director Wes Anderson, the film The Royal Tenenbaums revolves around three exceptionally talented yet quirky siblings, reunited by their unconventionally peculiar father. In a bid to reconnect with them and his former spouse, he feigns having a terminal illness.

Wes Anderson’s Style Is Unique but Not for Everyone

Wes Anderson’s unique, eccentric filmmaking approach, filled with irony and the bizarre, is apparent in “The Royal Tenenbaums” as well. This film, highly admired by critics, received a great deal of praise and recognition, but not everyone agrees. Some viewers might find the characters overly quirky, which could lead to their misinterpretation as shallow, making it challenging to form a personal bond with them. Similarly, his signature visual style and meticulous attention to detail may appear pretentious to some viewers.

For people seeking something beyond common Hollywood action films, it’s clearly not suitable for those who prefer movies rooted in real-life experiences instead.

Read More

2025-02-16 06:04