20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

As a horror enthusiast who has spent countless nights huddled under the covers, I find myself intrigued by these chilling tales that manage to send shivers down one’s spine even during daylight hours. Each of these films offers a unique twist on the genre, showcasing the talent and creativity of both seasoned and newcomer directors.


Horror movies are uniquely served by a standalone streaming platform called Shudder, which is supported by AMC Networks. This streaming service caters to every aspect of horror, encompassing both traditional and avant-garde content, as well as original productions that straddle the line between the familiar and the unusual. The success of Shudder has been significant, propelling them to become the exclusive distributors for notable films that might not have found a platform in today’s film landscape otherwise.

Clearly, Shudder stands out as the preferred choice for both well-known horror classics, which one might expect on a dedicated streaming platform for horror, and for the more unusual, offbeat, and unconventional content. We’ll call these unique finds “hidden gems” because they are truly worth your time and offer a diverse range of origins, eras, and filmmaking perspectives. Whether you’re seeking a traditional horror movie or something that will leave you puzzled, Shudder’s hidden gems are definitely worth exploring when you’re unsure about what to watch next.

20 Cheap Thrills (2013)

In “Cheap Thrills,” we find ourselves in a tough spot with the protagonist, Craig, recently unemployed as a mechanic. Seeking solace in a local bar and drowning his sorrows, he unexpectedly encounters Vince, an old classmate grappling with similar financial struggles. They commiserate over their predicament, but their night takes a turn when Colin and Violet, who appear to be well-off, join them. Intrigued by the duo, they propose a series of challenges for Craig and Vince, promising money as incentive. Initially appearing harmless, the games soon escalate into a twisted spectacle where boundaries are merely theoretical.

Cheap Thrills Is an Underrated Dark Comedy Thriller

In “Cheap Thrills,” Pat Healy, Ethan Embry, Sara Paxton, and David Koechner take on the leading roles, each delivering impressive performances. The movie’s allure goes beyond its comical portrayal of a chaotic situation; viewers with sensitive stomachs might want to keep a barf bag handy, as things get pretty intense. Despite receiving critical acclaim, “Cheap Thrills” failed to attract large audiences at the box office, earning less than $60,000 from a budget of $100,000, making it a significant financial flop.

19 The Void (2016)

In this narrative, several individuals converge at a local hospital. A string of violent occurrences unfolds as they arrive, prompting a Deputy Sheriff and State trooper to assume command in an attempt to decipher the mystery beyond the hospital’s walls. However, a nurse’s attempt on a patient’s life suggests that whatever is happening outside has somehow infiltrated the hospital. Mysterious figures in robes are spotted near the site, leading Deputy Daniel to suspect an otherworldly presence lurking within the hospital.

The Void Is a Practical Effects Spectacular

The movie, “The Void,” is a remarkable representation of Canadian horror genre. It showcases cutting-edge practical effects, spanning from makeup to creature design, transporting you back to the terrifying realm of ’80s horror for approximately 84 minutes. Critics and fans alike have praised this film as a Lovecraftian masterpiece since its debut. The duo behind the script and direction, Steven Kostanski and Jeremy Gillespie, had the opportunity to work on David Ayer’s “Suicide Squad,” meaning that some of the crew from the superhero film contributed to the visual effects in “The Void.”

18 The Innocents (2021)

In “The Innocents”, sisters Ida and Anna reside in a freshly-moved apartment complex with their parents. Anna, who has non-verbal autism, requires constant care from Ida, her older sibling. When Ida encounters a boy named Luke, who possesses the talent to manipulate objects telekinetically, their lives take an ominous twist as they uncover that these powers aren’t solely intended for beneficial purposes.

Superhero Genre Meets Supernatural Horror in The Innocents

2021 saw the debut of this joint Norwegian-Swedish production in Cannes, specifically within the “Un Certain Regard” segment. The movie, however, subverts traditional fairy tale motifs with a chilling twist, using its superhero genre resemblance to lead us into believing that these children’s powers could bring about something positive. Unfortunately, things don’t turn out as hoped.

17 Christmas Bloody Christmas (2022)

On Christmas Eve, Tori, a record store owner, chooses to spend the holiday with her employee Robbie. They later visit a friend who works at a toy store. However, an erratic robotic Santa Claus, whose programming malfunctions have led it to commit homicides, begins terrorizing Robbie, Tori, and the entire town.

One of the Best Christmas Horror Films in Recent History

In a striking, innovative film directed by Joe Begos, Abraham Benrubi steals the show with his chilling portrayal of Santa Claus as the central antagonist. The lead character adheres to classic final girl tropes and delivers a captivating performance, but it’s Benrubi’s haunting portrayal that truly sets this Christmas horror film apart. This genre, while seldom explored, is often praised for its unique blend of festive and frightening elements.

16 Carnival of Souls (1962)

In my own words, I’d express it like this:

The Underrated Classic That Always Calls For a Rewatch

As a devoted movie enthusiast, I can confidently say that “Carnival of Souls,” masterfully directed and starring the enigmatic Herk Harvey, stands as an undeniable gem in the realm of cult indie classics. Over time, it garnered acclaim from critics who were captivated by its chilling ambiance, a quality that emerged powerfully from its modestly funded origins. This unique blend of low-budget authenticity and Harvey’s knack for creating terror with just one image is truly mesmerizing. Without a doubt, “Carnival of Souls” deserves a spot on your Halloween watchlist for an unforgettable viewing experience.

15 Tigers Are Not Afraid (2017)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

In the movie titled “Tigers Are Not Afraid“, young Estrella is compelled to join a band of street children as her mother mysteriously disappears. They inhabit a Mexican metropolis devastated by cartel chaos and criminal activities, essentially discarded fragments of society. However, when Estrella links a piece of guidance from her teacher with a crime lord’s mission to eradicate her new group, she discovers she might possess an enigmatic ability.

A Relevant Commentary in the Form of an Indie Film

As a film enthusiast, I can confidently say that Issa López masterfully pens and directs one of the most chilling Mexican horror films ever crafted – “Tigers Are Not Afraid.” This movie might not fit traditional horror genre tropes, but its innovative exploration of magic realism certainly leaves a haunting and unsettling impact.

14 Huesera (2022)

“The Bone Woman” delves into the tale of Valeria, a young expectant mother, who begins experiencing vivid visions after announcing her pregnancy to her partner. Strained ties with her family only exacerbate her predicament, and as time passes, these visions grow increasingly real and unsettling. A mysterious woman-like entity that makes loud, grotesque adjustments to her bones torments Valeria. However, it may be Valeria’s aunt, Isabel, who holds the key to helping her before the situation spirals out of control.

Motherhood Is a Nightmare in Huesera

The movie “Huesera: The Bone Woman” is a Mexican-Peruvian production that invites viewers to understand Valeria’s struggle. As the story unfolds, it becomes increasingly intense and mysterious. This 2022 horror film, featuring breakout star Natalia Solián, delves into the concept of motherhood beyond just being a mother, focusing on what one leaves behind for their child and the pain of violating sacred rules in motherhood. On Rotten Tomatoes, it’s highly rated, with a score of 97%.

13 Resurrection (2022)

In the novel “Resurrection“, Margaret is a resilient single mother who has managed to overcome a troubled history with David, a man from whom she escaped an abusive relationship. However, it seems that David has re-entered her life and refuses to leave her alone, forcing her to confront him. By delving into her past, Margaret faces the trauma of losing her child to the manipulative tactics of a monster.

Trauma Is a Real and Tangible Monster in Resurrection

The movie features Rebecca Hall portraying a character that solidifies her status as a contemporary queen of horror, offering a genuine emotional depth that leaves viewers questioning the authenticity of what they’re witnessing. This uncertainty is crucial to grasping the essence of the storyline: it illustrates the impact of trauma and how it can cause victims to perceive things beyond our reality.

12 I Trapped the Devil (2019)

The Christmas Conundrum)

An Underrated Christmas Horror Film

In Josh Lobo’s initial directorial work, we find a compelling, gradual-unfolding movie that leaves an eerie impression within just a few minutes. Steve’s choice to imprison an unidentified man in the basement seems plausible, yet the persistent uncertainty adds a captivating layer to the storyline. This ambiguity serves as a narrative tool, skillfully intertwining with the psychological dimensions of the plot. The ominous and confined ambiance might just shatter any hopes for a cheerful holiday season.

11 The Wretched (2019)

“The Ostracized” narrates the tale of Ben Shaw, a young man compelled to live with his estranged father following his parents’ separation. Initially, Ben exhibits hostility and resistance towards his father’s words, a trait that complicates matters when he starts harboring suspicions about his new neighbor, Abbie. It seems she might be under the influence of an ancient witch, a creature known for its appetite for children.

An Indie Film That’s Way Better Than You’d Think

In the vein of traditional witches’ lore, the movie “The Wretched” adheres to a common horror structure where a boy suspects his neighbors are nefarious. But what sets this film apart is its chilling second act filled with unsettling, albeit tastefully graphic violence and an unabashed willingness to put children in peril. This isn’t a movie for the whole family, and that might just be its strongest point. Due to an unusual release during the COVID-19 pandemic, the film held the number one spot at the box office for six weeks straight.

10 Calvaire (2004)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

In the movie titled “Calvaire“, an elderly singer embarks on a journey seeking employment opportunities. Marc, though not exceptionally skilled as a performer, manages to find work in retirement homes and resides in his van. However, his vehicle unexpectedly malfunctions in a remote location, leaving him no choice but to seek aid from strangers. Among these individuals is Mr. Bartel, a solitary man who’s recently been abandoned by his wife. Desperate for companionship, he offers assistance.

Visiting Hell Itself in Calvaire

The movie “Calvaire” adheres to the conventions of 2000s-era torture porn films, but offers a unique twist: it delves into the motives behind the antagonist’s actions. Unlike other films in this genre, it avoids excessive exposition and lengthy monologues from deranged characters. Instead, it delves into the dark underbelly of small-town life, portraying it as a nihilistic playground for absolute depravity where onlookers become active players. Due to its intense and disturbing nature, viewers should exercise caution when watching this film.

9 La Llorona (2019)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

The tale of La Llorona revolves around the trial of a former dictator, Enrique Monteverde, who was accused of brutally suppressing indigenous communities. Despite these charges, he managed to return home. His household staff, an Indigenous woman named Rosario, is compelled to hire a new maid due to her increased workload. However, the enigmatic and mute young woman, Alma, seems to exert some influence over Monteverde’s fragile psyche. In response, she sets out on a path of vengeance.

La Lloronoa Is Socially Relevant and Very Poignant

In its initial release, Jayro Bustamente’s Guatemalan import was warmly praised and even made it onto the shortlist for the Best Foreign Language Film category at the Oscars. Despite this recognition, it seems that not enough people are aware of it, as it boasts a remarkable 96% score on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics have noted how Bustamante skillfully combines folk horror with insightful social commentary within the film’s premise. This is an often overlooked gem in international horror cinema.

8 The Devil’s Candy (2015)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

The story titled “The Devil’s Candy” focuses on Jesse Hellman, an artist, and his family who relocate to a picturesque country home in Texas. Despite being informed about the previous owners’ tragic deaths, they are determined to establish fresh beginnings. However, their new neighbor, Raymond Smilie, a troubled man, persistently hears voices and believes these voices originate from an evil force residing within the house. Unbeknownst to Jesse, this malevolent presence seems to be expressing itself through his art creations.

The Best Heavy Metal Horror Film You Never Saw

Featuring Ethan Embry, a teen idol, this movie offers a chilling spin on the haunted house theme, complete with unexpected turns. It’s set against a heavy metal soundtrack that integrates seamlessly into the narrative, following the story of a tormented man who falls prey to something demonic. With a 92% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, this film has garnered acclaim, particularly for the impressive direction by Sean Byrne, which horror aficionados have praised enthusiastically.

7 Evolution (2015)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

In my own narrative, I, a young boy named Nicholas, reside in a coastal town where everything seems strikingly similar. The boys around my age are under constant supervision by nurses who dress identically and exhibit peculiar behaviors that leave me uneasy. One fateful day on the beach, I come across what appears to be a lifeless body, causing me to question the true identities of those around me, especially my mother and the other adults.

An Extremely Underrated Fantasy Horror Film

As a lifelong horror enthusiast and a huge fan of Guillermo del Toro’s work, I must say that this European import was unlike anything I have ever seen before. It had an eerie, unsettling quality to it that reminded me of some of my favorite creature features. Although the film didn’t go all-in on graphic horror, its atmosphere alone was enough to give me chills. The third act was particularly mind-bending, leaving me scratching my head for days as I tried to piece together what happened at the end. Overall, this movie is a must-watch for anyone who loves a good mystery and a well-crafted horror film that will leave you questioning reality long after the credits roll.

6 Anything for Jackson (2020)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

For Jackson, Anything Goes: Audrey and Henry, a deeply religious woman and a doctor, are struggling to cope with the sudden death of their grandson, Jackson. In an attempt to find solace, they conceive a desperate plan: they believe they can resurrect Jackson by performing a reverse exorcism. This ritual involves a pregnant woman acting as a vessel for Jackson’s soul, using a satanic incantation to complete the process.

An Excellent Sample of Canadian Horror

In the movie “Anything for Jackson“, the genre blend stands out remarkably and complements a storyline that’s inherently unique from the start. Although the plot takes a chilling turn in the third act, it’s really the captivating performances of Julian Richings and Sheila McCarthy that steal the show. Their acting skills offer a wide spectrum of emotions, allowing viewers to empathize with their characters and their complex motivations, even when they seem unconventional.

5 The Strings (2020)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

The Strings

The Most Obscure Film on the List Is Also One of the Eeriest

Newcomer Ryan Glover’s experimental film, titled “The Haunting Whispers,” was not widely viewed upon release, mainly limited to festival circles. However, it’s an intriguing piece that caters more towards art-house enthusiasts seeking something beyond the ordinary scares. The movie’s uniqueness lies in its hauntingly atmospheric soundtrack, which beautifully complements a tormented protagonist’s emotional journey.

4 Z (2019)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

In the peaceful setting of their ideal home, the seemingly perfect couple Kevin and Beth, along with their son Joshua, encounter an unlikely situation. At first, they think Joshua’s new “friend” named Z is just a harmless figment of his imagination. However, as time goes by, this supposedly benign entity starts to reveal its true malevolent character by controlling Joshua and subjecting the family to unspeakable fear and horror.

Z Is an Eerie Iteration of the Classic Horror Trope

Maybe Z’s movie isn’t a twist on the common theme of “the seemingly benign imaginary friend who reveals an evil side.” Yet, it excels within the traditional horror genre, standing out among many indie horror films due to its effectiveness. The standout aspect is Keegan Connor Tracy’s captivating performance (known for her roles in Psych and The 4400), which has earned the film an impressive 97% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

3 The Beach House (2019)

The Seaside Retreat

A Perfect Execution of “Deadly Virus” Horror

The movie spends a curiously large amount of time trying to solve its character dynamics without revealing that it’s about an infection slowly taking over everything. But in the end, it works as an excellent exemption to the rules of horror storytelling. However, when it enters horror territory, this one gets pretty gnarly. The film is a great example of a film director debuting in the horror genre with a solid first movie.

2 Spiral (2021)

20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder20 Best Hidden Gems on Shudder

In the story of Spiral, Aaron and Malik, a loving couple, choose to relocate to a different neighborhood for a fresh beginning and to provide their daughter with a secure upbringing. Initially, everything seems perfect, as neighbors extend them a friendly greeting. However, their optimism is shattered when they come to understand that the welcome wasn’t as warm as it appeared.

Spiral Is Not What You Think

In a seemingly predictable pattern of a progressive society targeting its victims, there is an unexpected twist that proves to be both original and fitting within the narrative context. This production, particularly the performances by Jeffrey Bowyer-Chapman and Lochlyn Munro, is more thought-provoking than frightening, delivering a powerful and moving experience.

1 Son (2021)

The tale unfolds around Laura, a young mom who found herself in motherhood at a tender age while fleeing a cult. Her son, David, is now eight. Until recently, Laura had successfully concealed her past; however, an unsettling wave of mysterious individuals has infiltrated their lives. The predicament arises as David starts exhibiting signs of an unusual illness, forcing Laura to abandon discretion and shield them from the cult’s grasp.

A Mother’s Love Is Unconditional in Son

Under the guidance of director Ivan Kavanagh (known for “The Canal”), the movie “Son” is a relatively unknown gem that managed to escape widespread attention. Despite this, it’s an extraordinarily chilling film starring budding actress Andi Matichak, who portrays a tenacious mother fighting for her son, regardless of his mysterious nature. The film’s production was marred by unfortunate events, fueling speculation that it might have been haunted.

Read More

2024-08-11 01:33