25 Years Later, The Blair Witch Project Is Still a Deeply Unsettling Horror Film

25 Years Later, The Blair Witch Project Is Still a Deeply Unsettling Horror Film

As a cinephile who’s seen my fair share of horror films, I must say that “The Blair Witch Project” has left an indelible mark on me. Having watched it for the first time back in 1999, when I was just starting to explore the vast universe of cinema, this film struck a chord that resonated deeply within me. The way it blurred the lines between reality and fiction, using a found-footage approach that felt raw, authentic, and terrifying, was truly groundbreaking.


Back in 1999, The Blair Witch Project was everywhere. 

Whether you saw the film or not –– and a lot of people saw the film –– you could not escape the found footage hit from directors Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sanchez. Posters were everywhere, ads were all over TV, and even the “dossier” that purportedly detailed the case was on shelves in every bookstore. Then of course, there were all the people talking about the movie, from theatergoers in the concession lines to talk show hosts to your friends at school who’d watched it over the weekend. The spell it cast was vast and potent, so it’s no wonder that there was inevitable backlash.

There has always been a certain perspective in our culture about horror films that suggests the best way to enjoy one is by trying to outsmart it, disproving its ability to scare you, the supposed superior viewer. Movies like The Blair Witch Project, with its subtle plot and minimal monster scenes, were particularly susceptible to this mindset. Although it attracted many fans, there were also those who criticized it, claiming that “nothing happens” or “it’s not very scary” or “this movie is simply dull.” This debate continued even after the film’s initial release and still exists today, a quarter-century later.

However, beyond the ongoing discussion about the effectiveness of “The Blair Witch Project” in creating fear through its minimalistic approach, a persistent unease pervades the movie’s compact 82-minute duration. This oppressive feeling is so potent that if you experience it, you’ll remain captivated within the film’s ominous atmosphere. To validate this, simply log onto Peacock and watch it instantly.

Want more horror?

1. This Week in Genre Lore, The Blair Witch Project Deceived Us

The Familiar Roots of The Blair Witch Project

about:blank

In this movie, even if you haven’t watched it before, you might be familiar with the plot due to its widespread popularity over the years and its straightforward narrative. A group of three student filmmakers – Heather (Heather Donahue), Josh (Joshua Leonard), and Mike (Michael Williams) – venture into the dense woods of Maryland for a weekend, intending to create a documentary under Heather’s direction about a local witchcraft tale. They mysteriously vanish and are not found for a year; later, their footage is uncovered, and what we see on screen is claimed to be an account of what truly happened to these actual students.

Starting from that assumption, things begin quite straightforwardly. The group is depicted buying necessary marshmallows for roasting near the fire while grocery shopping, and later exploring the town of Burkittsville to learn about the Blair Witch folklore. They engage with locals, sometimes gathering interesting tales and other times encountering nonsensical stories, sharing laughter over the peculiar individuals they meet. As they journey deeper into the woods, their struggles with heavy backpacks are shown, and we even catch a glimpse of Heather recording an unremarkable segment of the legend’s history.

In simpler terms, these scenes are crucial not just for evoking memories of 90s kids exploring woods with handheld cameras, an experience many can identify with, but also for reminding us of the mysterious, sometimes unclear paranormal documentaries we watched growing up. Just like those documentaries, it’s clear in the early scenes of “The Blair Witch Project” that Heather, Josh, and Mike aren’t entirely convinced by what they’re filming, even though Heather’s narration seems serious. They’re more about creating a compelling tale than seeking the truth. There’s a touch of playfulness and artificiality to it all, which adds to the horror as the movie progresses, when this facade begins to crumble.

How The Blair Witch Project leans into the simple terror of being lost

about:blank

As they delve deeper into the forest, the trio encounters increasingly bizarre visuals and auditory phenomena that unsettle them. Stone piles pop up near their campsite, eerie wooden figurines dangle from trees, and at night, they’re haunted by strange noises like banging and laughter resembling children. It seems a mysterious entity has taken interest in them and refuses to let go, but the scariest aspect of this journey is yet to come.

As a fan, I must admit that the peculiar incidents happening deep within the forest are downright chilling, especially the night when it seemed like a horde of children invaded our tent and forced us out into the woods, sending shivers up my spine. The movie masterfully escalates this tension, making it hard to ignore. It’s misleading to suggest that nothing significant happens during these moments; instead, they are filled with an unsettling kind of fear that the film expertly weaves. However, there’s a deeper, more philosophical layer to this as well – the film invites us to contemplate the unknown and question our existence in the face of such unexplained events.

25 Years Later, The Blair Witch Project Is Still a Deeply Unsettling Horror Film

Halfway through the movie, the trio begins to suspect they might be wandering off course. At this point, Heather offers an insight: They’re in America, with towns, roads, and signs of everyday civilization not far away, implying they can’t really be lost. If they are, then they certainly won’t remain so. Later, when they discover they’ve been circling the same area and have misplaced their map, Heather repeats her initial thought in a desperate appeal, exclaiming “This is America!” as if it were a fervent prayer.

The idea of getting lost in the civilized world is a terrifying, existential one unto itself, something that would be hard for any of us to grasp until we were truly in that moment. But then The Blair Witch Project takes it just a little deeper, in a scene of peak tension when Josh, having taken Heather’s camcorder, remarks that he understands why she refuses to stop filming them. The camera, he tells her, is “not quite reality.” It’s a slight remove, a chance for her to retreat into the mode of observer, however tenuously, and pull away from their situation. 

These two ideas, Heather’s observation about America and Josh’s about the camera, create a darker layer of fear within the film. These are people who believe they understand objective reality, but they’re also people out in the woods trying to make a documentary about a story that may or may not be true. The very act of attempting to make their film with sincerity, even if they don’t believe the story, places them in a certain liminality, and that liminality is furthered by the characters’ observations. Josh understands that the camera lens adds a layer of liminality itself, while Heather understands that they should be on a kind of border between civilization and wilderness, and that border should be easily penetrable. Instead, they’re stuck in-between, unable to break free of the woods even though they know exactly where they are on a map of Maryland. They are trapped in a limbo, a loop that won’t end, and that’s more terrifying than any sound going bump into the night.

A Remarkable Exercise in Craft

about:blank

The movie “The Blair Witch Project” owes a significant part of its success to Myrick, Sanchez, and their team, but it thrives primarily on the skills of its lead actors. Donahue, Leonard, and Williams are responsible for handling all filming equipment, coming up with spontaneous dialogue, and evoking real emotions in a contrived setup. They manage this task exceptionally well, capturing everything from happy mishaps to moments of genuine fear. However, the pièce de résistance among their accomplishments is undeniably the final scene of the film.

One well-known horror scene in contemporary cinema, often imitated or analyzed extensively, is the one under discussion here. As Josh is nowhere to be found, calling out for assistance from an unseen location, Heather and Mike embark on a search, discovering an old house nestled deep within the woods as their destination. They enter the house to continue their search, with Heather handling the black-and-white 16mm film camera they utilized for the documentary, while Mike manages the camcorder for all other purposes. Unfortunately, their sound recording system was left behind, leaving only the microphone on the camcorder as a means of capturing audio.

25 Years Later, The Blair Witch Project Is Still a Deeply Unsettling Horror Film

Working in unison yet occasionally splitting up due to Josh’s calls, Heather and Mike systematically search different parts of the compact house. At times they move synchronously, while at others they explore distinct areas on separate floors or rooms. The small size of the house allows the camcorder to capture both their voices, although there are moments when Heather moves further away, creating a haunting sensation as her voice softens and then becomes clearer again.

The story reaches its climax in the last scene where Heather discovers Mike in the basement of the house, cornered with his camera fallen due to an invisible force. Since Heather, similar to us, has followed the tale’s mythos attentively, she recognizes this as a sign of impending death. As the movie comes to an end, her screams escalate from a chilling, reverberating wail to a peak of terror, as she moves nearer and nearer to the camera, ultimately meeting her fate when she too is seized by the unseen force.

Having grown up watching “The Matrix” multiple times, I can confidently say that the sound design in this film is nothing short of remarkable, even if it was unintentional. It effectively conveys the sense that these characters are trapped in a world that’s not their own, one that has been altered beyond recognition and keeps them stuck in limbo until their inevitable deaths. The sound design adds an extra layer of depth to the film’s narrative, making it even more haunting and thought-provoking. After 25 years since its release, “The Matrix” still holds up as a masterpiece, demonstrating that its power has not waned over time. In my opinion, this movie is a timeless classic that continues to resonate with audiences today.

Read More

2024-08-20 22:17