32 Classic TV Characters That Weren’t Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Reflecting upon these fascinating tales of characters who rose from obscurity to become beloved figures in their respective shows, I find myself utterly captivated by the serendipitous nature of fate and talent colliding. It’s as if these actors were destined for greatness all along, waiting patiently for their moment to shine!


It might appear as though your beloved character from your preferred TV series has always been a permanent member of the main cast, but this may not be accurate. In reality, several legendary TV characters were initially intended to make only brief appearances in one or two episodes before a behind-the-scenes choice extended their stay. Here are some well-known instances that could cause you to view your favorite show’s upcoming guest star in a new light.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Jesse Pinkman (Breaking Bad)

Apart from Aaron Paul’s exceptional, compassionate portrayal of Jesse Pinkman, it was Vince Gilligan’s initial plan for Walter White’s associate to meet an early end that left studio executives stunned. Fortunately, this unexpected idea was abandoned, ensuring the survival of the beloved character in the series until its conclusion.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Andy Dwyer (Parks And Recreation)

Initially planned for only six episodes in the first season of “Parks and Recreation,” the charmingly forgetful character Andy Dwyer, who was then dating Ann Perkins (portrayed by Rashida Jones), was unexpectedly kept on the show due to Michael Schur finding Chris Pratt, the future box-office hit actor, too amusing to let go. This led to his promotion as a series regular and eventually, Andy developing a romantic relationship with April Ludgate, played by Aubrey Plaza.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Arthur “The Fonz” Fonzarelli (Happy Days)

Initially, it was a minor role that brought Henry Winkler into the limelight, but eventually, it turned out to be the lead character in “Happy Days.” Interestingly, the character now known as “Fonzie” started off small before the audience’s overwhelming response prompted producers to increase his screen time.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Frasier Crane (Cheers)

Initially, Kelsey Grammer’s character Dr. Frasier Crane in the “Cheers” cast was planned for just a few episodes. However, he gained immense popularity and ended up being one of NBC’s sitcom’s beloved figures. His success led to a spin-off series, “Frasier,” which rivaled the original show in quality.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Spike (Buffy The Vampire Slayer)

Initially, Spike was simply another vampire for Sarah Michelle Gellar’s character to battle when he debuted in the second season of Joss Whedon’s successful show “Buffy the Vampire Slayer.” However, his rising fame eventually led to James Masters securing a permanent role on the series and even developing a romantic interest for Buffy.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Chandler Bing And Phoebe Buffay (Friends)

Initially, the television series Friends was planned to focus on just four young New Yorkers as main characters. However, after Matthew Perry (Chandler) and Lisa Kudrow (Phoebe) demonstrated their captivating charm during auditions, creators David Crane and Marta Kauffman decided these actors deserved leading roles instead of occasional appearances, as they had initially intended.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Carol Hathaway (ER)

In its original version, if the pilot episode of ER had been filmed as written, it would have marked the first and last appearance of Carol Hathaway, portrayed by Julianna Margulies, who was initially intended to commit suicide. However, when test audiences noticed the strong chemistry between the nurse manager and George Clooney’s character, Doug Ross, the lead writers decided to keep her alive on the show until Margulies departed in Season 6.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Luke Danes (Gilmore Girls)

Luke Danes, the diner owner, was initially conceived as a female character by creator Amy Sherman-Palladino. However, when the network requested more male characters, she decided to change the gender. It wasn’t until they observed the strong chemistry between Scott Patterson and Lauren Graham, two of the ‘Gilmore Girls’ cast members, that their intriguing will-they-won’t-they relationship was added to the dramedy series.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Lafayette Reynolds (True Blood)

In the second book of Charlaine Harris’ “The Southern Vampire Mysteries” series, Lafayette Reynolds is killed off. However, the psychic cook’s television counterpart, portrayed by Nelsan Ellis, survived in the HBO series adaptation (and one of the best horror TV shows on Max), “True Blood”, after creator Alan Ball recognized that the character complemented the world particularly well.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Castiel (Supernatural)

Initially appearing on Supernatural in Season 4 as Misha Collins’ character, Castiel was initially planned for a three-season stint. However, following this, Collins was upgraded to a regular cast member, and the angel Castiel established a long-term alliance with Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean (Jensen Ackles) Winchester.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Steve Urkel (Family Matters)

Initially, the spin-off of “Perfect Strangers” focused on the Winslow family’s life. However, as the sitcom progressed, the spotlight shifted from the Winslows to their quirky neighbor, Steve Urkel, played by Jaleel White. His appearance in Season 1 saved the show from being canceled, and he went on to make more appearances and eventually became a regular cast member of “Family Matters” starting from Season 2.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Andy Bernard (The Office)

In the third season, Ed Helms first appeared as Andy Bernard, a character initially intended to last just one year on ‘The Office.’ However, the show’s creator, Greg Daniels, found Andy so appealing that he decided to keep him around, even after his stint in anger management, making him a permanent member of the Dunder Mifflin clan.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Sgt. Fin Tutuola (Law & Order: SVU)

Although Ice-T is often recognized for a song that talks about police killings, surprisingly, his most notable acting gig is portraying a police officer on Law & Order: SVU. Interestingly, Fin Tutuola, a character initially intended as a five-episode guest appearance in 2000, eventually became a permanent cast member.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Jack Shephard (Lost)

Prior to Matthew Fox’s addition to the cast as Jack Shephard on Lost, it was initially planned that his character would perish in the pilot episode to underscore the show’s survival drama concept where no character is invulnerable. Michael Keaton had agreed to play the role under this stipulation, but he withdrew when they decided to make him the main character because he wasn’t ready to dedicate himself to a series at that point in time.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Felicity Smoak (Arrow)

Originally appearing as a recurring character in the first season of “Arrow”, Felicity Smoak is based on a DC Comics character. Later, as her role evolved and became more significant, particularly as Oliver Queen’s main love interest, Emily Bett Rickards was upgraded to a series regular.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Steve Harrington (Stranger Things)

Steve Harrington (played by Joe Kerry), initially portrayed as a typical ’80s high school bully with a limited lifespan in the first season of Stranger Things, experienced a significant transformation due to fans’ favorable reception. Fortunately, this response prompted a reworking of the character, making Keery an essential part of the Hawkins group.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Boyd Crowder (Justified)

Enjoying the dynamic between U.S. Marshal Raylan Givens, played by Timothy Olyphant, and criminal mastermind Boyd Crowder, portrayed by Walton Goggins, is one of the most captivating aspects of the show Justified. We’re grateful that Boyd survived the initial episode, unlike in Elmore Leonard’s original short story, “Fire in the Hole,” and that Goggins was given a permanent role in the series.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

NoHo Hank (Barry)

As a devoted fan, I can confidently say that Anthony Carrigan shines among the stellar cast of HBO’s Barry, particularly in his portrayal of the charismatic Chechen criminal NoHo Hank. It comes as no surprise that his character’s role grew beyond Season 1, even though he was originally slated for a more dramatic exit, given his exceptional performance.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

The Armorer (The Mandalorian)

One intriguing character from Disney+’s “Star Wars” TV series, “The Mandalorian,” is The Armorer (played by Emily Swallow). This character is known for her complex and captivating layers. An almost climactic moment in her storyline was nearly included in the first season, where a deleted scene showed her making a selfless sacrifice, giving up her life.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Logan Roy (Succession)

It would have been impossible for anyone else to fill Logan Roy’s shoes on the HBO series “Succession,” as his character was crucial to the show. However, had things gone according to the original plan, Brian Cox’s character might not have survived past Season 1, leaving a significant gap. Fortunately, Cox’s role endured and has become one of the most cherished in this popular dramedy.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Topanga Lawrence (Boy Meets World)

In the beloved Friday series by creators Michael Jacobs and April Kelly, Topanga Lawrence initially appeared as the peculiar girl in Cory Matthews’ (Ben Savage) class within the show ‘Boy Meets World’. However, following the decision to make her character Cory’s romantic interest, Danielle Fishel was given a permanent role in the series cast.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Gunther (Friends)

Initially, James Michael Tyler joined the cast of Friends as an extra for scenes set at Central Perk. However, in Season 2, his character was established as Gunther, the coffee shop manager, and he was upgraded to a recurring supporting role, eventually appearing in a total of 185 episodes.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Janitor (Scrubs)

As a devoted Scrubs fan, I was initially intrigued by the enigmatic janitor character, who started off as a recurring role in my beloved show. However, it wasn’t until the end of Season 1 that we were supposed to discover his existence within J.D.’s (Zach Braff) imagination. But, brilliant creator Bill Lawrence had other plans – he recognized Neil Flynn’s exceptional improvisational talents and decided to elevate the janitor to a permanent member of the Scrubs cast. And boy, was that a stroke of genius!

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

President Josiah Bartlet (The West Wing)

Initially, Aaron Sorkin envisioned his Emmy-winning political series primarily revolving around the White House staff, with the President appearing sporadically or not at all. However, fortunately, this plan was altered, leading to Martin Sheen’s remarkable portrayal of Josiah Bartlet on NBC’s The West Wing, which ultimately became a cherished and inspiring aspect of the show.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Elijah Krantz (Girls)

As a gamer putting myself in the shoes of Andrew Rannells, I initially appeared in a minor role as Hannah’s ex-closeted college boyfriend, Elijah Krantz, on HBO’s hit show, Girls. Over time, I made occasional appearances throughout the first three seasons. But by the fourth season, the creative minds behind the dramedy, Lena Dunham and Jenni Konner, decided to bring me on board as a series regular. This transformation allowed Elijah to become one of the most unforgettably humorous characters in the series.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

April Ludgate (Parks And Recreation)

April Ludgate, as seen on Parks and Recreation, wasn’t initially planned for a significant part in the series. In fact, there were no plans to include her at all until the creator, Michael Schur, encountered Aubrey Plaza during auditions. He was so captivated by her acting skills that he devised a character specifically for her.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Aram Mojtabai (The Blacklist)

Initially, Amir Arison joined NBC’s The Blacklist as a cyber crime consultant for a single episode in the first season, at the request of the FBI. However, the writers appreciated his improvisation, which led to him being frequently re-cast and eventually becoming a main character in Season 2.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Summer Roberts (The O.C.)

In the initial episode of The O.C., Rachel Bilson’s character, Summer Roberts, had minimal screen presence and was primarily depicted as an unacknowledged friend to Marissa (played by Mischa Barton). However, the show’s creator, Josh Schwartz, found Bilson’s interpretation of Summer captivating. This intrigue, coupled with her on-screen chemistry with Adam Brody (Seth), prompted him to expand her role significantly in the developing drama series.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Joshua Rosza (The Originals)

Initially, Steven Krueger appeared sporadically in the series “The Originals” as Joshua Rosza. But by Season 5, his vampire character transitioned into a main role in the popular supernatural TV show.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Killian Jones/Captain Hook (Once Upon A Time)

In the second season of ABC’s fairy tale series “Once Upon a Time,” Captain Hook (originally intended for a five-episode stint as Peter Pan’s adversary, Killian Jones) was initially well-received by viewers due to his on-screen chemistry with Jennifer Morrison. However, it was Colin O’Donoghue’s exceptional performance that ultimately convinced the show’s cast and crew to make him a permanent cast member.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Brittany S. Pierce (Glee)

Initially, Heather Morris was hired on the Glee set to instruct the cast members in dance moves from Beyonce’s “Single Ladies” music video. Later, Ryan Murphy, one of the show’s creators, recognized her comedic skills and started giving her character, Brittany Pierce, more lines. Eventually, Morris was upgraded from a recurring character to a series regular due to this newfound talent.

32 Classic TV Characters That Weren't Originally Planned For Such A Big Role

Kima Greggs (The Wire)

As a gamer pouring over seasons of “The Wire”, I stumbled upon an unexpected twist during the filming of its first season: my character, Shakima “Kima” Greggs, was initially meant to bite the dust in episode 10. But luck shone on me when HBO executive Carolyn Strauss took a liking to Kima, successfully persuading showrunner David Simon to let me dodge that bullet and stick around for the rest of the crime drama’s run.

Read More

2024-08-09 20:38