32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

As a film enthusiast with a soft spot for intriguing character transformations and the occasional behind-the-scenes drama, I find it absolutely captivating how these talented actors and actresses have breathed life into various roles throughout the history of entertainment. Some of them started strong but had to pass the baton to their successors due to unforeseen circumstances, while others stepped in at the last minute to bring a unique perspective to a beloved character.


In the world of movies and TV, certain characters are strongly associated with a specific actor. However, there are also instances where these roles have been shared among two or more performers. While this is not an uncommon occurrence in today’s industry with its focus on reboots and remakes, we will be discussing instances where the same character appeared in the same cinematic franchise or TV series but was portrayed by different actors due to various reasons. Let’s delve into some notable examples of this phenomenon.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Vivian Banks (The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air)

In the early stages of “The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air” sitcom, Janet Hubert portrayed the character of Vivian Banks, Will Smith’s aunt. Yet, tensions arose between Hubert and Smith during filming, causing Daphne Maxwell Reid to take over the role in seasons four through six. Jazz, played by DJ Jazzy Jeff, playfully referenced this change on more than one occasion.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

James “Rhodey” Rhodes (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

Towards the end of 2008’s “Iron Man,” Terrence Howard, portraying James Rhodes, contemplates one of Tony Stark’s (Robert Downey Jr.) unfinished armored suits and intends to test it out in the future. Regrettably, there wasn’t a future opportunity for Howard as he departed due to contract issues and was subsequently replaced by Don Cheadle in “Iron Man 2.” Since then, Cheadle has portrayed Colonel Rhodes, also known as “Rhodey,” in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Catwoman (Batman)

Julie Newmar and Eartha Kitt are known for their iconic portrayals of Catwoman in the TV series “Batman.” Additionally, Lee Meriwether took on the role in the film adaptation based on the 1960s version led by Adam West.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Emperor Palpatine (The Star Wars Movies)

Most contemporary Star Wars fans, who haven’t obtained an authentic, unaltered version of “The Empire Strikes Back” from the 1980s, may be unaware that Emperor Palpatine was initially depicted physically by Elaine Baker and gave his voice performance by Clive Revill. However, since Ian McDiarmid assumed the role in “Return of the Jedi” in 1983, footage of him was inserted into the 2004 edition of “Empire.”

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Cleveland Brown (Family Guy)

Some people might be shocked to learn that one of the Black characters in “Family Guy,” an animated series, was voiced by a white actor until 2020. Mike Henry, who also provides the voices for Herbert and Consuela, chose to relinquish this role. Arif Zahir, whose impressive acting abilities were discovered on YouTube, took over the part instead.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Evelyn O’Connell (The Mummy Movies)

As a gamer, I can tell you that after two exciting adventures as Evelyn O’Connell (née Carnahan) in “The Mummy” (1999) and “The Mummy Returns” (2001), Rachel Weisz, an esteemed Academy Award-winning actress, decided against reprising her role for a third installment. Consequently, Maria Bello stepped up to the challenge and brought the brash librarian character to life in “The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor” (2008).

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Darrin Stephens (Bewitched)

When Emmy-nominated actor Dick York found it harder to work on “Bewitched” due to a back injury, he had to give up the role of Darrin, Samantha Stephens’ mortal husband, played by Elizabeth Montgomery. The producers then turned to their initial pick for the part, Dick Sargent, who was engaged in another project but ultimately took on the character for the last three seasons of the magical sitcom.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Jack Ryan (Jack Ryan Movies)

As a huge fan of Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan novels, I’ve been thrilled to see how different actors have brought the character to life on the big screen. In 1990, Alec Baldwin was initially cast as Jack Ryan in “The Hunt for Red October.” However, due to his commitment to a stage production of “A Streetcar Named Desire,” Harrison Ford stepped in and became the lead in “Patriot Games” (1992) and “Clear and Present Danger” (1994). Later on, Ben Affleck took over the role in “The Sum of All Fears” (2002), and a decade and a half later, Chris Pine portrayed Jack Ryan in “Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit.” Most recently, John Krasinski has been named as the lead for Amazon Prime’s new series based on the character.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Harriette Winslow (Family Matters)

As a big fan of “Family Matters,” I’ve heard that things weren’t always smooth behind the scenes. Jaleel White, who brought Steve Urkel to life, and JoMarie Payton, our beloved Harriette Winslow, reportedly had some disagreements. These tensions and creative differences led JoMarie to leave the show during the ninth season, and she was replaced by Judyann Elder as Harriette.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Albus Dumbledore (Harry Potter Movies)

As a huge Harry Potter fan, I’d like to share that the brilliant two-time Academy Award-nominated actor, Richard Harris, brought Albus Dumbledore to life in the first two movies. Sadly, he passed away in 2002 before completing the series. Fortunately, Michael Gambon stepped in and officially joined the magical world of Harry Potter with “Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban” in 2004.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Newman (Seinfeld)

Jerry’s adversary and Kramer’s friend, called Newman, was initially planned as a character only heard, not seen, with Larry David from “Seinfeld” providing the voice-overs. But in the third season of this popular sitcom, Newman, who is a postal worker in the US, made his debut appearance on screen, portrayed by Wayne Knight.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Bruce Wayne (Batman Movies) 

I was thrilled when Michael Keaton donned the cape and cowl to portray Batman in Tim Burton’s films, “Batman” (1989) and “Batman Returns” (1992). But when Tim stepped aside and Joel Schumacher took over as director, I was disappointed that Keaton chose to leave. He was then replaced by Val Kilmer in “Batman Forever,” and later, George Clooney took on the role of Bruce Wayne in “Batman & Robin.”

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Rick Sanchez And Morty Smith (Rick And Morty)

Justin Roiland was a co-creator of the hugely popular animated TV show “Rick and Morty,” providing voices for both Rick and Morty. However, allegations against him resulted in his departure, allowing Ian Cardoni to take over as the voice of Rick, while Harry Belden stepped in as Morty.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Sabretooth (X-Men Movies)

As a big fan of the X-Men comics, I remember when Sabretooth, the fierce and ageless mutant with animalistic features, was brought to life on the silver screen for the first time by professional wrestler Tyler Mane in the early live-action adaptations. However, when it came time to tell Sabretooth’s origin story in X-Men Origins: Wolverine, the filmmakers decided to cast Liev Schreiber instead. Even though the intent was to create a direct prequel, they chose to have Schreiber join Hugh Jackman once again as they reprised their roles as Logan and Sabretooth, respectively.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Gregor “The Mountain” Clegane (Game Of Thrones)

In the world of “Game of Thrones,” it wasn’t surprising or unusual for cast members to be killed off or recast. A clear example of this occurred when Craig Stevens, who played “The Mountain,” was replaced by Ian Whyte in Season 2 and later by Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson for the rest of the show’s run.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Chewbacca (Star Wars Movies)

In “Star Wars: The Force Awakens,” Peter Mayhew once again brought Chewbacca to life on screen, but due to the character’s more demanding physical scenes, Joonas Suotamo stepped in to help out. After Mayhew’s passing, Suotamo took over completely as Chewbacca and continued portraying him in “Solo: A Star Wars Story” and “Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker.”

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Becky Conner (Roseanne)

Becky Conner’s role on “Roseanne” was taken over by two actors at irregular intervals during the show’s original run. Alicia Goranson initially portrayed the character for the first five seasons, as well as the eighth season and the revival series. In contrast, Sarah Chalke joined the cast for seasons six through nine, but later returned for “The Conners” in a distinct recurring role.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Bruce Banner (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

As a gamer, I’d put it like this: When I jumped back into my role as Bruce Banner for Disney+’s She-Hulk, I was struck by how drastically different things were the last time Emil Blonsky (Tim Roth) transformed into his “hulked-out” self. Back then, when we clashed in The Incredible Hulk from 2008, I was an entirely new character. That Bruce Banner was portrayed by Edward Norton, not me.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Laurie Forman (That ’70s Show)

Lisa Robin Kelly gained popularity for her role as Laurie Forman in “That ’70s Show” during its first five seasons. However, before her character was phased out, Christina Moore took over and played Eric’s older sister in the early part of Season 6.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Victoria (The Twilight Saga)

Prior to Rachelle Lefevre’s selection as Victoria in “Twilight” (2008) and its sequel “New Moon,” Bryce Dallas Howard was an early contender for the part. However, she believed the role wasn’t significant enough for her. After Lefevre’s dismissal allegedly due to scheduling issues, Howard agreed to assume the role of the malevolent vampire in “Eclipse.”

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Meg Griffin (Family Guy)

Meg Griffin is known for being voiced by Mila Kunis in “Family Guy,” but she didn’t join the show until Season 2, following Lacey Chabert’s departure. The series has made fun of this change by depicting scenarios where the order of events is reversed and Stewie notices that his sister’s voice is distinctly different.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Clarice Starling (Hannibal)

In 1992, Jodie earned an Academy Award for her chilling portrayal of FBI agent Clarice Starling in “The Silence of the Lambs,” directed by Jonathan Demme and winning the Best Picture Oscar. However, she couldn’t join forces with Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lector again for Ridley Scott’s “Hannibal” released in 2001. Instead, Julianne Moore stepped into the role.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Daario Naharis (Game Of Thrones)

I was thrilled when Ed Skrein made his debut on “Game of Thrones” as Daenerys Targaryen’s advisor and lover, Daario Naharis, during the third season. However, my excitement continued even after he departed from the show in the fourth season, as Michiel Huisman stepped in to take over the role.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Thanos (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

The first time I crossed paths with Thanos was during the mid-credits scene of “The Avengers” back in 2012, where Damion Poitier brought him to life through performance capture. But when Thanos made a reappearance in “Guardians of the Galaxy” two years later, Josh Brolin took over as the Mad Titan, a role he held until his ultimate defeat in “Avengers: Endgame” in 2019.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Carol Willick (Friends)

As a dedicated gamer revisiting “Friends” for the umpteenth time, I recall my initial surprise when Carol, Ross Gellar’s ex-wife and mother of his son Ben, made her appearance in the second episode of Season 1. Anita Barone brought her to life on screen, but her tenure was brief – she departed soon after, leaving a void that Jane Sibbett was poised to fill. For the rest of the show’s impressive run, it was Sibbett who embodied Carol, making her an integral part of the beloved sitcom’s rich tapestry.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Rachel Dawes (The Dark Knight Trilogy)

As a gamer, I can tell you that in the world of Batman, Rachel Dawes, my childhood friend and crush, was initially brought to life by Katie Holmes in the 2005 film “Batman Begins.” However, when she declined the opportunity to reprise her role in “The Dark Knight” in 2008, Maggie Gyllenhaal stepped in and became the new Gotham City attorney.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Greg Serrano (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend)

In the initial two seasons of “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend,” Rebecca Bunch (performed by Rachel Bloom) experienced a intricate relationship with Greg Serrano, portrayed by Santino Fontana. However, after his one-year contract ended, Greg was no longer available for the show. Consequently, when Greg reappeared in Season 4, he was substituted by Skyler Astin, renowned from “Pitch Perfect.”

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Jennifer Parker (Back To The Future Trilogy)

As a dedicated gamer, I can tell you that while some players might be familiar with Elizabeth Shue as Jennifer Parker, she was actually only in the second and third parts of the legendary “Back to the Future” trilogy. The love interest and future wife of Marty McFly, initially portrayed by Claudia Wells, graced our screens for the first time in the original 1985 time-travel masterpiece. Sadly, Claudia had to take a break from acting to focus on her family commitments and didn’t return for subsequent roles.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Ann Veal (Arrested Development)

George Michael Bluth’s forgettable girlfriend in “Arrested Development,” whom fans recognize as Mae Whitman (Michael Cera’s co-star), was initially played by Alessandra Torresani in the show’s first season for only one episode.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Gellert Grindelwald (Fantastic Beasts)

In the 2016 film “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them,” it was uncovered that Percival Graves, portrayed by Johnny Depp, was actually a disguised Gellert Grindelwald during the 2016 Harry Potter prequel. This revelation continued in the 2018 sequel, “The Crimes of Grindelwald.” However, due to legal issues, Warner Bros. replaced Depp with Mads Mikkelsen as the portrayer of Grindelwald in the upcoming film “The Secrets of Dumbledore,” set for release in 2022.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Reggie Mantle (Riverdale)

Ross Butler initially appeared in “Riverdale” during its first season as the recurring character Reggie Mantle, a football player. Yet, Butler’s dedication to “13 Reasons Why” compelled the show to hire Charles Melton instead when the role grew in significance.

32 Times A TV Show Or Movie Franchise Recast A Major Role Mid-Run

Marnie Piper (Halloweentown Movies)

In the 1998 Disney Channel Original Movie “Halloweentown,” Kimberly J. Brown played Marnie Piper, a young witch discovered by her family. Brown reprised her role in two sequels. However, for unknown reasons, Sara Paxton took over as Marnie in the fourth installment, “Return to Halloweentown,” released in 2006. Paxton dyed her hair brown for the part.

Read More

2024-07-18 16:38