After Watching Presumed Innocent’s Season 1 Finale, I Think There’s Only One Way Season 2 Could Work

After Watching Presumed Innocent's Season 1 Finale, I Think There's Only One Way Season 2 Could Work

As a dedicated fan of Apple TV+ and a follower of the gripping legal drama “Presumed Innocent,” I have developed a strong opinion regarding the potential direction for its second season. Having closely observed the first installment and considering my own background in the legal field, I believe that an anthology format would serve this show best.


I’m excitedly discussing “Presumed Innocent” Season 2 and its thrilling finale. But be warned, significant spoilers lie ahead! If you haven’t seen it yet, make sure to catch up with an Apple TV+ subscription before diving in.

After listening to “Presumed Innocent” for eight weeks on the 2024 TV lineup, we discovered the answer to whether Rusty Sabich (Jake Gyllenhaal) was responsible for killing Carolyn Polhemus (Renate Reinsve). The revelation took us by surprise. With the revival of Jake Gyllenhaal’s legal drama, the next query arises: How will they progress in the story now that we have learned the identity of the culprit?

As a longtime fan of legal dramas and having devoured Scott Turow’s “Presumed Innocent” and its sequel “Innocent,” I am both excited and intrigued about the upcoming second season of the series. Although the details are scarce, I appreciate that it will focus on an entirely new case instead of rehashing old ground. My experience with legal thrillers has taught me to expect the unexpected, and this approach keeps my curiosity piqued. Let’s hope for another gripping storyline that showcases the complexities of the law, the nuances of human relationships, and the suspenseful twists we’ve come to love from the “Presumed Innocent” universe.

Based on my experience as a dedicated fan of suspenseful storytelling and having read “Presumed Innocent” several times, I firmly believe that the most effective way to continue this captivating series is by transforming it into an anthology.

After Watching Presumed Innocent's Season 1 Finale, I Think There's Only One Way Season 2 Could Work

The Last Thing I Want To See Is More Of Rusty’s And His Family

Let’s begin by picking up from the end of Season 1. In the final episode of the highly praised show “Presumed Innocent,” an unexpected turn of events unfolded. It was revealed that Rusty’s daughter, Jaden (Chase Infiniti), had actually killed Carolyn with a fire poker. This shocking revelation came immediately after Rusty confessed that he had tied up his ex-lover, Barbara (Ruth Negga), because he suspected her of killing Carolyn. He made this move to divert law enforcement’s attention away from her as a suspect.

At the close of the series, the family united, vowing to keep their experiences a secret as the trial concluded and Rusty was declared innocent.

Though I found the surprise ending and Jaden’s revelation shocking and engaging, I have no desire to witness more of this family’s saga. I am content with where their story concluded.

I strongly oppose the idea of a child being involved in murder, and I believe it’s unnecessary to continue exploring the Sabichs’ story any further.

From a spectator’s perspective, we were given answers regarding the perpetrator of the crime, Rusty confessed to his shortcomings although he didn’t commit the murder of Carolyn, and their family is making progress. However, why prolong the pain and continue this narrative in Season 2 when an anthology format seems more fitting?

After Watching Presumed Innocent's Season 1 Finale, I Think There's Only One Way Season 2 Could Work

Season 2 Of Presumed Innocent Could Pick Up Where It Left Off, Adapt Innocent Or Become An Anthology. I’m On Team Anthology

Currently, “Presumed Innocent” might choose to title Season 2 as just “Innocent,” leap ahead twenty years, and portray Tommy (Peter Sarsgaard) and Rusty going head-to-head in a courtroom trial over Barbara’s demise. Nevertheless, if they followed this route, I believe the series would conclude post-trial.

While We Wait For Season 2, Check These Shows Out
After Watching Presumed Innocent's Season 1 Finale, I Think There's Only One Way Season 2 Could Work

10 Shows Like Presumed Innocent And How To Watch Them

If they continued from there, I’m worried they’d hit a dead end again. Perhaps there could be another installment based on the aftermath of discovering Jaden killed Carolyn. But, as I mentioned earlier, it seems unnecessary to prolong a tale that appears to have reached its conclusion.

As a gamer, I can tell you this: In the world of “Presumed Innocent” Season 2, we’ll embark on a fresh journey with a new case. This could mean that the show might part ways with the old storyline of Season 1 and introduce an entirely different narrative for us to explore.

Based on my experience as a dedicated viewer of anthology series, I strongly believe that both concepts could work wonderfully for Season 2 of this show. Having followed “American Horror Story” for years, I can attest to the intrigue and excitement that comes with an entirely new universe and cast. The allure of unfamiliar characters in a fresh setting keeps viewers on their toes and adds a sense of unpredictability to the storyline.

Each season of the show could present a new morally ambiguous case, similar to Rusty’s, filled with intricate complications. I’m eagerly anticipating a fresh mystery as complex and emotionally charged as the first one. A potential solution would be to transform “Presumed Innocent” into an anthology series akin to “The White Lotus.”

After Watching Presumed Innocent's Season 1 Finale, I Think There's Only One Way Season 2 Could Work

I Think Presumed Innocent Season 2 Should Take A Page Out Of The White Lotus’ Book

As someone who has closely followed HBO’s critically acclaimed anthology series “The White Lotus,” I can attest to the fact that each installment brings a fresh and intriguing cast and setting. The show’s unique premise revolves around a new White Lotus hotel in a different location every season, with only a few familiar faces recurring throughout. This approach keeps the storyline engaging and unpredictable, allowing us viewers to immerse ourselves in new worlds and characters with each episode.

In the first season, the story was set in Hawaii, while the second saw a change of location to Italy and introduced a fresh mystery, with Jennifer Coolidge reappearing as Tanya. Moving forward, the third installment of “The White Lotus” will transport its new cast to Thailand, including Natasha Rothwell’s character Belinda who made an appearance in the initial season.

As a longtime fan of thought-provoking and complex television shows, I strongly believe that “Presumed Innocent” should be developed as an anthology series. Drawing from my years of immersing myself in various intriguing narratives, I have come to appreciate the allure of standalone mysteries with morally ambiguous characters that interconnect within a larger universe.

As a devoted fan, I crave a fresh start with a completely different set of characters for the show. I’d love to see them tackle a complex and high-profile case in a new city like New York or Los Angeles. However, keeping it within the same universe opens up exciting possibilities for bringing back beloved characters from previous cases.

After Watching Presumed Innocent's Season 1 Finale, I Think There's Only One Way Season 2 Could Work

As a big fan of “White Lotus” and Peter Sarsgaard’s captivating portrayal of Tommy Malto, I’ve been pondering how intriguing it would be for his character to take on a new challenge. Just imagine, Tommy, the relentless prosecutor with a knack for getting to the heart of the matter, tackling a fresh case or investigative pursuit unrelated to Rusty. It’s an exciting prospect!

In essence, Season 2 of “Presumed Innocent” would offer fresh storylines and intrigue with distinct cases, conflicts, and characters. Yet, if connected to Season 1’s universe, it could subtly link through the appearance of recurring characters such as Sarsgaard’s Tommy.

The first season of “Presumed Innocent” on Apple TV+ was excellent in my opinion, but to maintain its success, I believe the creators should take a risks and go for something large and innovative in Season 2. Rusty’s character arc and the central mystery have been resolved, making an anthology format a viable option for introducing new and thrilling stories each season.

We can’t predict for certain how “Presumed Innocent” Season 2 will unfold. It’s possible that it could be an anthology series with new cases and characters each season. Fingers crossed for that! In any case, we’ll keep you posted as soon as we have more information about the next exciting chapter of this legal drama.

Read More

2024-07-24 23:38