Trying to Make Sense of Men in Black 3’s Time Travel Rules

by

As a seasoned gamer and time travel enthusiast with over two decades of experience navigating parallel universes, alternate realities, and complex narrative structures, let me tell you that consistency is key when it comes to time travel mechanics in any form of media. It’s like mastering the intricate puzzles in ‘The Witness’ or deciphering the lore of ‘Dark Souls’ – it all hinges on maintaining a clear and coherent set of rules.

There’s one essential rule of time travel: It must be internally consistent.

In essence, time travel as we understand it doesn’t exist in reality. Therefore, any form of entertainment such as movies, TV shows, books, comics, or other creative works that incorporate time travel are fictional. The challenge lies in making these time-travel narratives internally consistent within their own fictional worlds. For instance, it could involve multiple universes branching off over time, similar to the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), or perhaps going back in time might alter history and lead to one’s disappearance, as portrayed in Back to the Future.

In essence, what’s crucial is that the rules governing time travel remain consistent. For instance, if returning to the past creates a duplicate of you alongside the original version, this should always hold true. It would lead to confusion if the rules unexpectedly changed within your fictional universe, causing going back in time now to necessitate replacing your previous self instead. Isn’t that just illogical?

Unfortunately, even though 2012’s “Men in Black 3″ is generally well-regarded within the “Men in Black” series, it falls short in this aspect. Let’s delve deeper into why the time travel mechanics in “Men in Black 3” are inconsistent.

As a die-hard fan, here’s my take on those intriguing titles:

Men in Black 3‘s Flimsy “Rules” of Time Travel

about:blank

In “Men in Black 3”, Agent J (played by Will Smith) journeys through time when a wicked alien named Boris the Animal goes back to kill Agent K (Tommy Lee Jones). With K out of the picture, a vital shield designed to safeguard Earth from harmful aliens was never created. Determined to prevent this, J encounters the younger incarnation of K (portrayed by Josh Brolin) in the swinging ’60s. After proving his claim that he’s from the future, they team up to thwart Boris and his 1960s self, ensuring the safety of our planet once more.

In the ’60s, you’d find two characters named Boris the Animal, one from the contemporary era and another from days gone by. An unexpected turn of events discloses the presence of two Js as well, with a young boy who meets J turning out to be young “James.” Traveling back in time in Men in Black 3, therefore, transports you to an era where you coexist with any past versions of yourself that may have existed in that particular time period. Sounds straightforward, doesn’t it?

Instead of using time travel to evade Boris’ attacks during their fight on the Apollo 11 launch tower, J chooses a different approach when battling the alien. Rather than stepping back to avoid Boris’ spikes, he charges at him and learns the pattern of where the enemy is shooting. Once he knocks Boris off the tower, the fall triggers his time-travel device, sending him back to the top of the tower. Now aware of Boris’ firing location, J skillfully dodges the incoming spikes and eventually pushes Boris off the edge, resulting in the alien’s demise.

In the rules set by the movie ‘Men in Black 3’, when someone travels back in time, they shouldn’t replace their past selves. Instead, they create an alternate timeline where both versions of themselves exist concurrently. So, if J traveled back to that ledge, there should have been two Js present, not just one replacing the other. This is because Boris the Animal would have also replaced his 1960s self and J would already be a different person from the little kid version of himself. Such a scenario could indeed be quite unsettling.

Read More

2024-07-30 22:46