25 Underrated Horror Sequels That Deserve More Respect

Summary

Horror sequels can either replicate the original’s success or take a different direction, but all contribute to the genre’s evolution.
Films like Jaws 2, Child’s Play 3, and Predator 2 show how sequels can maintain the essence of the original while introducing new elements.
Underrated sequels like Return of the Living Dead III and Hellraiser III offer unique takes that appeal to fans seeking a fresh perspective.

As a long-time fan of horror films, I must say that these underrated gems are truly a delight to revisit! Let’s dive into some of them, shall we?

It’s no secret that follow-up films in the horror genre have been around for quite some time. It seems that viewers always crave more thrilling encounters with terrifying creatures, and every horror enthusiast could easily rattle off several notable sequels like Evil Dead II, Aliens, Nightmare on Elm Street 3, Scream 2. The number of sequels that surpassed or at least matched the original in quality is considerable and impressive. Moreover, since the late ’70s, slasher films have become a common feature in mainstream cinematography. It’s important to note that success often sparks continuation in any genre of film, and this is especially true for horror movies.

Additionally, consider that numerous horror series have produced multiple sequels, with some reaching as many as 8 or 9 films, and in some cases even more. However, not all of these can be considered high-quality productions. Despite this, it’s important to note that not every subpar sequel deserves the negative label, even if it is sometimes applied.

25 Jaws 2 (1978)

Roy Scheider initially resisted returning for “Jaws 2”, but a contract eventually brought him back, which we’re grateful for. While viewers don’t necessarily need to watch the third and fourth films, the first two are essential viewing. The original “Jaws” stands out not just as the best in its series, but also makes a strong case for being called ‘The Best Movie of All Time’. Remarkably, “Jaws 2” carries on much of what made the original film so effective.

What Makes It Great?

In a slightly different phrase, let me rephrase your text:

24 Damien: Omen II (1978)

Compared to its intelligent predecessor, the movie “Damien: Omen II” might seem like a shift towards horror tropes that are more common in slasher films. However, it’s important to note that it does take a step down from the original. Yet, this step-down is not without merit; it still manages to maintain an eerie and atmospheric feel. Until the release of “The First Omen” in 2024, “Damien: Omen II” held the title as the second best in the series.

But It Works Though, Right?

A more engaging approach to create a sequel for a movie that might not necessitate one is through “Damien.” Not only is it inventive in its kill scenes, but also stars William Holden and Lee Grant, who were instrumental in “Damien: Omen II” production. Despite not being as profound, thought-provoking, or shocking as the original, they made some commendable choices leading up to its release. Now available for streaming on Hulu.

23 Friday the 13th Part III (1982)

Although the Friday the 13th movies are generally known for their serious undertones, they are intentionally designed to be broadly comprehensible. However, there are some exceptions, and one such instance occurred with Friday the 13th Part III. This installment retained elements that made the first two successful while introducing unique, unsettling twists – like featuring an expectant mother as a victim, a first and last occurrence in any Jason film.

Why Is It the Underrated One of the Iconic First Four?

In a slightly different wording:

22 Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982)

“Although ‘Halloween III: Season of the Witch’ doesn’t have any connection to Michael Myers beyond sharing the Halloween title (and a promotional ad for the original film), it remains part of the franchise. Interestingly, this film is often overlooked, but in fact, it holds significant value within the IP.”

Has It Gotten Any Credit Over the Years?

While it’s true that “Season of the Witch” has gained more recognition lately, there’s still room for more. Directed by Tommy Lee Wallace, this unique and occasionally genuinely scary film is filled with endearing charm. Notably, it showcases Tom Atkins in his finest performance. You can now watch it on Apple TV+.

21 A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy’s Revenge (1985)

Following Wes Craven’s groundbreaking film “A Nightmare on Elm Street,” the slasher genre experienced a revitalization. However, with such an original idea, deciding on a direction can be challenging. This is particularly noticeable when writing the initial sequel, as it seems to struggle somewhat with this creative decision.

Why Was It Deemed a Disappointment?

In the movie A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy’s Revenge, they decided to bend the rules of the universe a bit (which might be why Freddy hasn’t returned to any other non-dream settings outside of this film), explore it as a possible gay allegory, and develop Freddy’s character more. For the most part, these strategies were successful. The movie isn’t the scariest in the series, but it definitely has that charming ’80s slasher vibe and an incredible opening sequence. You can watch it now on Apple TV+.

20 Friday the 13th Part V: A New Beginning (1985)

1985’s “Friday the 13th Part V: A Fresh Start” is often seen as a peculiar entry in the “Friday the 13th” series. Compared to “Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter,” which was released just one year prior, the speed at which part five followed was almost comical, given that the franchise hadn’t previously moved so swiftly from one installment to another. This hasty production is evident in the film. However, some argue that “A Fresh Start” more accurately encapsulated the essence of the first four films compared to any subsequent sequels.

Why Wasn’t It Properly Appreciated?

It was both a case of too much in too little time and a case of diminishing returns. Not to mention, having an imposter Jason in the film was always going to be a letdown after his grandiose death in The Final Chapter. And, yet, there are a couple of really solid kills, a pair of likable characters, and a bargain bin vibe that’s both effective and logical when one realizes the film was directed by someone used to helming pornos (not unlike the original film’s Sean S. Cunningham). Stream on Max.

19 Creepshow 2 (1987)

In a unique blend, the classic film “Creepshow” perfectly encapsulated the creative minds of directors George A. Romero and author Stephen King. The film comprises five captivating tales, each with its own level of appeal. These stories are not only engaging but also evoke a warm sense of nostalgia.

Is It as Good as the Original?

Titled “Creepshow 2“, this sequel, despite boasting a smaller budget and only three tales, serves as a follow-up. Admittedly, it may not reach the heights of its predecessor in terms of quality, but it’s advantageous to have it available for viewing immediately afterward. Notably, the sequel manages to maintain a similar atmosphere to the original, albeit with slightly less inventiveness. While the creativity might not be at par, each of the three narratives offers something unique, particularly “The Raft.” You can catch it streaming on platforms like Tubi or Prime Video.

18 Critters 2: The Main Course (1988)

Mick Garris, often associated with Stephen King adaptations, first stepped into the director’s chair with “Critters 2: The Main Course.” It’s safe to say he delivered an exceptional performance. The original “Critters” distinguished itself from “Gremlins,” not due to any intentional differentiation but because both were in development simultaneously. Unlike subsequent imitations like “Hobgoblins,” which followed, “The Main Course” sets itself apart even more, to its advantage. For example, the colossal rolling Critter that features prominently in the third act.

Why Hasn’t It Rightly Been Called the Best of the Bunch?

As someone who grew up in the ’80s and had a soft spot for B-movies, I must admit that I haven’t been particularly impressed with the Critters franchise as a whole. However, if there’s one film that stands out among them, it’s undoubtedly the first one. But let me be clear, this doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a great movie in its own right; instead, it seems to be more of an old cliché (“The first is always the best”).

17 Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989)

In 1988, “Halloween 4: The Resurrection of Michael Myers” is considered among the top entries in the series. However, its earnings at the box office indicated that the public was more captivated by Freddy Krueger rather than Michael Myers during that time.

What Happened with The Revenge, and Why Is It Underrated?

When Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers was released, audience excitement had decreased noticeably, making it a relatively forgettable theater experience. Despite its shortcomings and inferiority to its previous installment, there are many appealing aspects to Halloween 5. It maintains the distinctive autumn atmosphere of the series, offers more screen time for Danielle Harris as Jamie Lloyd, and reintroduces Doctor Loomis. You can stream it on Shudder.

16 Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan (1989)

As a devoted fan, I must confess that Rob Hedden’s “Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan” was brimming with ambition initially. However, during its production, certain edits were made which left many viewers labeling it as one of the worst in the series. Yet, paradoxically, it stands out as an unrivaled gem among late-night, slightly tipsy movie experiences. It’s a film that, despite its criticisms, never fails to entertain me and my fellow enthusiasts in our less sober moments.

What Makes Jason Takes Manhattan Such a Joyously Bonkers Ride?

Jason Takes Manhattan made for the eighth movie in a franchise born out of nothing more than the audience’s desire to see some bloodletting. It had been a long road but, even with an installment where Jason basically takes on Stephen King’s Carrie, it was mostly a case of repetition. And yet, even if much of it doesn’t even take place in Manhattan, the eighth Friday the 13th is a ludicrous ride with the single best boxing scene in cinema history (yes, even including Rocky). Stream on Max.

15 The Fly II (1989)

Was it truly essential for David Cronenberg’s take on The Fly to have a follow-up? Not in the least, as its storyline was well-rounded with fitting conclusions for each character. However, among unnecessary sequels, The Fly II manages to be appropriately unsettling, viscous, and boasts impressive practical creature effects, particularly in the third act.

Why Was It a Worthy Continuation?

Before that monstrous plot takes over, viewers can enjoy the charming dynamic between Eric Stoltz and Daphne Zuniga. Additionally, a slickly malevolent antagonist graces the screen, devoid of any moral compass. While this movie titled “Son of the Fly ” doesn’t compare to Cronenberg’s classic, it is far from the worst late-night viewing options. Stream on Apple TV+.

14 Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre III (1990)

It’s surprising that “Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre III” earned the least among all Texas Chainsaw films released before it, despite an impressive teaser trailer. This could be due to New Line Cinema’s struggles with the MPAA to avoid an X rating or perhaps audience fatigue with slasher movies. Even with a wide release in 1,107 theaters, “Leatherface” fell short of making an impact.

What Makes It Underrated?

As a longtime fan of horror films and someone who has seen their fair share of slasher movies, I can confidently say that “Leatherface” on Apple TV+ is a must-watch for any horror enthusiast. This film, packed with an authentic Texas ambiance, a steady pace, and a young Viggo Mortensen delivering a memorable performance as a Sawyer clan member, offers a unique take on the iconic franchise.

13 Gremlins 2: The New Batch (1990)

As a gamer, I’d say this: “The original Gremlins had this unique blend of classic Spielberg charm and chilling horror vibes. But when it comes to Gremlins 2: The New Batch, they traded the horror for more Looney Tunes-style shenanigans, but kept the rest of the recipe intact.”

What Makes Dante’s Sequel a Treat?

Labeling “Gremlins 2: The New Batch” as a horror film is misleading; the original was indeed scary, but this sequel is more of an absurd comedy. Despite its struggle at the box office due to this dramatic shift in genre, fans may have felt disappointed initially, but time has been favorable to “Gremlins 2.” As more predictable sequels based on popular IPs flood the market, a film like “The New Batch” that takes risks and aims high becomes increasingly valuable. Stream it on Apple TV+.

12 The Exorcist III (1990)

William Friedkin, who wrote both The Exorcist and its screenplay, took charge when it was time to adapt Legion. There are two versions of The Exorcist III, and both are remarkably nearly as chilling as the initial movie. Unfortunately, this cannot be said about Exorcist II: The Heretic.

What Makes The Exorcist III the Only Worthy Exorcist Sequel?

In a fresh take, The Exorcist III leans more towards a traditional crime investigation than the initial movie. Given that the central enigma revolves around a patient escaping from a psychiatric hospital to carry out gruesome murders, this investigation is quite intriguing. Notably, George C. Scott and Brad Dourif deliver outstanding performances, with Dourif particularly shining brighter in the director’s cut version. Consequently, The Exorcist III stands among the top horror films from the early ’90s. You can stream it on Peacock.

11 Predator 2 (1990)

1990 saw the release of Stephen Hopkins’ often overlooked horror sequel, Predator 2, which can hold its own against the original classic in terms of genre-blending, if not surpassing it. Coming a year after his American film debut with A Nightmare on Elm Street 5: The Dream Child, Predator 2 was far superior to the criticism that the latter deserved. Unlike The Dream Child, which unfortunately earned much of its negative reception, Predator 2 deliberately distinguishes itself from McTiernan’s original. Instead of treading water like its predecessor, Predator 2 goes out of its way to establish its unique identity in the Predator series.

What Makes Predator 2 Underrated?

Hopkins’ film is objectively inferior to McTiernan’s classic. But considering they couldn’t do the jungle thing again without it seeming rote, putting the Yautja in the middle of a gangland war was an interesting alternative. The scare factor is decreased with the creature being in such a densely populated area, but Predator is just as much an action IP as it is a horror one. Predator 2 works, besides Adam Baldwin’s wooden performance. Stream on Hulu.

10 Child’s Play 3 (1991)

Child’s Play 3 might leave you scratching your head about certain plot points (like why the initial scene is set in Good Guy headquarters and what purpose it serves), but it’s an enjoyable watch. Following the powerful duo of Child’s Play and Child’s Play 2, it was clear that the relationship between Chucky and Andy Barclay was a hit, so how could they keep things fresh?

How Did Child’s Play 3 Switch Things Up, and Did It Truly Fail?

In response to the events in Child’s Play 3, the solution was to enroll him in a military institution. Although this brings up several puzzling points (such as why there would be live ammunition stored at such an establishment), it provides an intriguing shift in setting. Now streaming on Apple TV+.

9 Hellraiser III: Hell on Earth (1992)

After immersing myself in the twisted realms of “Hellraiser” and “Hellbound: Hellraiser II”, I felt that the IP was ready for a change. Both seemed to be interconnected chapters rather than standalone stories, with an undeniable focus on the character Kirsty Cotton, portrayed by Ashley Laurence. However, the original film still stands strong as a captivating piece in its own right.

Is Watching Hellraiser III Actually Hell on Earth?

The movie “Hellraiser III: Hell on Earth” switches out Kirsty for a reporter and a seedy nightclub owner, while increasing the presence of Pinhead. It delves deeply into the demon’s past, exploring his transition from man to demon. In essence, it shows us more about his human days. Watch now on Paramount+.

8 Alien³ (1992)

The movie “Alien³” may have nearly dissuaded director David Fincher from pursuing a career in Hollywood, but there are many aspects that make it effective, particularly the Assembly Cut version. Additionally, it’s widely recognized for having the best ending among all films in the series. At the very least, its poignant final moments outshine any other “Alien” film in emotional impact.

Is It Truly That Weak a Sequel?

Is the third film as powerfully intense as Alien or Aliens? No, it isn’t. However, it’s far from being a weak or poor film. In fact, Alien: Resurrection, with its lacking emotional depth and destructive treatment of Ellen Ripley, is what I would consider to be the inferior one. Despite this, the third film attempts to build tension effectively, although the CGI Xeno running across ceilings can sometimes interfere with that. Overall, it’s worth a watch on Hulu.

7 Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday (1993)

1993’s “Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday” signified the resumption of Jason Voorhees’ on-screen appearances after a brief break, but unfortunately, it fared even worse financially than “Jason Takes Manhattan.” To be fair, Adam Marcus’ movie took an exceptionally strange approach to revitalize the series. However, attempting something daring in storytelling is preferable to a space-based plot, as there are certainly more disappointing directions to go. Additionally, this film boasts impressive practical effects, which unfortunately cannot be said for its successor, “Jason X.”

Why Does Shooting for the Fences Work?

As a longtime fan of the Friday the 13th franchise, I must admit that Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday stands out as a unique and intriguing entry in the series. Unlike any other Friday the 13th film before it, this installment introduces body-swapping and emphasizes the importance of the Voorhees bloodline – elements that were never previously hinted at in the franchise. The visual style of Jason Goes to Hell feels reminiscent of the Paramount years, adding a fresh twist to the familiar horror formula.

6 Return of the Living Dead III (1993)

The “Return of the Living Dead” series stands out as an unconventional gem in the horror genre. The original film cleverly paid homage to George A. Romero’s zombie saga while still carving its unique niche within the franchise. As for the second installment, it continued the same formula. However, “Return of the Living Dead III” takes a fresh and even more outrageous approach.

What Makes It an Underrated Entry?

As a longtime horror enthusiast with a penchant for obscure B-movies and cult classics, I can confidently say that “Return of the Living Dead III” is a hidden gem in the zombie genre. This film, if you haven’t guessed from its title, is not your typical zombie flick – it takes a sharp turn away from the established formula and embraces its quirks with gusto.

2024-08-03 04:32