Fans Originally Protested When Michael Keaton Was Cast As Batman. Why Tim Burton Says It Was The Right Move Anyway

Fans Originally Protested When Michael Keaton Was Cast As Batman. Why Tim Burton Says It Was The Right Move Anyway

As a gamer with a heart full of nostalgia and a mind brimming with memories of iconic movie moments, I can’t help but marvel at the transformative power of casting decisions. The news that Michael Keaton would don the cape and cowl was, to say the least, met with skepticism back in the day when I was just discovering the dark, brooding world of Gotham City. The man known for his comedic roles and spooky charm in “Beetlejuice” seemed an unlikely choice to play the caped crusader.


When a well-known figure from another form of entertainment moves to the silver screen, one question every enthusiast ponders is the casting decision. Who will be brought to life as the legendary character? It’s not unusual for fans to feel apprehensive about the selection to portray both heroes and villains, and this has been a recurring issue for many years, going back to when Michael Keaton was initially cast as Batman.

When it became known that Michael Keaton would star as the main character in Tim Burton’s Batman, many fans were taken aback due to Keaton’s reputation for smaller comedies at the time. In fact, he had previously donned the role in Burton’s Beetlejuice. Today, Keaton is widely regarded as one of the best live-action Batmen, and Tim Burton recently shared with GQ why he chose Keaton for the part back in the ’80s. He stated…

I adore Michael due to the unique vitality he possesses. This is the reason behind my desire for him to join the cast of Batman. His gaze conveys a sense of intelligence, danger, madness, and everything else simultaneously.

Michael Keaton’s portrayal of Batman was intelligent, intimidating, and unpredictable – qualities that perfectly fit the character. Fans were impressed, and the film, released in 1989, turned out to be the highest-grossing movie of that year. This iconic Batman movie not only kickstarted a franchise but also paved the way for today’s comic book-centric cinema landscape. It’s amazing to think back on a time when people were unsure about Keaton in the role.

But that was very true. It’s been reported that Warner Bros. received more than 50,000 letters from fans protesting Keaton’s casting. The internet wasn’t a thing then but one can imagine the message boards and social media posts that would have been out there claiming what a bad decision this was. If 50,000 people cared enough to write a letter in the ‘80s there were likely many more people with similar feelings who didn’t publicly voice their displeasure. It’s no wonder even Keaton wasn’t so sure about playing Batman.

Keaton wasn’t the only actor who faced skepticism when given a role in a comic book movie. For instance, Heath Ledger and Jared Leto faced backlash when they were chosen to portray The Joker in different DC films. Similarly, director Jon Favreau had to advocate for Robert Downey Jr.’s casting as Iron Man in the initial Marvel Cinematic Universe film.

Not every controversial casting decision becomes as iconic as Michael Keaton’s Batman, but Tim Burton clearly knew exactly what he was doing. When Keaton returned to the role in The Flash, his role was the most popular, and the most praised, part of that movie. After returning to the role of Batman, Keaton, and Burton are now returning to their original collaboration. Beetlejuice Beetlejuice is set for release next month.

Read More

2024-08-22 19:07