Battlefield Earth Only Has 3% on Rotten Tomatoes but Deserves a Second Look

Battlefield Earth Only Has 3% on Rotten Tomatoes but Deserves a Second Look

As a movie critic who has spent countless hours watching films spanning from the silent era to the modern age, I must say that my experiences have been as diverse as the reels themselves. Yet, there are certain movies that leave an indelible mark on me, not necessarily for their cinematic brilliance but for their sheer audacity and unapologetic campiness. One such film that falls squarely into this category is Battlefield Earth.


Occasionally, a movie with grand aspirations can receive unfavorable responses, harsh criticisms, and even be labeled as one of the worst films ever produced. This was the unfortunate fate that befell Battlefield Earth, which premiered in 2000. For its lead actor, John Travolta, a labor of love in the realm of science fiction, this project represented an adaptation of L. Ron Hubbard’s novel he had been eager to bring to life for quite some time. However, it is now commonly viewed as one of the most significant flops in film history.

Alongside The Room, Manos: The Hands of Fate, Birdemic, and Troll 2, Battlefield Earth is frequently mentioned as one of the lowest quality films, with a dismal rating of only 3% on Rotten Tomatoes. Despite its poor reputation, it remains a subject of conversation and can be found on streaming platforms like Tubi and Prime Video. In reality, Battlefield Earth suffered from being released at a time when viewers expected more in terms of plot development and world-building.

The Paranoia of Y2K and High Expectations

Battlefield Earth Only Has 3% on Rotten Tomatoes but Deserves a Second Look

In 2000, as people worldwide let out a collective sigh after the supposedly anxiety-inducing Y2K bug turned out to be less catastrophic than feared, the film “Battlefield Earth” was released. This movie, which tells the story of a dystopian future where humans are enslaved by an alien race called the Psychlos, now seems like it could be a satire on our excessive reliance on technology.

By the year 2000, there was a fresh benchmark for what viewers desired and anticipated in a sci-fi movie, with the Star Trek and Star Wars series setting the bar high in terms of imaginative universes and intricate characters. In that very year, Battlefield Earth found itself going head-to-head against blockbusters like X-Men, Unbreakable, and Titan A.E., all of which were more favorably received. However, Battlefield Earth was quite distinct from the direction that sci-fi had taken by then, offering a glimpse of a bygone era in the genre.

The early days of science fiction weren’t overly complicated because space exploration hadn’t yet taken place. Consequently, the initial creations from the pioneers of this genre were far from dramatic or grandiose. Movies like Forbidden Planet, The Blob, Planet of the Vampires, and even the old serials of Flash Gordon and Buck Rogers had a unique, almost kitschy appeal that fostered an environment for unbridled creativity in stories involving monsters, aliens, planets, and robots.

Presentation and Performance That’s Anything But Subtle

Battlefield Earth Only Has 3% on Rotten Tomatoes but Deserves a Second Look

A frequent comment on the movie “Battlefield Earth” is the overly dramatic acting of several cast members, but this very quality makes the film unique and enjoyable for many viewers. The performance of John Travolta as the villainous alien leader Terl is so exaggerated that it becomes a continuous source of amusement. One reason why fans find it charming is because Travolta doesn’t try to hide his voice, allowing us to easily recognize him. His enthusiastic portrayal in “Battlefield Earth” offers a hilarious departure from his earlier roles in films like “Saturday Night Fever“, “Staying Alive“, “Grease“, and even “Welcome Back Kotter“.

Critics also point out that the visual style of Battlefield Earth might be an issue due to its heavy use of the Dutch angle camera technique. This method gives everything a slanted appearance, which could potentially be disconcerting for some viewers. However, it’s important to note that this technique was also used in the classic Batman series, particularly when Adam West’s character appeared on screen in the villain’s lair. In the context of , the recurring use of the Dutch angle contributes to its overall campy and absurd atmosphere, making it an intentional choice rather than a distraction.

Being Entertained and the Suspension of Disbelief

Battlefield Earth Only Has 3% on Rotten Tomatoes but Deserves a Second Look

Although Battlefield Earth may not deliver the intense drama or classic space opera experience that many science fiction enthusiasts are used to, it certainly has an undeniable knack for providing entertainment. Be it John Travolta’s flamboyant and excessive acting style, the unique Dutch angle presentation of the movie’s content, or the nostalgic camp feel reminiscent of B-grade movies from the drive-in era, Battlefield Earth is worth acknowledging as a fun, lighthearted adventure that should not be taken too seriously.

In Tim Burton’s biopic about Ed Wood, the main character and unconventional director famously remarks, “What do you know? Aren’t you familiar with the concept of suspending disbelief?” Imperfect films are part of cinema’s grandeur. The most memorable movies often feature puzzling predicaments that remain unsolved, unexplained plot inconsistencies, and items that challenge our understanding of logic and reason. Films are intended to entertain, and by suspending disbelief, Battlefield Earth offers a delightful, cheesy, and over-the-top experience.

Stream Battlefield Earth on Tubi.

Read More

2024-09-15 06:01