The Truth About Batman And The Joker’s Relationship Explained

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

As a longtime fan and observer of the dynamic duo that is Batman and the Joker, I can’t help but be captivated by their complex and intriguing relationship. Having spent countless hours immersed in their stories, I find myself pondering what would become of these two iconic figures should they ever part ways.


Although Batman and Robin have always been called the Dynamic Duo, the relationship between Batman and his biggest nemesis, the Joker, is arguably way more dynamic. Batman and the Joker have been clashing for decades (the pair celebrated their 80th anniversary in 2020), and their relationship is … complicated, to say the least. There’s not exactly a single, definitive story behind their dynamic (the Joker prefers it to be multiple-choice), but there are definitely some common threads in every Batman and Joker story that define their relationship.

In this article, we delve into the intricacies of the relationship between the Caped Crusader and his longtime adversary, the Clown Prince of Crime. We explore the reasons behind Batman’s unwavering policy against killing the Joker, the Joker’s inexplicable commitment to keeping Batman’s identity hidden, and the complex dynamics that fuel their seemingly endless conflict. So, let’s dive deep into the fascinating world of these two iconic characters who are bound by a unique codependency.

Batman may have created the Joker

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

It’s plausible that Batman played a role in the Joker’s descent into madness and darkness, as per the storyline presented in “Batman: The Killing Joke.” If you accept this portrayal, it was during their pursuit that the Joker fell into the chemical vat that ultimately transformed him.

In a symbolic sense, it’s possible that Batman’s vigilante methods might have unwittingly fostered the emergence of the Joker. By the end of “Batman Begins,” Jim Gordon (played by Gary Oldman) cautions Batman (Christian Bale) about his decision to don the cape and cowl, suggesting it could exacerbate Gotham’s criminal activities. In Gordon’s words, “When we resort to using semi-automatics, they upgrade to automatics.” He continues, “As our protection improves with kevlar, they find armor-piercing rounds.” Furthermore, Gordon notes that once Batman started patrolling in costume, a new figure began mirroring his dramatic approach – the Joker.

Absolutely, it’s a point often debated among fans that the Joker could have emerged without Batman. The 2019 film “Joker” itself showcases this, as Arthur Fleck transforms into the Joker in a world where Batman doesn’t yet exist. If it wasn’t the vat, it could have been someone else – perhaps the police or the mob. In that hypothetical situation, the Joker would likely view that individual as his arch-nemesis instead.

Batman could never kill the Joker

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

Regardless of how often the Joker manages to flee Arkham Asylum, Batman will never resort to taking the Joker’s life. In fact, on numerous occasions, Batman has intervened to preserve the Joker’s existence. This is a principle that Batman strictly adheres to, and it sets him apart from the lawbreakers he apprehends. Batman understands that succumbing to the Joker’s ways would grant his arch-nemesis the victory. More critically, Batman fears the consequences of violating this “one rule.” He believes that this rule is the only factor preventing him from releasing his darker nature.

In the gripping comic “Scars” from “Batman Noir: Eduardo Risso”, I, as a fan, find an intriguing perspective on why Batman consistently spares the Joker’s life. He poses, “Ever wondered what true power is?” It’s not about taking a life, but preserving it. It’s the moment you gaze into someone’s eyes and witness that fleeting spark of understanding, that instant they recognize something they’ll never forget… they owe you.” This could imply that Batman derives satisfaction from showing mercy—or it might suggest he finds a chilling thrill in knowing that the Joker is indebted to him for his life.

As a dedicated gamer, I can’t help but point out the key factor behind Batman’s unyielding resolve not to take the life of the Joker: it’s all about preserving the narrative. The Joker is a fan favorite, and he boosts comic sales like no other. Why on earth would DC Comics toss that golden goose?

Batman and the Joker need each other

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

Despite not being hesitant about committing mass murder, the Joker in “The Dark Knight,” portrayed by Heath Ledger, has no desire to kill Batman himself. Instead, everything he does is aimed at provoking Batman because with Batman out of the picture, their game would end. There’s no other character strong and broken enough to serve as his adversary.

Although he may not openly acknowledge it, Batman also relies on the Joker. The Joker serves as a continual reminder for Batman about why he fights and represents a boundary that Batman must not cross. Moreover, Batman employs the Joker to justify his vigilante actions, since without him, he wouldn’t know how to spend his time. To illustrate, in “Batman: The Dark Knight Returns,” after retiring, Batman indulges in competitive car racing and watching “The Mark of Zorro,” but nothing compares to the thrill of crime-fighting. As Robert Pattinson, who played Batman in “The Batman,” explained during an interview with GQ, for Batman, fighting crime is almost like a powerful addiction, and without the Joker, he could no longer satisfy this craving.

In the story “Batman: The Clown at Midnight,” the Joker expresses a profound truth: “If you try to eliminate me, you’ll end up like me. On the other hand, I can’t eradicate you because you’re the only person who can match my pace. Isn’t it ironic?

The Joker is infatuated with Batman

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

Regardless of the specific narrative, it is hard to ignore the clear signs that suggest the Joker harbors feelings beyond mere villainy towards Batman. Throughout his comic book appearances, the Joker has been portrayed as having queer tendencies and often makes suggestive comments during their interactions. Additionally, in the movie “The Dark Knight,” the Joker’s statement “you complete me” from “Jerry Maguire” implies a deep, romantic attachment.

In the video game “Batman: The Telltale Series,” the villain, the Joker, confesses his folly for underestimating Batman. On the other hand, in “Catwoman Vol. 3: Death of the Family,” Catwoman speculates that the Joker harbors deep affection for Batman, which the Joker himself admits. Interestingly, Harley Quinn understands on multiple occasions why the Joker never reciprocates her affections: it’s because Batman is the one whom the Joker truly loves.

Interestingly, the family-friendly film “The Lego Batman Movie” subtly explores a dynamic that hints at an unspoken affection between characters. Although never explicitly stated, the film suggests that The Joker (played by Zach Galifianakis) may harbor feelings for Batman (Will Arnett). This is suggested through various cues such as Joker’s jealousy towards Superman and his application of lipstick before speaking with Batman. The final exchange between the two characters, where they both say “I hate you,” implies a deeper emotion that goes beyond simple hatred.

Batman and the Joker have sometimes worked together

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

It might surprise you how frequently Batman and the Joker find themselves working together, although their partnerships are rarely permanent. For example, in “Justice Leagues: The Justice League or Arkham,” Batman makes a choice to free several supervillains from Arkham Asylum, including his longtime friend the Joker, with the intention of recruiting them. Meanwhile, the video game “Batman: The Telltale Series” presents John Doe, who will eventually become the Joker, and Batman fighting together initially. However, their alliance in this series doesn’t last long. In “Batman: Europa,” these sworn enemies reluctantly form an alliance after they both contract the Colossus Virus and travel across Europe seeking a cure. The cure, as it turns out, is found within each other’s blood all along, a discovery that neither one takes kindly to.

In a striking turn of events, Batman and his longtime adversary, the Joker, join forces in the game “Batman: Arkham City”. This time, it’s a lethal virus that binds them – when the Joker contracts Titan Disease and infects Batman, the Dark Knight is compelled to find a cure for them both. Unfortunately, he discovers the antidote too late to save the Joker. The fact that Batman carries the lifeless body of his foe mirrors his earlier grief-stricken moment when he carried Robin’s body in “Batman: A Death in the Family”.

The Joker hates Robin

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

The Joker has an intense dislike for Robin that might surpass his hatred towards Batman. Intriguingly, he’s been reported to fire at robins sitting on fences due to their resemblance to Batman’s partner, Robin.

As a devoted fan, there’s no moment quite like “Batman: A Death in the Family” that encapsulates the Joker’s animosity towards Robin. The way he mercilessly kills Jason Todd is chilling. Later on, when Jason returns from the dead and dons the Red Hood to fight crime, the Joker can barely contain his rage. It’s not just because the Joker once wore the mantle of the Red Hood himself; it’s also because he had hoped to break Robin (and by extension, Batman) through torture. But instead, the Red Hood stands as a testament that the Joker’s efforts were in vain, a living, breathing reminder of his failure.

Among all the Robins, it seems Tim Drake is the one he dislikes the most, as suggested in “Robin” #85. In this issue, the Joker voices his annoyance to his therapist about the different boys who have taken on the Robin role, particularly emphasizing that Tim is unbearable. What irks the Joker is that Tim can outsmart him without any assistance from Batman, which means less time for the Joker to engage in battles with Batman. Given the Joker’s obsession with confronting Batman, having a Robin around limits his opportunities to torment Batman and manipulate his psyche since the presence of Robin prevents Batman from being fully isolated. The Joker resents any Robin due to this reason, as long as Batman has a partner, it makes it difficult for the Joker to focus on Batman exclusively.

Batman and the Joker are more alike than you think

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

In a conversation with CBR, renowned comic book writer Alan Moore, creator of the timeless graphic novel “Batman: The Killing Joke,” expressed that Batman and the Joker share striking similarities, likening them to mirror reflections. Upon closer examination, this comparison certainly holds merit.

The reason why Batman and the Joker are able to anticipate each other’s moves so often is because they think so much alike. Both Batman and the Joker’s romantic relationships are in shambles as well for the exact same reason. Both Catwoman and Harley realize the same thing about their lovers – Batman never gives Catwoman his full attention because he can’t stop thinking about the Joker, and the same goes for the Joker and Harley. Even their mannerisms are identical. If you pay close attention to the party scene from “The Dark Knight,” both Batman and the Joker dump their drinks in the same way.

As a gamer, I can’t help but notice how deeply affected both characters are by a life-altering tragedy. The Joker hints that his madness stems from a single terrible day, implying that anyone, even the most sane among us, could be pushed to the edge given similar circumstances. In “Batman: The Killing Joke,” he suggests that Batman’s own ‘one bad day’ (the loss of his parents) might have tipped him into becoming a vigilante. By the end of the comic, where we see both characters sharing a laugh at the same joke, it becomes clear that the line separating Batman and the Joker is fragile at best.

Does the Joker know Batman’s secret identity?

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

Could it be that among various characters, the Joker is one who might have uncovered Batman’s hidden identity? The “Death of the Family” storyline suggests this strongly as the Joker appears to know Batman intimately, such as breaking into Wayne Manor and attacking Alfred, an action that would only hurt Batman if he knew Bruce Wayne was his alter ego. Furthermore, Batman suspects that the Joker may have known his identity since their very first encounter. This is supported by Batman’s recollection of finding a joker playing card in the Batcave after their initial fight, which could only have been planted by the Joker if he had access to Wayne Manor. A coincidence seems highly unlikely in this case.

As a devoted fan, I ponder if the most profound hint lies concealed within the subconscious of the Joker himself, as portrayed in “Knight Terrors: The Joker.” In this chilling tale, the Joker finds himself ensnared in a horrifying dreamscape where Batman meets his demise and the Joker is left without an adversary. Within this dreadful nightmare, the Joker stores Batman’s lifeless body within his closet, yet somehow Bruce Wayne survives, as the Joker perceives him and the Dark Knight as two distinct entities.

As a fervent admirer, I can’t help but ponder if perhaps the Joker is solely fixated on Batman’s disguise, implying that he might be aware of Bruce Wayne’s hidden persona. Yet, it could also be that the Joker chooses to remain oblivious to this knowledge.

The Joker doesn’t want to expose Batman’s secret identity

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

Over the course of comic book lore, Batman has taken some rather unusual measures to preserve his anonymity. What might seem even more peculiar, though, is that The Joker has consistently attempted to safeguard Batman’s true identity.

It’s apparent that the Joker prefers not to discover who lies behind the mask. In the game “Batman: Arkham City,” for example, he prevents Harley Quinn from revealing Batman’s identity by saying, “Let’s not ruin the amusement.” Conversely, in the series “Harley Quinn,” Scarecrow (Rahul Kohli) removes Batman’s mask hoping to impress the Joker (Alan Tudyk). However, this revelation enrages the Joker and plunges him into despair, as he recognizes that his bond with Batman will never remain a secret. “A significant part of our relationship was the intrigue!” he exclaims.

Regardless of his own knowledge about Batman’s real identity, the Joker consistently works to keep it hidden from the public. In various instances like an episode of “The Batman” animated series and in “Batman: Three Jokers” #3, the Joker has gone to great lengths to protect this secret. For example, he used laughing gas to silence supervillains who threatened to reveal Batman’s identity. Furthermore, one version of the Joker even declared that he knows Batman’s true identity and would take it with him to his grave instead of exposing it. The essence of the Joker’s fascination with Batman lies in the mystery of his anonymity; the Joker believes that Batman is more intriguing when his true identity remains unknown.

The Joker is willing to die to break Batman

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

In a stark contrast, though Batman refuses to take the Joker’s life, the Joker yearns for Batman to break his rule – a willingness that could cost him dearly. To illustrate this dynamic, consider the memorable scene from “The Dark Knight” where Batman and the Joker engage in a perilous game of bluff on motorcycles. As Batman rushes towards the Joker, the Joker defiantly stands still, challenging Batman to go beyond his moral boundaries. The Joker whispers urgently, “I want you to do it, I want you to do it.” In the end, Batman fails to comply, leaving the Joker disheartened.

In the comic “Batman: The Dark Knight Returns,” the Joker is unable to make Batman kill him, so instead he devises an alternative plan. Realizing that Batman will not take his life, the Joker manipulates the situation by breaking his own neck, which effectively frames Batman for murder and removes any decision from Batman’s hands. This act isn’t the first or last time the Joker dies in the comics, but it is particularly chilling because it underscores the fact that even in death, the Joker can come out on top.

What would Batman and the Joker do without each other?

The Truth About Batman And The Joker's Relationship Explained

One way to rephrase the given text in a natural and easy-to-read manner could be: Various narratives have speculated about what would happen if Batman or the Joker were absent from each other’s lives. For example, following the death of the Joker in the game “Batman: Arkham City,” its successor “Batman: Arkham Knight” depicts how Batman continues to grapple with the ghostly appearances of his arch-nemesis. However, it is only when Batman confines the Joker within his own mind that he manages to break free from the villain’s grip.

In essence, the character of Joker is essentially void without Batman as a foil. This is illustrated in the comic “Killing the Batman” from “The Joker 80th Anniversary 100-Page Super Spectacular”, where Joker attends Batman’s funeral and realizes his mistake, asking himself, “What have I done? And what on earth do I do now?” Similarly, in the story “Knight Terrors: The Joker”, Batman dies in an anticlimactic manner, and Joker is left without satisfaction since he can’t claim credit for it. As a result, the Clown Prince of Crime finds himself stuck in a mundane job and seeking a new purpose in life. However, his obsession with Batman persists, even keeping Batman’s decaying corpse in his closet.

“Batman: Finding Normality

Read More

2024-09-22 14:30