The Best Underrated TV Series Based on True Stories

The Best Underrated TV Series Based on True Stories

As a history enthusiast and film critic with a soft spot for compelling stories that delve into the human condition, I find myself captivated by these three underrated series.


Some TV executives argue that audiences gravitate towards screens to escape into fantastical realms detached from everyday life. While there’s certainly a market for such stories, it seems an increasing number of viewers are drawn to series and films grounded in reality. These programs may not always mirror our own experiences, but knowing they were based on true events adds an unexpected depth to the viewing experience.

14 A Friend of the Family (2022)

The series titled “A Friend of the Family” revolves around the Broberg household. In the ’70s, the Brobergs appeared as an ordinary family, with parents Bob and Gail, along with their three offspring. A local man named Robert Berchtold gradually becomes a part of this family’s life. He appreciates Bob, admires the bond between the Brobergs, and manages to form a connection with the children. However, his affinity for them might have been a tad excessive. As Bob starts noticing some concerning signs in Robert’s actions, an unthinkable event occurs – their daughter is kidnapped. Shockingly, this isn’t the only time it happens.

Can’t Trust Anyone

As a movie critic, I must confess that “A Friend of the Family” left me uneasy in numerous aspects. The recurring abductions of Jan are undeniably chilling, but it’s the intricate relationship between Berchtold and the family that truly sends shivers down one’s spine. The film masterfully captures the essence of the ’70s, a time when trust seemed more abundant among people. For those who wish to delve deeper into this chilling tale, I recommend exploring the numerous documentaries based on this case, as well as the book penned by Jan’s mother, which offers additional insights.

13 Tokyo Vice (2024)

In Tokyo Vice, you’ll find gripping fight sequences involving weapons, along with intense dialogues between underworld figures, but don’t let that fool you – this isn’t a work of fiction. Instead, it’s based on the true experiences of Jake Adelstein, an American journalist who joined a Tokyo newspaper as their first foreign correspondent in 1999. Eager to delve into a recent murder case, he was instructed by his editor not to pursue it. However, his friendship with detective Jin Miyamoto opened the door to the treacherous world of the yakuza, Japan’s organized crime network. As Adelstein navigates his new role and the enigmatic deaths that are being kept under wraps, he finds himself caught between his journalistic ambitions and the secrets he must uncover.

Living in an Action Movie

Adelstein has made quite a journey, starting from being advised against reporting these crimes to eventually publishing a book and creating an HBO Max series. The stories he tells about his time in Tokyo have sparked controversy, with some questioning whether he exaggerated or outright fabricated certain incidents. Yet, the debate only fuels the interest when watching the show. For two seasons, Ansel Elgort captivated audiences as the main character.

12 The Dropout (2022)

As a movie enthusiast, I found myself captivated by the gripping tale unfolding in “The Dropout.” This film delves into the enigmatic journey of Elizabeth Holmes, a charismatic visionary who revolutionized the biotech industry with her company Theranos. At first glance, she appeared as an enterprising, intellectually gifted young woman, determined to reshape healthcare for the better.

Drive Turned Dangerous

In a blend of humor, emotion, and suspense, “The Dropout” offers an engaging viewing experience. Amanda Seyfriend delivers a compelling portrayal of Holmes, transforming her from a zealous college student into the figure now infamous for ambition and ethical decay. However, the series does not portray her as a one-dimensional villain. Instead, it aims to humanize Holmes and shed light on the challenges she encountered, all while avoiding any justification for her later actions. Despite its critical success, garnering numerous nominations, this true story was underappreciated in terms of the acclaim it deserved due to its exceptional performances.

11 Under the Banner of Heaven (2022)

In the 1980s, nestled in Utah, the inhabitants of the made-up city of East Rockwell felt invulnerable to harm. However, their tranquility was shattered when a woman named Brenda and her child were brutally slain. Brenda was a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS). Detective Jeb Pyre, also an LDS adherent, found himself inexorably drawn to this case due to his personal connection. Initially, Pyre assumed the husband was the culprit, but his probe compelled him to reconsider this assumption and grapple with both the case and his religious convictions.

A Man Questioning Everything

The account of Brenda Lafferty, her daughter Erica, and Jeb Pyre initially gained prominence through a book authored by Jon Krakauer, known for crafting other well-received nonfiction works. “Under the Banner of Heaven” delves into the complexities of crime and religion, exploring them individually and their alarming convergence points. Many spectators admired a subtler representation of Mormonism, as depicted in Pyre’s and other characters’ (possibly linked to the murders) portrayals. Garfield delivered one of his finest performances by portraying this man who was compelled to reassess his moral compass.

10 George & Tammy (2022)

The Best Underrated TV Series Based on True StoriesThe Best Underrated TV Series Based on True StoriesThe Best Underrated TV Series Based on True Stories

George Jones and Tammy Wynette were legendary figures in the realm of country music, commanding the charts throughout the ’60s and ’70s. A biographical drama miniseries titled George & Tammy delves into their professional journeys and personal lives. The first episode unfolds prior to their acquaintance, as George battles alcoholism and Tammy is married to someone else. Their lives took a dramatic turn when Tammy witnessed George’s performance at the Grand Ole Opry, marking the beginning of a new chapter in country music lore.

A Compelling Look into the Lives of Two Legends

For those not acquainted with the genuine tale of Jones and Wynette, this might seem like the beginning of a heartwarming love story. However, it’s important to note that while there is beauty in parts of their relationship, it was also filled with tension and conflict from the very beginning. Each played a pivotal role in shaping the other’s life – for better and for worse. The musical aspects certainly add an interesting layer, but it’s the off-stage moments that will leave a lasting impression on viewers.

9 Alias Grace (2017)

Alias Grace is a limited TV series adapted from Margaret Atwood’s novel. The plot centers around a string of murders dating back to the 1800s. Thomas Kinnear, along with his housekeeper Nancy, are discovered murdered on their property. The main suspects are Grace Marks, an Irish immigrant servant, and James McDermott. In the contemporary timeline, McDermott has already been executed, while Grace awaits her trial. However, she recounts her version of events to a psychiatrist in this narrative that jumps between two time periods.

What is the Truth?

Without a doubt, the most recognized adaptation of Atwood is “The Handmaid’s Tale.” Although “The Handmaid’s Tale” rightfully receives all its praise, some fans feel that “Alias Grace” deserved a bit more attention too. Given its format as a miniseries, it offers a self-contained storyline that concludes neatly. However, it doesn’t mean the ending is predictable; just like the real story, several questions about the truth in this case remain unanswered.

8 When They See Us (2019)

Ava DuVernay, the director known for movies like Selma, A Wrinkle in Time, and 13th, has created a drama titled When They See Us. This production focuses on the Central Park jogger case, involving five teenage boys who were falsely accused and later referred to as the Central Park Five. In 1989, a woman was viciously attacked and sexually assaulted while jogging in Central Park. That night saw numerous crimes occurring within the park’s limits, leading to the arrest of these five young men. They were eventually convicted but released years later when the real perpetrator confessed to the crime.

No Justice

The authentic tale of “When They See Us” resonated deeply throughout the nation. Not only did it stir emotions among everyday people, but also prominent figures voiced their indignation, some even suggesting harsh consequences for the Central Park Five. The series illustrates how these boys were pressured into confessing falsely, their prison terms, and the struggles they faced in readjusting to life outside.

7 A Very English Scandal (2018)

The Best Underrated TV Series Based on True StoriesThe Best Underrated TV Series Based on True StoriesThe Best Underrated TV Series Based on True Stories

As a dedicated cinephile, I found “A Very English Scandal” an intriguing exploration of the Thorpe affair, a scandal that rocked Britain’s political landscape in the not-so-distant past. At the heart of this drama was Jeremy Thorpe, a prominent figure in the Liberal Party who served as a leader in parliament. However, what many didn’t know was that for years, he carried on a clandestine relationship with a stablehand named Norman.

A Brighter Addition

This series, centered around a murder mystery, possesses a more playful atmosphere compared to many others on the list. In it, Hugh Grant portrays Thorpe, and Ben Whishaw takes on the role of Norman. The show is marked by its witty humor, with standout performances from both leading actors. If you’re not familiar with the Thorpe affair in the UK, this scandalous dramedy will undoubtedly captivate you as well.

6 Black Bird (2022)

In “Black Bird,” character James Keene (known as Jimmy) believed he was living the high life, with wealth and admirers who also feared him. However, everything came crashing down when the FBI stormed his residence and took him into custody. It turned out that Keene didn’t build his fortune through legal means. Instead, he now faces a potential ten-year prison sentence. But then, law enforcement presents an offer: they will release him and expunge his record if he agrees to cooperate in a way that would help them capture a bigger criminal.

A Tough Dilemma

In 2010, the actual individual known as Keene published an autobiography that revealed his personal journey. This book was not well-known until Apple TV cast Taron Egerton as Keene, which brought the story to a larger audience. While the portrayal of certain side characters and adversaries in the series can be heavy-handed and lack depth, the central question it presents is captivating enough to hold viewers’ interest. Could we risk danger for the chance at a new beginning? Viewers might find their own opinions shifting before and after watching Black Bird.

5 Landscapers (2021)

The Best Underrated TV Series Based on True StoriesThe Best Underrated TV Series Based on True StoriesThe Best Underrated TV Series Based on True Stories

A film titled “Landscapers” offers a humorous yet grim perspective on a long-unsolved murder case that finally came to light after over a decade. Living secluded lives, William and Patricia Wycherley raised few eyebrows for nearly fifteen years without any reported sightings. The chilling revelation was made when authorities investigated their home and uncovered the buried remains of the couple in the backyard. The shocking truth emerged that the murderers were none other than Susan Edward, the Wycherleys’ daughter, along with her spouse Christopher.

A Standout True Crime Series

Many unsolved true crime cases have lingered without resolution for a long period. What sets this case apart is that the murder went undetected for an unusually extended timeframe. The series “Landscapers” reveals every instance of fraud committed by the Edwards to attain a more affluent lifestyle. Olivia Colman and David Thewlis portray the murderous couple, expressing their intention to leave viewers feeling disoriented. Is it warranted for us to feel any empathy towards the Edwards?

4 The New Look (2024)

In the realm of cinema, I found myself immersed in “The New Look,” a captivating tale inspired by the real-life odyssey of two titans in the world of haute couture: Coco Chanel and Christian Dior. Amidst the grim backdrop of World War II’s occupation of Paris, these two visionaries found solace not in survival alone but in their unwavering passion for art and creativity. As one character poignantly put it, “Creation may not halt the bullets, but creation is our path forward.

During World War II, numerous aspects have already been extensively explored. However, for those intrigued by this period, it might be questioned if there are still unexplored perspectives. The New Look demonstrates that indeed, fresh angles do exist. Although discussing fashion during wartime might seem trivial, be assured that much deeper insights await. It’s captivating to unravel how even dressmaking was perceived as a possible threat by the Nazis and it’s intriguing to learn about how renowned brands navigated opposition during this time.

3 We Were the Lucky Ones (2024)

“We Were the Lucky Ones” presents another captivating account set during World War II. The narrative is inspired by a real-life account penned by a woman, who chronicles her family’s past in a book. The Kurcs are a Jewish family residing in a modest Polish town named Radom. Despite growing anti-Semitism fueled by Nazi presence, they assume their town remains untouched by Hitler’s plans. However, the arrival of soldiers shatters their peace, leading to a fragmentation of this once tightly-knit family. As survival becomes crucial, they are forced to scatter – concealing themselves in Radom, fleeing to various Polish cities, or leaving Poland entirely.

Why It’s Great

Despite sharing some similarities with other World War II narratives, what sets “We Were the Lucky Ones” apart is its captivating performances and characters. Actress Joey King, portraying one of the main Kurc family members, has truly evolved since her days in “The Kissing Booth.” The series cleverly unfolds across two timelines – before and after the war – each maintaining a high level of tension. It seems that many might have dismissed it as “just another WWII story,” but for those who did, they are missing out on a truly compelling viewing experience.

2 Candy (2022)

In Wylie, Texas during the 1980s, Candy Montgomery was known as an ordinary housewife – quiet, religious, well-mannered, and seemingly unremarkable. However, beneath this facade may have lurked a more complex individual. Candy, who appears to be the namesake of the sweet treat, was close friends with her neighbor Betty Gore and her husband Allan. The bond between Candy and Allan deepened beyond friendship, but their relationship remained hidden from most. The shocking discovery of Betty’s brutal murder with an axe left many questioning if there were darker aspects to Candy’s character that went unnoticed.

Closing In on a Rotted Woman

As a movie enthusiast, I find it essential to capture the tight-knit atmosphere of small towns when portraying brutal crimes that unfold within them. The film “Candy” achieves this masterfully, instilling a sense of confinement in its viewers. In Wylie, people know each other intimately, but the events surrounding Candy prove that appearances can be deceiving. In this town, you might think you know everyone, but as the story unfolds, it becomes painfully clear that no one truly knows anyone at all.

In the show “Candy,” Jessica Biel takes on the lead role, with her husband Justin Timberlake making appearances as a sheriff in multiple episodes. However, despite these high-profile stars, the series didn’t receive much attention, possibly because it was competing against another miniseries called “Love & Death” featuring Elizabeth Olsen and Jesse Plemmons, both of whom are also from Montgomery. This competition may have contributed to the relatively low profile of “Candy.

1 Five Days at Memorial (2022)

The Best Underrated TV Series Based on True StoriesThe Best Underrated TV Series Based on True StoriesThe Best Underrated TV Series Based on True Stories

Five Days at Memorial is a medical drama set in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, focusing on New Orleans, Louisiana, where the disaster was most severe. In this story, Vera Farmiga portrays Dr. Anna Pou, one of many dedicated healthcare professionals at Memorial Hospital who brace themselves for the chaos the storm will bring. However, they are utterly unprepared for what follows.

Hitting Too Close to Home?

After the pandemic’s impact on hospitals became evident worldwide, this series assumed a completely new dimension. Scenes of people battling against surging waters, navigating through rundown hospital corridors, and unsuccessful rescue attempts give off a bleak, dystopian vibe at times. Originally, it was adapted from a book written by a journalist chronicling hospital life. Unfortunately, many missed out on the show when it debuted on Apple TV+ in 2022. But, it’s always beneficial to discover an overlooked gem – there’s still time for you to do so!

Read More

2024-09-22 21:02