How the World’s Top News Orgs Hope to Tackle Misinformation as a Historic U.S. Election Looms

How the World’s Top News Orgs Hope to Tackle Misinformation as a Historic U.S. Election Looms

As a seasoned journalist with years of experience under my belt, I must say that the initiative to combat misinformation and fake news is not only necessary but also commendable. The collaboration between different media outlets to share resources and pool their expertise is a game-changer in this digital age where the spread of false information can happen at breakneck speed.


With a democracy-defining election on the horizon, it’s never been more vital to trust the news.

In a heated debate hosted by ABC News on September 10th, Republican presidential contender Donald Trump clashed with Vice President Kamala Harris from the Democratic party. The discussion became particularly intense when Trump was challenged for making false statements about Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, who he claimed were stealing pets from local residents to eat them. In this debate, these claims were immediately debunked as false.

The woman in question recently stated that she believes transgender surgeries should be performed on undocumented immigrants who are currently incarcerated. This statement comes from her interpretation of a comment made by Harris, where she expressed support for providing necessary treatment to transgender individuals receiving state care, as part of an ACLU questionnaire in 2019.

As a fervent supporter, I can’t help but express my dismay at the persistent assertions made by the Republican, claiming victory in the 2020 election against Joe Biden. This belief persists even though election officials from all corners of the nation have unequivocally confirmed that no fraud or rigging took place. During a recent debate moderated by David Muir and Linsey Davis of ABC News, Trump made several contentious statements, one of which was that certain U.S. states allow for the “execution” of newborn babies. However, Linsey Davis swiftly corrected him, stating emphatically: “There is not a single state in this country where it’s legal to kill a baby after it’s born.

However, verifying claims on social media has not proved as rigorous, or indeed instantaneous. Trump, for example, also took some heat in recent weeks for falsely sharing AI-generated images of Taylor Swift endorsing him for the 2024 election (the popstar later declared her intention to vote for Harris on her official Instagram account). It didn’t stop the images from swirling around on Elon Musk’s X and Mark Zuckerberg’s Facebook for weeks.

A recent survey conducted by the World Economic Forum highlights that misinformation has been identified as the most significant worldwide threat within the next two years, surpassing concerns about climate change and war. This year, elections are taking place in approximately 50 countries around the world, with nearly half of the global population participating. The emergence of deepfakes, false news, and propaganda is creating unparalleled challenges for verifying content in newsrooms and reputable media outlets.

The responsibility falls upon major global news outlets to deliver genuine and accurate journalism to online audiences worldwide. As per Pew Research Center findings, around 54% of American adults obtain some of their news through social media. Given that even a former U.S. president and presidential candidate may have the potential to frequently lie during debates, it’s crucial to emphasize truthfulness.

Currently, several prominent international news outlets, spearheaded by the BBC and CBS News, are joining forces on an industry-spanning initiative titled “Design Your Arsenal in the Battle Against Misinformation“. This collaborative effort, part of the IBC Accelerator Media Innovation program, aims to assist organizations in confronting the issue of misinformation in media by working together for the first time to combat this problem.

Beyond BBC and CBS News, a variety of other organizations such as The Associated Press (AP), Paramount, Reuters, ITN, Globo, Al Jazeera, and Channel 4 are participating in this initiative. As Tim Forrest, ITN’s content editor, explains to The Hollywood Reporter, disinformation has been a longstanding issue, but what we’ve witnessed recently is an escalation of false information. Essentially, journalists and news organizations have always questioned the truth, and they still do today. However, in addition to this, they will now also need to consider whether the information is authentic. This is a shift that everyone involved needs to understand and adapt to.

AP’s social media editor Nadia Ahmed expresses: “How can we assist our viewers in distinguishing fact from fiction, and reality from non-reality?” In simpler terms, they aim to screen out any misinformation so that only accurate content reaches you, their audience.

How the World’s Top News Orgs Hope to Tackle Misinformation as a Historic U.S. Election Looms

The initiative has three key components, the first of which is establishing the source – whether a statement, image, or video – known as its origin. This concept can be likened to a nutritional label on food, according to BBC’s head of standards & industry, Judy Parnall. So, just like we know what’s in our food, it’s equally important to understand the components of your media. This means knowing where it originated, who is responsible for it, and how it was produced. In essence, this isn’t about passively accepting a video and assuming its truthfulness based solely on its source.

Parnall says the BBC has even seen this with “shallowfakes,” which are far less edited than a deepfake, but can still change a story entirely. To address this, news orgs want to find out what tools are out there to investigate a story’s provenance. “What are the different approaches? Do you need to use blockchain? How complex is it to use?” she said.

Ahmed emphasizes the importance of detection tools as users may lack provenance information, and these tools need to identify genuine content. “This technology is incredibly novel,” Ahmed explains. “Since creation itself is so fresh, the detection tools are, in essence, playing catch-up. For the most part, there’s not a great deal of financial incentive, so what we’ve discovered through our Accelerator initiative is examining a broad range of existing tools on the market.

She goes on to say: “A useful strategy can be to blend various methods to gather as much relevant data as possible. This manual verification process ensures that you’re not overly dependent on machines for determining whether something is real or false.

Modern artificial intelligence (AI) technology is now available for swiftly identifying whether an image has been manipulated or modified, offering a reliable means of verification.

As a gamer, I’m checking out the analysis here, which comes with a confidence rating. It seems there might be some AI-generated issues or artifacts around the face in this photo, or within the voice of this video. From there, it’s up to journalists, or eventually any user, to assess that information and make their own judgement about its reliability or trustworthiness.

But what makes this initiative a game-changer is collaboration. The outlets are hoping to figure out a way forward together and, crucially, share their resources. “We will be in a position very soon where the human eye cannot tell the difference [between real and fake],” Forrest says. “No one organization can fix this. The scales that we’re talking about here mean that even as national broadcasters, we’re often operating against platforms that are the size of nations and have the budgets to go with it, and unless we collaborate, then we really can’t hope to get a grip on this.”

Ahmed emphasizes that progress can only be made through openness and truthfulness. Recognizing deceptions and honestly communicating with your audience is paramount. The danger of misinformation is evident: “At this stage, instances of misinformation are significantly impacting public opinion and influencing elections worldwide. It’s a critical concern.

Besides Meta (previously Facebook, owned by Zuckerberg) and X (owned by Musk), are also stepping in to assist. Mark Smith, chair of IBC Council and head of the IBC Accelerator Programme, often hears that social media platforms have been missing from discussions. He emphasizes the need for more dialogue on these platforms since they play a significant role in this context.

Just recently, the European Union cautioned Elon Musk about adhering to fresh regulations concerning false information and Russian propaganda. This came after it was discovered that, among major social media platforms, Twitter (formerly known as X) had the highest proportion of misinformation posts.

Speaking of our roles as news providers, we have a long-standing reputation that’s been built on trust over several decades. Our aim is to leverage this knowledge in the current context. That’s what we’re striving for here, says Forrest. Parnall adds, “It benefits everyone if truth prevails, not just traditional news providers and broadcasters, but also social media platforms. If users realize they can’t depend on social media platforms, they’ll seek alternatives. In essence, when the truth wins, it raises all ships.

Back in December 2020, a survey by Redline revealed that nearly 4 out of every 10 U.S. news consumers unwittingly spread false or misleading information on social media. Given how fast AI technology has been advancing over the past couple of years, I can’t help but feel it’s highly probable that this percentage might be even higher by 2024. As a gamer, I’ve seen firsthand how easy it is for misinformation to spread online, and it’s crucial we all stay vigilant.

2024’s IBC event, an annual media trade show held in Amsterdam, has revealed that a grand total of 45,085 attendees from 170 different countries joined the conference between September 13th to 16th. This gathering served as a platform for bringing together professionals from the global realms of media, entertainment, and technology. The event showcased cutting-edge innovations and addressed pressing industry issues, such as the fight against misinformation.

Ahmed states that “as media organizations, we don’t aim to be the judges of what is true.” Instead, our role is to present the facts as we discover them, for facts carry and should maintain their inherent power.

Read More

2024-09-30 22:25