As a scholar and critic of cinema, I find myself deeply troubled by the tales of torment that some filmmakers have inflicted upon their actors. The stories of Bernardo Bertolucci, Stanley Kubrick, and others who used fear, manipulation, and emotional distress to extract performances from their casts are truly disheartening.
Actors such as Robert De Niro and Daniel Day-Lewis have often relied on method acting to create more genuine characters. This technique, typically linked with on-screen performers, has also been utilized by directors to draw out superior performances from their actors. However, it’s important to note that some directors have gone too far in their pursuit of intense emotions for the screen, which might involve subjecting cast members to distress. While a few directors have applied this approach responsibly, others have overstepped boundaries – creating abusive work environments in the process.
This directing style has a rich history stretching back to Alfred Hitchcock and Stanley Kubrick, with many modern directors following in their footsteps. However, due to the significant impact these influential filmmakers had, a concerning pattern has arisen, often negatively impacting actresses and young actors more frequently. This problematic conduct on set was largely addressed in recent times, thanks mainly to the #MeToo movement and unions limiting the once-unchecked authority of directors who were known for overstepping boundaries with their casts.
Although such power imbalances will inevitably lead to problems, they probably won’t sink to the extremes witnessed in earlier eras, when unchecked power led to corruption without bounds. Here are ten instances where directors pushed their actors to extreme limits in pursuit of a genuine portrayal.
10 David O. Russell Brought George Clooney to Blows on Three Kings
Three monarchs found themselves in a tense situation reminiscent of a pressure cooker, as four soldiers devised a gold theft scheme amidst the turmoil of the first Gulf War. George Clooney held the lead role, and director David O. Russell’s approach towards actors seemed designed to mirror the film’s intense narrative, which unfortunately resulted in a harmful work environment. When Russell verbally attacked an extra, Clooney believed the director had overstepped boundaries, resulting in a physical altercation between the two prominent figures.
Russell and Clooney Reconciled… Or Did They?
Regardless of their past altercation, Clooney eventually reconciled with Russell at a later gathering. Although Clooney seemingly pardoned the director, he never forgot the incident – which is why, during a recent interview, Clooney shared his reasons for being selective about who he collaborates with nowadays. “It’s not as simple as saying, ‘I’ll do an excellent film like Three Kings, and David O Russell will make my life a living hell,'” Clooney stated. “He would make every crew member’s life difficult too.” Clooney continued, “At this stage in my life, it’s not worth the hassle, just for a good end result.
9 Eduardo Sánchez and Daniel Myrick Took the Cast of The Blair Witch Project Through Hell
As a passionate cinephile, I can’t ignore the fact that Eduardo Sánchez and Daniel Myrick truly shook up the horror genre with their innovative approach to filmmaking in “The Blair Witch Project”. However, their revolutionary techniques didn’t come without controversy. They managed to deceive a significant number of viewers into believing their movie was an authentic snuff film, partly by subjecting their cast to some discomfort.
In Seneca Creek State Park, Maryland, the actors received vague guidelines and secret hints. However, they largely created their own scenes as they navigated through the park. The directors made every effort to frighten the actors during their journey.
Heather Donaghue Railed Against the Directors’ Effect on Her Life
In this scenario, using Heather Donaghue to handle the Hi-8 camera during filming allowed the directors to experiment with their actors throughout the production process, including an incident involving them shaking Donaghue’s tent without prior warning in the now-notorious tent scene set in a dark state park. With only her flashlight for illumination and no other crew members present, Donaghue was left feeling traumatized by this experience due to the lack of light and companionship.
Given that Donaghue and her fellow actors didn’t receive any payment for their roles in the movie which earned a staggering $248 million, it’s not surprising why the actress decided to leave Hollywood and adopt a new identity (as the film utilized her real name).
8 Quentin Tarantino Put Uma Thurman in a Bad Spot in Kill Bill
Following what appeared to be a harmonious collaboration between Quentin Tarantino and Uma Thurman during the production of “Kill Bill”, hinted by Tarantino’s “Q + U” credit, signs of tension in their relationship gradually emerged. Many years after the movie’s premiere, Thurman disclosed an incident involving a hazardous classic car that she had crashed while filming a driving scene.
Thurman Had a Dangerous Car Accident When Set Safety Was Disregarded
During the time when Harvey Weinstein was in charge at Miramax, Thurman admitted that she had experienced his mistreatment. However, in an interview with the New York Times, she stated that her experiences with both Weinstein and director Tarantino during the filming of “Kill Bill” were even more traumatic than Weinstein’s abuse. Thurman was aware of problems with the car, but she asked not to perform the stunt, as Tarantino insisted on it, wanting Uma Thurman to be driving The Bride. This car accident resulted in injuries that have affected her for the rest of her life.
7 Alejandro Iñárritu Put Leonardo DiCaprio Through the Ringer for The Revenant
As a devoted cinephile, I can’t help but share my personal take on the unforgettable experience Alejandro Iñárritu subjected me to, or rather, Leo DiCaprio, during our grueling 9-month journey in the frosty wilderness of Canada. In his relentless pursuit of authenticity for “The Revenant”, Iñárritu pushed DiCaprio to his absolute limits. He had me, as Hugh Glass, plunging into frigid waters, chowing down on raw bison, and even crawling within the carcass of a deceased horse. On the less appetizing topic of the bison liver, Leo joked, “The tough part was the membrane around it. It felt like inflating a balloon.
For DiCaprio, Surviving the Shoot Was Worth the Accolades
According to a report by The Hollywood Reporter, the filming process was described as “a living hell” by one crew member. There were accounts of constant indecision due to bad weather, intense arguments between director Alejandro G. Iñárritu and one of his producers, and disregard for safety, such as an actor being forced to traverse ice naked multiple times. For Leonardo DiCaprio, who won the Best Actor Oscar at the 88th Academy Awards, the experience may have been worth it, but for others, perhaps not.
6 William Friedkin Left Ellen Burstyn with Chronic Pain From Stunts on The Exorcist
As a passionate cinephile, I can’t help but admire Ellen Burstyn for her unwavering dedication to portraying intense roles such as Chris MacNeil in “The Exorcist” and Sara Goldfarb in “Requiem for a Dream.” This commitment has not been without its price, as Burstyn endured significant hardships under the demanding direction of William Friedkin. To achieve the chilling scenes where Regan (played by Linda Blair) is possessed, Friedkin utilized harnesses attached to both Blair and Burstyn by his stunt coordinator, a move that left me with an injury in my back that I’ve never fully recovered from.
The Role Made Ellen Burstyn Famous, but She Has Her Regrets
Despite earning acclaim for her role, Burstyn’s experience working with Friedkin altered her opinion of him. She remarked, “Billy is a director who is so committed to capturing the perfect shot that I believe other aspects can sometimes be overlooked. He’s incredibly talented, and I don’t want to criticize him, but during our work together, I sustained an injury in my lower back which has affected me ever since. Remarkably, the shot taken when I was injured was included in the final film, explaining the intense screaming you hear in that scene.
5 James Cameron Nearly Scared Kate Winslet Into Quitting Titanic
It can be noted that James Cameron, famously known for directing movies such as Titanic in the ’90s, has become more relaxed compared to his past. During that time, his authority on set was largely unquestioned, which resulted in numerous accounts of actor mistreatment. The most well-known instance involved Kate Winslet, who portrayed Rose, and since then, she has openly stated, “It would take a significant amount of money for me to work with Jim again.
Cameron’s Set Proved Life-Threatening for Winslet
Instead of deflecting blame for his supposedly dictatorial conduct on set, Cameron said, “I believe Kate may have been emotionally affected by the massive scale of the Titanic production and the weight of her role within it.” It seems that Cameron is unwilling to take responsibility for the actress’s hypothermia caused by scenes filmed in a water tank.
Besides this, there was an instance where she nearly drowned when her coat got entangled on a submerged gate. It’s no wonder that Winslet finds it difficult to collaborate with the director once more. In response to the incident, Cameron is said to have simply replied, “Alright, let’s try again.
4 Alfred Hitchcock’s Terrible Treatment of Tippi Hedren Was for The Birds
The saying goes never to meet your heroes, and Tippi Hedren’s account of Alfred Hitchcock’s behavior during the filming of “The Birds” certainly supports this notion. Although Hitchcock is considered one of the most influential directors in Hollywood history, Hedren revealed in her memoir that he demanded other cast members not to engage with her or physically touch her and became irritable if he saw her conversing with other men.
Hedren’s Allegations Made Hitchcock’s Legacy More Complicated
According to Tippi Hedren, it wasn’t just Alfred Hitchcock’s inappropriate and aggressive behavior during filming, but he also physically assaulted the actress. For instance, he reportedly jumped on her in a limo and had a door built connecting his office with her dressing room. The HBO movie “The Girl” supports Hedren’s claims of abuse. Although it may be challenging to bring legal action against events from over five decades ago, these allegations will forever tarnish Hitchcock’s reputation — and rightfully so.
3 Roman Polanski’s Treatment of Faye Dunaway on Chinatown Set Was One of Many Reprehensible Chapters for the Director
There has been much discussion about Roman Polanski’s legal issues, stemming from a statutory rape case in the 1970s at Jack Nicholson’s home, which led him to flee the United States. During the filming of Chinatown, Faye Dunaway faced persistent harassment from the director. Polanski believed that this would enhance Dunaway’s performance, as her character, Evelyn Cross-Mulwray, was written to be frequently defensive. Dunaway described this treatment as outright harassment.
Dunawway Was Disgusted by Polanski’s Behavior and the Company He Kept
During the film, Dunaway received an Oscar nomination, but it was this experience that made her aware of Polanski’s abhorrent actions, which later became known to a larger portion of Hollywood. In her memoir, she shared her recollections about the experience.
[Polanski] frequently socialized with girls who were quite young. Girls of that age aren’t intimidating, they don’t have formed ideas, and they’re not self-reliant. At that time, I was mature, independent, an accomplished actress with firm convictions about my craft. These differences laid the foundation for conflict.
2 Bernardo Bertolucci Tricked Maria Schneider Into a Harrowing Scene in Last Tango in Paris
In many of his films, filmmaker Bernardo Bertolucci relied on a strong element of shock, often surprising not only his audience but also his actors. A notable example occurred during the production of “Last Tango in Paris,” when 19-year-old actress Maria Schneider was unexpectedly subjected to an unscripted sexual assault scene involving Marlon Brando. Although the act itself was simulated, its impact was significant because Schneider had not been forewarned about it.
Bertolucci and Brando Showed Little Sensitivity to Scheider
Looking back, Schneider admitted she should have reached out to her representative or legal counsel during the incident, as actions beyond the script aren’t required. However, at the time, she was unaware of this fact. Brando apparently offered no comfort after the event, merely advising her to calm down because it was “just a movie.” The scene is even more difficult to bear today, knowing that Schneider’s tears were genuine.
1 Stanley Kubrick Terrorized Shelley Duvall During The Shining
As a devoted cinema enthusiast, I can’t help but reflect on instances where directors have pushed their actors to great heights – and none more notorious than Stanley Kubrick’s treatment of Shelley Duvall during the filming of “The Shining.” While some argue that his abrasive methods were essential for coaxing her terrified performance, behind-the-scenes footage paints a different picture. It appears that Kubrick, in moments like yelling at Duvall after a missed cue and accusing her of wasting everyone’s time, crossed the line into unprofessional behavior.
Kubrick Got the Performance He Wanted, At a Cost for Duvall
Though it’s likely Stanley Kubrick prioritized the excellence of his film, making Duvall endure techniques such as the 127 takes during a scene where she wept and used a baseball bat for protection could be seen as a form of emotional coercion or manipulation. Angelica Huston, who was romantically involved with Jack Nicholson (the lead actor) at that moment, might have offered an insightful viewpoint, being a fellow actress herself.
Huston shared with The Hollywood Reporter that he felt, based on Jack’s comments at the time, that Shelley Duvall was struggling to handle the emotional depth of the project and that the atmosphere on set seemed unsupportive, as if she was being isolated. This incident was one of many factors that eventually drove Shelley Duvall out of Hollywood.
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-10-07 00:04