As a film enthusiast who has spent countless hours immersed in the world of Westerns, I must say that these two films, “No Country for Old Men” and “Winchester ’73”, are absolute masterpieces that breathe new life into this classic genre.
The Western film genre has been around since the discovery of moving pictures. As the Wild West took place from approximately 1865 to 1895, this was modern times when cinema was discovered, and the Old West’s themes and culture were embedded in American cinema at its roots. As the Western themes in the U.S. are at the origins of United States history, these themes have always been a significant part of America’s storytelling. From the Old West to modern-day Texas, the Western genre has carried a poetic beauty that encompasses a lot of what makes filmmaking one of the greatest arts.
On October 15, 2024, an update by Soniya Hinduja: For those who love Western movies, this collection has been expanded to include additional renowned and critically acclaimed classics.
The Western genre is so prolific in its distinctive genre conventions that these conventions have proven to make for a compelling narrative spanning multiple genres throughout cinema history. The typical archetypes of Western narratives and characters can be seen even in non-Western films ranging from Logan to Nope. Through more than 120 years of existence, western cinema has brought some of the most fascinating adventures, darkest character studies, and some of the most iconic imagery and music to ever grace the screen. Rotten Tomatoes has used the adjusted ratings of their Tomatometer (which uses metrics like the number of reviews and the age of the film) to calculate the best films of the Western genre. Here’s a closer look at the top 30.
30 Little Big Man (1970)
Under the guidance of director Arthur Penn, the film titled “Little Big Man” serves as an early exploration of revisionist Westerns. It centers around Jack Crabb, a man who claims to have lived for 121 years and narrates his life’s story to a historian. As a young boy, Jack was abandoned and taken in by the Cheyenne tribe, where he received an exceptional upbringing that molded him into a skilled gunslinger among Native Americans. Later on, he joins General Custer as a scout during the Battle of Little Bighorn. The movie portrays his thrilling escapades and his quest for identity as he experiences significant milestones in American history.
An Epic Spanning Centuries
In essence, “Little Big Man” isn’t just a typical Western; it incorporates aspects from various genres such as action, comedy, drama, and adventure. This film paved the way for a unique form of meta-western storytelling by playfully subverting traditional Western conventions, creating a narrative that is at once poignant and humorous. The stunning visuals combined with Dustin Hoffman’s memorable portrayal are among the reasons why “Little Big Man” is often hailed as one of the most intelligent and thought-provoking movies of its time. Watch it now on Apple TV or Prime Video.
29 Sweet Country (2017)
In a narrative inspired by real-life occurrences, the movie titled “Sweet Country” takes you back to 1920s Australia. There, we meet Sam Kelly, an Aboriginal farmworker residing in the outback, who defends himself against a belligerent and intoxicated World War I veteran. Fearing for their lives, Sam and his wife Lizzie flee, with relentless Sergeant Fletcher hot on their heels across treacherous landscapes and escalating conflicts. Eventually, they are forced to surrender due to mounting dangers and rising tensions.
The Best Australian Western of the Century
Warwick Thornton’s exceptional direction vividly portrays the 1920s Australian countryside in a manner that complements a deeply moving and aesthetically pleasing drama. To elaborate, Sweet Country is an artistically stunning Western film that employs a delicate narrative style to infuse depth and compassion into its most contentious themes. This captivating motion picture was honored with the Special Jury Prize at the Venice International Film Festival, with critics hailing it as “a powerful tale that excels as a character study.” Alongside Hamilton Morris, notable guest appearances are made by Bryan Brown and Sam Neill. You can watch it on Prime Video, Tubi, or The Roku Channel.
28 3:10 to Yuma (1957)
3:10 to Yuma (2007 remake by James Mangold), a critically praised Western film, revolves around hard-pressed rancher Dan Evans, who’s grappling with the burden of supporting his extensive family. In a difficult decision, he agrees to chaperone the infamous outlaw Ben Wade to prison aboard a train. As they wait in a modest hotel for the Yuma train, due at 3:10, the tension escalates, triggering a dangerous battle of principles and intellect as Wade’s gang attempts to free him.
A Tense Duel Between Heflin and Ford
Under the skillful guidance of director Delmer Daves, this timeless play unfolds in a captivating manner, with its intricate storyline and thought-provoking moral dilemmas coming to life. The plot immediately grips you and continues to intensify through a claustrophobic setting and character-focused narrative. Actors Van Heflin and Glenn Ford deliver profoundly emotional yet complex performances, inviting audiences to delve into the nuances of the subversive hero figure and the film’s examination of themes like desperation, survival, and redemption.
27 The Misfits (1961)
In their final films together, the iconic duo Clark Gable and Marilyn Monroe starred in “The Misfits”, a deeply moving drama that unfolded during a period when the vast Western landscape was slowly fading into oblivion. The story revolves around a motley crew of individuals who seem disillusioned with life’s purpose. At the heart of this intricate web is Roslyn, played by Monroe, who has just ended her marriage to an unstable partner. She unexpectedly finds companionship among a group of contemporary cowboys, including war veteran Guido (Eli Wallach) and Gay Langland (Gable).
A Beautifully Crafted Masterpiece
This classic film, penned by Arthur Miller and helmed by John Huston, is notable for its powerful and poignant storyline. The exceptional acting by the cast truly brings to life the genuine longings and vulnerabilities of the mature characters. However, it’s the plot’s exploration of shifting frontiers and themes such as trauma and mortality that give it the enduring significance it holds today. Critics have labeled The Misfits as a pivotal moment in cinema, making it a prime example of cinematic artistry at its finest.
26 The Wild Bunch (1969)
In the film industry, it’s common to use violence and raw action when portraying tales of the American West, but few productions stir up as much controversy. One such film is The Wild Bunch, a pioneering Western that takes place in Texas in 1913. The story revolves around a band of old-timer outlaws, led by Pike Bishop, who are attempting to escape their criminal past. However, they decide to carry out one last daring heist on the border between Texas and Mexico before calling it quits.
Has an Enduring Impact on the Western Genre
The Wild Bunch was helmed by Sam Peckinpah, earning him an Academy Award nod for Best Original Screenplay. Renowned for its groundbreaking narrative structure and pioneering depiction of graphic violence, this film injected a gritty authenticity and unusual realism into the Western genre, inspiring countless other filmmakers and storytellers in the years to come. The cast, spearheaded by Ernest Borgnine and Robert Ryan, delivered exceptional performances that defied conventional Western stereotypes with their introspective and emotionally charged portrayals.
25 The Ballad of Buster Scruggs (2018)
Hailing from the creators of highly praised films like O’ Brother Where Art Thou and No Country for Old Men, among others, The Ballad of Buster Scruggs offers a brilliant attempt at an anthology by Joel and Ethan Coen. Set in the early western frontier, the six tales encompass a range of experiences – from bizarre and amusing misfortunes to profound introspective challenges faced by different characters. Each brief story leaves a lasting impression.
Western Staged as an Anthology
The lighthearted yet profound narrative of “The Ballad of Buster Scruggs” contains subtle messages that invite viewers to ponder the lives of individuals who managed to endure history, often existing on society’s outskirts. One particularly striking episode focuses on Liam Neeson’s character, who serves as a tour manager for a quadriplegic performer. Each story is distinctive and unfolds through the familiar, engaging perspective of the Coen brothers, showcasing vibrant characters, intense drama, and dark humor. Notably, “The Ballad of Buster Scruggs” received three Academy Award nominations.
24 Bad Day at Black Rock (1955)
Personally, I’d describe “Bad Day at Black Rock” as a movie where I, as a one-armed war veteran, embark on a journey to a mysterious town named Black Rock. Initially, it seems like a simple quest to find a man, but things take a dark turn as I unearth hidden truths and secrets that lead to shocking revelations. Beneath its surface, this film delves into profound themes such as resentment, misguided prejudice, and racial injustice. The character of John J. Macreedy, skillfully portrayed by Spencer Tracy, encapsulates the essence of the movie with his poignant line: “A man is only as big as what he allows to provoke him.
A Deliberately Paced Thriller
Under the guidance of director John Sturges, the gripping drama Bad Day at Black Rock masterfully escalates tension to stunning peaks, thanks to its cinematography that bears the influence of film noir. Tracy delivers a compelling portrayal of his morally ambiguous character with both bravery and subtlety. The deliberate pace ensures the suspense remains taut and subtly disquieting. This timeless western, rich in thought-provoking themes, was recognized by the Academy with three nominations, including one for Best Actor (Leading Role) for Spencer Tracy’s exceptional performance. Stream it on Apple TV or Prime Video.
23 Giant (1956)
The narrative centers on Bick Benedict, a Texan rancher deeply rooted in his principles, even as the times shift on his Texas property. During a journey to the East Coast for horse purchasing, he encounters and falls for Leslie Lynnton, a socialite. Upon returning from a visit home, they tie the knot, but Bick’s sister disapproves of Leslie. Simultaneously, Leslie hires Jett Rink, a laborer, who develops feelings for her.
Epic Family Tale of a Changing Frontier
This movie, titled “Giant,” boasts a brilliantly executed cinematography and is driven by four iconic stars: Elizabeth Taylor, Rock Hudson, James Dean, and Carroll Baker. Spanning over three hours and twenty-one minutes, it’s an extensive but impactful storytelling experience. The narrative delves deeply into the lives of a family across several decades, while also shedding light on the struggle against development that reshaped the frontier, as depicted through Rock Hudson’s character. Nominated for ten Academy Awards, George Stevens earned the Best Director award for his exceptional work on this epic western.
22 Major Dundee (1965)
As a passionate movie enthusiast, I’d say “Major Dundee” is a grand Western tale unfolding during the American Civil War. In this film, I find myself immersed in the journey of a Union cavalry commander who guides an unruly band of Army personnel, Native American scouts, and Confederate captives on a perilous expedition into Mexico with the objective of annihilating a notorious Apache gang that has been wreaking havoc on U.S. forts and settlements in New Mexico.
Peckinpah’s Epic Was Ahead of Its Time
Although it initially didn’t garner many reviews upon release, this film has since proven to be an exceptional example of Cowboy cinema, earning a place in history as one of the best. However, the movie that eventually hit theaters was heavily edited from Sam Peckinpah’s original vision, causing much controversy. Nevertheless, the Western with its flaws was applauded for its authenticity, intricate characters, breathtaking scenery, and engaging finale. Watch now on Apple TV or Prime Video.
21 The Shooting (1967)
“The Shooting
A Western That’s Unafraid to Challenge Norms
The movie, “The Shooting,” initially didn’t have a theatrical release and wasn’t particularly noteworthy upon its debut. However, Jack Nicholson’s exceptional performance, an engrossing journey through the Wild West, and a surprising finale that leaves viewers eager for more, elevate this film to one of the greatest Westerns ever made. It continues to be iconic in its exploration of the psychological complexities and moral dilemmas faced by intricate male characters. You can stream it on Amazon Prime Video, Max, Peacock, or Tubi.
20 Shane (1953)
In this George Stevens-produced film, we see the solitary figure of the gunslinger brilliantly depicted amidst the tumultuous landscape of Wyoming during the late 19th century – a time marking the twilight of the American West. The lead role in Shane is played by Alan Ladd, a man who yearns for tranquility after years of combat, but is once again forced to take up arms when he needs to defend those dear to him from a merciless cattle baron.
George Stevens’ Greatest Masterpiece
In the eyes of critics, Shane is hailed as a deeply emotional and dramatic visual representation of the American wilderness. Ladd’s performance lends depth and weight to his character, whose hidden past serves as the foundation for this poignant story. The direction by Stevens only adds to its brilliance, enriching both the thrilling action scenes and the themes of camaraderie and collective spirit. Additionally, the film’s music and innovative approach to Westerns are noteworthy highlights. You can watch it on Pluto TV or Hoopla.
19 Once Upon a Time in the West (1969)
In the second, unofficial trilogy of spaghetti westerns that established Sergio Leone’s legend, the film “Once Upon a Time in the West” shines as a pristine gem of cinema. Unlike his previous works, this time Leone was without Clint Eastwood, but he assembled an exceptional ensemble cast featuring Henry Fonda portraying an unconventional villain and boasting a storyline co-developed with Dario Argento and Bernardo Bertolucci. The tale, as ancient as the sands of time, carries layers of brutality yet is grand and epic in scope.
An Icon Among Westerns
One time, in a tribute to the classic western genre, “Once Upon A Time in the West” both pays homage and pushes boundaries by drawing upon movies like “Johnny Guitar” and “The Searchers,” yet surpassing these influences. The intriguing personalities within this masterpiece continue to spark thoughtful debate. Moreover, this film explores the demise of the cowboy era and the rise of modernity as a symbolic goodbye to the essence of traditional western stories.
18 El Dorado (1967)
As a movie enthusiast, I must say that “El Dorado” presents itself as a creative reinterpretation of Harry Brown’s novel, “The Stars in Their Courses.” The story revolves around Bart Jason, an unyielding tycoon, who seeks to oust the MacDonald family from their town for the illicit purpose of seizing their land. In this tale, I found myself rooting for John Wayne as Cole Thornton, a seasoned gunslinger, who steps in to aid the family by ensuring that his friend, Sheriff J.P. Harrah, remains robust and ready to confront Jason’s thugs.
Effortless and Entertaining
In Howard Hawks’ final movie, the powerful performances of veterans John Wayne and Robert Mitchum, alongside a young James Caan, breathe life into a thematically consistent film that aligns with Hawks’ previous works. Leigh Brackett’s screenplay for El Dorado is a revision of Rio Bravo, emphasizing Wayne’s age and featuring plenty of witty banter, making it a classic Western with engaging dialogue that adds depth to the narrative. Watch it on Hoopla
17 Old Yeller (1957)
In the animal-human bond genre, the film Old Yeller is a heartwarming tale of growth and companionship. When Travis’ father goes on a cattle drive, it’s up to him, his brother, and their mother to manage the ranch. A stray dog, initially causing trouble for the family, gradually becomes friends with Travis as he protects his brother from a bear attack. Together, they learn about love and the challenges of growing up.
A Tender Tale of Frontier Friendships
Disney films are consistently ageless, and that certainly applies to the classic “Old Yeller.” This movie strikes a poignant balance between warmth and sadness, making it as delicate as it is tough – much like real life. The exceptional acting from the cast, featuring Dorothy McGuire, Fess Parker, Tommy Kirk, and Kevin Corcoran, beautifully encapsulates the emotion behind the universal themes of maturing and accepting responsibilities.
16 Fort Apache (1948)
In this iconic John Ford film, a struggle between giants unfolds. The legendary Western actors Henry Fonda and John Wayne are pitted against each other when Fonda’s character enters Arizona to assume command of Fort Apache. Both men seek military honor, but their views diverge as Fonda aims to destroy an Apache chief, a move strongly opposed by Captain Kirby York (Wayne). As Fonda persists in his stubbornness, the impending clash with the natives becomes inevitable, leading swiftly to tragic results.
Social Commentary Ahead of its Time
One of Ford’s compassionate endeavors, “Fort Apache” was one of the earliest films to present an authentic and respectful portrayal of Indigenous peoples in the commonly stereotyped western genre of the 1950s and preceding years. His direction encompasses all the social nuances and perils inherent in the Western frontier. Renowned for its striking realism, it provides not only exhilarating action but also valuable insights about the natives that are worth delving deeper into. Stream on Apple TV or Prime Video.
15 The Rider (2017)
Following a fateful incident at a rodeo where he sustained severe head injuries, a once-promising cowboy grapples with an unpredictable future as he seeks a fresh meaning in his existence, navigating through cultural conflicts and mounting hardships. The latest movie on this list, “The Rider“, is inspired by real events. It offers a moving account of self-exploration and acceptance, healing and the pursuit of purpose, with director Chloé Zhao breathing vitality into the genre.
A Powerful, Award-Winning Rendition
This movie delicately explores the complexities of masculinity in turmoil, offering an unusual portrayal of male characters compared to traditional Westerns, which often depict stereotypical tough guys and violence. For its unique perspective, The Rider was widely acclaimed, earning recognition as a “powerful drama.” The film boasts a cast of untrained actors, with Brady Jandreau delivering an exceptional performance. His real-life experiences serve as the foundation for the movie’s plot. Watch it on Max.
14 A Fistful Of Dollars (1964)
As a passionate cinephile, I can’t help but reflect on the groundbreaking impact that “A Fistful of Dollars” had when it graced our screens. This movie signified the introduction of the spaghetti Western to American audiences – a genre that playfully mocked and paid homage to the classic western, all while infusing it with a distinctly European flair.
The Pioneering Spaghetti Western
In this rendition, Sergio Leone’s second film, which kicked off his “Dollars Trilogy,” was an unofficial remake of Akira Kurosawa’s Yojimbo. This was Clint Eastwood’s debut as the leading actor, and it premiered in America three years after its initial release in Italy. The subsequent two films also starring “The Man With No Name” followed suit, propelling Eastwood into fame. Moreover, Leone’s rugged filmmaking style revolutionized the archetype of Western heroes, eventually earning a passionate fanbase who appreciated this new formula.
13 No Country for Old Men (2007)
Among the Coen brothers’ top movies, one standout is “No Country for Old Men,” featuring outstanding performances from Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin, and Tommy Lee Jones. This film is both ominous and aesthetically pleasing; it’s rare for a contemporary western to carry the same sense of danger and unpredictability as the iconic classics of the genre. The narrative unfolds when Llewelyn Moss stumbles upon drug money at a gunfight scene, decides to keep the cash, but soon finds himself pursued by a ruthless assassin.
A Noir Deconstruction Of Violence
This film tells a chilling story of unchecked greed, brutal violence, and pervasive corruption. The characters find themselves hemmed in by time’s relentless march, the overwhelming power of forces beyond their control, and their choices narrowing with each passing moment. The tension builds slowly, mirroring the grim reality that drug money and violence have become an accepted part of modern life. This dark theme is embodied by the terrifying character of Anton Chigurh, played masterfully by Javier Bardem in one of his most iconic roles to date, a villain destined to be remembered for generations.
12 Winchester ‘73 (1950)
Winchester ’73
Features the Greatest Actor-Director Duo
The movie “Winchester ’73” skillfully intertwines multiple character stories within its concise plotline. For example, once Brown snatches the rifle, McAdam embarks on a chase that leaves uncertainty about whether his goal is still the original one, or if it’s become an all-consuming quest for the rifle itself, which seems to carry a deeper tale than initially perceived. The shift from film noir to Western by director Anthony Mann also marked a new chapter in Jimmy Stewart’s career, introducing a series of more intricate characters that the actor would portray following “Winchester ’73”. Stream it now on Apple TV or Prime Video.
11 Red River (1948)
One of the highly esteemed films in its genre, “Red River” tells a fictional story about one of the earliest cattle drives from Texas to Kansas. The narrative centers around Thomas Dunson, a strong-willed rancher who spent decades building his reputation as a respected landowner. During this journey, he encounters friction with his adopted son, Matt Garth, who disagrees with Thomas’ methods. This growing discord eventually escalates into a violent confrontation.
Most Memorable Father-Son Western
In this film, masterfully directed by Howard Hawks, who has a proven track record, much like other movies in this collection, John Wayne’s powerful persona and dedication drive the narrative. Almost ten years after his role in Stagecoach, Wayne takes on another western-themed road movie where the tense action revolves around his character’s contentious relationship with his adopted son during a grueling journey. Despite appearing to be a simple plot, it delves into complex themes of strained family ties and shifting frontier societies, making it thought-provoking and meaningful. Watch it on Tubi.
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-10-17 00:35