20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

As a seasoned connoisseur of crime thrillers and a devoted fan of the giallo genre, I must say that these three films have left an indelible mark on my cinematic journey. Each one offers a unique perspective on the human condition, delving deep into themes of corruption, violence, and the darker aspects of our psyche.


Finding someone who doesn’t enjoy a good mystery sounds impossible. A suspenseful story alone can be a powerful hook. A chilling murder mystery? An ominous secret society? Or perhaps a century-long family secret? Despite our familiarity with these introductions, these stories venture into various routes. While some remain simple mysteries, others experiment with the narrative. Both, however, unveil a greater truth about the world. Sprinkled with juicy bits of information, audiences can’t help but dig deeper. Among enigmatic characters, the story is transformed from typical fodder to an unforgettable thriller. Each character, with its defining traits, witty dialogue, and decisions made under duress, reveals more than meets the eye, pulling us closer to the astonishing climax.

Some literary greats such as Agatha Christie are often recognized for laying the groundwork for the mysteries we enjoy in books and movies today. However, there have been a number of mystery films that didn’t receive much attention during their initial release due to factors like their country of origin, plotlines, or conclusion methods. With the rise of online accessibility, these movies have been rediscovered and sparked discussions among audiences. Below is a list of some lesser-known but highly praised mystery films, presented in no specific order:

Devil (2010)

Workplace horrors take the dread, stress, and exhaustion that seemingly permeates the office and expands on it, creating a fantastical tale that drives the point that no one is truly safe anywhere. M. Night Shyamalan’s Devil takes a typical fear and transforms it into a terrifying dance with the devil, literally. Following five co-workers in a Philadelphia office, the film finds them entrapped in an elevator. Initially weary of their predicament, the experience takes a turn for the worse when they endure debilitating and frightening encounters, leading up to the revelation that one of them is the Devil.

The Devil is in the Details

The movie had a variety of opinions from critics upon release, with some doubting the acting abilities of the cast and its uniqueness. Nevertheless, as a fresh take on the classic “whodunit” plot, it hits the mark perfectly. For those who find M. Night Shyamalan’s work to be unpredictable, Devil offers one of his more straightforward tales that is easier to grasp compared to others. You can rent or stream Devil on Prime Video, Apple TV, or YouTube.

Stray Dog (1949)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

In my humble opinion as a movie critic, Akira Kurosawa’s 1949 masterpiece, “Stray Dog,” is a gripping Japanese film noir drama that follows the harrowing journey of a newly promoted homicide detective named Murakami (played brilliantly by Toshiro Mifune). On one scorching day in Tokyo, Murakami endures what may very well be the most challenging day of his career. The plot thickens as a cunning pickpocket makes off with his gun, leading our resilient detective on an all-day pursuit to track down the culprit. Simultaneously, we are given an intimate portrayal of postwar Tokyo, offering viewers a captivating glimpse into the city’s streets during this transformative period.

A Stunning Thriller From Japan’s Greatest Director

This film, captivating audiences with stunning visuals, deviates from conventional storytelling by focusing on a protagonist who is both intriguing and relatable – Detective Murakami. Initially composed, Murakami’s investigation of the city plunges him into turmoil when he discovers that his gun, an item deeply tied to his emotional state, is being used in a string of crimes. The film masterfully portrays Murakami’s distress through his connection with his gun. What sets Stray Dog (1949) apart as a cinematic gem by Akira Kurosawa is its enlightening portrayal of postwar Japan and the widespread trauma experienced by its people. You can catch Stray Dog on The Criterion Channel.

Incendies (2010)

As a cinephile, I’m captivated by the intricate tapestry of generational struggles, immigration, and family reputation that unfolds in the movie “Incendies.” This profound film takes us on an intimate journey into the lives of siblings Jeanne (Mélissa Désormeaux-Poulin) and Simon (Maxim Gaudette). Following the passing of their mother Nawal (Lubna Azabal), they discover a series of letters revealing hidden family members and Nawal’s past in her native land.

A Profound Story Spanning Generations

Although “Incendies” might not have the pulse-pounding intensity of an action flick, it is undeniably a powerful film that will captivate and move audiences deeply. The complex conflicts portrayed within the story and the genuine quest of the siblings to rediscover their mother in a fresh light make this movie a must-see, and Denis Villeneuve’s adaptation of Wajdi Mouawad’s play is nothing short of impressive. If you haven’t already seen it, I highly recommend catching “Incendies” on Apple TV, Prime Video, or YouTube.

Memories of Murder (2003)

As a cinephile delving into the captivating world of Bong Joon-ho, I can’t help but marvel at his genius, showcased in masterpieces such as “Parasite” and “Snowpiercer”. Yet, it’s essential to acknowledge that he has a rich portfolio of acclaimed films, particularly in East Asia. One such gem is the gripping 2003 thriller, “Memories of Murder”, which is now garnering renewed interest from devoted Bong Joon-ho enthusiasts and captivating new admirers alike.

An Early Masterpiece From the Director of Parasite and Snowpiercer

From the police officers we follow to the locals, Memories of Murder separates itself from other crime thrillers. The satirical nature of the film would prove to be the driving force behind its cult classic status and overall veneration. Finding the characters succumb to the pressure of the investigation and their comical attempts to unwind makes the film engaging and enthralling for mystery fans. You can stream Memories of Murder on Tubi.

Zero Effect (1998)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

In 1998, the movie “Bill Pullman as the world’s most private detective Daryl Zero” presented a unique blend of comedy and mystery. Daryl’s solitary nature is instrumental in his professional triumphs and fame. His grumpy persona keeps him away from meeting clients directly; instead, he works through his assistant Steve Arlo, portrayed by Ben Stiller. In this film, both Daryl and Steve are enlisted by the wealthy Greggory Stark of Portland to unravel the secret hidden in a crucial safe box.

A Dark Yet Humorous Mystery

In the movie’s premiere, it received mostly positive feedback, but what truly captivated viewers was the remarkable on-screen partnership between Bill Pullman and Ben Stiller. This portrayal of friendship resonated more deeply with audiences than the film’s central mystery. If you’re looking for a mystery infused with bold personalities or a unique comedic twist in a typically grim genre, then Zero Effect is an excellent choice to begin your exploration. You can conveniently rent this movie on Apple TV, Prime Video, or YouTube.

I Am Mother (2019)

Incorporating elements of science fiction into its narrative, the film “I Am Mother” presents us with the story of humans who have survived in a bunker after a disastrous event. The character known as Mother, played by Rose Byrne, is a robot that nurtures and births a child, whom she names Daughter (portrayed by Clara Rugaard). Mother keeps Daughter within the confines of the bunker, warning her about the perils that lie beyond. However, a mysterious woman (Hilary Swank) suddenly appears, posing a threat to the secrets that Mother has been safeguarding.

Sci-Fi Mystery Exploring Motherhood

The chilling atmosphere of the bunker alone creates a uniquely unsettling feeling that keeps audiences engaged and, more importantly, concerned with Daughter’s safety. With the introduction of both Mother and Woman, poignant conversations about motherhood and the human connection start to break through, resulting in a refreshing, dystopian, sci-fi mystery that subverts expectations. You can stream I Am Mother on Netflix.

Crimson Peak (2015)

In simpler terms, “Crimson Peak” is a 2015 film blending elements of mystery and horror, primarily set in Buffalo, New York, during the year 1887. The narrative revolves around Edith Cushing (played by Mia Wasikowska), an aspiring author, who enters into marriage with English baronet Thomas Sharpe (portrayed by Tom Hiddleston). Following their union, they move to a mansion shared with Sharpe’s sister Lucille (Jessica Chastain). As Edith settles in, she starts experiencing eerie supernatural visions. As she delves into the origins of these visions and uncovers more about her new home, she unearths a chain of secrets that significantly alters her perception of the world around her.

A Stylish Supernatural Mystery

As a cinephile, I must commend the captivating acting in this movie, particularly Chastain’s mesmerizing portrayal of Lucille. Some viewers found her performance downright chilling, while others, like Bryan Alexander, aptly described it as “beautifully bad.” The film masterfully weaves a gripping tale that centers around the enigmatic mansion but leaves one pondering the complexities of love and envy. If you haven’t already, I highly recommend catching Crimson Peak on Prime Video.

Devil in a Blue Dress (1995)

Although it didn’t fare well at the ticket counters, “Devil In A Blue Dress” remains a beloved and overlooked ’90s mystery. Set within the genre of modern noir crime thrillers, this film is an on-screen rendition of Walter Mosley’s 1990 novel with the same title. The protagonist, Ezekiel “Easy” Rawlins (played by Denzel Washington), is a memorable African American detective. In “Devil In A Blue Dress,” viewers get to track him as he embarks on his initial investigation of an enigmatic woman.

Adapting an Iconic Detective to the Screen

In the late 1940s, Easy’s adventure delves into the political ramifications of the vanished woman and the racial undercurrents that influence her disappearance. Although the suspense keeps viewers engaged, “Devil in a Blue Dress” focuses more on the reasons behind the mysterious vanishing rather than the perpetrator, resulting in a thought-provoking ending to a film brimming with impressive performances from Denzel Washington and Don Cheadle. You can rent “Devil in a Blue Dress” on Apple TV, Amazon Prime Video, or YouTube.

Missing (2023)

Read our Review

In a 2023 thriller, titled “Missing”, the narrative unfolds entirely within an online setting, making it both contemporary and innovative. The story revolves around 18-year-old June Allen (played by Storm Reid) and her mother, Grace (portrayed by Nia Long). A seemingly ordinary weekend sets the stage for the plot, until June’s mother announces a week-long vacation to Colombia with her new partner, Kevin (Ken Leung). As Grace departs, leaving June alone, it appears to be just another weekend. However, when June arrives at the airport to welcome her mother home, she finds that Grace is nowhere to be found, sending June on a desperate digital quest to locate her.

An Engaging Tale of a Young Internet Sleuth

Exploring the creation of a movie centered around the internet is undeniably thrilling and thought-provoking, but Missing skillfully weaves an enthralling narrative about a daughter’s quest to find her mother using solely online tools. This innovative take on the screen-life sub-genre not only resonates with personal experiences but also delves into deeper, more nuanced aspects of technology. Don’t miss out on this captivating tale – stream Missing on Netflix today.

Presumed Innocent (1990)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

Innocent Until Proven Guilty

A Courtroom Drama With Twists and Turns

Delving deep into the intriguing world of mystery, Presumed Innocent offers a captivating glimpse into the legal realm and enlightens viewers about fundamental courtroom procedures and the subtler, often overlooked aspects of the American judicial system. Masterfully directed by Alan J. Pakula, the film deftly navigates the intricate labyrinth of courtroom drama and criminal investigations. The shocking climax not only satisfies but also sheds light on a disturbingly common occurrence that many prefer to keep hidden. Rent Presumed Innocent on Apple TV, Amazon Prime Video, or YouTube.

Winter’s Bone (2010)

As a passionate cinephile, I can’t help but relate to the crushing sensation of waking up to a parent who’s gone missing – a feeling that “Winter’s Bone” vividly portrays. Similar to the protagonist in this gripping movie, I too found myself on a quest, much like Ree Dolly (brilliantly played by Jennifer Lawrence). The story follows her relentless pursuit to locate her father, who vanishes just as he puts their home up for bail. In an effort to shield my family from homelessness, I found myself delving into our family’s hidden truths and unraveling their web of deception – all in search of the answers I so desperately needed.

The Strength to Go Against Family Traditions

The captivating aspect of “Winter’s Bone” lies in its portrayal of Ree’s solitude. By shattering her family’s unspoken pacts, Ree’s resilience resonates with anyone who dares to challenge their loved ones, ask tough questions, and potentially sacrifice comfort and relationships for truth. Jennifer Lawrence delivered an outstanding performance in this film. You can watch Winter’s Bone on Kanopy or Plex.

A Perfect Murder (1998)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

The 1998 film titled “A Perfect Murder,” while bearing some similarities to Alfred Hitchcock’s “Dial M for Murder,” stands out as an exceptional murder mystery in its own right. The film features Michael Douglas, Gwyneth Paltrow, and Viggo Mortensen. The story revolves around Steven Taylor, a discontented financier who learns of his wife Emily’s infidelity. In a chilling turn of events, Steven devises a plan to kill her. However, things take an unexpected turn when he enlists David (portrayed by Viggo Mortensen) as the assassin, leaving him less than pleased with the arrangement.

Envy Can Make a Man Do Horrible Things

As a true admirer, I must acknowledge the challenge of replicating a Hitchcock masterpiece, but the exceptional acting from the star-studded cast and the updated storyline have led to an unexpected appreciation. Initially met with a mix of reactions due to its romantic undertones and flashy elements, the movie has gained more love over the passing days, captivating viewers with its numerous twists and turns. If you haven’t already, I strongly recommend you watch A Perfect Murder, available for rent on Apple TV, Prime Video, or YouTube.

The Empty Man (2020)

In a small town distraught by the vanishing of multiple teenagers, James Lasombra (James Badge Dale), who has experienced loss himself, delves into the mysterious occurrences surrounding their disappearance. His investigation leads him back to events dating centuries old, uncovering an ancient deity with devoted followers, and hinting that he could be entangled in their sinister schemes.

A Lovecraftian Detective Story

Invoking Lovecraftian-style fears, The Empty Man stands out as one of the most polarizing films from 2020. Unlike what many anticipated, this film veered away from typical “creepy pasta” scares and delved deeper into a prolonged, somber exploration of the enigmatic. If you’re drawn to mysteries with a dash of horror, The Empty Man is undoubtedly worth your time. You can conveniently stream it on Hulu.

Tenebrae (1982)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

Renowned director Dario Argento released “Tenebrae” in 1982. This movie centers around Peter Neal (Anthony Francoisa), an American writer in Rome, promoting his latest murder-mystery book. As word spreads about a murderer who seems to be inspired by his novel, Peter enlists the aid of local cops and his agent to help stop the potential wave of violence.

Dario Argento’s Ode to Giallo

Through the use of themes of duality and cinematographic techniques like character perspective filming, viewers have pointed out that Dario Argento employs “Tenebrae” as a means to dissect criticisms of his previous work while revisiting his signature style. Renowned for his influence on the giallo subgenre, “Tenebrae” showcases the director delving into horror’s obsession with the brutal murder of women and the ensuing glamorization of the trope. In essence, this film serves as a poignant farewell piece, marking the end of the first wave of giallo genre popularity. You can stream “Tenebrae” for free on Tubi and Plex.

Black Coal, Thin Ice (2014)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

Black Coal, Thin Ice is a chilling Chinese crime drama that follows the gruesome murder and dissection of an unidentified victim. The various parts of the body are sent to different cities as coal shipments. Detective Zhang Zili (played by Liao Fan) takes on the case, aiming to discover the true identity of the enigmatic woman behind the crime.

A Gruesome Murder Mystery

The movie “Black Coal, Thin Ice” offers viewers an intriguing exploration of a chilling act of violence, initially shrouded in mystery, and gradually unveils the role of officers implicated in the case as well as the individuals connected to the murder. It not only keeps audiences hooked with its gripping narrative but also underscores the power of silence in shielding crime and upholding rigid social structures. You can stream this captivating film on Prime Video, Tubi, or Plex.

Master (2022)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

Read our Review

In this rephrased version:

An Uncomfortable Truth Unearthed

The movie “Master” thoughtfully addresses ongoing debates about tokenism and the concept of “blackfishing,” skillfully weaving these discussions into a chilling narrative. Characters like Gail, Jasmine, and other faculty members have been particularly well-developed, leading critics to praise “Master” as a deeply nuanced, character-focused production. You can catch this 2022 release on Prime Video now.

Body Double (1984)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

In another suspenseful offering akin to “A Perfect Murder,” the movie titled “Body Double” adds itself to the list of thrillers influenced by Alfred Hitchcock’s timeless masterpieces. The story revolves around Jake Scully (Craig Wasson), an actor struggling to make ends meet, whose misfortunes escalate when he is replaced on set and catches his girlfriend being unfaithful. In a twist of fate, Jake encounters Sam Bouchard (Gregg Henry) and agrees to house-sit Sam’s luxurious home in the upscale Hollywood Hills. Here, Jake unwittingly becomes a witness to an unsettling incident that sets the stage for a thrilling tale of mystery and deception.

A Visually Stylish Erotic Thriller

In a nutshell, “Body Double” delves into Jake’s intrigue-filled probe and underscores discussions about voyeurism, exhibitionism, and deception. It offers a captivating peek into the world of adult entertainment, subtly exploring misogyny present not just in villains but also in seemingly benevolent characters. Despite receiving mixed criticism, Brian De Palma’s cinematography in “Body Double” is so exquisite that you can savor the crime-thriller simply for its style. You can conveniently rent “Body Double” on Prime Video, Apple TV, or YouTube.

Deep Red (1975)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

A 1975 Italian horror movie titled “Deep Red” begins with the slaying of a clairvoyant. When musician Marcus Daly, portrayed by David Hemmings, stumbles upon the corpse, he becomes determined to uncover the killer’s identity. This determination intensifies as a personal tragedy makes the crime more pressing. Partnering with journalist Gianna Brezzi (Daria Nicolodi), they collaborate to track down the murderer and thwart further catastrophes.

A Classic Giallo

Regarded as a classic in the giallo genre, “Deep Red” skillfully blends elements of crime and mystery. Characteristic of giallo films, this movie features graphic murder scenes and keeps viewers guessing, often delving into themes such as delusion, paranoia, sexuality, trauma, and isolation. It masterfully crafts a captivating mystery that plays with one’s mind while providing ample doses of body horror and suspense. You can stream “Deep Red” on platforms like AMC+, Shudder, Scrambox, or The Criterion Channel.

The Place Beyond the Pines (2013)

“Beyond the Motorway’s Edge

A Chilling Crime Thriller with an All-Star Cast

Corruption is, seemingly, a tale as long as time. The Place Beyond The Pines excellently explores lives forever changed by secrets and lies. Furthermore, the film stresses the lasting impacts of said omissions. A leap forward finds the actions of Avery and Luke, as well as their peers, influencing the next generation, highlighting that the truth can never be buried under the sands of time. You can rent The Place Beyond the Pines on Prime Video, Apple TV, or YouTube.

Cure (1997)

20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries20 Underrated Movies with Darkly Compelling Mysteries

In this narrative, I, as an observer, find myself following along as our protagonist unravels a string of puzzling murders. Detective Kenichi Takabe, skillfully portrayed by Koji Yashuko, finds himself hot on the heels of suspects immediately after they’ve carried out these heinous acts. What sets these cases apart is the consistent appearance of an “X” at each crime scene. As if that wasn’t enough to pique one’s curiosity, the film delves into Fumie, Takabe’s wife, who battles with schizophrenia, adding another layer of complexity to this intricate tale.

Churning in the Dark Underbelly of Tokyo

At its heart, the psychological thriller “Cure ” left both critics and viewers spellbound, transforming from a routine police procedural into an indelibly chilling masterpiece. Timeless films often resonate with a universal truth, and “Cure” is no exception. It serves as a profound exploration of the human mind, leading viewers away from the alluring facade of 90s Tokyo to reveal a hidden, sinister side. “You can stream Cure (1997) on The Criterion Channel“.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-10-21 06:34