Is the $1 Million ‘Survivor’ Prize Losing Its Value in Reality TV?

by

“Want to know what you’re playing for?”

Jeff Probst, the executive producer and host of the popular show “Survivor,” has frequently emphasized that his statement ranks alongside the iconic phrase “the tribe has decided.

However, the prizes that Survivor contestants compete for aren’t as substantial as they once were. Most legacy competition shows have failed to adjust for inflation, while contemporary reality shows on streaming platforms are offering staggering prize amounts similar to lottery winnings.

In 2000, when CBS introduced the reality show “Survivor”, its $1 million grand prize seemed almost inconceivable. This amount was equivalent to the highest possible winnings on ABC’s game show “Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?”, which had premiered the previous year. The following year, CBS also launched another competition series, “The Amazing Race”, that also offered a $1 million prize.

All of a sudden, having $1 million as the television contest prize became incredibly appealing. Hearing “One… million… dollars” never failed to sound fantastic. With that amount, you could easily afford a home in various locations, together with a high-end vehicle and some exotic getaways where you’d savor gourmet dishes instead of the usual rice and beans.

Looking back over the past 25 years, it’s striking how much things have changed, particularly when considering an extended period of high inflation that stubbornly persists.

Interested in understanding how much a million dollars from the past compares to now? As per the Bureau of Labor Statistics, that same amount would be equivalent to approximately $534,850 in terms of purchasing power during the 2000s.

Inquired about the decreasing purchasing power of the “Survivor” prize, a show insider responded, “One million dollars remains a substantial amount – more than most other shows provide – as it presents a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for the fortunate few who get to take part. Money isn’t the only incentive; the life experience and personal development are significant motivators for those who apply.

It’s accurate to say that Survivor continues to reign as a ratings powerhouse, heading towards its 50th season with an average of 8 million viewers and being the most-watched non-sports program in primetime for adults. Interestingly, CBS even upped the ante by offering a $2 million prize for Survivor: Winners at War in 2020, demonstrating that they aren’t afraid to mix things up every now and then.

It’s clear that Survivor appears more generous than American Idol, given the significant reduction in the top prize offered by the latter. In its initial phases on Fox, American Idol used to award its winner $1 million; however, this amount has been reduced to just $250,000 (along with a recording contract).

One long-running television cooking competition that has significantly increased its prize money over the years is Bravo’s popular show “Top Chef.” When it initially aired in 2006, the grand prize was a respectable $100,000, but today, it stands at an almost exhilarating $250,000.

In contrast to the wages at Taco Bell, the new reality TV shows sponsored by streaming giants have significantly larger prizes. For instance, Netflix’s “Squid Game: The Challenge” debuted in 2023 with a top prize of $4.56 million, which was the largest cash prize in TV history until Amazon’s “Beast Games” came along in December and offered a $5 million top prize. Remarkably, the prize for “Beast Games” doubled to an astonishing $10 million in its finale. Furthermore, during the show, it also featured a “Survivor”-like sequence of mid-season episodes set on an island where Mr. Beast gave away the actual island (valued at $1.8 million).

If it seems like the prizes on Beast Games are driven by a show of one-upmanship, then that’s likely the case. In a backstage video, co-creator and host of Beast Games, Mr. Beast, admitted openly what many might have suspected. He stated, “I needed to take a jab at regular shows.” He continued, “A million dollar grand prize? [He mimics spitting] Beast Games! I gave away a million dollars in the first minute and 42 seconds. This is asserting control.

In this digital age, where social media thrives on showcasing lavish lifestyles, it seems only natural that even our favorite TV series might start boasting about who’s amassed the most wealth. After all, who doesn’t love a good financial flex?

In contrast, the attention paid to financial gains from reality TV overlooks a more substantial advantage of appearing on such shows. While it was different when Survivor and The Amazing Race initially arose, a complete economic infrastructure has since developed that empowers reality stars to expand their personal brands following their stint on these programs.

June Deery, a Professor of Communication & Media at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, stated that what’s highly sought-after in reality shows isn’t just the prize, but also the publicity. Even if contestants don’t become top-tier celebrities, the visibility they gain on TV can be turned into financial gain through online platforms – for example, by endorsing sponsors or earning revenue from YouTube ads.

Alexandra Devlin, who works as a Brand Endorsement Agent at William Morris Endeavor, concurred, emphasizing some crucial differences. “Social media allows individuals to generate income through their own platforms – whether that’s brand partnerships, podcasts, or live performances,” she explained. “However, the sustainability of this can be unpredictable.” She also pointed out that a reality show could either significantly boost your brand visibility or potentially harm it, depending on how you are presented.

Devlin pointed out that numerous individuals believe they need an over-the-top, obnoxious personality to capitalize on their time on these shows, but that’s not often true. “If you garner attention by being extremely vocal, controversial, and argumentative, you may be missing out on chances that could have come your way outside of the show,” the agent explained.

People who effectively capitalize on their new TV stardom, she explained, are often those who already possess a thriving business and well-known brand. They can then utilize their screen time to significantly elevate their business. For instance, Bethany Frankel marketed herself as an entrepreneur upon her debut on The Real Housewives of New York City.

Talent agents view Bravo’s “Housewives” franchise as the ideal reality TV platform for securing profitable chances, primarily because shows centered around a person’s lifestyle and personality tend to have significantly greater earning potential for cast members compared to regular competition series that offer prize money but are often considered “goal-oriented.

So do you really want to know what you’re playing for? It’s clout, not cash. 

— Steven Zeitchik contributed to this report 

Read More

2025-02-26 17:25