3 Actresses, 9 Years: The Crazy Casting Story Behind Lisbeth Salander Revealed!

by

In 2005, Stieg Larsson’s novel “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” was initially published, and it was translated into English in 2008. Interestingly, despite being the first book to introduce the character Lisbeth Salander, different actresses have taken on the role in various live-action adaptations of Larsson’s debut novel and subsequent sequels. The original Millennium book series was so popular that other authors were commissioned to continue the storyline after Larsson’s unexpected death in 2004. Although he didn’t get to witness the phenomenal success his story achieved, there is no denying his lasting impact.

The Lisbeth Salander books follow a straightforward, linear sequence of events, but the movies present a more complex picture. There have been three actresses portraying Lisbeth, and these films were released relatively close together. While some viewers might assume these films form one extended series, this isn’t accurate. To determine the right starting point for watching these movies, a bit of research is required, as each film features a different lead actress.

Noomi Rapace Played Lisbeth Salander In The Swedish Millennium Trilogy Movies

All Three Noomi Rapace Movies Were Released In 2009

Initially, Stieg Larsson submitted the manuscripts for his original three-book series collectively, right before his death in 2004. Consequently, the first three volumes are frequently regarded as the peak period of the Millennium series, despite it now being widely known by that name. It took a few years after that for these books to be transformed into films. A collaboration of Swedish production companies was responsible for adapting the novels, and all three movies were released in 2009. Noomi Rapace portrayed Lisbeth Salander in this trilogy.

Noomi Rapace’s Millenium Trilogy Movies Rotten Tomatoes Score
Movie Year IMDb Score
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 2009 85%
The Girl Who Played with Fire 2009 69%
The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets’ Nest 2009 53%

During those movies, Rapace kept the original Swedish from the books, which isn’t something later adaptations by other studios followed. Moreover, she was the initial actress to portray Lisbeth Salander in live-action and is currently the only one who has repeated the role so far. She featured in the entire Swedish Millennium trilogy, and these films were edited to form a six-episode miniseries titled Millennium in 2010. This was quite an intense time for Rapace because of the continuous shooting and release schedules, but her dedication has left an indelible mark, making her iconic as the punk hacker.

Rooney Mara Played Lisbeth Salander In David Ficher’s The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo

Mara Starred Alongside Daniel Craig’s Mikael Blomkvist In 2011

In 2011, a new adaptation of Stieg Larsson’s first book, “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo,” was unveiled, only two years after the complete Swedish film trilogy had been premiered. Given the quick succession of productions, it was theoretically possible for Noomi Rapace to reprise her role as Salander. However, director David Fincher opted for a different choice in casting the lead character. Instead, Rooney Mara took over the role, sharing the screen with Daniel Craig portraying Mikael Blomkvist.

Even though the praise and solid box office earnings suggested a sequel, director David Fincher never took on the challenge to continue his Swedish contemporaries’ work by adapting “The Girl Who Played with Fire,” Stieg Larsson’s second book. Consequently, neither Daniel Craig nor Rooney Mara reprised their roles for the sequel or its subsequent installment, making this specific portrayal of Lisbeth Salander a standalone production.

Claire Foy Took Over As Lisbeth Salander In 2018’s The Girl In The Spider’s Web (After Skipping 2 Books)

Foy’s Movie Was The First Non-Larsson Adaptation From The Millennium Series

Time elapsed without advancement on Fincher’s delayed second Millennium film, but eventually it was decided to change directors from Fincher to Fede Álvarez for the sequel. Coincidentally, Mara was also replaced with Claire Foy taking over as Lisbeth Salander in 2018’s “The Girl in the Spider’s Web”. This movie dared to skip over both “The Girl Who Played with Fire” and “The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets’ Nest”, venturing beyond Stieg Larsson’s original works and into David Lagercrantz’s subsequent novels.

In 2018, “The Girl in the Spider’s Web” was a reboot of the series that occurred prior to its premiere. Although you didn’t need to watch David Fincher’s movie to understand this one, they both belonged to the same storyline due to the cast change. Essentially, it was assumed that the events in Fincher’s film transpired, but they didn’t directly impact the plot of this sequel. The unique narrative style may have contributed to its poor performance at the box office and negative critical reception. Regrettably, like Rooney Mara, Foy never got another chance to portray Salander.

Why Noomi Rapace’s Lisbeth Salander Is The Best Live-Action Version Of The Character

Rapace Benefited From Having The Opportunity To Play Out Lisbeth’s Entire Millennium Trilogy Arc

Among the three actresses who have portrayed Lisbeth Salander, each has uniquely shaped the character; however, it would be misleading to rank anyone but the original interpreter at the top in a discussion about who played it best. While Mara and Foy shone brilliantly in their films, Rapace had the edge due to her ability to enact Salander’s entire development from the initial three Stieg Larsson novels. Her portrayal of the character felt the most genuine and remained truest to the source material.

Despite the fact that Mara played Salander in the standalone story of “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo,” the subsequent journeys of the character in the following two books are crucial to her growth, which means Mara missed an opportunity to further explore the arc. Similarly, Foy’s time as Salander might have been more fulfilling if her film had been more successful and she could have reprised her role in adaptations of the other Lagercrantz books. Rapace was fortunate in her situation, but it doesn’t negate the fact that she delivered a better portrayal than the other two actresses.

Amazon’s Girl With The Dragon Tattoo Show Means There Will Be A Fourth Lisbeth Salander

Another Salander Actress Should Be Announced Soon

Despite Amazon’s TV adaptation of “The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo” still lacking specifics, the production is confirmed and is expected to begin soon with Veena Sud at the helm. Given that the upcoming reboot aims to distinguish itself from previous attempts, it’s unlikely that any actress who played Lisbeth Salander in the past will be returning for this new version.

Reflecting on the matter at hand, it’s evident that the original actresses are no longer suitable for reprising their roles due to age constraints. The character of Lisbeth Salander, initially portrayed at 24 years old, needs to be accurately represented in Amazon’s upcoming project. Therefore, it seems inevitable that a fresh face will join the roster of actors who have brought Lisbeth Salander to life on screen. If Amazon’s “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” proves successful, the newcomer could very well surpass Noomi Rapace as the iconic embodiment of Stieg Larsson’s legendary character.

Dream Casting For The Fourth Lisbeth

Cailee Spaeny, Maya Hawke, And Others Have Been Suggested

The unveiling of the upcoming TV series remake of “The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo” has sparked much debate among fans, primarily due to the selection of Lisbeth Salander’s new actor. Given the significance of this character, it is evident that fans have strong feelings about who should assume the role next. While some vocal supporters argue that Noomi Rapace’s portrayal is unparalleled or advocate for Rooney Mara to reprise her part, there have been other intriguing fan-casting proposals.

On the fan-forum MyCast, there’s a strong suggestion that Cailee Spaeny should be cast as Lisbeth in an upcoming project. Spaeny, a rising star, has garnered attention for her impressive performances in films like “Civil War” and “Priscilla.” However, it was her gritty portrayal in “Alien: Romulus” that truly showcased her talent and makes her the top contender to play the tough heroine of this series.

Among the potential candidates suggested by MyCast for the leading role are a number of young talents making waves in Tinseltown. With the final season of ‘Stranger Things’ on the horizon, speculation abounds that Natalia Dyer might break free from her character Nancy Wheeler and take on Lisbeth. Additionally, Maya Hawke, another Stranger Things alum, is being considered as a possibility. Moreover, Hailee Steinfeld, Jenna Ortega, Thomasin McKenzie, and Anya Taylor-Joy are also popular choices for the role.

Among the robust options for portraying the heroine in “Girl with the Dragon Tattoo,” there are some intriguing, unconventional suggestions that could potentially excel. For instance, one Reddit user advocates Aubrey Plaza for the character. Additionally, Margaret Qualley has gained recognition following her powerful acting in “The Substance,” and recent Academy Award winner Mikey Madison’s exceptional performance in “Anora” adds weight to her casting consideration.

Read More

2025-04-19 14:20