Elrond’s Family Tree Hides a Forgotten Genius Nobody in Middle-earth Listened To

by

Elrond, despite being called Half-elven, had a much more intricate lineage than that title suggested. Neither of his parents were human; instead, his paternal grandfather, Tuor, and maternal great-grandfather, Beren, were human, making Elrond just over one-third human genetically. Additionally, Elrond’s family tree was not limited to Elves and Men, as his great-great-grandmother, Melian, was a Maia – a type of divine spirit like the Wizards, Balrogs, and even Sauron, the Dark Lord. J.R.R. Tolkien briefly mentioned Melian in the novel version of The Lord of the Rings, but she had a more significant role in The Silmarillion, which delved into Middle-earth’s ancient history.

In the realm of the Maiar, Melian stood out as an extraordinary being, even by their lofty standards. As described in “Of Thingol and Melian,” she was not only beautiful but also wise beyond measure, possessing an unparalleled skill in enchanting songs. Her wisdom stemmed from her ability to foresee future events, a gift that few possessed. Interestingly, Melian was the only known Maia in Tolkien’s legendarium to marry and bear children. One might assume that such a powerful, foresightful queen would be able to shield her kingdom and loved ones from harm. However, a recurring theme in “The Silmarillion” is that Melian’s counsel was often disregarded, with tragic consequences for those who ignored it.

Galadriel Confessed the Noldor Clan’s Crimes to Melian

Melian and Thingol first encountered each other during the Ages of the Trees prior to the start of the First Age in Middle-earth. At that time, Morgoth, Sauron’s master and the Dark Lord, was confined in the Everlasting Lands, keeping the world relatively tranquil. However, Melian foresaw that the tranquility of Arda would not endure forever. She warned Thingol that Morgoth would resume his wicked ways as soon as his imprisonment ended, suggesting they reinforce their kingdom’s defenses. This was the only time in The Silmarillion that a character heeded Melian’s counsel. With the Dwarves’ assistance from the mountains, Thingol constructed Menegroth, an underground city that combined fortification with concealment. Menegroth served as a sanctuary for Elves, including Thingol and his kin. True to Melian’s prediction, Morgoth’s tyranny resumed upon his release, and he reclaimed the enchanted gems called Silmarils before returning to Middle-earth. Even in the face of Morgoth’s darkness, Menegroth remained steadfast.

After Morgoth’s departure, numerous Elves from the Noldor lineage embarked on a voyage to Middle-earth with the intention of reclaiming the Silmarils and exacting vengeance against Morgoth. This group included Galadriel, a character known from ‘The Lord of the Rings’, along with her brothers Finrod and Angrod. Following significant events such as the Kinslaying, which resulted in their exile from the Undying Lands, they were forbidden to return unless they repented for their wrongdoings. Galadriel and her family members had no direct involvement in the Kinslaying, yet they endured the repercussions of their kin’s actions, feeling remorseful about their failure to halt the senseless violence. To conceal their true purpose, they asserted that they were emissaries of the Valar.

Galadriel and her siblings initially resided in Menegroth for a while, receiving a warm welcome. However, Melian, a powerful Maia, expressed concern about their claim. In a private conversation with Galadriel, she suggested revealing the truth to Thingol, ensuring transparency between them. But Galadriel felt too ashamed to disclose the reason for their arrival in Middle-earth. In essence, Melian advocated for honesty and openness between Galadriel and Thingol. However, Galadriel’s shame prevented her from divulging the truth at that time.

In the part titled “The Noldor in Beleriand,” it’s mentioned that Thingol discovered the history of the Noldor through malicious gossip: “It didn’t take long for stories about the Noldor’s past to circulate among the Sindar. It was clear where they originated, and the dark truth was distorted further by lies.” Thingol was infuriated when he found out that his guests had concealed information about the Kinslaying from him, given that his people were related to the Teleri. When he confronted Galadriel’s brothers over this matter, Angrod reacted imprudently, taking offense at being associated with the Kinslayers. Thingol expelled Finrod and Angrod from his presence, refused to collaborate with the Noldor, and showed hostility towards them. Had Galadriel been truthful with Thingol from the start, as suggested by Melian, he probably would have responded more sympathetically.

Ignoring Melian’s Advice Led to Certain Death for The Silmarillion’s Characters

In the tale of “Túrin Turambar,” Thingol welcomed a young man who eventually became like a son to him. When Túrin was taken prisoner by Orcs, his companion Beleg Strongbow embarked on a mission to save him. Thingol granted Beleg permission to choose any weapon that he felt would aid him in his endeavor. Beleg opted for Anglachel, a sword forged from a meteorite by the elusive Eöl the Dark Elf. Melian cautioned Beleg about Anglachel’s curse, “There is evil within this blade. The malevolent spirit of its maker lingers there. It will not serve nor protect the hand that wields it; it will not stay with you for long.” Yet, as long as it was effective against Orcs, Beleg disregarded the potential dangers. As Melian foretold, Anglachel ultimately led to Beleg’s demise. In his delirium after being captured, Túrin mistook Beleg for an Orc and used Anglachel to kill him. Had Beleg chosen any other weapon besides the one Melian warned against, he may have survived his rescue attempt.

In “Of Beren and Lúthien,” Tolkien narrates that Thingol, a powerful Elven king, had a daughter named Lúthien who fell in love with Beren, a mortal man. Thingol was against their union, so he set an impossible task for Beren to complete before agreeing to the marriage. Melian, another powerful elf and Thingol’s wife, advised him not to let his anger dictate his decision-making, but her advice fell on deaf ears. After Beren departed, Melian warned her husband that if he failed in his mission or succeeded, both Lúthien and Thingol himself were doomed. If Beren failed, Thingol would lose his daughter; if he succeeded, the realm of Doriath would be drawn into a greater conflict. True to form, Beren completed the task, but not without great hardship. He lost a hand and later succumbed to his injuries, prompting Lúthien to give up her mortality to revive him. However, this did not bring peace to Thingol, as the Silmaril made Doriath a target for other realms. Despite Melian’s pleas, Thingol refused to relinquish the Silmaril and commissioned the Dwarves of the Blue Mountains to craft it into a beautiful necklace called Nauglamír. Unsurprisingly, the dwarves murdered Thingol in their pursuit of the Silmaril, leading to the destruction of Menegroth, Thingol’s capital city.

Elrond Inherited the Gift of Foresight From Melian

  • Melian’s name meant “Dear Gift” in the Elvish language of Sindarin.
  • Melian was associated with birds, specifically nightingales, whom she taught to sing.
  • In the episode “Doomed to Die” from Prime Video’s The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, Adar told Elrond, “You have the beauty of your foremother, Melian of the Valar. If even a fragment of her wisdom is in your veins, you must know you cannot defeat me.”

Over time, Melian became increasingly frustrated as her wisdom seemed to be disregarded by all around her. In “Of Beren and Lúthien,” there came a moment when Thingol sought counsel, and at this juncture, Melian chose not to share her insights with him, stating that the fate he had set in motion should run its course and that he must now trust time. By the end of the First Age, Melian was no longer present, so she could not participate in the War of the Ring, a conflict during which it’s doubtful anyone would have heeded her advice regardless.

Looking on the positive note, the ability to see into the future was inherited by her great-great-grandson, and in Peter Jackson’s movie versions, even her great-great-great-granddaughter shared this gift. The protagonists of “The Lord of the Rings” were not as clouded by arrogance like Thingol or a young Galadriel, so they were receptive to Elrond’s counsel. The Fellowship concurred with his judgment that the One Ring must be destroyed, and it was through executing Elrond’s strategy that they managed to free the world from Sauron’s oppression.

Read More

2025-05-03 06:11