Is Criminal Minds Evolution Setting Up a Shocking Prentiss & JJ Romance?

by

Attention: Potential Plot Reveals for Criminal Minds: Evolution Season 3, Episode 5.
In its quest to distinguish itself from the original series, Criminal Minds: Evolution might be introducing a significant shift in the relationship between JJ and Emily. Introduced as regular cast members in season 2 (Emily Prentiss, played by Paget Brewster) and since the pilot episode (Jennifer “JJ” Jareau, portrayed by A.J. Cook), these two characters formed a strong bond within the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit. Over the years, they have been instrumental in taking down numerous dangerous criminals and predators, but their personal lives have also evolved significantly. Notably, Emily faked her death in Criminal Minds season 6, and JJ got married to Will LaMontagne (Josh Stewart) in season 7.

In contrast to the earlier seasons of Criminal Minds, where the unsettling stories of the unsubs often overshadowed the personal narratives, Criminal Minds: Evolution has a more even balance in storytelling between the heroes and villains. This revival provides fresh conflicts and opportunities to revisit old plots with a new perspective. New characters such as Tyler Green (Ryan-James Hatanaka) and Rebecca Wilson (Nicole Pacent) join the team, while original members like David Rossi (Joe Mantegna), Penelope Garcia (Kirsten Vangsness), Luke Alvez (Adam Rodriguez), and Tara Lewis (Aisha Tyler) add depth to their characters in unexpected ways.

Prentiss’ Reason For Breaking Up With Mendoza Has Ties To JJ Explained

The Agents Broke Up Prior To The Events Of Criminal Minds: Evolution

In the TV series “Criminal Minds: Evolution”, certain characters who were previously present suddenly vanished without any clear explanation. One of these characters is Andrew Mendoza, who was Emily’s ex-boyfriend and appeared in seasons 14 and 15 of “Criminal Minds”. After the season 15 finale, Mendoza was never seen again, and the reason for his absence from the continuation remained unexplained. However, in a recent development, Emily reveals the cause of their off-screen breakup: Mendoza repeatedly pressed for a threesome, which eventually led to Emily ending their relationship.

In the fifth episode of season 3 of “Criminal Minds: Evolution”, the narrative progresses as JJ probes further, causing Emily to hint that JJ could have potentially joined their trio. Although Emily does not explicitly state this, she responds with “We never got that far” when JJ asks if she was their third option. The purpose of this conversation is to discourage JJ from using work as a means to escape her pain, but instead leaves the audience pondering: why would JJ be considered for Emily and Mendoza’s hypothetical threesome?

JJ Being Mendoza’s Personal Choice For His Proposed Threesome Doesn’t Make Sense

Mendoza’s Late Arrival Makes JJ’s Hypothetical Involvement Confusing

In the TV series Criminal Minds, it seemed unusual that Mendoza, a new character, would propose JJ as an extramarital partner given the long-standing and deep relationship between Will and JJ. This suggests that JJ’s involvement in a threesome fantasy might have been linked directly to Emily, potentially leading to significant consequences for their future. If Mendoza had wanted to involve someone else from the team, it would have made more sense for him to suggest one of Emily’s single colleagues, like Penelope, rather than JJ.

It’s plausible that Mendoza asked Emily about the woman she’d feel most at ease with, and it’s possible Emily picked JJ because of their strong friendship. Similarly, Mendoza might have noticed their close bond and suggested JJ to help Emily consider a threesome. Whatever the case may be, Emily’s selection of JJ as a potential sexual partner could hint at emotions for her best friend that go beyond simple friendship. The show “Criminal Minds: Evolution” might delve deeper into this and reveal Emily’s romantic feelings or keep them as merely passionate, but this revelation could have significant implications.

Can Prentiss & JJ Actually Be A Couple In Criminal Minds: Evolution?

“Jemily” Is Not A New Concept

In the series Criminal Minds: Evolution, there were hints that characters JJ and Emily (often referred to as “Jemily”) might develop a romantic relationship. However, just because this was suggested in the earlier stages doesn’t necessarily mean it will be explored further in the revival.

For example, in the original Criminal Minds series, there was a love triangle involving Penelope, Tyler, and Luke that lasted for several seasons. Interestingly, this dynamic has been completely disregarded in season 3 of Criminal Minds: Evolution.

Similarly, in the final season of Criminal Minds, Matthew Gray Gubler’s character Spencer Reid had a storyline about his feelings for JJ. However, these romantic overtures were not reciprocated at that time. In a twist, Criminal Minds: Evolution has chosen to overlook any potential romance between JJ and Reid.

To put it another way, if they were planning a deeply emotional love story involving redemption, there’s no doubt that JJ and Emily would be their top choices. Since the initial airing of Criminal Minds, these two characters have shared one of the strongest bonds within the team, with JJ being the only one who knew about Emily’s secret alive status during her “death” arc. With Will’s demise in Criminal Minds: Evolution season 3 leaving JJ a widow, it also means that Emily is now in a position to assist JJ as she navigates through her grieving process.

As a devoted fan of Criminal Minds: Evolution, I can’t help but ponder over the intriguing dynamics between JJ and Emily. Their connection seems ripe with potential, and if they were to acknowledge their feelings and grapple with the decision to act upon them, it would undoubtedly inject a compelling undercurrent of tension into the narrative.

Furthermore, developing their friendship into a gradual, smoldering romance could be a masterful move, providing the perfect canvas for the show to delve into what fans have longed for since Emily’s initial appearance. It would offer a fresh perspective on their relationship and introduce new challenges that would enrich their storylines and keep viewers hooked.

What A Possible Romance Between Prentiss & JJ Means For Criminal Minds & The BAU?

Evolution Would Have A New Love Story To Root For

While there’s an opportunity to explore a romantic relationship between JJ and Emily in “Criminal Minds: Evolution”, it wouldn’t come without complications. Given that Emily is JJ’s superior, their potential romance could create a complex power dynamic. Even if they held equal positions within the FBI, a relationship between them would significantly alter the dynamics of the team in “Criminal Minds: Evolution”. Just as the split between Tara and Rebecca presented unique hurdles for the BAU in season 1, two members of the team dating could be risky.

If Emily and JJ were to date and part ways amicably, they are experienced enough to ensure their personal issues don’t affect their work on the Behavioral Analysis Unit (BAU). However, their friendship could be irrevocably changed if they attempt a deeper relationship and fail. It might be prudent for Criminal Minds: Evolution to maintain them as friends rather than romantic partners, but there’s undeniable chemistry between them that could make a romantic plot compelling. Such a romance could bring fresh dynamics to Criminal Minds: Evolution, albeit with potential consequences.

📺 Love keeping up with ScreenRant’s prime-time coverage? Click ‘Sign Up’ below and subscribe to our weekly Network TV newsletter! You’ll receive exclusive behind-the-scenes updates directly from the stars and creators of your favorite shows. Don’t forget to select “Network TV” in your preferences!

Read More

2025-06-07 16:28