10 albums from the 2010s that were critically acclaimed (but extremely overhyped)

In the 2010s, music was less tied to traditional albums and instead became closely linked with significant moments, thanks to the influence of social media and streaming platforms. This shift not only altered how people listened to music but also accelerated their reactions to it. As a result, certain albums were hailed as classics almost immediately after release, often due to viral excitement, dedication from fan bases, and eye-catching events rather than thorough critical appraisal.

As the discussion about music grew more intense, it wasn’t always well-informed, leading to some albums being excessively lauded without thorough scrutiny.

With streaming services revolutionizing the music industry, there’s been a shift in album production – quantity has become more emphasized than quality. Artists and record labels are now focusing on producing longer albums with up to 25 tracks to boost stream numbers. This trend has led to an influx of lengthy, inconsistent projects that temporarily top the charts but fail to make a lasting emotional or creative impression.

10 overrated albums of the 2010s

The collections weren’t always poor quality; they contained popular tracks. However, they tended to be overly expansive or lacking depth, relying excessively on collaborations, fads, or publicity rather than a strong artistic direction.

Ultimately, the celebrity image significantly magnified some albums during this period when the artist’s persona frequently eclipsed their musical talent. In situations where branding took precedence over the music itself, an artist’s personal life or public image could substantially enhance an album’s popularity long before its sound was experienced.

READ MORE: Sammy Hagar almost single-handedly ruins Black Sabbath farewell concert

Consequently, certain projects garnered acclaim due to their creators rather than their quality. Reflecting on this period now, it becomes evident that not all highly anticipated releases from the 2010s were destined for longevity or warranted the exalted position they were given.

DJ Khaled – Grateful (2017)

Brimming with celebrity elements and renowned producers, Grateful seemed to prioritize spectacle over substance. Although it boasted numerous hit singles, the album was criticized for being overly bloated, repetitive, and lacking a consistent narrative voice. It appeared as though it had been assembled primarily for streaming performance rather than storytelling or cohesion.

Sam Smith – In the Lonely Hour (2014)

Sam’s vocal abilities are indisputable, yet his debut seemed excessively reliant on overused heartbreak tropes. Despite the massive success of “Stay With Me,” the album tended to be emotionally redundant and limited in terms of style.

Justin Timberlake – The 20/20 Experience (1 of 2) (2013)

Presented as a sophisticated, artistic rebound, this album garnered extensive early acclaim. However, beneath its grandiose production, it was weighed down by excessively lengthy tracks and failed to recapture the magic of Justin Timberlake’s earlier chart-toppers.

Macklemore & Ryan Lewis – The Heist (2012)

A Grammy win over Kendrick Lamar’s good kid, m.A.A.d city speaks volumes. The Heist had a strong appeal on the radio, but its superficial commentary and contrived emotions didn’t withstand scrutiny from critics.

Lana Del Rey – Born to Die (2012)

In a unique turn of events, Lana’s style served as a model, yet the tunes in her initial release frequently failed to align with the atmosphere she was promoting. Although it garnered a devoted fanbase, the album came across as excessively polished and devoid of emotional connection.

Childish Gambino – Because the Internet (2013)

Certainly imaginative, yet perhaps excessively lauded. Ambitious in idea, but flawed in execution, resulting in an inconsistent outcome. The praise is more frequently directed towards its intended form rather than its actual achievement.

Ed Sheeran – ÷ (Divide) (2017)

The album “Divide,” with smash hits such as “Shape of You,” sold exceptionally well, yet its songwriting relied heavily on unoriginal structures and recurring topics. Despite being ubiquitous, the music tended to play it too safe musically.

The Weeknd – Starboy (2016)

Regardless of its polished presentation and collaborations with Daft Punk, Starboy seemed to fall short in terms of emotional depth compared to Beauty Behind the Madness. Instead of feeling like a cohesive album, it came across as more of an attempt to rebrand rather than a fully fleshed-out musical piece.

Lorde – Melodrama (2017)

Some people praised the album “Melodrama” as a masterpiece, yet its sparse style and symbolic song lyrics didn’t resonate with everyone. Although it was musically intriguing, it tended to focus too much on atmosphere and not enough on actual melodies.

Travis Scott – Astroworld (2018)

The performance was remarkable, yet at times, “Astroworld” seemed less like a complete album and more about setting a mood or vibe. It appeared to be short on deep lyrics and leaned heavily on featured artists, giving it the feel of a curated playlist rather than a personal expression.

The 2010s were a dynamic yet tumultuous era for music, characterized by visibility over substance and hype that outpaced genuine criticism. Many albums we recall as “defining” were more symbolic of the moment than the actual music. They gained prominence due to marketing strategies, viral sensations, and fan enthusiasm rather than originality or harmony.

While it’s important to note that these artists certainly weren’t devoid of skill, in fact, quite the opposite, their most renowned pieces often didn’t stand as their best work. A second listen with a fresh perspective makes this clear. Popularity and accolades don’t necessarily define an artist’s lasting impact. Over time, some works can lose their shine as the noise dies down – and that’s perfectly fine.

The focus shifts towards honoring albums with lasting value due to their depth rather than their popularity or fame.

2025-07-10 13:00