As a dedicated fan of mystery and crime shows, I’ve seen my fair share of whodunits that promise more than they deliver. But “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” on Netflix was an enjoyable surprise, even if it wasn’t perfect. Based on Holly Jackson’s novel, this six-episode series from the BBC had me hooked from the very first scene.
Netflix’s collection of streaming content includes a abundance of murder mysteries, crime shows, and whodunits. So, it was likely just another addition to their lineup for Netflix’s executives when they acquired the international rights to the BBC’s six-episode series “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.” This show premiered in the U.K. about a month ago and is based on Holly Jackson’s novel of the same name. The adaptation, created by Poppy Cogan, aligns perfectly with Netflix’s preferences: a brief and addictive whodunit centered around high-school students that focuses more on intriguing plot twists than character development. With forgettable characters but an appealing melancholic atmosphere, complicated relationships, and a captivating murder investigation that grows increasingly complex with each episode, it offers a lighter version of true crime for the summer season.
In the small English town of Little Kilton, lives 17-year-old student Pippa “Pip” Fitz-Amobi, better known as Wednesday’s werewolf Emma Myers. Five years ago, the mysterious death of local beauty Andie Bell, whose body was never found, and her boyfriend Sal Singh, who later took his own life, left the town in shock. With doubts lingering about the case, Pip uses a school project as an excuse to delve deeper into the unsolved mystery. The inconsistencies include Andie’s missing corpse and Sal’s questionable testimony, which seems insincere given his reputation as a kind and gentle person. As a close acquaintance of both Andie and Sal, Pip is convinced of Sal’s innocence. To uncover the truth, she contacts Sal’s brother, Ravi, and they embark on a journey to piece together what truly transpired between the tragic couple while developing feelings for each other along the way.
Little room for characterization
“A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” faces a challenge in striking the right balance between being lighthearted and serious. However, it falls short in delivering both effectively. Shows like “Pretty Little Liars,” “13 Reasons Why,” and “Looking for Alaska” successfully achieved this tone without appearing contrived or exaggerated. Unfortunately, the characters in “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” often come across as one-dimensional and flat. While some of this can be attributed to the script’s focus on plot over character development, the actors’ inexperience also contributes to underdeveloped performances.”
Despite playing the main role as Emma Myers’ fragile and delicate Pip, it’s challenging to believe she could perform the thrilling stunts depicted in the series in real life. Additionally, Myers and Zain Iqbal exhibit little romantic chemistry on screen, resulting in a lackluster and unconvincing intimacy. Unfortunately, many of the supporting actors struggle to leave an impact, their presence on screen feeling average at best. However, if you choose to engage with the story, it’s essential to overlook some of its noticeable flaws.
A strong mystery and soundtrack
Revising the given text,
Without a doubt, “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” shines most when it focuses solely on the intriguing plot twists surrounding the murders and their suspects. The show masterfully keeps viewers guessing by introducing red herrings and puzzling clues that don’t fit initially. From suspicious drug dealers to hidden affairs or elusive police footage of intense interrogations, it’s a challenge to pinpoint the real culprit. Although the writers’ tactics may not be subtle, the pleasure lies in pondering how these deceiving elements contribute to the overall storyline. Kudos to the writers for skillfully tying up every seemingly loose end that turns out to be crucial by the end of the six episodes.
The program delicately explores complex issues like drug addiction, infidelity, statutory rape, and homicide. While the murder investigation is undeniably the main attraction, it never crosses the line into exploitation or distastefulness. Instead, every character receives a thoughtful examination and adequate screen time, allowing viewers to form their own opinions. Even seemingly insignificant details play crucial roles in solving the puzzle. Ultimately, like many mystery shows, getting the story right is key, and “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” manages to do just that, despite its challenges.
Season 1 of “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” hits Netflix on August 1.
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-07-25 20:30