After Re-Watching Scream, I Need To Talk About Matthew Lillard’s Stu And The Theories About His Death

by

After years of watching horror films and countless discussions with fellow enthusiasts, I’ve come to appreciate the unpredictable nature of these stories. And let me tell you, there’s nothing more intriguing than the possibility of a character’s return, even after seemingly meeting their untimely end.

At the close of the film “Scream”, Billy Loomis is undeniably killed by Sidney, receiving a fatal gunshot wound to the head. However, there’s some uncertainty about the fate of his accomplice Stu Macher. Although he was stabbed and hit by a falling TV, it leaves one wondering if he might have somehow survived after re-watching this terrifying movie classic.

Let’s explore the question surrounding whether Matthew Lillard’s character actually perished or not, as it seems intriguing enough for us to delve into the details.

I Can’t Believe I Didn’t Give Stu’s Fate A Second Thought After Watching Scream The First Time

Approximately a year back, I experienced “Scream” for the first time, and during this autumn season, my peers and I opted to stream it using Max subscription due to its fitting theme for Halloween. Unlike my initial viewing, where I was consistently startled by the film’s unexpected twists and turns, this time I managed to maintain a more analytical perspective throughout. This allowed me to better absorb and critically evaluate every aspect of the movie.

At the conclusion of the movie, it became evident that Stu’s ultimate outcome remained uncertain. After all, as the saying goes, if a character in a thriller or horror film doesn’t meet their demise on screen, there’s always a possibility they might still be alive.

While it’s generally unusual for a character like the Ghostface Killer to resurrect or survive in their movies, I must admit there’s something intriguing about bringing back Matthew Lillard’s wild character. Upon reflection, I believe there could be a way to make it happen.

It turns out, there’s a significant discussion and numerous interpretations surrounding the final outcome of Stu, a topic that both the actor portraying him and the scriptwriter responsible for his character have their own perspectives on.

Matthew Lillard Thinks Stu Is Still Alive, And There Are Theories Floating Around That He Is

Through time, numerous theories and discussions have emerged about whether Stu survived the events from the original Scream. This topic was even acknowledged in Scream 6 , as Kirby examined a shattered TV that had been on his head, and she questioned his death. In response, Mindy simply said, “If you think he’s dead.

Some people argue that Stu didn’t really die, as there was a plan, according to The Daily Beast, to bring him back as the mastermind of the killer cult in Scream 3. Additionally, the actor who plays Stu made a brief appearance in Scream 2, hidden in the background of a scene. As a result, some fans speculate that he’s been alive all this time and has managed to stay out of sight. Although it seems unlikely, it wouldn’t be surprising if the franchise decided to do something like this, and Matthew Lillard enjoys fueling the rumors.

Over the years, questions about the actor reprising his role as Stu have been frequent. Lately, he’s gone ahead and made a strong declaration regarding his character, stating on Drew Barrymore’s talk show (as reported by Bloody Disgusting) that he “absolutely” believes his character is still alive, expressing his readiness to return if it aligns with the franchise’s continuity.

He’s held that stance for a long time as well. Back in 2020, the actor humorously took to X to post:

I mean… it was just a TV? Right? You’d think he’d SURVIVE?

Currently, my coworker Ryan LaBee firmly believes Stu will rejoin the cast for “Scream 7”. Despite rumors suggesting his character’s demise, he posits that considering the challenges the sequel has encountered, including another legacy cast member could be beneficial. Furthermore, when discussing this possibility with Game Spot, Lillard humorously hinted at returning and then stated:

Indeed, I’m not featured in the film. In fact, should the occasion arise where I might appear, I wouldn’t hesitate to tell you a white lie right to your face. Until its release, rest assured that I’d continue to spin tales to keep you guessing.

It’s quite a puzzle: Is he faking his death or is Stu truly deceased? Frankly, it can be tricky; actors often mislead about their roles to preserve secrets, so the situation remains uncertain. Yet, I must admit that there seems to be compelling proof pointing towards him having perished decades back. On the other hand, I’d love for this legendary figure to resurface, but the evidence is quite persuasive.

However, Many, Including Kevin Williamson, Believe Stu Is Dead

Despite the ongoing excitement and speculation fueled by Matthew Lillard’s performance, as well as fun theories about his character, Scream’s screenwriter Kevin Williamson definitively clarified in 2022 that Stu is indeed deceased. He made this confirmation emphatically.

Indeed, he’s not alive anymore. It seems his demise might be connected to the university lifestyle, particularly the fraternity parties, as he was often present in the periphery. That evening, he had just dropped by the filming location.

Indeed, this seems to be corroborating evidence. Moreover, the idea that the villain from the TV show could survive being stabbed and shocked by an electric television is rather challenging to the notion that he’s still alive. However, there’s additional evidence to support the claim. As Game Rant reports, there’s a prolonged shot in Scream 6 featuring photographs, one of which indicates Stu’s death in 1996.

Moreover, numerous individuals on Reddit strongly believe that the character in question is deceased, as evidenced by the impassioned post from Ghostface215.

As a gamer, I can’t help but think back to that intense moment when Billy almost took me down with those deep, grueling stabs. It feels like just yesterday I was lying there, feeling my life ebb away due to those wounds. Even I could sense my own mortality, gasping for breath and struggling to stay alive. But in a desperate bid to survive, I summoned every last ounce of adrenaline, attempting to bring down Sidney. Alas, I fell short, and if not for the TV incident that unfolded later, I would have bled out regardless.

In a logical turn of events, it appears more plausible that Stuart met his end that fateful night instead of surviving. The circumstances surrounding the original “Scream” movie suggest as much, and the imagery in “Scream 6” further solidifies this theory by hinting at Stu’s demise within the franchise’s narrative.

Despite the assumption that he might be deceased, it’s worth considering that he could potentially return to life. After all, we witnessed Billy returning as a ghost in both “Scream” (2022) and “Scream VI”, demonstrating that characters like Matthew Lillard’s could indeed reappear, regardless of whether you think his character is still alive or not.

Speaking for myself, after enjoying Lillard’s performance even more upon re-watching the movie “Scream”, I can’t help but express my hope for Stu’s return in this series somehow. Moreover, it would certainly amplify the anticipation if he were to make a comeback in “Scream 7”, especially since Kevin Williamson is at the helm of its direction. However, as the actor has pointed out, any return should be executed thoughtfully so that it benefits the franchise.

Back in 1996, my gameplay was legendary, unforgettable. If I’m coming back, I need to make an entrance worthy of that iconic status – just like the original movie!

Read More

2024-11-03 23:42