Agatha All Along Review: A Supernatural Snoozer Kathryn Hahn Can’t Save

Agatha All Along Review: A Supernatural Snoozer Kathryn Hahn Can't Save

As a seasoned gamer with a soft spot for Marvel shows and a knack for deciphering narrative twists, I must confess that “Agatha All Along” left me a tad puzzled. Don’t get me wrong; I was intrigued by Agatha in WandaVision, but the spin-off felt like an attempt to stretch a one-trick pony too far.


Agatha All Along” is a spin-off of my beloved Marvel series on Disney+, “WandaVision”. However, it’s not Agatha (Kathryn Hahn) herself that I found captivating in the show, but rather the character she portrayed, Agnes, within Wanda’s (Elizabeth Olsen) and Vision’s (Paul Bettany) world. Consequently, when I heard about a spin-off focusing on Agatha, my initial reaction was apprehensive. After all, Agatha is a complex character: an ancient witch who mastered dark magic until losing it all to Wanda. But how could they develop this character enough for a whole series? With my tepid feelings towards Agatha and the decline in quality I’ve noticed in Marvel’s Disney+ shows recently, my doubts were abundant. In the first four out of nine episodes released for critics, my concerns were largely validated, albeit with some significant exceptions.

Initially, Agatha All Along introduces us to Agatha in her Agnes character, yet characters like “Teen” (Joe Locke) subtly hint for her to change this persona. However, Agnes remains oblivious. This pattern continues until approximately two-thirds into the first episode, where a remarkable scene unfolds that echoes her personas from WandaVision. From then on, the series adopts a more traditional Marvel format – as traditional as a series about witches can be.

Agatha manages to persuade Rio Vidal, the sorceress set to end her life, to postpone their encounter until she regains her magical abilities, as it promises a more thrilling experience. Subsequently, she gathers four witches – Jennifer Kale (Sasheer Zamata), Alice Wu-Gulliver (Ali Ahn), and Lilia Calderu (Patti LuPone) – along with one unaware woman, Sharon Davis (Debra Jo Rupp, famously known as “Mrs. Hart” from “WandaVision”) to embark on the Witches’ Journey with her.

It appears she has several objectives: one involves attempting to seize powers from her fellow witches, though this might not succeed given Lilia’s warning to the others; secondly, she intends to fulfill her heart’s desire by traversing the Witches’ Road, a journey that could be fatal for all involved. This is where the story stands at the end of Episode 4.

The story is only so-so

Agatha All Along Review: A Supernatural Snoozer Kathryn Hahn Can't Save

In the opening scene of the premiere episode, it’s striking how Agatha appears convinced she’s a detective solving murders. The atmosphere is gloomy, with muted visuals hinting at a world turned upside down. However, the similarities to “WandaVision” are noticeable, so changes might be necessary. Yet, the necessity for Agatha to collaborate with new witches and weave their tales into the narrative seems like a classic Marvel approach, where multiple stories intertwine.

As someone not well-versed in Agatha’s comic book adventures, I can’t say for certain about the Witches’ Road. But, it’s intriguing that it’s being introduced now on our screens for the first time. Given Wanda’s long-standing role in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, this new element feels somewhat unexpected.

In addition, it seems we must delve into the pasts of these other witches, even though our initial feelings might not compel us to do so. Yet, I found myself intrigued by the storylines surrounding Alice’s mother and Jennifer’s latent powers as they navigate the challenges presented by the Witches’ Path. This underscores the skill of the actors and writers, particularly Jac Schaeffer who has been instrumental in creating “WandaVision” and “Agatha All Along,” in developing characters that provoke empathy.

Despite its appeal, it’s challenging not to feel frustrated with the contrived nature of the plot’s mechanics. The Witches’ Road functions as an almost perfect MacGuffin, and this series, like many contemporary Marvel productions, seems to overlook attempts at making the narrative feel more authentic within the storyline. Yes, Agatha is a potent witch, but she typically operates independently, making the plot seem contrived. Furthermore, Rio’s decision to let Agatha live in the initial episode adds an element of absurdity to the entire scenario.

Fantastic production values and acting

Agatha All Along Review: A Supernatural Snoozer Kathryn Hahn Can't Save

Regardless of certain problems mentioned earlier, there are indeed captivating aspects to “Agatha All Along.” For instance, the quality of production is remarkable. The camera work, credited to Caleb Heymann, Jon Chema, and Isiah Donte Lee, is superb, particularly as characters transition between various settings – initially the Agnes cop show, then the brooding Witches’ Road, and eventually diverse homes – each symbolizing a trial. The lighting also effectively highlights the differences in the witches’ hallucinations when they are drugged within one residence. Moreover, the production design by John Collins, along with the costumes by Daniel Selon, contribute significantly to this magical experience.

The acting also keeps up with these changes. While Kathryn Hahn leads the cast with an assured performance, she’s matched by Debra Jo Rupp, Sasheer Zamata, Ali Ahn, Patti LuPone, and Joe Locke, who each do a great job bringing their slippery characters to life. And as she did in “Legion,” Aubrey Plaza as Rio, the most enigmatic witch of them all, can play all sides of a character, including the very creepy, so well that she almost sells the idea she let Agatha live because of some internal character dynamics instead of a script imperative.

While “Agatha All Along” didn’t stir intense affection in me, neither did it provoke outright dislike. The plot, I feel, is rather slim and appears overly engineered to captivate viewers. However, it was engaging enough for me to continue watching. I’m intrigued to see where the story goes next, particularly since another witch trial seems imminent, promising a fresh house and setting. Additionally, there seem to be hints of a past connection between Agatha and Rio that I’m eager to uncover. Yet, I remain undecided as to whether this show is merely a collection of excellent elements that fail to equate to more than the sum of their parts. Only the unfolding events will reveal the truth.

Agatha All Along starts off with a double premiere on Wednesday, September 18th, followed by one new episode each week on Wednesdays, concluding with a two-episode finale on October 30th.

Read More

2024-09-19 06:30