Arrival: Villeneuve’s Sci-Fi Masterpiece Before Dune 2

by

Quick Links

  • ‘Arrival’ Is a Unique Alien Invasion Film
  • The Critical Response to ‘Arrival’

In the ongoing captivation of Denis Villeneuve’s masterpiece “Dune: Part Two”, it’s valuable to reconsider arguably his most impressive science fiction story yet. Although “Blade Runner 2049” is an outstanding cinematic accomplishment on its own, it can never eclipse the impact of Ridley Scott’s groundbreaking original. Instead, the thought-provoking, high-budget art-house sci-fi film “Arrival” remains Villeneuve’s most significant career milestone to date.

Eight years before adapting Frank Herbert’s expansive Dune, Denis Villeneuve’s Arrival stands among the greatest films about aliens landing on Earth. Unlike conventional alien invasion stories where humans battle extraterrestrial adversaries in a straightforward good versus evil conflict, Arrival delves into its theme with nuanced sensitivity, creating an intriguing gray area that raises more questions than it solves definitively. Often considered his most engaging film to watch repeatedly, here’s why Arrival stands out as Denis Villeneuve’s finest science fiction work so far.

‘Arrival’ Is a Unique Alien Invasion Film

Denis Villeneuve, as director, brought Eric Heisserer’s screenplay for the film “Arrival” to life, which was originally a short story by Ted Chiang. The movie revolves around linguist Louise Banks, portrayed by Amy Adams, who is tasked with communicating with an enigmatic extraterrestrial race that has arrived on Earth via various spaceships across the globe. Their arrival incites significant global tension, teetering on the brink of a worldwide conflict.

To avert an impending intergalactic conflict, Louise becomes part of a unique team dedicated to dialoguing with the extraterrestrials to learn about their identity, purpose for visiting Earth, and their objectives, among other things. Over a dozen alien spacecraft are suspended over our planet. In Montana, Louise along with physicist Ian Donnelly (portrayed by Jeremy Renner) scrutinize two of these. Within the spaceships, they uncover beings known as “Heptapods,” which resemble ominous, massive, Lovecraftian-style claws that trigger widespread apprehension.

Although they seemed threatening at first glance, Louise and Ian quickly learn that the Heptapods possess a unique understanding of time and a complex language of their own. Communicating through palindromic phrases and symbolic representations, these aliens eventually instruct Louise in operating their sophisticated technology.

Yet, a linguistic barrier among nations arises due to the Heptapods’ statement about bringing a “tool” or “weapon.” The Chinese misunderstood this as an instruction to “use” the weapon, leading them to consider harming the Heptapods. This misinterpretation sparked international tension. Fortunately, Louise and Ian translate that the Heptapods’ language refers to the tool/weapon they’ve given to humanity, averting a global crisis at the last moment.

The Critical Response to ‘Arrival’

So far, Villeneuve’s highest-rated science fiction film has been Arrival, earning a 94% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes. This is a two-point advantage over the upcoming Dune: Part Two, which currently holds a 92% Certified Fresh rating. Additionally, Arrival has a Metascore of 81, compared to Dune: Part Two’s 79, suggesting greater critical acclaim. Notably, Arrival was recognized with a Best Motion Picture nomination at the 89th Academy Awards, an honor that many anticipate Dune: Part Two will also receive when the 97th Academy Award nominations are announced on January 23, 2025.

On Rotten Tomatoes, Arrival‘s critical consensus beams:

The movie, titled ‘Arrival,’ offers an unmissable experience for enthusiasts of thoughtful science fiction. It skillfully combines profound themes with heartfelt emotions and an outstanding portrayal by Amy Adams.”

Or, more concisely:
“‘Arrival’ is a must-see sci-fi movie, blending deep ideas with genuine emotion and stellar performance from Amy Adams.

In contrast to Denis Villeneuve’s usual sci-fi work, the intellectually stimulating narrative of “Arrival” sets it apart. Initially appearing as a classic alien invasion story, it cleverly avoids every predictable genre trope to unfold as a tale emphasizing understanding, compassion, and interstellar harmony. Instead of relying on sensationalistic thrills, Villeneuve crafts a poignant emotional conclusion about Louise’s painful past, which viewers must engage with actively, offering hope when many similar films focus solely on negativity. As Mark Kermode from “The Observer” highlighted in his glowing review:

Perhaps arrival is the refreshing poem we’ve been seeking; a break from the grim, dystopian images that have started to feel distressingly real, a reminiscence of a future where light continues to illuminate the shadows.

Why ‘Arrival’ Remains Villeneuve’s Best Sci-Fi Film

In a skillful fusion of grand cosmic themes and intimate human emotions, Villeneuve’s ‘Arrival’ stands out among his science fiction works, largely due to its portrayal of Louise’s emotional journey. At the film’s outset, Louise is grappling with the tragic loss of her young daughter Hannah, who succumbed to an incurable illness. As she interacts more closely with the alien Heptapods, Louise finds herself haunted by painful dreams and recollections of Hannah.

When conversing with the Heptapods, Louise understands that mastering their language changes how humans perceive time, making it less sequential. The intricate, circular symbols used by the Heptapods reflect their unusual, non-linear approach to time, allowing them to recall future events as if they were past experiences. In a poignant twist, Villeneuve reveals that Louise’s heartbreaking memories of her deceased daughter Hannah have yet to unfold and will take place at some point in the future. The skillful narrative weaves together the broader alien arrival plotline with Louise’s personal struggles to produce a compelling and indelible science fiction story.

As Louise decides to have Hannah despite her tragic destiny, she realizes that the brief time they’ll spend together will outshine any sorrowful ending. She promises to treasure each moment of the child’s life. Simultaneously, she pens and releases a book titled “The Universal Language“, which deciphers the Heptapod language. By doing so, Louise not only finds personal peace but also aids humanity by providing a guide on how to perceive time beyond linearity, potentially leading to their own evolution.

Given the continuous influx of grim, dystopian sci-fi films in cinemas over the past decade, Arrival offers a fresher perspective by presenting a more hopeful and optimistic take on extraterrestrial encounters. Instead of a joyous finale, it leaves a subtly uplifting impression suggesting interstellar harmony through the discovery of a common language.

As a cinephile, I find myself deeply moved and intellectually challenged by the thought-provoking and debate-instigating masterpiece that is “Arrival.” Among Villeneuve’s sci-fi works, this film stands as his most impressive, surpassing even the grandeur of “Dune” and “Blade Runner 2049.” Unlike those films, “Arrival” isn’t a remake or sequel; instead, it’s a fresh, original concept brought to life by one of today’s most talented filmmakers. If you haven’t seen it yet, I highly recommend streaming “Arrival” on Paramount+.

Read More

2025-01-19 05:03